- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
In Re: Paraquat Products Liability Litigation v. Syngenta Crop Protection, LLC
Page 1 of 2
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
In re: PARAQUAT PRODUCTS
LIABILITY LITIGATION
This Document Relates to All Cases Case No. 3:21-md-3004-NJR MDL No. 3004
ORDER ADOPTING SPECIAL MASTER'S
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
ROSENSTENGEL, District Judge:
Pending before the Court are two Report and Recommendations filed by Special Master Randi S. Ellis pertaining to MDL member cases that are subject to dismissal due to noncompliance with Case Management Order No. 10 ("CMO 10"). (Docs. 5677, 5796). The Special Master recommends that 27 cases be dismissed due to the Plaintiffs' failure to comply with their production obligations under CMO 10. (Id.).
Case Management Order No. 10
The Court issued CMO 10 on October 27, 2021, to "govern[] the implementation of the Plaintiff Assessment Questionnaire ("PAQ")" in this MDL. (Doc. 469). CMO 10 requires all Plaintiffs to complete a PAQ and serve it upon Defendants within 30 days of their complaint being entered on the docket. If a Plaintiff fails to comply with this deadline, CMO 10 implements a notification process by which Defendants are required to send Plaintiff's counsel a Notice of Overdue PAQ. The receipt of a Notice of Overdue PAQ triggers a 30-day grace period for a Plaintiff whose PAQ is overdue. If, after the expiration of the grace period, the Plaintiff still has not completed the PAQ or cured a
Page 2 of 2
material PAQ deficiency, Defendants may seek review by the Special Master. Once the Special Master becomes involved, a Plaintiff has 10 days to either (a) substantially complete and serve the PAQ upon Defendants; or (b) submit an opposition to Defendants' request for review demonstrating "good and justified cause" for the delinquency. After this additional 10-day period expires, the failure to cure or justify the noncompliance with CMO 10 subjects the Plaintiff's case to dismissal without prejudice. Defendants initiated the CMO 10 review process with respect to the 27 cases identified in the Special Master's Report and Recommendations. The Special Master found that "none of the Plaintiffs or their Representatives . . . has served a PAQ, nor has any Plaintiff . . . demonstrated good cause or justified cause for failing to timely submit a PAQ." Having received no objections from the Plaintiffs whose cases are subject to dismissal, the Court fully ADOPTS the Special Master's Report and Recommendations (Docs. 5677, 5796). See F ED R. CIV. P. 53(f).
The 27 member cases listed in Exhibit A of each Report and Recommendation (Doc. 5677-1, 5796-1) are DISMISSED without prejudice pursuant to CMO 10.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED: June 10, 2026 ____________________________
NANCY J. ROSENSTENGEL
United States District Judge
Alert