Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shree Ram Mills Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax.

Bombay High Court
Apr 20, 1991
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Reference under Section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a reference made by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal to the High Court under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in relation to assessment year 1969-70. The Tribunal posed the question whether it erred in law in holding that the assessee-company was not entitled to a deduction in respect of Rs. 3,05,981 shown as share-issue (prospectus) expenses.

Facts as stated in the opinion:

  • The assessee-company manufactured textile and engineering goods. Up to 15 August 1965 it was managed by a managing agents' firm (Messrs. Bhogilal Menghraj & Co. Ltd.), the interests in which were held by two groups (the Shri Bhogilal Laherchand group and the Shri Lalchand Menghraj group).
  • A dispute arose between the two groups in 1965 (context included the Government policy to abolish the managing agency system). Following disputes, litigation concluded by a consent decree dated 4 September 1968 requiring the assessee-company to purchase 30,975 equity shares (face value Rs.100) at Rs.206.50 per share and to effect a reduction of capital; the total payable was Rs.63,96,337 in instalments as per the court's order.
  • Because of the anticipated adverse effect on working funds, the board decided in November/December 1968 to issue 62,750 fresh equity shares of Rs.100 each at par. A prospectus was issued on 2 December 1968 inviting the public to subscribe. Approximately Rs.32 lakhs was received as share application money in calendar year 1968, and the shares were subsequently issued.
  • The assessee's profit and loss account for calendar year 1968 (relevant to the assessment year) disclosed Rs.3,05,981 as share-issue expenses. The assessee claimed this amount as a revenue deduction; the Assessing Officer disallowed it and relied on the Supreme Court decision in India Cements Ltd. v. CIT (1966) 60 ITR 52. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner agreed. The Tribunal held the expenditure to be capital in nature, referring to Tata Iron & Steel (1921) 1 ITC 125 and India Cements (1966) 60 ITR 52 and confirmed disallowance, leading to the reference question.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal erred in law in holding that the assessee is not entitled to deduction in respect of the sum of Rs. 3,05,981 being expenditure incurred on the issue of prospectus, etc., for raising working capital by way of replenishment?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (as presented by Shri Mistry)

  • The additional capital raised did not confer any real advantage to the assessee; the capital raised (Rs.62,75,000) was almost equal to the sum (Rs.63,96,337) required to be paid to the minority shareholders under the consent decree, so there was no enduring benefit from raising capital.
  • Therefore the expenditure incurred on issuing shares could not be characterized as capital expenditure giving an enduring advantage; it should be allowed as revenue expenditure.
  • Reliance was placed on two High Court decisions: Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT (1984) 145 ITR 793 (where the court followed India Cements but held that not every expense connected with raising capital requires disallowance; legal/printing expenses in ordinary course may be revenue) and Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd. (1990) 181 ITR 59 (Bombay) where, in somewhat similar circumstances, expenditure connected with raising additional share capital was treated as revenue.

Revenue's Arguments (as presented by Dr. Balasubramanian)

  • The Revenue strongly relied on the Tribunal's conclusion that the expenditure was capital in nature and on applicable precedents, in particular Bombay Steam Navigation Co. (1953) Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT (1965) 56 ITR 52, which the Revenue submitted was against the assessee.
  • The Revenue contended that the Glaxo decision was distinguishable on the facts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras, [1966] 60 ITR 52 (SC) Relied upon by the Assessing Officer and Tribunal to support the view that expenditure in connection with floating additional capital is capital in nature and not allowable as revenue deduction in certain circumstances. The court noted that the Income-tax Officer relied on this Supreme Court decision; the Tribunal also referred to it and agreed with departmental authorities. The High Court considered it among the authorities but its detailed application is subsumed in the court's broader factual analysis.
Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd., In re, [1921] 1 ITC 125 (Bombay) Authority dealing with characterization of expenditure in connection with raising capital (used by Tribunal as precedent for capital characterization). The High Court observed that the facts of the present case are more akin to the Tata Iron and Steel decision and treated that similarity as supporting a capital characterization of the expenditure.
Bombay Steam Navigation Co. (1953) Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT, [1965] 56 ITR 52 (SC) Held that expenditure incurred in raising a loan (a liability) is revenue in nature because a loan is not an enduring advantage or asset. The Revenue relied on this decision as being against the assessee. The High Court recorded the decision and its principle but found the present facts distinguishable in outcome, applying other authorities and analysis to reach its conclusion for capital treatment.
Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793 (Bom) Stands for the proposition that not every item of expenditure connected with raising additional capital must be disallowed; certain ordinary trading expenses (legal, printing, etc.) incurred in the ordinary course may be revenue expenditures. The court observed that there were no details on record as to the composition of the Rs.3,05,981 shown as share-issue expenses; consequently, it was not possible to determine whether or to what extent Bombay Burmah would apply. The absence of particulars prevented reliance on this decision to allow the expenditure on revenue account.
Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59 (Bom) Held that expenditure in connection with raising capital by additional issue of shares could be revenue expenditure where there was a direct nexus between the business need and the raising of capital (in that case, to secure continuance of a technical collaboration deemed essential for profitable operation). The assessee relied strongly on Glaxo. The High Court compared the facts and distinguished Glaxo: in Glaxo there was an established lack of need for funds but a need to secure technical collaboration (a direct nexus with business), whereas in the present case funds were needed for a project and to meet liabilities arising out of the consent decree—facts which the court found materially different and more akin to Tata Iron & Steel.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court undertook a fact-sensitive analysis, focusing on whether the expenditure had a direct nexus with the assessee's carrying on of its business and whether it conferred an enduring advantage (i.e., capital character) or was of the ordinary revenue nature.

  1. Nature of the underlying problem: The Court emphasized that the dispute that led to the consent decree was between constituents of the managing agency firm and had no direct nexus with the company's ordinary business activities. Although settled by a consent decree, the settlement required the company itself to purchase the minority group's shares—a step the Court regarded as generally not done and not directly linked to the company's business operations.
  2. Prospectus-stated purposes: The prospectus (dated 2 December 1968) explicitly stated three purposes for the issue: (a) to obtain listing on the Bombay Stock Exchange; (b) to raise additional finance for investment in the Reishaure Chucks Project at Udhna, Gujarat; and (c) to provide funds partly to pay off instalments due under the consent decree for the purchase of minority shares. The Court treated the first two aims as typical capital-raising purposes (listing and project finance) and the third as a purpose arising out of the settlement of the dispute.
  3. Two-fold purpose and its consequences: The Court noted that to the extent the issue was for project investment (Udhna), the expenditure was necessarily capital in nature. The other purpose—meeting obligations caused by the managing-agency dispute—did not have a direct nexus with the company's carrying on of its business. Therefore, that purpose too pointed away from the expenditure being revenue in nature.
  4. Comparison with cited authorities: The Court compared the present facts with Glaxo (where there was a direct nexus between business needs and raising capital to secure technical collaboration) and concluded Glaxo was materially different. The Court considered the present facts to be more akin to Tata Iron & Steel. The Court also observed that Bombay Steam Navigation's principle (loan is liability and not an asset; expenditure to raise a loan can be revenue) was relied upon by the Revenue, but the Court resolved the present case on its own fact matrix and comparison with other authorities.
  5. On Bombay Burmah authority: The Court recorded that Bombay Burmah held that not every item of expenditure connected with raising capital is necessarily capital; however, the Court noted the absence of any detailed breakup of the Rs.3,05,981 (the profit & loss merely described it as 'share issue expenses'). Because there were no particulars to identify whether portions of the expense were of the kind that Bombay Burmah would treat as revenue (e.g., ordinary legal or printing expenses), the Court found it impossible to apply Bombay Burmah to allow any part of the claim.
  6. Conclusion of analysis: Having regard to the stated purposes of the share issue, the lack of a direct nexus between the dispute-driven need for funds and the company's business, the comparators, and the absence of detailed particulars of the expenditure, the Court concluded that the expenditure was not of a revenue nature.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the expenditure of Rs. 3,05,981 shown as share-issue (prospectus) expenses is not of revenue nature and therefore not allowable as a revenue deduction. The Court answered the referred question in the negative and in favour of the Revenue.

Implications and direct effect:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's view that the expenditure is capital in nature is affirmed by the High Court; the claim for deduction of Rs. 3,05,981 as revenue expenditure is disallowed.
  • Broader precedent or policy: The Court confined its decision to the facts before it and compared earlier authorities; it did not purport to lay down an expansive new principle beyond applying established authorities to the present factual matrix. (The opinion contains an observation that the phrase used in the referential question—“for raising working capital by way of replenishment”—is not quite correct, but the Court did not pursue this further.)

Order on costs: There will be no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

T.D Sugla, J.:— This is a reference at the instance of the assessee-company. The assessment year involved is 1969-70. The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal has referred to this court the following question of law for opinion under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal erred in law in holding that the assessee is not entitled to deduction in respect of the sum of Rs. 3,05,981 being expenditure incurred on the issue of prospectus, etc., for raising working capital by way of replenishment?”

2. The assessee-company carries on business in the manufacture of textile and engineering goods. Up to August 15, 1965, it was being managed by the managing agents, Messrs. Bhogilal Menghraj and Co. Ltd. The interest in the managing agency firm was held by two groups known as Shri Bhogilal Laherchand group and Shri Lalchand Menghraj group. There developed a rift between the two groups in the year 1965 when the Government of India announced the policy of gradual abolition of the managing agency system. Shri Pratap Bhogilal was appointed managing director with effect from August 16, 1965, with the approval of the Central Government as a result of which there were serious disturbances in the proper functioning of the day-to-day business of the company. There was litigation in this court which ended in a consent decree dated September 4, 1968. In terms of the consent decree, the assessee-company was required to purchase 30,975 equity shares of the face value of Rs. 100 each relating to the minority group at a price of Rs. 206.50 per share and effect suitable reduction in capital. The assessee-company was, thus, required to pay a sum of Rs. 63,96,337 in instalments as per our court's order dated September 4, 1968, to the minority group of shareholders. As a consequence, the assessee company's Working funds were to be affected adversely. In order to get over the situation, the board of directors of the assessee-company decided some time in November/December, 1968, to issue 62,750 fresh equity shares of Rs. 100 each at par. Prospectus was issued on December 2, 1968, whereby members of the public were invited to purchase the shares. A sum of Rs. 32 lakhs odd was received during the calendar year 1968 itself as share application money. The shares were issued subsequently. The profit and loss account for the calendar year. 1968 relevant for the year under reference disclosed a sum of Rs. 3,05,981 as share-issue expenses.

3. The assessee claimed the above expenditure as deduction on revenue account. The claim was rejected by the Income-tax Officer who relied on the Supreme Court decision in India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras., [1966] 60 ITR 52. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner agreed with the Income-tax Officer. The Tribunal, inter alia, referred to the Bombay High Court decision in the case of Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd., In re, [1921] 1 ITC 125, and the Supreme Court decision in India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras., [1966] 60 ITR 52 and agreed with the departmental authorities that the expenditure was incurred on the floating of capital by additional issue and was, therefore, capital in nature.

4. Shri Mistry, learned counsel for the assessee, submitted that, by raising the additional capital, the assessee was not in any way benefited. The additional capital raised was Rs. 62,75,000 which was almost equal to the amount of Rs. 63,96,337 the assessee was to pay to the minority group of shareholders for purchasing their 30,975 shares in terms of the consent decree. It is not quite correct to say that, by raising the capital by issue of additional shares, the assessee got any advantage, far less an advantage of enduring nature. The Tribunal was, therefore, not correct in confirming the disallowance of the expenditure as revenue expenditure. Shri Mistry stated that our court, in the case of Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793, and in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59, considered this issue. In Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793, our court held, following the Supreme Court decision in India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras., [1966] 60 ITR 52, that it was not every item of expenditure incurred in connection with the raising of the additional capital that required disallowance. Expenditure such as legal expenses, printing expenses, etc., which a trader is expected to incur in the ordinary course of its capacity as a trader have to be allowed as revenue expenditure even though a part of it might relate to the issue of the raising of the additional capital. In particular, Shri Mistry placed strong reliance on our court's judgment in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59. It was stated that, in more or less similar circumstances, the expenditure incurred on the raising of capital by additional issue of shares was held to be a revenue expenditure. This case, according to him, was squarely applicable in the facts of this case and, therefore, it must be held that the expenditure incurred herein is also a revenue expenditure.

5. Dr. Balasubramanian, learned counsel for the Revenue, on the other hand, strongly relied upon the Tribunal's order. In particular, he stated that the Supreme Court decision in the case of Bombay Steam Navigation Co. (1953) Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT, [1965] 56 ITR 52, was applicable and was against the assessee and that our court's judgment in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59 was distinguishable.

6. We have carefully considered the Supreme Court decision in India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras., [1966] 60 ITR 52, and our High Court's decisions in Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793 and Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59. In order to appreciate the facts of the case in the light of the decisions relied upon, it is desirable to mention that, in the present case, the dispute was between the two constituents of the managing agency firm. The dispute was no doubt settled in terms of a consent decree. However, the fact cannot be overlooked that the dispute had no direct nexus with the assessee company's carrying on of its business. In normal circumstances, the dispute between the two constituents could and should have been settled by one group buying out the other group. In the present case, the disputing groups compromised and obtained a consent decree in terms of which the assessee-company had to purchase the shares of the minority group which is generally not done. In the circumstances, we do not think it is quite correct to say that the depletion of the assessee-company's funds for the purpose of buying out one of the constituents of the managing agency firm has a direct nexus with the assessee's carrying on of the business or of the assessee-company's raising of the additional capital.

7. The prospectus issued on December 2, 1968, inviting the public to purchase the assessee-company's shares indicates the purpose of the issue of the shares as under:

“Purpose of the present issue:

The company intends to issue to the public 62,750 equity shares for the following purposes:

(a) The company desires to have its shares listed on the Bombay Stock Exchange and, accordingly, the issue covered by this prospectus is offered to the public.

(b) The company requires additional finance for investment in the Reishaure Chucks Project at Udhna in the State of Gujarat referred to above.

(c) The company has, pursuant to an order and decree dated September 4, 1968, passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Company Petition No. 102 of 1967 (Lalchand Menghraj v. Shree Ram Mills Ltd.), purchased 30,975 equity shares of the face value of Rs. 100 each of the company at a price of Rs. 206.50 per share and consequential reduction of the capital by 30,975 shares. Under the said decree, as adjusted by an order passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay on September 5, 1968, the purchase price of shares is to be paid by ten equal monthly instalments, commencing from September 21, 1968. The company has paid instalments due till date and it now requires funds partly to pay off the balance of the instalments as and when due. The total amount paid so far is Rs. 19,18,901.”

8. Evidently, the purpose of the issue of additional shares is two-fold. To the extent the purpose is to raise additional capital for the project at Udhna in Gujarat, the expenditure incurred cannot but be held to be on capital account. The other purpose is to meet a situation that was caused due to dispute between the two groups in the managing agency firm which resulted in a consent decree. To say the least, the second purpose does not have a direct nexus with the assessee's carrying on of the business.

9. We will refer to our court's judgment in Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793, a little later. In the Supreme Court decision in Bombay Steam Navigation Co. (1953) P. Ltd. v. CIT, [1965] 56 ITR 52, the expenditure was incurred for raising a loan. Observing that a loan is a liability and not an asset, it was held that a loan, i.e, a liability, cannot be an advantage, far less an advantage of enduring nature. The expenditure was treated to be of revenue nature primarily for that reason. The facts in our court's judgment in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Glaxo Laboratories (India) Ltd., [1990] 181 ITR 59 were that the assessee manufactured pharmaceutical products and had, for the purpose, entered into an agreement of technical collaboration with its parent company in the U.K which was due to expire in the beginning of 1967. The assessee applied to the Government of India for permission to enter into a fresh collaboration agreement so that it could continue to obtain the benefit of research being carried out by the parent company and also day-to-day advice in respect of the manufacture of existing and new products. The Government, however, informed the assessee that it would grant permission to enter into a fresh technical collaboration agreement only if the assessee agreed to dilute the shareholding of the parent company in its capital by offering at least 25% thereof to the Indian public. It was in these circumstances that the assessee-company raised capital to the extent of 25% to be subscribed by the Indian public in order to dilute the capital contribution of the parent company. A question arose as to whether the expenditure in connection with the raising of such capital would be revenue expenditure. Our court held that the expenditure incurred was a revenue expenditure.

10. Comparing the facts of the case before us with those of the Glaxo case, [1990] 181 ITR 59 (Bom), we find that the facts are materially different. In that case, our court has observed that (at p. 65): “It is established, upon the Tribunal's finding, that the assessee had no need for funds. It is established that it had need only of the technical collaboration arrangement to run profitably. What, therefore, motivated the businessman in the assessee was the expediency of ensuring the continuance of the technical collaboration arrangement.” There was, thus, a direct nexus between the assessee's business and the raising of the capital. As against that case, in the case before us, it is the admitted position that the assessee needed funds for a project in Gujarat and for making payment to buy out the minority shareholders in the managing agency firm. Under the circumstances, the facts in the present case are more akin to our court's decision in Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd., In re, [1921] 1 ITC 125.

11. As regards our court's decision in Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793, we have only to mention that there are no details available on record of the expenditure of Rs. 3,05,981. In the profit and loss account, the expenditure is shown as share issue expenses. It is true that the Tribunal has described this expenditure in paragraph 8 of its judgment as being expenditure incurred on the issue of prospectus, legal and other expenses for the new issue of capital. However, in the absence of details, it is not possible to hold whether and to what extent the decision in Bombay Burmah Trading Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1984] 145 ITR 793 will at all apply. Having regard to the above discussion, we hold that the expenditure incurred herein is not of revenue nature. Accordingly, we answer the question in the negative and in favour of the Revenue. Before concluding we would like to observe that the expression used in the question “for raising working capital by way of replenishment” is not quite correct. However, we need not pursue this aspect of the matter further.

12. There will be no order as to costs.