Or. Admin. R. 413-115-0130 : — DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES, CHILD WELFARE PROGRAMSAPPLICATION OF THE INDIAN CHILD WELFARE ACT (ICWA) —115-0130 - Standards of Evidence and Minimum Qualifications for a Qualified Expert Witness
(1) Preponderance of the Evidence.
Emergency removals. When requesting court authorization for
emergency removal at a shelter hearing, the
Department must demonstrate to the court that the
Department has complied with
ORICWA Notice requirements, that removal of the
Indian child or ward is in the
Indian child's best interest, and that a preponderance of the evidence indicates that protective custody is necessary to prevent
imminent physical damage or harm to the
Indian child.
(2) Clear and Convincing.
(a)Foster care placement. Except during an
emergency proceeding, when requesting court authorization for the placement of an
Indian child in foster care, the
Department must demonstrate, by clear and convincing evidence, that continued custody of the
Indian child with the
parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child. The
Department's presentation of evidence must include the testimony of at least one QEW, as defined in section (3) of this rule.
(b) Durable
Guardianship finalization pursuant to ORS
419B.366. When requesting court appointment of a
guardian pursuant toORS
419B.366, the
Department must demonstrate, by clear and convincing evidence, that
continued custody of the
Indian child with the
parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child. The
Department's presentation of evidence must include the testimony of at least one QEW, as defined in section (3) of this rule.
(3) Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.
(a) Permanent
Guardianship finalization pursuant to ORS
419B.365. When requesting court appointment of a
guardian pursuant to ORS
419B.365, the
Department must demonstrate, by evidence beyond a reasonable doubt, that
continued custody of the
Indian child with the
parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child. The
Department's presentation of evidence must include the testimony of at least one QEW, as defined in section (3) of this rule.
(b)Termination of parental rights. When requesting judicial
termination of parental rights, the
Department must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that
continued custody of the
Indian child by the
parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child, and that active efforts to reunite the
Indian family did not eliminate the necessity for termination based on serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child. The
Department's presentation of evidence must include the testimony of at least one
QEW, as defined in section (3) of this rule.
(4)Qualified expert witness (
QEW).
(a) A
QEW must be qualified to testify regarding:
(A) Whether the
Indian child's
continued custody by the
Indian child's
parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child; and
(B) The prevailing social and cultural standards and
child rearing practices of the
Indian child's tribe.
(b) The
Department must work with the
Indian child's tribe to determine who should be designated to testify as a QEW. If the
Indian child's tribe declines or is unable to designate a
QEW, the following individuals, in order of priority, may testify as a
qualified expert witness:
(A) A
member of the
Indian child's tribe or another person of the tribe's choice who is recognized by the tribe as knowledgeable of tribal customs regarding family organization, extensive knowledge of prevailing social and cultural standards and
child rearing practices;
(B) A person having substantial experience in the delivery of
child and family services to
Indians and extensive knowledge of prevailing social and cultural standards and
child rearing practices within the
Indian child's tribe; or
(C) Any person having substantial experience in the delivery of
child and family services to
Indians and knowledge of prevailing social and cultural standards and
child rearing practices in
Indian tribes with cultural similarities to the
child's tribe.
(c)Department staff may not serve as a QEW in any
child custody proceeding.