Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Board of Professional Responsibility, Wyoming State Bar v. Vaughn H. Neubauer, Wsb 6-3443

Supreme Court of Wyoming
Apr 29, 2026

IN THE SUPREME COURT, STATE OF WYOMING

2026 WY 48

April Term, A.D. 2026 April 29, 2026

BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL

RESPONSIBILITY, WYOMING

STATE BAR,

Petitioner, v.

VAUGHN H. NEUBAUER, WSB

#6-3443,

Respondent.

D-26-0002

ORDER OF THREE-YEAR SUSPENSION

[¶1] This matter came before the Court upon a Report and Recommendation for Three- Year Suspension, filed herein March 24, 2026, by the Board of Professional Responsibility for the Wyoming State Bar, pursuant to Rule 16 of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure. The Court notes Respondent has not filed an objection to the Board of Professional Responsibility's Report and Recommendation. The Court, after a careful review of the Board of Professional Responsibility's Report and Recommendation and the file, finds that the Report and Recommendation should be approved, confirmed and adopted by the Court, and that Respondent Vaughn H. Neubauer should be suspended from the practice of law for three years. It is, therefore,

[¶2] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that the Board of Professional Responsibility's Report and Recommendation for Three-Year Suspension, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein, shall be, and the same hereby is, approved, confirmed, and adopted by this Court; and it is further

[¶3] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that, as a result of the conduct set forth in the Report and Recommendation for Three-Year Suspension, Vaughn H. Neubauer shall be

1

suspended from the practice of law for three years, with the period of suspension to begin May 29, 2026; and it is further;

[¶4] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that, during the period of suspension, Respondent shall comply with the requirements of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, particularly Rule 21 of those rules. That rule governs the duties of disbarred and suspended attorneys; and it is further

[¶5] ORDERED that, pursuant to Rule 25 of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, Mr. Neubauer shall reimburse the Wyoming State Bar the amount of $50, representing the costs incurred in handling this matter, as well as pay the administrative fee of $750.00. Mr. Neubauer shall pay the total amount of $800 to the Wyoming State Bar on or before May 11, 2026. If Mr. Neubauer fails to make payment in the time allotted, execution may issue on the award; and it is further

[¶6] ORDERED that the Clerk of this Court shall docket this Order of Three-Year Suspension, along with the incorporated Report and Recommendation for Three-Year Suspension, as a matter coming regularly before this Court as a public record; and it is further

[¶7] ORDERED that, pursuant to Rule 9(b) of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, this Order of Three-Year Suspension, along with the incorporated Report and Recommendation for Three-Year Suspension, shall be published in the Wyoming Reporter and the Pacific Reporter; and it is further

[¶8] ORDERED that the Clerk of this Court cause a copy of this Order of Three-Year Suspension to be served upon Respondent Vaughn H. Neubauer. [¶9] DATED this 29thday of April, 2026.

BY THE COURT:

/s/

LYNNE BOOMGAARDEN

Chief Justice

2

IN

THE SUPREME COURTSTATE OF WYOMING

FILED

MAR

24 2026

BEFORE

THE

SUPREME COURT

STATE OF WYOMING

WSB #6-3443,

)

BPR 2025-88 Respondent.

)

)

SHAWNA GOETZ, CLERK

In the matter

of

D-26-0002VAUGHNH. NEUBAUER REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION FOR THREE-YEAR

SUSPENSION

THIS

MATTER

came before a Hearing Panel of the Board of Professional Responsibility of the Wyoming State Bar ("BPR") on March 5, 2026, for a sanction hearing via

Zoom

telecon- ference. Hearing Panel members Kylie Waldrip (chair), Susan Chapin Stubson and Brett McPeak were in attendance. The Wyoming State Bar was represented by Bar

Counsel, Mark W. Gifford. Respondent Vaughn Neubauer was present. Having considered Bar

Counsel's sanction hearing briefand the parties' presentationsdur- ing the sanction hearing, the Hearing Panel unanimously FINDS, CONCLUDES and RECOM- MENDS as follows:

Findings of Fact

A Formal Charge was filed in this

matter on January 2, 2026. Respondentwas

servedvia certified mail and email the same day. Rule 14, W.R.Disc.P.,

provides:

Rule 14. Answer to Formal Charge -

Filing,

Failure to Answer, Default.

(a) Answer. Within twenty (20) days

after service of theformal charge, or within suchgreater period of time asmaybeapprovedbytheBPR oraDisciplinary Judge, the respondent shall file the original ofananswertotheformal

chargewith the BPR Clerk and shall

servea

copy

upon Bar Counsel.

Intheanswertherespond- ent shall either admit or deny every material allegation contained

intheformal charge, orrequestthattheallegationbesetforth with greater particularity.Inaddi- tion, the respondent shall set forth in theanswer any affirmative

defenses. Any

3

objection to the formal charge whicharespondentmay

assert, including achallenge to the formal

charge for failuretocharge misconduct constituting

grounds for dis- cipline, mustalso besetforthintheanswer.

(b) Failure to answer; default; failuretoappear.

(1) If the respondent failstofileananswer withintheperiod providedby subsection (a) of this Rule, Bar

Counsel shall fileamotion for

default with the BPR

Clerk. Thereafter, the

BPR

Clerk

shall enteradefaultand the formal charge shallbedeemed admitted; provided, however, thata respondent who fails to fileatimely

answer may, uponashowingthat the failure to answer was theresult of mistake,

inadvertence,

surprise, or excusable neglect, obtain leave oftheBPRtofileananswer.

(2)

Notwithstandingtheentry ofadefault,Bar

Counsel

shallgivethere- spondent notice ofthesanction hearing, atwhich

Bar

Counselandthe respondent may appearandpresent evidenceandargumentstotheBPR regarding the form of disciplinetobeimposed. ThereaftertheBPR

shall conduct a sanction hearing andorderaprivate

reprimandorsubmitits report and recommendationtotheCourtasprovided in Rule15.

(3) Iftherespondent shouldfailtoappearwhensoorderedby theBPR, the respondent shallbedeemedtohave

admittedthefactual allegations which weretobethesubject ofsuch

appearance and/ortohavecon- ceded any motion or recommendationstobeconsidered atsuch

appear- ance. The BPR

shall not,

absent good

cause, continue or delay

proceed- ings due to therespondent's failuretoappear. Respondent failed to fileanAnswertotheFormal

Charge.OnFebruary 2,2026, Default was

entered. PursuanttoRule 14(b)(1), theallegations oftheFormal

Chargearedeemed admitted. By

virtueof

Respondent's failuretorespondtotheformal

chargeand thedefault

entered in this matter,thefollowing

allegations of theformal charge aredeemed admitted

pursuanttoRule 14(b)(1), W.R.Disc.P.:

1. Respondent Vaughn

Neubauer was

admitted to the Wyoming

State Bar on April 25, 2001. His

Laramie-based

practicehaslargely

focusedoncriminal law,

thoughheoccasionally does civil

litigation.

2. Over

the years,

the Office of

Bar

Counsel has received 17 complaints

against Re- spondent, with eight of those received since

2021. He receivedaprivate

reprimand

in 2009 and a

2

diversion in 2022. During 2025, theWyoming

Supreme Court

approvedastipulated, 30-day sus- pension

stayeduponsuccessful completion of six

months' probation. The

order stemmedfromtwo complaints, onesubmitted byaclientforwhom

Respondenthadbotchedanappeal andtheother submitted

by

a client for whom Respondent's office

missedafiling

deadlineonapetition for

post- conviction relief. The stipulated disciplinesetterms of Respondent's

probationasfollows:

*

Respondent will

submit monthly,

written reports to the Office of Bar

Counsel ("OBC") regarding Respondent's

compliance

with the terms of his

probation. The monthly reports shall commence30days

aftertheentry ofanOrder by theWyo- ming Supreme Courtandshall continue untiltheprobationary termofsix

months is

complete. *

Within ten days of the entry of an Order by the Wyoming

Supreme Court, Re- spondent will

reviewtheself-audit checklist

available ontheBar website https://www.wyomingbar.org/for-lawyers/lawyer-resources/law-office-self-audit- checklist/) and take the

ALPS

Virtual

Ethics Risk

Assessment

Quiz andreviewthe practice tools availableathttps://www.alpsinsurance.com/resources/risk-manage- ment. Respondent will provide thecompleted self-audit checklistto theOBC

for review and feedback.ThePanel notes thatRespondenthasalready

commenced re- view of the self-audit checklist. *

Within 30 days of

the entry of

an Order by

the Wyoming

Supreme Court, Re- spondent will review

his electronicandpaper filestodetermine whether improved organization is

needed. Respondent will

separate closed mattersfrom openmatters. The Panel notes thatRespondentandAssistant

reviewedmanyfiles

aftertheCom- plaints were filedbutwilldosoagainaspartof

probation. *

Within

thirty days of the entry of an Order by

the Wyoming

Supreme Court, Re- spondent will

implementacalendaring strategy thatprovides multiple

remindersin advance of

deadlines. Upon agreeingtorepresentation, Respondentandhisoffice staff will

identify deadlines anddeterminethelength of timeto setremindersin advance of the deadlines. The deadlines willbeon,ataminimum,

Respondent's and one office staff member's

calendar. The

Panel notes that Respondenthasal- ready reviewed

deadlinesandadjusted

reminderstoensure greater notice of

dead- lines. ¢

Within sixty days of the entry of an Order by the Wyoming

Supreme Court, Re- spondent will develop andadopt detailed law

office policies andprocedures for calendaring/docketing asstated above,

periodic reviews of

active cases,mailpro- cessing, client

relationship,

termination of

representation andstaff

management. Said policies andprocedures will bereviewedandapprovedby theOBCandreflect Respondent's vigilant

commitmenttobestpractices assetforthin theWyoming State Bar's Law

Office Self-Audit

Checklist. Respondent shall

attendaminimum of

three Continuing Legal

Education

Credits ("CLE") related to law

office

management or time management. Additionally, Re- spondent shall attend aminimum of

three CLE

credits relatedtolaw office man- agement, or time-management,orwell-being.

Respondent will

provide proof of

3

CLE totheOBC. *

Respondent will address with office staff the importance of

accuracy in all

mat- ters, including communications with third parties via email ormail. ¢

During the period of probation, which

shall be a six-month probation, Respondent shall commit no further violations oftheWyoming Rules of

Professional

Conduct. The six-month probationary period was to beginJune2,

2025, andconcludeon orabout December

2, 2025.

3. Neubauer's compliance with

the terms of his

probation

was

spotty. He

submitted his monthly reports for June, JulyandAugust, submitted his

September reportamonth late, and essentially didn't submit reports for

OctoberorNovember.

4. This formal charge stems from acomplaint

submitted inlateJuly

of2025by Kyle and Kaelyn Christensen, who

were namedasindividual

defendants along with

their company, K-

K

Construction,

LLC, inabreachof

contract action broughtby acouple,TimandLoriLibel, who paid the defendants $180,000toconstructabarndominium!ontheir

property. The

lawsuit was filed in March 2024intheDistrict CourtfortheFirst Judicial Districtby

Cheyenne

attorney Justin Hesser.

5. The defendants were first

represented by

Cheyenne

attorney Kaleb

Gibertoni, who timely filed an answerandcounterclaimsonbehalfof alldefendants, but thensoughttowithdraw after the defendants couldnotcomeupwithhis

retainer. Judge

Catherine Rogers

allowed

Gibertoni to withdraw from representing the Christensens

but conditioned his withdrawalasthe attorney for K-K

Construction,LLC, ontheentryof

appearanceby

replacement

counsel.

6. The Christensens

then retained Respondent in

late June

2024,

agreeing to pay him a $30,000 flat fee. Respondent

entered his

appearance

on behalfof all

defendants

on July 2, 2024. tbarndominium noun [C] UK / ba:n.do'min.i.om/US/ba:rn.domin.i.sm/,atypeofhousemadeofmetalorwoodthatcom- bines a large,

open-plan living

space with agarage orworkshop. https://dictionaryblog.cam- bridge.org/2025/02/24/new-words-24-february-2025/

4

7. Hesser filed

an amended complaint

on September 20, 2024.

Respondent never filed an answer. On October 4, 2024, Hesser filedamotion for order compelling

discovery from

de- fendants. Respondent

did not filearesponse.

8. On February 3, 2025, Judge Rogers

entered an order imposing

sanctions against all defendants for failure to comply with discovery, ordering thedefendantstopay plaintiffs $2,879.14 within 30 days.

9. On February 20, 2025,

Hesser filed amotion for

summary judgment and supporting brief onbehalf oftheplaintiffs.

Respondent never filedaresponse.

10. On June 17, 2025, Judge Rogers

issuedanorder setting

a hearing

on plaintiffs' motion for summary judgmentforJune30,2025. Phone

records produced bytheChristensens support their claim thatRespondent never informed themofthesummary judgment

motion until the night before the hearing, when they

hada14-minute conversation with

Respondent.

11.

On July 21, 2025, Judge Rogers

entered a judgment

against

defendants in the amount of$186,000. On July 30, 2025, theChristensens

submittedacomplaint

against

Respondent to the Office of Bar Counsel.

12. Respondent's failures fortheChristensens

occurred in

the same time

frame his sus- pension with

probationcasewas workingitsway totheCourt.OnMarch

21, 2025,

Respondent signed an affidavit of

conditional

admissiontoviolations of

Rule1.3inthetwo

pending discipli- nary matters.OnMarch26,2025, astipulation for

suspension with

probation was filed with the Board

of

Professional Responsibility. The BPR's

reportandrecommendationtoapprove thestip- ulation was filed with theCourtonApril21,2025. The

Court

issuedits

orderonMay29,2025.

13. Upon receipt of the Christensens' complaint,

the Office of

Bar

Counsel

requested additional

documentation from thembefore initiatinganinvestigation. When theChristensen's produced the requested recordsinearly

September, Bar

Counsel initiatedaninvestigation

for

5

potential violations of Rules

1.3 (diligence) and1.4(communication with clients), mailing Re- spondent a

copy of

the complaint and supporting documents. Bar

Counsel requestedawritten response by September 22,

2025,

to be accompanied by "your engagement agreement, time records and all

emails

or other evidence of communications

in the underlying case."

14. Respondent did not submit a timely response. On

September 26,

2025, Bar Counsel wrote to Respondent again, requesting a written response by

October10,2025. Latetheevening of October 10, 2025, Respondent emailed his

three-page responsetoBarCounsel.

Respondent claimed he should

not

have taken the case and he "didn't know whattodoorhowtodoit." He said it was difficult to get documents from his clients andconceded, "I knowIamnotblameless in this disaster. I never should have

taken the case, I should have

hired co-counsel,Ishould have made a greater effort to communicate with Mr.

Christensen,andIshould have withdrawn from the case once I realized Mr.

Christensen would not comply with the plaintiffs

discovery

requests."

Respondent said he was "in the midst ofaprettybadcaseof

depressionat thetime. I'm sure this affected my performance. I know I share blame here,butIthink Mr.

Christensen carriesalot

too."

He concluded his responsewiththefollowing:

This happened before Iwentonprobationoverother matters, andI'm

makingalot of progress on this

front. IknowIdidwrongforMr.Christensen,butnotnearlyas wrong asheclaims. I shouldhavewithdrawn,andIdon't really haveagoodex- planation for why

J

didn't. I know I didn't

perform perfectly,

butMr.

Christensen's lack of assistancewasthemainfactorinmy

opinion. Thank you

for your

consideration ofthis

response.Iwill

of

course provideany further answers or documents you

may

request; just please letmeknow. LikeIsaid, I know I failed in certain requests

here. I would just ask that you

consider that I have taken a LOT

of steps tocopewith my

depression since then.Ihaveresolved to never touch another civil case again.Ihave

taken steps in a lot of

other respects since all this happened. Ihopewe canhaveaproductive discussion whenconsid- ering what consequences I need to facefor

this.

15. On

October 23, 2025, Bar

Counsel sent

the following emailtoRespondent:

6

In my opening letter dated September 8, 2025, I asked

you to produce, with

your response to the Christensen complaint, a copy of your engagement agreement, time records andall

emails orother evidence

of

communicationsintheunderlying case. Please produce these records by the close of business tomorrow.

16. On October 24,

2025,

Respondent produced 30 pages of records, including acopy of the engagement agreement with Christensens,

phone recordsandscattered emails.

17. Respondent did not comply

with the monthly reporting requirement for the last

two months of his

probationary period.

18. Bar Counsel's

investigation of Respondent has revealed clear

and convincing evi- dence of violations ofRule 1.3 (diligence) in his

representation oftheChristensens. Moreover, his failure to comply with the terms ofhis probation places himinviolation ofRule

3.4(c) (knowingly disobeying an obligation under the rules of a tribunal).

19. On

December 29, 2025,

the Review

and Oversight

Committee

issuedanorder of finding of probable cause, authorizing Bar Counseltofile aformal charge against

Respondent. Respondent's misconduct havingbeenestablished, itnowbecomes necessaryfortheHear- ing Panel to determine the appropriate discipline.SeeRule 15(b)(3)(C), W.R.Disc.P. Sanction

Analysis Rule 15(b)(3)(D), W.R.Disc.,P., lists thefactorstobeconsideredin

determining lawyer sanctions:

(D) Inimposingasanction afterafindingof

misconductby therespondent,the

BPR

shall considerthefollowing

factors,asenumerated intheABA

Stand- ards for Imposing Lawyer Sanctions, which

standards shallbeapplied bythe BPR in

determiningtheappropriate sanction:

(i) Whether thelawyerhasviolatedadutyowedtoaclient,to thepublic, to the legal system, or to the profession;

(ii)

Whetherthelawyer acted intentionally, knowingly,ornegligently;

(iii) The actual orpotential injury causedby thelawyer's

misconduct; and

7

(iv) Theexistenceofanyaggravating ormitigating

factors. The American Bar Association's

StandardsforImposing Lawyer

Sanctions(the"ABA Standards") state, "The purpose of

lawyer discipline proceedings is

to protect

the public and

the administration ofjustice from lawyers who havenotdischarged, willnotdischarge,orareunlikely properly to discharge their professional dutiestoclients, thepublic,thelegal system, andthelegal profession."

ABA

Standard

3.0 lists

the factors to be considered in imposing

a sanction

after a finding of lawyer misconduct,andessentially mirrorsthelanguage of

Rule 15(b)(3)(D):

(a) thedutyviolated;

(b) thelawyer's

mental state;

(c) the potential or actual injury causedby thelawyer's

misconduct;and

(d) the existence of

aggravatingormitigating

factors. The First Factor: The

Duty Violated Respondent's violations of

Rule1.3(lack of

diligence) callsintoplay

Standard4.4,"Lack of

Diligence,"

of theABA StandardsforImposing Lawyer

Sanctions.

Standard4.4setsforththe following

guidelines:

Absent

aggravating ormitigating

circumstances, uponapplication ofthefactors set out in Standard 3.0, thefollowing

sanctions aregenerally

appropriate in cases involving a failuretoactwith

reasonable diligenceandpromptnessin

representing a client:

4.41 Disbarment is generally

appropriate

when:

(a) a lawyer abandons thepracticeandcauses serious orpotentially

serious injury to a client;or

(b) a lawyer knowingly failstoperform services foraclientandcause seri- ous orpotentially

serious injurytoaclient; or

(c) alawyer

engagesinapattern of

neglectwith

respecttoclient

matters and causes

serious orpotentially serious injury toaclient.

4.42

Suspensionisgenerally

appropriate when:

(a) alawyer knowingly failstoperform servicesforaclientandcausesin- jury or potential injurytoaclient,or

(b) alawyer engagesinapattern of

neglect with

respecttoclient

matters and causes injuryorpotential injurytoaclient.

8

4.43 Reprimand [i.e., "public

censure" under Rule 9(a)(3) of theRules of Disci- plinary Procedure]

is generally appropriatewhenalawyerisnegligentand does notactwith reasonable diligence

in representingaclient,andcauses injury or potential injury to a client.

4.44 Admonition [i.e., "private

reprimand" under Rule 9(a)(4) oftheRules of Disciplinary Procedure] is generally appropriatewhenalawyerisnegligent and does not act with reasonable diligence in representingaclient,and causes littleorno actualorpotential injurytoaclient. The presumptive sanction for Respondent's violation of

Rule1.3isdisbarment. Respondent's violation ofRule 3.4(c) (knowingly disobeyinganobligation undertherules of a tribunal) fall under Standard

6.2:

6.2

Abuse

of the Legal Process Absent aggravating or mitigating

circumstances, uponapplication of thefac- tors setout in Standard 3.0,thefollowing sanctions aregenerally

appropriate in cases involving failure to expedite litigationorbringameritorious claim,orfailure to obey any obligation undertherules of thetribunal except foranopen refusal based on an assertionthatno valid

obligation exists:

6.21 Disbarment is generally

appropriate whenalawyer knowingly

violatesacourt order or arulewiththeintenttoobtainabenefit forthelawyeror

another, and causes serious orpotentially serious injurytoapartyorcauses serious or potentially serious interferencewithalegal

proceeding.

6.22 Suspension is generally

appropriatewhenalawyer

knowsthat heorsheis violating a court orderorrule,andcauses injuryorpotential injurytoaclient or a party, orcauses interferenceorpotential interference with alegal

pro- ceeding.

6.23 [Public

censure]isgenerally

appropriatewhen alawyer

negligently failsto comply withacourt

orderorrule, andcauses injuryorpotential injurytoa client or other party, orcauses interference orpotential interferencewith a legal

proceeding.

6.24 [Private

reprimand]isgenerally

appropriatewhenalawyer engagesinaniso- lated instance of

negligence in complying with acourt

orderorrule, and causes littleornoactualorpotential injurytoaparty,orcauses littleorno actual or potential interference withalegal

proceeding. The presumptive

sanction for Respondent's

failure to comply

with the terms of

his disciplinary order

is

a suspension.

9

The Second Factor:

Respondent's

Mental State The preamble to the ABA Standards includes

the following discussion regarding mental state:

The mental states used in this model are defined as follows. The

most culpable mental state is that of intent,

when the lawyer acts with the conscious objective or purpose to accomplish a particular result. The next most culpable mental state is that

of knowledge, when the lawyer acts with conscious awareness of the nature or attendant circumstances of his or her conduct both without the conscious objective or purpose to accomplish a particular result. The least culpable mental state is neg- ligence, when a lawyer fails to be aware of a substantial risk that circumstances exist or that a resultwill follow,

which failure is

a deviation of a care that a reason- able lawyer would exercise in the situation. It is clear that

Respondent acted with conscious awareness of the nature or attendant cir- cumstances of his conduct.

The Third

Factor: Potential/Actual Iniury Caused

By

Respondent's Conduct Under the ABA Standards, "injury" is

defined as "harm to a client,thepublic,thelegal system, or

the profession which results from a lawyer's

misconduct. The level of injurycanrange from 'serious'

injury to 'little or no'

injury;areferenceto'injury' alone indicates anylevel of injury greater than 'little orno'injury."

The record is clearthatRespondent's

misconduct

imposed actual injury on his clients and the judicial process. The

Fourth Factor: AggravatingandMitigating

Circumstances

ABA

Standard

9.0,

entitled "AggravationandMitigation," provides asfollows:

9.1 Generally After misconduct hasbeenestablished, aggravatingandmitigating

circum- stances maybeconsideredindeciding what

sanctiontoimpose.

9.2

Aggravation

9.21 Definition. Aggravation oraggravating

circumstances areany

considerations or

factors

that may justify anincrease in thedegree of discipline tobeim- posed.

10

9.22

Factors

which may

be considered in aggravation. Aggravating factors in-

9.3

clude:

(a)

prior disciplinary offenses; (b)

dishonestorselfish motive;

(c) apattern ofmisconduct;

(d) multiple offenses;

(e) bad faith obstruction of thedisciplinary

proceedingbyintentionally fail- ing to comply with rules ororders ofthedisciplinary agency;

(f) submission of false evidence, false statements,orother deceptive prac- tices during the disciplinary process;

(g)

refusaltoacknowledge wrongful nature of conduct; (h)

vulnerability ofthevictim;

(i) substantial experience in the practiceoflaw; (j)

indifferenceinmaking restitution; and

(k) illegal

conduct, includingthatinvolvingtheuseofcontrolled

substances. Mitigation

9.31 Definition. Mitigation or mitigating

circumstances are any considerations

or factors thatmay justifyareduction inthedegree of disciplinetobeimposed.

9.32 Factors

which may beconsideredinmitigation. Mitigating factors include (a)

absence ofaprior disciplinary

record; (b)

absence ofadishonestorselfish motive;

(c) personal or emotional problems; (d)

timelygood

faith efforttomake

restitutionortorectify

consequences of misconduct;

(e) full andfreedisclosure of

disciplinary board orcooperative

attitudeto- ward

proceedings; (f)

inexperienceinthepractice oflaw; (g)

characterorreputation; (h)

physical disability;

(i) mental disabilityorchemical

dependency including

alcoholismordrug abuse when:

(1)

thereismedical evidencethattherespondentisaffectedbyachemical dependency ormental disability;

(2) the chemical

dependencyormental disability

causedthemisconduct;

(3) therespondent's recovery fromthechemical

dependency ormental disability is demonstratedbyameaningfulandsustained period of successful

rehabilitation;and

(4) the recovery

arrestedthemisconduct andrecurrence of thatmiscon- duct is unlikely.

(j)

delayindisciplinary

proceedings;

(k)

imposition of other penalties orsanctions; (1) remorse;

and 1]

(m) remoteness of prior

offenses.

9.4

Factors

Which

Are

Neither Aggravating nor Mitigating. The following factors should notbeconsideredaseither aggravatingnormit- igating:

(a) forced orcompelled restitution;

(b) agreeing to the client's

demandforcertain

improper behaviororresult;

(c) withdrawal of

complaint againstthelawyer;

(d) resignation prior to completion of

disciplinary

proceedings;

(e) complainant's

recommendationastosanction;and

(f) failure of

injured clienttocomplain. The following

aggravating factors arepresentinthis

case:

(1)

Prior discipline

(2) Pattern of misconduct

(3)

Vulnerability of victim

(4)

Substantial experiencein thepractice of law

(5)

Indifferencetomaking

restitution

(6)

Failuretocomplywiththeterms of theprevious

stipulated discipline Recommendation

Based upontheforegoing findings andconclusions, theReview

Panel

recommends that the Court

issue an order of

three-year

suspension of

Respondent; and that Respondent be required to pay an administrative fee of $750.00

and costs of $50.00 to the Wyoming

State Bar as provided in Rule 25(b), W.R.Disc.P. Dated this ay ofMarch,

2026.

Kylie Waldrip,

Hearing

Panel Chdir Board

of

Professional Responsibility Wyoming

StateBar

12