- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Adarsh Kumar & Anr. v. State Of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, Adarsh Kumar and others, applied under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act for determination of the value of a property and the corresponding stamp duty payable. The Sub-Registrar submitted a valuation report fixing the stamp duty at Rs. 86,300/-. Following this, the Collector Stamp directed the Sub-Registrar to communicate the decision regarding the stamp duty payable. Subsequently, a sale deed was registered on 9-8-2004 with stamp duty of Rs. 83,600/- paid accordingly. Mutation in the revenue records was alleged to have taken place based on this deed. The petitioners applied under Section 143 of the U.P.Z.A & L.R Act to have the land declared as Abadi, which was granted.
The petitioners intended to establish a petrol pump on the land. Neighbouring plot holders complained to the Collector alleging non-payment of proper stamp duty. The Collector directed an enquiry, and the Tehsildar initially reported that the stamp duty was correctly paid. However, the Collector Stamp required a fresh report, which revealed that the petrol pump was already constructed and that the land's potential had been suppressed at registration, indicating a deficiency in stamp duty. A notice under Sections 47-A/33 of the Stamp Act was issued. The petitioners objected, claiming the stamp duty had been duly paid under Section 31 and that further proceedings were not maintainable.
The petitioners filed a writ petition which was stayed temporarily but ultimately dismissed for availability of statutory appeal under Section 56-A of the Stamp Act. The Collector Stamp demanded Rs. 33,80,300/- along with an equal amount as fine. The petitioners appealed under Section 56-A, but the appeal was dismissed. The present writ petition challenges these orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the initial valuation and stamp duty determination under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act constituted a valid adjudication barring further proceedings under Sections 33 and 47-A of the Act.
- Whether the stamp duty demand based on the commercial potential of the land at the time of sale is justified, despite the petitioners’ claim that the land was agricultural at that time.
- Whether the penalty imposed, equal to the evaded stamp duty, is excessive or justified in the facts of the case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Adjudication under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act had already been done, and stamp duty was paid accordingly; hence, proceedings under Sections 47-A/33 are not maintainable.
- The land was agricultural at the time of purchase, and subsequent change in use for a petrol pump cannot form the basis for additional stamp duty demand treating the land as commercial.
- Reliance was placed on judgments including 1991 (2) ARC 364, 2006 (2) AWC 1492 (2006 (1) ALJ 711), and 2007 (102) RD 842 (2007 (4) ALJ 98) to support their contentions.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Surendra Swaroop Sharma v. Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue), Bulandshahr, 1991 (2) ARC 364 | Bar on proceedings under Section 33 if there is an expression of opinion under Section 31 by the Collector. | Distinguished as no expression of opinion under Section 31 was found in the present case, thus not barring proceedings under Section 33. |
| Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan v. Deputy Commissioner, AIR 1956 All 453 | Procedure for Sections 31 and 32: Collector’s opinion is advisory; Collector cannot compel payment or levy penalty. | Referred to explain the scope of Sections 31 and 32 and to clarify that no adjudication under Section 31 had taken place in the present case. |
| Government of Uttar Pradesh v. Raja Mohammad Amir Aham Khan, AIR 1961 SC 787 | Affirmation of the procedure and principles laid down in Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan case. | Used to support the interpretation of Sections 31 and 32 of the Stamp Act. |
| Orissa Cement Limited, Sahupuri, Varanasi v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, Allahabad, 2004 (1) AWC 871 (2004 All LJ 277) | Requirement that reasons must be disclosed for valuation and adjudication under Section 31 of the Stamp Act. | Applied to hold that no reasoned order or certificate was passed or obtained under Section 31 in the present case. |
| Shakumbari Sugar and Allied Industries Limited v. State of U.P, 2007 (102) RD 842 (2007 (4) ALJ 98) | Stamp duty to be determined with reference to the date of transaction, not a future date. | Accepted and applied to confirm that commercial potential was assessed as on the date of transaction. |
| Smt. Sushila Verma v. State of U.P, 2006 (2) AWC 1492 (2006 (1) ALJ 711) | Similar principle regarding valuation date for stamp duty assessment. | Accepted as consistent with the approach adopted in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the procedural history and found that no actual adjudication under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act had taken place because no instrument was presented before the Collector for adjudication and no reasoned order or certificate was issued as required under Section 32. The report submitted by the Sub-Registrar and the endorsement by the Additional District Magistrate did not constitute an adjudication under Section 31. Therefore, the petitioners’ contention that proceedings under Section 33 were barred by an earlier adjudication was rejected.
The Court noted the substantial discrepancy between the stamp duty paid (Rs. 83,600/-) and the amount later demanded (Rs. 33,80,300/-), indicating evasion of stamp duty with possible collusion, which is against public interest and must be dealt with firmly.
The Court further held that the commercial potential of the land was rightly determined with reference to the date of transaction, supported by evidence such as the petitioner’s application for petrol pump dealership, submission of site plans, and the commercial nature of the surrounding area. The finding that the land had commercial potential at the time of sale was affirmed by both the Additional District Magistrate and the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority.
Consequently, the demand for stamp duty at commercial rates and the penalty imposed were upheld. The Court declined to interfere under Article 226 of the Constitution, finding no perversity or lack of evidence in the authorities’ decisions.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is dismissed.
The Court upheld the demand for stamp duty at commercial rates based on the land's commercial potential at the time of sale and affirmed the penalty equal to the evaded amount. The decision confirms that no prior adjudication under Section 31 barred proceedings under Section 33 and that valuation for stamp duty purposes must reflect the true nature of the property as on the date of transaction. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the correct application of existing law and principles to the facts of this case. The direct effect is that the petitioners remain liable for the stamp duty demand and penalty as determined by the authorities.
1. Petitioners, Adarsh Kumar and others made an application under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act for determination of the value of the property, which was to be subject matter of transfer, and for determination of the stamp duty payable accordingly.
2. According to the petitioner the Sub-Registrar on 22-7-2007 submitted a valuation report in respect of the land as well as the stamp duty payable thereon, which was fixed at Rs. 86,300/-. After such determination, the report was placed before the Collector Stamp, who vide order dated 26-7-2007 directed the Sub-Registrar to communicate the decision so taken qua the stamp duty payable on the transaction under Section 31 of the Act. After such determination a sale-deed in respect of the property in question was registered on 9-8-2004 and stamp duty of Rs. 83,600/- was paid in respect thereto with reference to valuation report referred above. On the strength of the sale-deed, mutation in the revenue record is also alleged to have been taken place. The petitioner after such execution of the sale-deed on 10-2-2005 made an application for the land being declared as Abadi under Section 143 of the U.P.Z.A & L.R Act. The application so made by the petitioners was allowed and a declaration qua the change of the user of the land dated 20-5-2005 has been issued.
3. Since the petitioners wanted to set up a petrol pump on the land. The neighbouring plot holders filed a complaint before the Collector stating therein that the stamp duty has not been paid on the instrument of sale in accordance with law. On the aforesaid complaint, Collector Mahoba required the Tehsildar to hold an enquiry. The Tehsildar submitted his report on 14-2-2006 and opined that the stamp duty has rightly been paid on the sale-deed.
4. The Collector Stamp, however, required the Sub-Registrar to submit a fresh report, who on 18-3-2006 submitted his report and pointed out that petrol pump has already been constructed and was standing on the land in question. The fact qua the potential of the land was suppressed at the time of registration of the sale-deed. Hence there was a deficiency in the stamp duty paid. Accordingly, a reference was made. The Collector, Stamp issued a notice under Section 47-A/33 of the Act dated 20-3-2006. Petitioners filed their objections dated 4-4-2006 stating therein that the stamp duty has been paid as per the adjudication of the stamp duty under Section 31 of the Act and therefore proceedings on the strength of alleged deficiency are not maintainable and are liable to be dropped.
5. Against the notice the petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 22793 of 2006, wherein an interim stay order was granted. However, ultimately the writ petition was dismissed on the ground of availability of statutory appeal under Section 56-A of the Stamp Act.
6. The Collector, Stamp vide order dated 24-4-2006 held that the land purchased by the petitioners had commercial potential on the date it purchased and therefore the petitioner was liable to pay stamp duty at the rate applicable to area having commercial value. Accordingly, a demand of Rs. 33,80,300/- along with the fine of like amount has been raised against the petitioners. The total amount demanded has been fixed at Rs. 67,60,600/-.
7. Feeling aggrieved by the order of the Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue), the petitioner filed an appeal under Section 56-A of the Indian Stamp Act before the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, U.P, Allahabad, being Stamp Appeal No. 77/2006-2007. The appeal has been dismissed vide judgment and order dated 9-3-2007. It is against these two orders that the present writ petition has been filed.
8. On behalf of the petitioner it is contended that once adjudication has been done under Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act qua valuation of the property and stamp duty payable and further since the petitioners have acted upon the same by depositing the stamp duly, as calculated, no proceedings under Section 47-A/33 of the Stamp Act would be maintainable. It is stated that on the date the land was purchased, it was meant for agricultural purposes and subsequent change in the user of land, for establishing the retail out let, cannot be the basis for demand of additional stamp duty treating the land as having commercial potential. Reliance has been placed upon the Judgments reported in 1991 (2) ARC 364 : 2006 (2) AWC 1492 : (2006 (1) ALJ 711) and 2007 (102) RD 842 : (2007 (4) ALJ 98).
9. I have heard counsel for the parties and have gone through the records of the writ petition.
10. So far as the determination of the value of the land and stamp duty payable under Section 31 of the Stamp Act is concerned, suffice is to refer to the findings of the Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) as per his order dated 24-4-2006. It has been recorded that along with application for valuation of the property and stamp duty payable no instrument was presented and further that the application had only been submitted for the purposes of creating an evidence by the petitioner in his favour. It has been recorded that the application was initially presented before the Additional District Magistrate, who marked the same to the Stamp Clerk on 31-5-2004. The application was not presented before the Stamp Clerk by the petitioner, on the contrary was retained by him.
11. After the Additional District Magistrate was transferred and a new incumbent joined, a note was obtained to the effect that Sub-Registrar may submit the valuation report. The Sub-Registrar submitted his valuation report on which the Additional District Magistrate made a note that he may inform at his own level. The order of the Additional District Magistrate reads as follows:
“Sub-Registrar
(Vernacular Matter Omitted……Ed.)
12. Thereafter the deed was presented and the Sub-Registrar got the same registered without the same being ever presented before the Collector, as required under Section 32 of the Indian Stamp Act, for necessary certificate. It has been held that at no point of time any instrument in fact was presented, for adjudication of the proper stamp duty payable thereon, before the Collector nor any reasoned order was ever passed by the Collector qua adjudication of the proper stamp duty. It has also been recorded that at no point of time any certificate, as contemplated by Section 32 of the Act, was ever obtained on the instrument qua sufficiency of the stamp duty either before registration or subsequent to its registration.
13. From the facts, which have been noticed herein above, this Court has no hesitation to record that as a matter of fact no adjudication, as contemplated by Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act, has taken place in the facts of the present case. Report submitted by the Sub-Registrar, on which the endorsement made by the Additional District Magistrate is to the effect that the report may be communicated by the Sub-Registrar himself, specifically in the background where no instrument was presented along with the application for adjudication of the proper stamp duty, cannot be treated to be an adjudication contemplated by Section 31 of the Indian Stamp Act. Such order of the Additional District Magistrate is not referable as an adjudication of proper stamp duty under Section 31 of the Act.
14. This Court may record that the finding recorded by the Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) in its order dated 24-4-2006 are in accordance with law and are based on true and correct interpretation of scope of Section 31 read with Section 32 of the Indian Stamp Act. The Hon'ble High Court, Allahabad in the case of Orissa Cement Limited, Sahupuri, Varanasi v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, Allahabad/Revising Authority, reported in 2004 (1) AWC 871 : (2004 All LJ 277), has specifically issued directions that for an adjudication, to be made under Section 31 of the Stamp Act, reasons must be disclosed for the basis of the valuation of the property and the adjudication of the stamp duty.
15. From the facts of the present case it is apparently clear that the only order on record passed by the Additional District Magistrate, which according to the petitioner is an order under Section 31 as already been quoted hereinabove, is to the effect that the Sub-Registrar may communicate his report. Such orders by no stretch of imagination can be termed to be an adjudication under Section 31 of the Act. Consequently, the plea raised on behalf of the petitioner to the effect that the proceedings initiated under Section 33 of the Stamp Act are hit by the order issued under Section 31 is totally misplaced and is based on complete non-consideration of the order, which was passed by the Additional District Magistrate dated 20-7-2004 on the application made by the petitioner.
16. In view of the aforesaid facts, the judgment relied upon by the counsel for the petitioner in the case of Surendra Swaroop Sharma v. Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue), Bulandshahr, 1991 (2) ARC 364 is clearly distinguishable, inasmuch as there has been no expression of opinion under Section 31 of the Act by the Collector, which may bar the proceedings under Section 33. Reference may also be had to paragraph 4 of the said judgment wherein, with reference to the Full Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan v. Deputy Commissioner, AIR 1956 All 453, it has been noticed that the procedure, in qases to which Sections 31 and 32 apply is that when an instrument is brought before the Collector, he proceeds to give his opinion. After the Collector has given his opinion it is left entirely to the applicant to pay the duty or not and the Collector cannot, under the either of these sections compel its realization, nor can he levy any penalty though it may be that he can order the prosecution of the applicant. This Full Bench judgment has been affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Government of Uttar Pradesh v. Raja Mohammad Amir Aham Khan, AIR 1961 SC 787.
17. As already noticed above there has been no expression of opinion by the Collector under Section 31 in the facts of the present case and, therefore there can be no restriction on the proceedings under Section 33 of the Act on the instrument, as has been got registered by the petitioner.
18. Another striking feature specifically noticed in the facts of the present case is that according to the report of the Sub-Registrar, which according to the petitioner is referable to Section 31, the total stamp duty adjudicated on the instrument and in fact paid was Rs. 83,600/-. The stamp duty calculated in proceedings under Section 33, after determination of the true value of the stamp duty payable on the transaction, is fixed at Rs. 33,80,300/-, which is nearly 40 times the assessment as made by the Sub-Registrar earlier and which according to the petitioner is referable to Section 31. The difference between these two figures is too larger and cannot be overlooked. Evasion of stamp duty with the connivance of the officers, so as to cause loss to public exchequer, would be against public interest and has to be dealt with firmly.
19. Therefore, even if the contention raised on behalf of the petitioner is taken as correct for the sake of arguments, this Court would refuses to exercise its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in favour of the petitioner.
20. The Court may also deal with the other objection raised on behalf of the petitioner to the effect that the potential of the land is to be determined with reference to the date on which it was purchased and not with reference to any future date. The legal position as stated by the counsel for the petitioner with reference to the judgments in the case of Shakumbari Sugar and Allied Industries Limited v. State of U.P, 2007 (102) RD 842 : (2007 (4) ALJ 98) and Smt. Sushila Verma v. State of U.P, 2006 (2) AWC 1492 : (2006 (1) ALJ 711) is not in dispute.
21. In the facts of the present case it would be apparent from the reasons recorded hereinunder that the commercial potential of the property under transaction has been arrived at with reference to the date of transaction and not with reference to any future date. The authorities have found that on the date transfer has been executed, the property in question had commercial potential and therefore they have determined the stamp duty payable, after application of the commercial rates applicable to the area. For the said conclusion following facts have been noticed.
22. The Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue) has recorded that even before making an application under Section 31 of the Stamp Act, the petitioner had already made an application on 12-9-2003 for grant of Dealership of a petrol/diesel outlet. A site plan for construction of the retail outlet on the land subject matter of the instrument was submitted by the petitioner for the purposes of obtaining no objection certificate qua grant of an Explosive licence under the Petroleum Act and Rules. The land is situate on National Highway Mirzapur-Jhansi (NH-76) in the commercial area of city Mahoba, within 300 meter of the land, Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Roadways, District Hospital, Civil Court, District Magistrate residence, Magistrate Office and other commercial establishments like Banquiete Hall, Marriage Hall, Motor Vehicle Showroom were in existence. Lastly it has been noticed that the total area of land covered by the transaction is so small so as to be put to any agricultural use.
23. In the totality of the circumstances noticed above, it has been held that the land purchased by the petitioner had commercial potential and therefore stamp duty applicable at the commercial rate in the area had to be applied.
24. The total stamp duty payable on such transaction has been fixed at Rs. 33,80,300/-. The findings of fact recorded by the District Magistrate have been affirmed by the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, U.P, Allahabad in an appeal under Section 56-A of the Stamp Act. The findings of fact cannot be said to be perverse or based on no evidence so as to warrant any interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
25. This Court may record that both the authorities under the Stamp Act have recorded a categorical finding that a deliberate attempt was made by the petitioner to evade the stamp duty and evidence was created for the purposes of defrauding the State Exchequer.
26. In view of the aforesaid conclusion arrived at by the authorities, the demand of penalty of an amount equivalent to the stamp duty evaded in the facts of the case cannot be said to be exorbitant.
27. Writ petition lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.
28. Petition dismissed.
Alert