Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Matter of Scott E. v. Annette D.

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, New York
Nov 12, 2026

Matter of Scott E. v Annette D.

2026 NY Slip Op 06597 November 12, 2026 Appellate Division, Third Department Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. This decision is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports. In the Matter of Scott E., Respondent,

v

Annette D., Appellant. (And Two Other Related Proceedings.)

Decided and Entered:November 12, 2026

CV-24-0096

Calendar Date: September 17, 2026

Before: Clark, J.P., Ceresia, Mcshan, Powers And Ryba, JJ.

Stephanie L. Hanrahan, Syracuse, for appellant.

Sara Morton Law, Elmira (Sara A. Morton of counsel), for respondent. Andrea J. Mooney, Ithaca, attorney for the child.

[*1]

McShan, J.

Appeal from an order of the Family Court of Chemung County (Mary Tarantelli, J.), entered December 13, 2023, which, among other things, granted petitioner's applications, in two proceedings pursuant to Family Ct Act article 6, for custody of the parties' children.

Petitioner (hereinafter the father) and respondent (hereinafter the mother) are the parents of the subject children (born in 2014 [hereinafter the son] and 2019 [hereinafter the daughter]). The parties were in a relationship for approximately 10 years and resided in the City of Elmira, Chemung County from January 2021 to February 2022. Following separate neglect adjudications against each parent â​​ both stemming from the mother's intoxicated state while caring for the son â​​ the maternal grandparents, who reside in North Carolina, were awarded custody of the son in April 2017. Three months later, the parents were awarded joint legal and physical custody of the son upon the parents' and the grandparents' consent.

In 2022, the father brought the children to the grandparents' home in North Carolina where they would remain for the 2022-2023 school year while the mother engaged in treatment nearby for her alcoholism. In March 2023, the mother filed a custody petition and a petition for an order of protection in North Carolina and the North Carolina District Court issued an order of protection against the father in favor of the mother but not for the children. In response, in May 2023, the father filed a petition in New York to establish custody as to the daughter and petitions for modification and enforcement of the existing custody order as to the son.FN1 Following a fact-finding hearing and a Lincoln hearing, Family Court granted the parties joint legal custody, with final decision-making authority to the father, and awarded the father primary physical custody with liberal parenting time to the mother. In reaching this determination, the court construed the father's modification petition as an initial custody petition and, accordingly, focused its analysis exclusively on what custodial arrangement would serve the children's best interests. Separately, the court also granted the father's enforcement petition and issued an admonishment to the mother.FN2 The mother appeals. We affirm. To begin, we agree with the mother that because there had been a prior custody order for the son, Family Court erred in construing the matter as an initial custody determination as to him. Although Family Court did not make an express finding of a change in circumstances due to this erroneous interpretation, "this Court's authority in custody cases is as broad as that of Family Court and, therefore, we may review the record and make an independent determination as to whether the requisite showing of a change in circumstances was made" (Matter of Andrea II. v Joseph HH., 203 AD3d 1356, 1357 [3d Dept 2022] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; accord Matter of Joshua PP. v Danielle PP., 205 AD3d 1153, 1155[*2][3d Dept 2022], lv denied 39 NY3d 901 [2022]). Having conducted our own independent review, we find that the mother's relocation to North Carolina coupled with the breakdown of the parties' informal agreement that the children would return to New York at the conclusion of the 2022-2023 school year establish the requisite change in circumstances pertinent to the son (see Matter of Linden L. v Justin M., 246 AD3d 1226, 1226 [3d Dept 2026]; Matter of Jennifer HH. v Alavanh II., 243 AD3d 1170, 1171-1172 [3d Dept 2025]). Our inquiry thus distills to what custodial arrangement is in the best interests of the children, which "requires the consideration of factors such as the quality of the parents' respective home environments, the need for stability in the child[ren's] li[ves], each parent's willingness to promote a positive relationship between the child[dren] and the other

1

parent and each parent's past performance, relative fitness and ability to provide for the child[ren's] intellectual and emotional development and overall well-being" (Matter of Dusten T. v Trisha U., 235 AD3d 1215, 1216 [3d Dept 2025] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citations omitted]; see Matter of Collen NN. v Patrice OO., 249 AD3d 1256, 1257 [3d Dept 2026]). As relevant here, "[w]hen determining the children's best interests, Family Court must consider the effect of domestic violence when the allegations of domestic violence are proven by a preponderance of the evidence" (Matter of Justin K. v Jutonynea L., 221 AD3d 1335, 1336 [3d Dept 2023] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citations omitted]). Further, where, as here, relocation is implicated due to a parent's desire to move, "relocation must be considered within the framework of what custodial arrangement would serve the child[ren]'s best interests"

(Matter of Jennifer HH. v Alavanh II., 243 AD3d at 1172 [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Douglas CC. v Musique DD., 243 AD3d 1180, 1181-1182 [3d Dept 2025]). "Because Family Court is in a superior position to assess witness credibility and make findings of fact, this Court will not disturb Family Court's decision so long as it is supported by a sound and substantial basis in the record" (Matter of Thomas K. v Shauna L., 242 AD3d 1335, 1337 [3d Dept 2025] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Aden HH. v Charish GG., 226 AD3d 1109, 1111 [3d Dept 2024]).

The record demonstrates that both parties are loving caregivers and desire to play a meaningful role in the children's lives. However, the mother's long struggle with alcoholism, and the effect it has had on her ability to parent, was front and center throughout the hearing and was a notable factor in Family Court's determination (see generally Matter of Sierra KK. v Brett LL., 248 AD3d 1643, 1645 [3d Dept 2026]). To be sure, the mother had seemingly made progress in treating her addiction and the maternal grandmother, who lives nearby, offered a support system [*3]for the mother while she pursued that goal. Yet, the record established that the mother had previously made similar attempts that had failed, and her recent attempt to attain sobriety was still in its early stages. We find that these facts provide a sound and substantial basis for Family Court's determination that granting primary physical custody to the father offered a more stable environment for the children (see Matter of Kowatch v Johnson, 68 AD3d 1493, 1496 [3d Dept 2009], lv denied 14 NY3d 704 [2010]; cf. Matter of Erick RR. v Victoria SS., 206 AD3d 1523, 1526 [3d Dept 2022]; Matter of Shirreece AA. v Matthew BB., 195 AD3d 1085, 1090 [3d Dept 2021]).

Further, the mother's decision to relocate and her ensuing efforts to hide that choice from the father until filing for custody in North Carolina provide support for Family Court's assessment that the father was more willing to foster a relationship between the children and the mother. The mother characterizes this decision as an effort to protect herself from domestic violence, however, the record reflects that her relocation was due to her being admitted into a substance abuse treatment facility rather than fleeing an abusive situation (compare Matter of Hill v Dean, 135 AD3d 990, 991- 992 [3d Dept 2016]). Moreover, deferring to Family Court's credibility assessments, we find no basis to disturb its determination that the mother's allegations of physical violence were unsupported or that any of the inappropriate exchanges between the parties impacted the children. On that point, the record fairly reflects that both parties bore responsibility for the acrimonious relationship between them and, ultimately, Family Court gave appropriate consideration to the domestic violence concerns raised by the mother (see Matter of Alex Y. v Mindy X., 245 AD3d 1114, 1117 [3d Dept 2026]; see also Matter of Frankie CC. v Rachel CC., 225 AD3d 1112, 1115 [3d Dept 2024]; compare Matter of Justin K. v Jutonynea L., 221 AD3d at 1336). All told, deferring to Family Court's credibility determinations and assessing the totality of the circumstances, we find that the court's determination granting the parties modified joint custody with primary physical custody to the father has a sound and substantial basis in the record (see Matter of Alexander I. v Allison I., 246 AD3d 1230, 1232 [3d Dept 2026]; Matter of Jesse HH. v Lindsey II., 233 AD3d 1410, 1413 [3d Dept 2024], lvs denied 43 NY3d 906 [2025], 43 NY3d 906 [2025]; see also Matter of Mathena XX. v Brandon YY.,

189 AD3d 1733, 1737 [3d Dept 2020]).FN3 Finally, the mother's contention that Family Court exhibited bias throughout the proceeding is unpreserved based upon her failure to move for recusal (see Matter of Amanda YY. v Faisal ZZ., 198 AD3d 1125, 1129 [3d Dept 2021], lv denied

38 NY3d 908 [2022]; Matter of Patrick EE. v Brenda DD., 129 AD3d 1235, 1238 [3d Dept 2015], lv denied 26 NY3d 908 [2015]) and, in any event, is unsupported (see Matter of Amanda YY. v Faisal [*4]ZZ., 198 AD3d at 1129; Matter of Carl KK. v Michelle JJ., 175 AD3d 1627, 1629 [3d Dept 2019]). The mother's remaining contentions, to the extent not expressly addressed herein, have been considered and found to be lacking in merit. Clark, J.P., Ceresia, Powers and Ryba, JJ., concur.

ORDERED that the order is affirmed, without costs.

Footnotes

Footnote 1 Family Court communicated with the appropriate North Carolina District Court over the subject matter jurisdiction of the children and the North Carolina District Court ultimately entered an order determining that New York was the home state for the children and that North Carolina would decline to exercise any jurisdictional authority that state may possess (see generally Domestic Relations Law art 5-A).

Footnote 2

In March 2026, the father filed a modification petition. That proceeding remains pending as of the time of this decision. Footnote 3

The mother's contentions directed at Family Court's observations of the children during the Lincoln hearing, and the mother's ability to challenge those findings, are without merit. "As we have explained, information shared by a child during a Lincoln hearing may serve to corroborate other evidence adduced at a fact-finding hearing or to ascertain a

2

child's thoughts and feelings regarding the crafting of a custodial arrangement, but such considerations must remain silent to ensure that the child's right to confidentiality is protected" (Matter of C.M. v Z.N., 230 AD3d 1409, 1413 [3d Dept 2024] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citation omitted]). The information garnered from the Lincoln hearing and the relevance of such information to Family Court's determination did not extend beyond those principles and could not be challenged due to its confidential nature.

3