Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Seshasayee Bros. (P.) Ltd.

Madras High Court
Feb 11, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Judgment delivered by N.V. Balasubramanian, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellate Tribunal stated a case referring three questions of law to this Court concerning tax treatment of two types of receipts of a private limited company (the assessee) for the assessment year 1970-71.

Relevant factual matrix (as set out in the opinion):

  • The assessee acted as managing agents for Mettur Chemicals & Industrial Corporation Ltd. and South Madras Electric Supply Corporation under agreements providing minimum remuneration and additional remuneration based on profit computed under the Companies Act provisions (sections 349–351). Minimum remuneration was Rs.30,000 and Rs.12,000 respectively (with the additional remuneration payable only when profits warranted and approved by the general meeting after audited accounts were placed and approved).
  • The Income-tax Department historically assessed the additional remuneration in the year when audited accounts were placed before and approved by the general meeting, but for 1971–72 the Assessing Officer treated the additional remuneration as accruing on the date it became due under the agreements (arguing it was due earlier) and assessed it accordingly. The assessee appealed through Appellate Assistant Commissioner and then to the Appellate Tribunal.
  • The Tribunal allowed the assessee's appeal on the additional remuneration issue, following this Court's decision in CIT v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Pvt.) Ltd. (1979) 120 ITR 913, holding the additional remuneration accrued only when it became payable (i.e., after approval of audited accounts by the general meeting), and declined to depart from the historical practice of assessment.
  • Separately, the assessee received Rs. 60,000 from Southern Asbestos Cements Ltd. as compensation for termination of a consultancy agreement entered on January 1, 1965 (originally a 10-year agreement providing consultancy remuneration of Rs.20,000 p.a. pre-production and Rs.30,000 thereafter). The Assessing Officer treated the payment as a capital receipt but assessed it under section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act. Appellate authorities reached differing conclusions; the Tribunal held the payment was a capital receipt and not taxable under section 28(ii)(c) because the agreement was for consultancy (principal‑to‑principal) and not an agency.

The Department referred three precise questions of law to this Court: (1) Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding that the additional remuneration should not be included in the assessment for AY 1970-71; (2) Whether the Tribunal had materials to hold that termination of the contract with Southern Asbestos affected the assessee's business structure and hence the sum was a capital receipt not liable to tax; and (3) Whether section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 applied to the Rs.60,000 received.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that the additional remuneration received by the assessee should not be included in the assessment relevant for the assessment year 1970-71?
  2. Whether the Appellate Tribunal had materials to hold and was correct in holding that the termination of the assessee's contract with Southern Asbestos Limited affected the structure of the business of the assessee and consequently whether the said sum was in the nature of a capital receipt not liable to tax?
  3. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in holding that the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Income‑tax Act, 1961 are not attracted in regard to the sum of Rs.60,000 received by the assessee from Southern Asbestos Limited?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • On the additional remuneration (Question 1): The Revenue (Mr. S.V. Subramaniam, Senior Standing Counsel) submitted that the additional remuneration accrued under the terms of the agreements and there is no distinction between minimum and additional remuneration for accrual purposes; if minimum remuneration is taxable on accrual then the additional remuneration should be taxable on the same accrual principle.
  • On the Rs.60,000 compensation (Questions 2 and 3): The Revenue submitted that the Rs.60,000 cannot be regarded as a capital receipt but is a revenue receipt and therefore taxable. Further, even if it were regarded as capital, it would still be taxable under section 28(ii)(c) because the consultancy agreement was, in substance, an agency agreement; the Tribunal erred in holding that section 28(ii)(c) did not apply.

Assessee's Position (as recorded in the opinion and adopted by the Tribunal)

  • On the additional remuneration: The assessee's practice (accepted previously by the Department) and the contract terms meant additional remuneration became payable only after the audited balance-sheet and profit & loss account were placed before and approved by the general meeting; thus accrual occurred only on that approval and not at the end of the accounting year.
  • On the Rs.60,000 compensation: The assessee's case (upheld by the Tribunal) was that the agreement with Southern Asbestos Cements Ltd. was for consultancy services (principal-to-principal), not an agency; termination harmed the business structure (an enduring trading asset was impaired) and the payment for termination was compensation (capital receipt), not taxable under section 28(ii)(c).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Pvt.) Ltd., [1979] 120 ITR 913 The Court's earlier holding that where an agreement contains no provision as to when additional remuneration accrues, the accrual is at the time when it becomes payable — i.e., when profits are known and payable; absence of specific accrual provision means accrual occurs when payable. The Court relied on and followed this precedent to hold that the additional remuneration in the present case accrued only when it became payable (after audited accounts were approved by the general meeting) and therefore was not includible in assessment for AY 1970-71.
Daruvala Bros. (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Central), Bombay, [1971] 80 ITR 213 Illustration that even where a distributorship agreement described the distributor as an agent, section 28(ii)(c) may not apply; the question whether an agreement creates an agency must be decided on the facts. The Court noted this decision to support the proposition that applicability of section 28(ii)(c) turns on whether there is an agency agreement on the facts; the Tribunal's factual finding that the consultancy agreement was not an agency agreement made section 28(ii)(c) inapplicable in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed each of the three referred questions by reviewing the factual findings of the Appellate Tribunal, the terms of the agreements as recorded, and relevant authority.

Question 1 — Additional remuneration (accrual timing)

  • The Tribunal recorded that the agreements with Mettur Chemicals and South Madras Electric Supply Corporation were similar to the agreement considered in CIT v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Pvt.) Ltd. and that, lacking a provision as to when additional remuneration accrues, accrual occurs when it becomes payable.
  • The Tribunal found that additional remuneration was approved only after the audited balance-sheet and profit & loss accounts were placed before and approved by the general body meeting; the assessee maintained accounts on mercantile basis and earlier departmental practice was to assess on that basis.
  • The Revenue failed to show any term in the agreements making the additional remuneration due prior to approval by the general meeting; accordingly, it was not possible to treat the amount as due on the last date of the accounting year.
  • Applying the precedent in South Madras Industrial Development Co., the Court held the Tribunal's conclusion that the income did not accrue on or before March 31, 1970 was correct.

Questions 2 and 3 — Rs.60,000 compensation: capital vs. revenue and applicability of section 28(ii)(c)

  • Factual base: the consultancy agreement with Southern Asbestos Cements Ltd. (10-year term beginning Jan 1, 1965) was terminated on March 27, 1970; five years of the term remained. Southern Asbestos paid Rs.60,000 in lieu of Rs.1,42,500 that would otherwise have been payable.
  • The Tribunal found that termination affected the assessee's business structure and that the unexpired period was sufficiently long; termination impaired the profit‑making/trading structure, amounting to loss of an enduring trading asset. Thus the payment was a capital receipt.
  • The Revenue's contention that the sum represented remuneration for the unexpired period was rejected: the clause in the agreement fixing damages provided a measure to quantify compensation in the event of termination (in terrorem), and did not evidence the payment being remuneration for future or past services.
  • The Tribunal further found the agreement was for consultancy (assistance in securing foreign collaboration, technical assistance, discussions with Government) and was between principal and principal — not an agency agreement. Section 28(ii)(c) applies to payments received by a person "holding an agency in India" in connection with termination/modification of the agency; the section therefore presupposes an agency relationship.
  • The Court noted the Tribunal's reliance on Daruvala Bros. to show that even agreements described as agency/distributorship may not attract section 28(ii)(c) depending on facts, and that the question of agency must be decided on the agreement's facts. The Revenue did not challenge the Tribunal's factual finding nor produce the agreement for review, so the Court proceeded on the Tribunal's finding that no agency relationship existed.
  • Given the Tribunal's findings on capital nature of the receipt and absence of agency, the Court concurred that section 28(ii)(c) was not attracted and that the payment was not assessable under that provision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court answered all three referred questions in the affirmative and against the Department.

Direct consequences for the parties (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The additional remuneration based on audited and approved accounts did not accrue on or before March 31, 1970 and therefore was not liable to be included for assessment for assessment year 1970-71.
  • The Rs.60,000 received from Southern Asbestos Cements Ltd. on termination of the consultancy agreement was properly characterized by the Tribunal as a capital receipt (the termination impaired an enduring trading asset) and, because the agreement was found to be one for consultancy (not an agency), the amount was not assessable under section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act.
  • No order as to costs was made by the Court.

Broader implications: The opinion resolves the referred questions in favour of the assessee on the particular facts and records reliance on existing precedent (South Madras and Daruvala Bros.). The judgment does not state or advert to the creation of a new precedent beyond applying and following prior authority; the decision's practical effect is limited to the assessment consequences for these particular receipts as described above.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

N.V Balasubramanian, J.:— Pursuant to the directions of this court, the Appellate Tribunal has stated a case and referred the following questions of law for the opinion of this court:

“1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that the additional remuneration received by the assessee should (not) be included in the assessment relevant for the assessment year, 1970-71?

2. Whether, the Appellate Tribunal had materials to hold and was correct in holding that the termination of the assessee's contract with Southern Asbestos Limited affected the structure of the business of the assessee and consequently whether the said sum was in the nature of a capital receipt not liable to tax?

3. Whether, on the fact vand in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in holding that the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, are not attracted in regard to the sum of Rs. 60,000 received by the assessee from Southern Asbestos Limited?”

2. The second and third questions are interconnected in the sense that the contention of the Revenue is that if the receipt is held to be not a revenue receipt it is still assessable under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. We clarify that in the third question referred to us, though there is a reference to the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the provisions of law ought to be section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The assessee is a private limited company and during the previous year relevant to the assessment year 1970-71, the assessee acted as managing agents for Mettur Chemicals and Industrial Corporation Limited and also South Madras Electric Supply Corporation. The assessee entered into an agreement on March 1, 1965, with Mettur Chemicals and Industrial Corporation Limited and under the agreement, the assessee was entitled to claim remuneration at a certain percentage, on a sliding scale, from the profit of the company as computed under the provisions of sections 349 to 351 of the Companies Act, 1956. The assessee-company was entitled to a minimum remuneration of Rs. 30,000. The assessee-company entered into another agreement with South Madras Electric Supply Corporation and there also, the assessee was entitled to claim remuneration of 10 per cent, of the net profit and the assessee was also entitled to a minimum remuneration of Rs. 12,000 per annum. The minimum remuneration was received every month and there is no dispute about its taxability. The additional remuneration which was payable to the assessee was with reference to the profit at a specified percentage in the event of remuneration payable exceeding the minimum remuneration under the agreement, and the additional remuneration drawn by the assessee was only after the audited balance-sheet and profit and loss account of the relevant year were placed before the general body meeting and approved by the general body meeting. The assessee was offered additional remuneration on the basis of the approval of the audited balance-sheet and profit and loss account by the company. There is no dispute that the assessee was maintaining its accounts on mercantile basis and the Department was also making assessment up to the assessment year 1970-71 on the basis that the additional remuneration was assessable in the hands of the assessee when the relevant balance-sheet and profit and loss account was placed before the annual general meeting and approved in the said meeting. But, in the year 1971-72, the Income-tax Officer changed the method of taxation of the additional remuneration and according to the Assessing Officer, the additional remuneration became due to the assessee as per the agreements entered into with Mettur Chemicals and Industrial Corporation Ltd. and South Madras Electric Supply Corporation and it is assessable in the year in which the minimum remuneration was payable and the fact that it was paid subsequently is not a relevant consideration. The assessee preferred an appeal before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Trichirapalli, against the assessment of the additional remuneration, and the Appellate Assistant Commissioner confirmed the assessment. The assessee preferred an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal against the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Appellate Tribunal, following the decision of this court in the case of CIT v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Private) Ltd., [1979] 120 ITR 913 found that the terms of the agreements entered into by the assessee with the said companies were similar to the agreement which was the subject-matter of consideration of this court in South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Pvt.) Ltd.'s case, [1979] 120 ITR 913. According to the Appellate Tribunal, the additional remuneration was approved only after the audited balance-sheet and profit and loss accounts were placed before the general body meeting of the managing company and approved in the said annual general body meeting. The Tribunal also noticed that the method adopted by the assessee was also accepted and followed by the Department consistently in the earlier years and there is no justification to depart from the practice that has been adopted hitherto. In this view of the matter, the Appellate Tribunal allowed the appeal of the assessee and the Department has come before us by way of reference with reference to the first question.

3. Mr. S.V Subramaniam, learned senior standing counsel appearing for the Revenue submitted that in so far as the first question is concerned, the additional remuneration accrued on the basis of the agreement and there is no difference between the minimum remuneration and the additional remuneration payable under the agreement and once it is found taxable on the basis of the accrual the same principle should also apply in the case of taxing the additional remuneration as well.

4. We have seen that the Tribunal has recorded a categorical finding that the terms of the agreements entered into by the assessee with Mettur Chemical and Industrial Corporation Limited and South Madras Electric Supply Corporation are similar to the agreement which was the subject-matter of consideration before this court in case of CIT v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Pvt.) Ltd., [1979] 120 ITR 913. This court has held that in the absence or inadequacy of the profit, under the agreement, the managing agent was entitled to the minimum remuneration payable at such rate for each year and in so far as the additional remuneration is concerned, there was no provision of agreement as to when it accrues. This court held that in the absence of any provision in the agreement as to when it accrues, it accrued at the time when it became payable to the assessee. Similarly, on the facts of the case the contract is silent as to when the amount becomes due and in the absence of any material, we have to hold that it is not possible to treat the amount as being due on the last date of the accounting year. The finding of the Appellate Tribunal is that the additional remuneration became due only after the audited balance-sheet and profit and loss account of the company were laid before the company's general body meeting and approved by the same. Since the additional remuneration is based on the profit and unless the amount of profit is known, it is not possible to hold that the additional remuneration accrued at the end of the relevant accounting year. Learned counsel for the Department is not able to show that under the provisions of the agreement, the additional remuneration became due prior to the approval in the general body meeting. The agreement is not in any way different from the agreement which was-the subject-matter of consideration in the case of South Madras Industrial Development Co. (Private) Limited, [1979] 120 ITR 913. Therefore, we hold that the view of the Appellate Tribunal that the income did not accrue to the assessee on or before March 31, 1970, and the additional remuneration received by the assessee is not liable to be included for the assessment year 1970-71 appears to us, to be in order. In the result, we answer the first question in the affirmative and against the Department.

5. The facts leading to the second and third questions are as under: The assessee-company received a compensation from one Southern Asbestos Cements Limited for the termination of its agreement with the assessee. The assessee-company was holding some industrial licence for manufacturing cement from the Government of India and it was subsequently transferred to Southern Asbestos Cements Limited with the concurrence of the Government of India for the utilisation of the licence. Southern Asbestos Cements Limited appointed the assessee as its business consultant in the matter of securing foreign collaboration and for rendering technical assistance to assist in export, foreign publicity, etc., under the agreement entered into by the assessee with Southern Asbestos Cements Limited, the assessee was entitled to a remuneration of Rs. 20,000 per annum from January 1, 1965, to the date of commencement of production by Southern Asbestos Cements Limited and Rs. 30,000 thereafter. The agreement also provided that in the event of, termination of the agreement by Southern Asbestos Cements Limited for any reason whatsoever, the assessee was to be paid a remuneration for the unexpired portion of the 10 year contract period. As Southern Asbestos Cements Limited felt that the consultancy service agreement of the assessee was no longer required, it wrote a letter to the assessee seeking termination of the agreement. There was a mutual agreement and ultimately it was decided that Southern Asbestos Cements Limited was to pay a sum of Rs. 60,000 in lieu of Rs. 1,42,500 which would have been otherwise payable by the said company to the assessee as per the agreement entered into on January 1, 1965. The Income-tax Officer proceeded on the basis that it was a capital receipt, but however, he held that the amount of compensation received is taxable under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner, on appeal, felt that the consultancy agreement of the assessee with the said company was terminated during the accounting year ending on March 31, 1970, and the compensation became due for the accounting year ending on March 31, 1970, and therefore, the amount received was taxable for the assessment year 1970-71 under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. The first appellate authority, therefore, held that the sum of Rs. 60,000 was rightly assessed as tax by the Income-tax Officer. On the assessee's appeal, before the Appellate Tribunal, two arguments were advanced by the Revenue. One was that the amount of Rs. 60,000 received by the assessee was not a capital receipt, but revenue receipt and even the receipt being regarded as capital receipt, it is taxable under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. The Appellate Tribunal held that the termination of the agreement affected the business structure of the assessee's business and the unexpired period of the agreement was sufficiently long and so, it could be inferred that the compensation amount paid for the termination of the agreement is a capital receipt. As regards the applicability of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act, the Appellate Tribunal held that the agreement entered into by the assessee with Southern Asbestos Cements Limited is not an agency agreement at all but an agreement entered into purely for rendering consultancy services and the arrangement is between principal and principal. In this view of the matter, the Appellate Tribunal held that the amount is not taxable even under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. This order of the Appellate Tribunal is the subject-matter of the reference before this court.

6. Mr. S.V Subramaniam, learned senior standing counsel appearing for the Revenue, submitted that a sum of Rs. 60,000 received by the assessee from Southern Asbestos Cements Limited cannot be regarded as a capital receipt and it is purely a revenue receipt and hence it is taxable under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. The further submission of learned counsel for the Revenue is that even if this court holds that it is a capital receipt, the amount would be taxable under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act, as the consultancy agreement is also an agency agreement and the Tribunal was not correct in holding that the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act are not applicable to the facts of the case.

7. The second and third questions are interconnected. The second question challenges the findings of the Tribunal that the compensation received from Southern Asbestos Cements Limited is a capital receipt and the third question challenges the finding of the Tribunal that even if it is held to be a capital receipt under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act the amount is assessable as business income. The Tribunal, after considering the agreement and the nature of the business of the assessee, came to the conclusion that on the termination of the agreement the business structure of the assessee's business was affected. We find that the agreement entered into was for a period of ten years from January 1, 1965, and the assessee was entitled to a remuneration of Rs. 20,000 per annum till the date of commencement of production and thereafter Rs. 30,000 per annum. On termination of the agreement, the assessee received the amount towards compensation. The agreement was terminated on March 27, 1970, and on the date of termination of the agreement, a period of five years was still available. The Tribunal found that the agreement cannot be termed as one of ordinary contract and it is a comprehensive one. The Tribunal also recorded its finding that it affected the business structure of the assessee's business. Considering the unexpired period, which is quite a long period and also in view of the finding that the agreement affected the business structure of the assessee, the view of the Tribunal that the amount received towards compensation is a capital receipt, according to us, appears to be justified.

8. Mr. S.V Subramaniam, learned counsel, contended that the amount was paid under the agreement and not for the termination of the agreement. He referred to the observation of the Tribunal that in the event of termination of the agreement, the assessee was entitled to be paid in advance the remuneration for the unexpired portion of the period of agreement. But we are not able to accept the contention advanced on behalf of the Revenue. As already said the compensation paid did not represent the remuneration for unexpired period. The clause providing for a fixed amount of damages has fixed the amount of damages that would be payable in the event of the termination of the agreement. The clause merely affords a measure to quantify the amount of compensation that would be payable in the event of termination of the agreement. Further, the compensation also did not represent the remuneration for the past services rendered by the assessee. According to us, it is not permissible to draw an inference that the amount paid represented the remuneration that would be payable for the unexpired period of the agreement. The clause was previously inserted as in terrorem to provide against the* breach of the contract and the compensation received cannot be regarded as a revenue receipt. As a matter of fact, the Assessing Officer as well as the first appellate authority have proceeded on the basis that the amount received was a capital receipt and it was only before the Tribunal, that a contention was raised by the Revenue that the amount was a revenue receipt which was rightly negatived by the Tribunal.

9. The finding of the Appellate Tribunal is that by termination of the contract, the profit making structure of the assessee was affected and that the termination of the contract involved loss to the assessee of an enduring trading asset. In other words, the finding of the Tribunal is that by virtue of the cancellation or the extinction of the contract the trading structure of the assessee was impaired and it is not the case of the Revenue that the agreement entered into by the assessee was in the course of carrying on its business. Hence, it cannot be said that the termination of the contract was a normal incident of the business of the assessee. As already seen, the cancellation of the contract has impaired the trading structure of the assessee which has resulted in a loss to the source of income to the assessee. Therefore, the payment made to the assessee for the cancellation of the contract was rightly held by the Appellate Tribunal to be a capital asset. In so far as the third quesiton is concerned, it relates to the application of section 28(ii)(c) of the Income-tax Act. Section 28(ii)(c) of the Act provides that if any compensation or other payment was received by any person, by whatever name called, holding an agency in India for any part of the activities relating to the business of any other person, at or in connection with the termination of the agency or the modification of the terms and conditions relating to it, the amount received would be regarded as profits and gains of business carried on by it. The section, a reading of it, shows that it aims at an agency agreement, and the prerequisite for the applicability of the section is that there must be an agency agreement. The assessee was appointed as a consultant and on a perusal of the agreement, the Appellate Tribunal recorded a finding that the agreement was purely one of consultancy service and what is contemplated in the agreement is between principal and principal. In other words, the finding is that there was no agency agreement. The agreement envisages assistance in securing foreign collaborations, technical assistance in its productions, assistance in discussion with Government. The Tribunal, therefore, came to the conclusion that the agreement was one for consulting services and there was no principal and agent relationship between the parties. The finding of the Appellate Tribunal has not been challenged by the Revenue in the reference. As already observed, the Revenue has not even requested to enclose a copy of the agreement which was the subject-matter of consideration by the Appellate Tribunal and in the absence of the copy of the agreement, we have to proceed on the basis of the finding of the Appellate. Tribunal that the agreement was not an agency agreement. The Tribunal, noticed a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Daruvala Bros. (P.) Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Central), Bombay.*, [1971] 80 ITR 213 wherein the Bombay High Court held that even in the case of a distributorship agreement which described the distributor as an agent, the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act were held to be not applicable. The question whether there was an agency agreement or not has to be decided on the facts of each case. Therefore, in view of the finding of the Tribunal, we are of the view that the compensation received by the assessee on termination of the agreement with Southern Asbestos Cements Limited is not taxable even under the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act. Therefore, the view of the Appellate Tribunal that the provisions of section 28(ii)(c) of the Act are not attracted to the facts of the case is in order. Therefore, we answer questions Nos. 2 and 3 as referred to us in the affirmative and against the Department.

10. Consequently, we answer all the three questions referred to us in the affirmative and against the Department. No order as to costs.