Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Of A.P Rep... v. M/S. Ampro Food Prod...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 18, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Court's Order

Factual and Procedural Background

These three connected Tax Revision Cases arise from assessments for the assessment years 1979–80 and 1980–81 concerning the same assessee (a biscuits manufacturing company). The Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal disposed of two connected second appeals on 29 August 1984 (T.A. Nos. 24 & 25 of 1982). The State filed T.R.C. No. 151 of 1985 (challenging the Tribunal's order as to assessment year 1979–80) and T.R.C. No. 154 of 1985 (challenging the Tribunal's order as to assessment year 1980–81). The assessee filed T.R.C. No. 195 of 1985 but did not press it.

For 1979–80 the assessing authority originally granted exemptions aggregating Rs. six crores and assessed the balance turnover on 20 November 1980. A successor Commercial Tax Officer inspected the assessee's premises on several dates (7-12-1980, 3-4-1981 and 8-4-1981), collected material and issued a show-cause notice under Rule 14-A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules read with Section 9(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1957 proposing to reopen the assessment and withdraw exemptions. The assessing authority rejected the assessee's objections and assessed the disputed turnover; the appellate authority upheld that assessment. The Tribunal allowed the appeals: it held reopening of the 1979–80 assessment was impermissible and set aside the orders, and it remanded the 1980–81 assessment because certain factual aspects remained undetermined.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the assessing authority had jurisdiction to reopen a concluded assessment and reassess turnover by invoking Rule 14-A(8) of the Central Sales Tax (A.P.) Rules read with Section 9(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act and Section 14(4)(cc) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act.
  2. Whether the power to reopen an assessment under the relevant provisions can be exercised merely on a change of opinion by a successor officer or requires fresh material de hors the assessment record.
  3. Whether the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal was justified in remanding the assessment for 1980–81 to the assessing authority for de novo enquiry rather than deciding the matter itself when, according to the State, all material was before the Tribunal.

Arguments of the Parties

Government Pleader for Commercial Taxes (State)

  • Contended that Rule 14-A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules read with Section 14(4)(cc) of the APGST Act and Section 9(2) of the CST Act vested jurisdiction in the assessing authority to reopen the assessment.
  • Argued that the Tribunal erred in holding the assessing authority had no power to reopen the assessment for 1979–80.
  • Maintained that the Tribunal should not have remanded the 1980–81 assessment since, according to the State, all material was before the Tribunal and it could decide the issues itself.
  • Pointed to inspections by the successor officer as having produced fresh material showing certain sales were inter-State and thus justifying reopening.

Assessee (and its Counsel)

  • Contended that the Central Sales Tax Act and the Central Sales Tax Rules did not confer a specific power to withdraw exemptions wrongly granted and reopen assessments; thus the assessing authority lacked the power it purported to exercise.
  • Argued that the assessing authority could not invoke the State Sales Tax Act power where there was no corresponding power under the CST Act and its rules (this alternative contention was not pressed strongly).
  • Contended that remand by the Tribunal was justified in relation to the 1980–81 assessment, given the factual findings recorded by the Tribunal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.S. Narayana Shenoi v. State of Kerala, 1961 12 STC 665 (Kerala) Interpretation of a reassessment rule (Rule 33 of Travancore‑Cochin General Sales Tax Rules, 1950): the opening words "for any reason" include legal errors as well as omissions or concealment. Used to show that reassessment rules may permit reopening not only for concealment but also for legal error; cited as analogous reasoning supporting the scope of Rule 14‑A(8).
K.K. Ismail v. State of Kerala, 1979 43 STC 123 (Kerala) Held provisions equivalent to Rule 14‑A(8) authorized reopening for escaped or under‑assessed turnover; the reason is immaterial, and reassessment can be valid even if successor officer reaches a different view on the same materials. Cited for the proposition that the reason for reassessment is immaterial and that reassessment can be valid even if based on the same materials as the earlier officer.
Dy. Commissioner Sales Tax v. Elias, 1993 90 STC 25 (Kerala) Expressed the same view as K.K. Ismail regarding the scope of reassessment powers under similar rules. Reinforced the view that reassessment power under comparable statutory provisions is broad.
State of Andhra Pradesh v. Sreenivas Trading Company, 1989 75 STC 206 (A.P.) Considered whether power to reopen assessments included cases where exemptions wrongly allowed; held Clause (cc) of Section 14(4) was clarificatory and clauses (a) and (b) of Section 14(4) already empowered reassessment. Relied upon to conclude that the assessing authority could exercise power to reassess where exemptions were wrongly granted and that analogous provisions exist in Rule 14‑A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules.
State of Andhra Pradesh v. Rathna Sree Box Makers, 1989 75 STC 82 (A.P.) Held that power to reopen assessments under Section 14(4) of the State Act can be exercised only on material de hors (outside) the assessment record and not on material already considered at the time of original assessment. Applied as authoritative support for the principle that reopening requires fresh material not previously before the assessing officer; the court applied this principle to Rule 14‑A(8).
Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Jamshedpur (27 STC 354) Authority on scrutiny of transactions to determine whether they constitute inter‑State sales under Section 3(a) — requires transaction-by-transaction analysis. Used by the Tribunal (and accepted by the court) to justify remand because the assessing authority had failed to categorize and scrutinize each transaction as required; the assessment was vitiated on that ground.
Supreme Court decision interpreting Section 34 of the Income Tax Act, AIR 1959 S.C. 257 Principle that relevant information enabling reopening must come into possession of the officer subsequent to the assessment. Quoted by the Tribunal in support of the proposition that reopening is justified only where fresh material became available after the original assessment; the court treated this as relevant precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two analytical stages: jurisdiction to reopen and the permissibility of reopening in the facts of this case.

1. Statutory framework and jurisdiction:

  • The court examined Section 9(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1957, which empowers authorities who assess under the State general sales tax law to exercise their powers on behalf of the Government of India in respect of the CST Act, subject to the CST Act and rules thereunder.
  • It then analysed Rule 14‑A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules which authorizes the assessing authority, after issuing notice and making such enquiry as considered necessary, to determine to the best of its judgment the correct turnover where turnover has escaped assessment or been under‑assessed and to assess the tax, subject to the time limits in clauses (a) and (b).
  • The court noted Section 14(4)(cc) of the APGST Act, which explicitly empowers the authority to “assess the correct amount of tax payable, in a case where any deduction or exemption has been wrongly allowed.”
  • Relying on the Andhra Pradesh Division Bench decision in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Sreenivas Trading Company, the court concluded that Clause (cc) is clarificatory and that reassessment to correct wrongly allowed exemptions can be effected under clauses (a) and (b) of Section 14(4), and that Rule 14‑A(8) contains analogous power for the assessing authority under the CST (A.P.) Rules.
  • Accordingly, the court held that the assessing authority did have jurisdiction under Rule 14‑A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules to reopen assessments where exemptions had been wrongly allowed.

2. Limitations on use of the reopening power — requirement of fresh material:

  • The court addressed whether the power to reopen could be exercised merely on a change of opinion by a successor officer or required "fresh material" de hors the assessment record. It referred to the Division Bench decision in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Rathna Sree Box Makers which held that reopening under Section 14(4) can be exercised only on material outside the assessment record and not on material already considered at the time of assessment.
  • The court applied that same principle to Rule 14‑A(8) and examined the factual findings of the Tribunal. The Tribunal found as a matter of fact that there was no fresh material that became available after the original assessment enabling the successor officer to justify reopening: the relevant information that would justify reopening must have come into the successor's possession subsequent to the original assessment.
  • Because the Tribunal recorded that no such fresh material existed, the court concluded that, although the assessing authority possessed jurisdiction in principle to reopen, the particular reopening for assessment year 1979–80 was illegal and unjustified for lack of fresh material; mere change of opinion was not sufficient.
  • Consequently T.R.C. No. 151 of 1985 (state's revision against the 1979–80 assessment) failed on that factual and legal basis.

3. Remand in respect of assessment year 1980–81:

  • The court examined the Tribunal's findings that for the 1980–81 assessment there were unresolved factual questions about whether many transactions were truly inter‑State sales under Section 3(a) of the CST Act or were movements occasioned otherwise (e.g., transfer between branches) and that the assessing authority had failed to categorise and scrutinise transactions individually.
  • The court noted the statutory framework governing the burden of proof under Section 6‑A, the role of Form‑F under Rule 12(5), and the effect of a declaration accepted under Section 6‑A(2) in rebutting the presumption of inter‑State sale under Section 3.
  • The Tribunal observed that although the assessee had filed certified Form‑F declarations, the assessing authority had not specifically found that the records disclosed only the identified instances; the Tribunal found there might be many more such transactions (aggregating about 5,000 for the two years and possibly more) and observed that absence of transaction‑by‑transaction scrutiny, as required by the Supreme Court in the Tata Engineering case, vitiated the assessment.
  • Given those factual findings, the Tribunal remanded the 1980–81 assessment to the assessing authority for de novo examination, giving the assessee opportunity to produce evidence and to file C‑forms if appropriate.
  • The court accepted the Tribunal's factual findings and concluded that remand for de novo enquiry was justified in respect of the 1980–81 assessment; it therefore upheld the Tribunal's remand and dismissed the State's revision in that respect as well.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The assessing authority has jurisdiction under Rule 14‑A(8) of the CST (A.P.) Rules (read with Section 9(2) of the CST Act and the State Act provisions) to reopen an assessment and determine escaped or under‑assessed turnover, including where exemptions were wrongly allowed.
  • However, the exercise of that power is constrained: reopening is permissible only where fresh material de hors the assessment record has come into the possession of the assessing authority; mere change of opinion does not justify reopening.
  • Applying these principles to the facts, reopening of the 1979–80 assessment was held to be illegal for want of fresh material; T.R.C. No. 151 of 1985 therefore failed.
  • With respect to 1980–81, the Tribunal's remand for a de novo enquiry (to scrutinise, categorise and examine each transaction and the related declarations/forms) was justified; the court upheld the remand and dismissed the State's revision in relation to that year (T.R.C. No. 154 of 1985).

Direct Consequences for the Parties:

  • T.R.C. No. 151 of 1985 (relating to assessment year 1979–80) is dismissed because the reopening was unsupported by fresh material.
  • T.R.C. No. 154 of 1985 (relating to assessment year 1980–81) is dismissed because the Tribunal was justified in remanding the matter for de novo enquiry; the Tribunal's remand is upheld.
  • T.R.C. No. 195 of 1985 (filed by the assessee) was not pressed by the assessee.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader Implications: The order affirms two points already present in the cited authorities: (a) assessing authorities may have power to reopen assessments to correct wrongly allowed exemptions under Rule 14‑A(8) (and related State provisions), and (b) that power is limited and may be exercised only where fresh material, post‑dating the original assessment, comes into the authority's possession; mere change of opinion is insufficient. The court did not purport to lay down a new, general precedent beyond applying established principles to the facts at hand.

Show all summary ...

Order of the Bench delivered by the Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri, J.:— These three Tax Revision Cases arise out of the orders of assessment of the turnover relating to the assessment years 1979–80 and 1980–81. The Assessee in the three T.R Cs., is the same. They arose out of a common order of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal T.A No. 24 of 1982 and T.A No. 25 of 1982 which were disposed of on August 29, 1984. The State preferred T.R.C No. 151 of 1985 against the common order relating to the assessment year 1979–80 and T.R.C No. 154 of 1985 against the said common order relating to the assessment year 1980–81. The assessee also filed T.R.C No. 195 of 1985 against the said order relating to the assessment year 1980–81.

2. As these cases are connected, they are heard together and they are being disposed of by a common order.

3. At the outset, we may note that the assessee does not press T.R.C No. 195 of 1985. Now we are left with T.R.C Nos. 151 and 154 of 1985 only filed by the State. We may notice the facts giving rise to these Tax Revision Cases. The assessee is a Biscuits Manufacturing Company. The turn over of the assessee for the assessment year, 1979–80 was determined by the Assessing Authority at about Rs. six crores after granting exemptions of Rs. six crores on November 20, 1980. It appears that the successor Commercial Tax Officer inspected the business premises of the assessee on 7-12-1980, 3-4-1981 and on 8-4-1981. On the basis of the material collected during the inspection, the assessing authority issued a show-cause notice as to why the assessment should not be reopened in regard to the exempted turn over relating to the assessment year, 1979–80. He also proposed not to allow those exemptions for the assessment year, 1980–81 as by that time the assessment for that year was not completed. The assessee filed its objections. The assessing authority rejected the objections and assessed the disputed turn over tax. That order of the assessing authority was upheld by the appellate authority. The assessee carried the matter in second appeal to the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal. On 29th August, 1984, the Tribunal held that the assessment for the year 1979–80 could not have been reopened by the assessing authority and therefore, set aside the orders of the assessing authority as well as the appellate authority by allowing the appeal. In regard to the assessment for the year 1980–81, the Tribunal found that some factual aspects were not determined by the authorities. So, the Tribunal remanded the matter by allowing the appeal. Thus, these Tax Revision Cases have come up before us.

4. Shri Ramaiah, the learned Government Pleader for Commercial Taxes, contends that Rule 14-A (8) of the Central Sales Tax (Andhra Pradesh) Rules, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘CST (A.P) Rules’) read with Sec. 14(4)(cc) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as the APGST Act) and Section 9(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as the CST Act) vest jurisdiction in the authority to reopen the assessment. Therefore, the Tribunal had erred in law in coming to the conclusion that the Assessing Authority had no power or jurisdiction to reopen the assessment. He further contends that there was no reason for the Tribunal to remand the case to the assessing authority as all the material was before the Tribunal and therefore, the remand was wholly unjustified in law.

5. We shall first take up the first contention of the learned Government Pleader. It has already been noted that for the assessment year 1979–80, the exemption was granted to a tune of six crore rupees and the balance of turn over was assessed on November 20, 1980. The assessment thus done has become final. However, the successor Commercial Tax Officer, on the basis of the material collected by him on inspection of the business premises of the assessee, issued a show-cause notice as to why the exemption granted for the assessment year 1979–80 should not be cancelled and the escaped/under-assessed turn over should not be assessed to tax. The show-cause notice issued by the assessing authority was under Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules read with Section 9(2) of the CST Act.

6. We shall refer to these provisions here.

7. Section 9(2) of the CST Act is in the following terms:—

“9. Levy and collection of tax and penalties:—

(1) xxxxxxxxx

(2) Subject to the other provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder, the authorities for the time being empowered to assess reassess, collect and enforce payment of any tax under the general sales tax law of the appropriate State shall, on behalf of the Government of India, assess, reassess, collect and enforce payment of tax, including any penalty, payable by a dealer under this Act as if the tax or penalty payable by such a dealer under this Act is a tax or penalty payable under the general sales tax law of the State; and for this purpose they may exercise all or any of the powers they have under the general sales tax law of the State and the provisions of such law, including provisions relating to returns, provisional assessment, advance payment of tax, registration of the transferee of any business, imposition of the tax liability of a person carrying on business on the transferee of, or successor to, such business transfer of liability of any firm or Hindu undivided family to pay tax in the event of the dissolution of such firm or partition of such family, recovery of tax from third parties, appeals, reviews, revisions, references, refunds, rebates, penalties, charing or payment of interest, compounding of offences and treatment of documents furnished by a dealer as confidential, shall apply accordingly:

Provided that if in any state or part thereof there is no general sales tax law in force, the Central Government may, by rules made in this behalf make necessary provision for all or any of the matters specified in this subsection”.

8. From a perusal of the above provisions, it is clear that the authority for the time being empowered to assess, reassess, collect and enforce payment of the tax under the APGST Act is vested with the power on behalf of the Government of India to assess or reassess, collect and enforce payment of the tax including any payment payable by the dealer under the CST Act as if the tax or penalty payable by the said dealer under CST Act is a tax or penalty payable under the general sales tax law of tine State and for that purpose, the authority can exercise all the powers it has under the sales tax law of the State enumerated therein. But the sweep of this power is subject to the provisions of the CST Act and the rules framed thereunder. It would be apt to refer to the rules framed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh under the CST Act. As the notice to reopen the assessment was given under Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules, it would be useful to extract it here:—

“If, for any reason, the whole or any part of the turnover of business of a dealer has escaped assessment to tax or has been under-assessed in any year, the assessing authority may after issuing a notice to the dealer and after making such enquiry as he considers necessary determine to the best of his judgment the correct turnover and assess the tax payable on such turnover—

(a) In cases were an order of assessment or levy had been passed earlier, within a period of four years from the date on which such order was served on the dealer:

(b) within a period of four years from the expiry of the year to which the turnover relates, in other cases”.

9. A plain reading of this sub-rule makes it evident that if whole or any part of tine turnover of the business of a dealer has escaped assessment to tax or has been under-assessed in any year for any reason, the assessing authority has discretion, after issuing notice to the dealer and after making such enquiry as he considers necesssary, to determine to the best of his judgment the correct turnover and assess the tax payable on such turnover. Clauses (a) and (b) deal with the period of limitation within which the power can be exercised. We are not concerned with the question of limitation here. From the above provision, two things are very clear i.e, tine assessing authority has power to redetermine the correct turnover to the best of his judgment and to assess the tax payable on the turnover so determined.

10. We may incidentally note the provisions of Section 14(4)(cc) of the APGST Act here:

“(cc) assess the correct amount of tax payable, in a case where any deduction or exemption has been wrongly allowed”;

11. The above extracted provision specifies one of the events in which the whole or any part of the turnover of the business of a dealer which has escaped assessment to tax or has been under-assessed or assessed at lower rate, among other things, can be correctly assessed and the tax can be collected thereof. Where the assessing authority has wrongly exempted whole or part of the turnover or made any deduction not permissible, clause (cc) of sub-section (4) of Section 14 specifically empowers the assessing authority to assess the correct amount of tax payable.

12. What is contended before us by the learned Counsel for the assessee is that such a specific power is lacking either under the CST Act or under the CST (A.P) Rules. Therefore, this power cannot be exercised by the assessing authority.

13. It is also contended the power to reassess the correct tax on the escaped turnover or under-assessed turnover under the CST Act and the rules made thereunder, cannot be exercised by invoking the provisions of the State Sales Tax Act, where there is no specific power under the CST Act and the rules thereunder.

14. Insofar as the alternative argument is concerned, it is not seriously pressed. We are, therefore, left with only one contention i.e, the Central Sales Tax and the rules thereunder do not empower the assessing authority to withdraw the exemptions wrongly granted by the assessing authority and reopen the assessment, levy tax on the escaped/under-assessed turn over, determined after withdrawing the exemptions wrongly granted. We may point out here that clause (cc) of sub-section (4) of Section 14 of the APGST Act, was inserted with effect from 17-1-1978.

15. In R.S Narayana Shenoi v. State Of Kerala . 1961 12 STC 665 Kerala. the Chief Justice Sri M.A Ansari speaking for the Division Bench of Kerala High Court, explained the ambit of Rule 33 of the Travancore-Cochin General Sales Tax Rules, 1950 which empowered the officer to make reassessment in case of escaped turnover. The learned Chief Justice, having considered the meaning of escaped turn-over and the opening words “any reason”, observed:

“The jurisdiction of an officer to make a reassessment under Rule 33(i) of the Travancore-Cochin General Sales Tax Rules, 1950, is not confined to cases where the turnover has escaped assessment, because it is not before the officer by reason of inadvertence, omission, or deliberate concealment on the part of the assessee, or because of want of care on the part of the officer. That rule also authorises the officer to reopen an assessment if a legal error has been committed in the original assessment”.

16. In K.K Ismail v. The State Of Kerala . 1979 43 STC 123 Kerala. proceedings were initiated by the assessing authority under Section 19 of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963. The provisions of Section 19 of the said Act are almost identical with me phraseology of Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules. The Division Bench of the Kerala High Court took the view that the power of the assessing authority extends to reopening the assessment if, for any reason, the whole or any part of the turnover of the business of the dealer has escaped assessment or under assessed or has been assessed at lower rate, observed:

“The reason being immaterial, it is of no consequence whether what happened was a mere change of opinion on the part of the succeeding officer from that formed by his predecessor. The reassessment in such a case would be valid even if the materials, on the basis of which the earlier officer and the successor officer proceeded, were practically the same”.

17. In Dy. Commissioner Sales Tax v. Elias . 1993 90 STC 25 Kerala. opinion to the same effect is expressed by another Division Bench of the Kerala High Court.

18. In State of Andhra Pradesh v. Sreenivas Trading Company . 1989 75 STC 206 A.P., the question before the Division Bench of our High Court was whether the power of the authority to reopen the assessments in cases where turnover has escaped assessment or in cases where turnover has been under assessed includes the case of reduction of turnover due to the fact that exemptions were wrongly allowed. In that case, certain turnover was under assessed due to granting of exemptions which were impermissible in law. It was contended that Clause (cc) of Section 14(4) was introduced on January 17, 1978, the assessment related to the assessment year, 1975–76 and the order of the assessment was passed in September, 1976, as such the power to reassess the escaped turnover on incorrect granting of exemptions, was not available for reopening the assessment. The Division Bench held that the Clause (cc) of Section 14(4) is merely clarificatory and that the power to correctly determine the turnover where there has been either wrong deduction or granting of impermissible-exemptions, can be exercised under clauses (a) and (b) of Section 14(4), of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act. On close reading of clauses (a) and (b) of Section 14(4) of the APGST Act we find that analogous provisions are contained in Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules. Therefore, even without invoking the provisions of Section 14(4)(cc) of the APGST Act, in our view, the assessing authority can exercise the same power under Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules. In this view of the matter, we are unable to uphold the view of the Tribunal that the assessing authority has no power to reassess the escaped assessment/under assessed turnover for the year, 1979–80 and granting of the exemptions. In our view, the assessing authority has such a power under Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules.

19. But the controversy does not end by regarding this finding. It is not well settled that to exercise power under Section 14(4) of the APGST Act, the assessing authority has to invoke the power to reopen the assessment only when there is fresh material and not merely when there is change of opinion. This is the view taken by our High Court in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Rathna Sree Box Makers . 1989 75 STC 82 A.P.. The Division Bench in that case held that the power of the concerned authority to reopen the assessment and to bring to tax the escaped/under assessed turnover, under Section 14(4) of the State Act can be exercised only on material de hors the assessment record, and not on material already considered at the time of the assessment.

20. In our view, the same principle should govern while exercising the power under Rule 14-A (8) of the CST (A.P) Rules. Having held that the assessing authority has power to reopen the assessment in case where the turnover has escaped assessment due to granting of exemptions wrongly and to correctly determine the turnover and assess the turnover thus escaped, we have to see whether there has been any fresh material before the assessing authority to reopen the assessment and assess the escaped turnover to tax.

21. The learned Government Pleader vehemently contends that the successor assessing authority had collected material on inspection which shows that the sales do not relate to mere consignment of the goods to the branch offices at different places, but they relate to inter-State sales. We are not concerned here with the nature of the sales. The short question which we may have to determine here is whether there was any fresh material before the assessing authority to reopen the assessment, for it is well settled that mere change of opinion is no ground to reopen the assessment.

22. As pointed out earlier, the learned Government pleader invited our attention to the fact that the successor assessing authority had made inspection of the branches and head office of the assessee and collected material which shows that there has been a fresh material which necessitated change of opinion. We are unable to accept this contention in view of the finding of fact recorded by the Tribunal. In paragraph 22 of the order of the Tribunal, it is stated:

“Assuming that the power to reopen can valid be exercised under sub-rule (8) of Rule 14-A of the CST Rules, we do not find on facts that the exercise of such powers is justified in this case. There is no fresh material which was not available at the time of the original assessment, but came into being subsequently enabling the successor officer to reopen the assessment. The relevant information enabling the competent authority to reopen an assessment must come into his possession subsequent to the assessment and this is the view taken by the Supreme Court while interpreting the scope of Section 34 of the Income Tax Act under which the Income tax Officer has the power to bring to tax any escaped assessment (AIR 1959 S.C 257)…………”

(Emphasis supplied).

23. In view of this finding of fact, we have no option but to hold that the reopening of the assessment by the assessing authority was wholly illegal and unjustified. Thus, though we uphold the jurisdiction of the assessing authority to reopen the assessment, yet we find that the circumstances in which the reopening of assessment is permissible, are lacking in this case viz., there is no fresh material de hors the assessment record in that behalf, therefore, we are unable to accept the contention of the learned Government Pleader. Accordingly, T.R.C No. 151 of 1985 fails.

24. The next contention which is only confined to T.R.C No. 154 of 1985 is whether there are circumstances to remand matter to the assessing authority. The learned Government Pleader submits that all the material was before the Tribunal and that it ought to have determined the issues before it instead of remanding the case. Shri Natarajan, the learned Counsel appearing for the assessee contends that remanding of the case was justified having regard to the finding of fact recorded by the Tribunal. We may note here that in a case of Section 6-A read with Sections 2(dd) and Section 3 of the CST Act, sale or purchase of goods shall be deemed to take place in the course of interstate trade or commerce in two circumstances viz., (a) where the sale or purchase occasions the movement of goods from one State to another; or (b) where it is effected by a transfer of documents of title to the goods during their movement from one State to another. There is no dispute that there has been movement of goods from one state to another. Prima facie, it is an inter-State sale within the meaning of Section 3. Section 6-A provides that where any dealer claims that he is not liable to pay tax under the Act (CST Act), in respect of any goods, on the ground that the movement of such goods from one State to another was occasioned by reason of transfer of such goods by him to any other place of his business or to his agent or principal, as the case may be, and not by reason of sale, the burden of proving that the movement of those goods was so occasioned shall be on that dealer and he is entitled to furnish to the assessing authority a declaration duly filled in and signed by the principal officer of the other place of business or his agent or principal, as the case may be, containing the prescribed particulars in the prescribed form which has to be obtained from the prescribed authority and that should be accompanied by the evidence of despatch of such goods. The assessing authority is given power to make an order to the effect that the particulars contained in the declaration furnished by the dealer are true. The consequence to such, an order would be that the movement of the goods to which the declaration relates shall be deemed for the purposes of the CST Act to have been occasioned otherwise than as a result of sale. But such an order has to be made at any time before the assessment or at the time of the assessment. Rule 12(5) of the Central Sales Tax (Registration and Turnover) Rules, 1957, provides that the declaration referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 6-A of the CST Act, shall be in Form-F. A reading of these provisions shows that where Form-F has been filed under Rule 12(5) which has been duly received under Section 6-A (2) of the CST Act, the presumption arising under Section 3, in case of the movement of the goods from one State to another could be revoked and the sale will not be treated as inter-State sale. The Assessee has filed those ‘F’ Forms duly certified. It appears that there are about 5000 transaction's, but the Tribunal found in para 47 of the order that number of such transactions could even be more for the reason that the assessing authority has not given a specific finding in both the assessment orders that those were the only such instances and that the record of assessment did not disclose any further instances and in the absence of such a specific finding, the Tribunal was inclined to believe that the instances could be more having regard to the fact that the transactions aggregated in number about 5,000 for the two years. It pointed out that the failure on the part of the assessing authority to categorise the transactions and scrutinise each of the transactions in order to decide whether each transaction is exigible to tax under Section 3(a) in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Tata Engineering and Locomotive Company Limited v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Jamshedpur (27 STC 354), the order of the assessment becomes vitiated. With regard to the assessment year in question, the Tribunal pointed out in paragraph 67 thus:

“from an examination of the factual position and legal position set out supra, we are of the view in respect of both the years of assessment 1979–80 and 1980–81 barringthe two kindsof transactions viz., where there was direct receipt of orders by the Head Office from the non-resident dealers and where such orders were transmitted by the branch office to the head office as a consequence of which in both the cases the goods were despatched directly by the dealers to the branch office without the intervention of the branch, the other transactions do not answer the description of interstate sales falling within the purview of Section 3(a) of the CST Act”.

and remanded the case to the assessing authority to examine de novo after giving notice to the assessee and affording opportunity to produce evidence, each of the transactions in the light of the observations contained in the judgment. The assessee was also directed to file the ‘C’ forms after de novo enquiry decides in the light of the observations contained in the judgment, to be inter-State transactions.

25. From the findings recorded by the Tribunal it is clear that the remand of the case for de novo enquiry is justified and we, therefore, dismiss the Tax Revision Cases for the aforementioned reasons. No costs.