Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Stevens Law Office v. Department of Labor (Kylie Cordner)

Supreme Court of Vermont
Jan 9, 2026
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Claimant applied for unemployment compensation after employer terminated her from a paralegal position at the end of a thirty-day trial period. Employer argued claimant was discharged for misconduct, asserting she misrepresented her abilities by listing her prior job title as "Litigation Paralegal." A claims adjudicator denied employer's disqualification claim; a hearing officer upheld that denial, finding claimant's prior title was accurate and that discharge for performance did not constitute disqualifying misconduct. The Employment Security Board adopted the hearing officer's findings and conclusions. Employer appealed to the Vermont Supreme Court, which affirmed the Board's decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether claimant was disqualified from unemployment benefits under 21 V.S.A. § 1344(a)(1)(A) for misconduct connected with her work.
  2. Whether claimant's use of the title "Litigation Paralegal" on her resume constituted a misrepresentation amounting to disqualifying misconduct.

Arguments of the Parties

Employer's Arguments

  • Claimant misrepresented her paralegal skills by listing her prior title as "Litigation Paralegal."
  • That alleged misrepresentation, combined with dissatisfaction with her performance, amounted to misconduct sufficient to disqualify her from benefits.

Claimant's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the claimant's separate legal arguments beyond the Board's findings that she did not misrepresent her prior job title.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Favreau v. Dep't of Emp. & Training, 151 Vt. 170, 174-75 (1989) Defines disqualifying misconduct as acting in substantial disregard of employer's interests, wilfully or with culpable negligence. Used to state the legal standard for disqualification and to evaluate whether claimant's conduct met that standard.
Johnson v. Dep't of Emp. Sec., 138 Vt. 554, 555 (1980) Allocates burden of proof to the employer to establish misconduct. Applied to conclude employer failed to meet its burden to prove disqualifying misconduct.
In re Gray, 127 Vt. 303, 305 (1968) Holds that misrepresentations not motivated by intent to misrepresent, conceal, or falsify do not constitute disqualifying misconduct. Relied upon to support the Board's finding that claimant's prior job title was not a false or intentional misrepresentation.
863 To Go, Inc. v. Dep't of Labor, 2014 VT 61, ¶ 8, 196 Vt. 551 Describes appellate review as highly deferential; factual findings stand unless clearly erroneous; conclusions upheld if reasonably supported. Applied to affirm the Board's factual findings and legal conclusions based on the record.
Frost v. Dep't of Emp. Sec., 135 Vt. 39, 40 (1977) States that weight given to testimony and inferences are matters for the Board, not the court. Invoked to reject employer's invitation to reweigh evidence and to defer to the Board's credibility determinations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court applied 21 V.S.A. § 1344(a)(1)(A) and the standard from Favreau to assess whether claimant's discharge amounted to misconduct. It observed that the employer bears the burden of proving misconduct (Johnson) and found the Board's factual findings supported by the record. The Board and hearing officer found claimant's prior title of "Litigation Paralegal" was in fact her title and not a deliberate misrepresentation; In re Gray was cited for the principle that non-intentional misstatements do not constitute disqualifying misconduct. The Board also relied on facts that employer imposed a thirty-day trial period and had assigned claimant the title "Legal Assistant," and that there is no regulatory licensure for paralegals in Vermont—factors undercutting a finding of intent to misrepresent. The court applied the deferential standard of review (863 To Go) and the rule that credibility and evidentiary weight are for the Board (Frost), concluding employer had not met its burden and that reweighing the evidence was inappropriate. Accordingly, the Board's conclusion that employer failed to prove disqualifying misconduct was upheld.

Holding and Implications

AFFIRMED

Direct effect: The Employment Security Board's determination that claimant was entitled to unemployment compensation is affirmed; claimant is not disqualified for benefits. The opinion does not announce a broader change in law or establish new precedent beyond its application to the facts; the Court applied existing statutory standards and cited precedents to support its deferential review and conclusion.

Show all summary ...

VERMONT SUPREME COURT

Case No. 25-AP-272

109 State Street Montpelier VT 05609-0801 802-828-4774

www.vermontjudiciary.org Note: In the case title, an asterisk (*) indicates an appellant and a double asterisk (**) indicates a cross- appellant. Decisions of a three-justice panel are not to be considered as precedent before any tribunal.

ENTRY ORDER

JANUARY TERM, 2026

Stevens Law Office* v. Department of Labor (Kylie Cordner)

}

}

APPEALED FROM:

} Employment Security Board } CASE NO. 11-24-081-01 In the above-entitled cause, the Clerk will enter:

In this appeal, employer challenges the Employment Security Board's determination that claimant was entitled to unemployment compensation. We affirm. The record indicates the following. Claimant applied for unemployment compensation after employer terminated her from her position as a paralegal. A claims adjudicator rejected employer's argument that claimant was discharged for misconduct related to her work and thus should be disqualified from receiving benefits. A hearing officer upheld this decision. The hearing officer found that before being hired by employer, claimant worked for two years at another law firm. Her title at that job was "Litigation Paralegal." Employer decided to hire claimant for a trial period based on what appeared to be some gaps in her skill set as a paralegal. The parties signed a contract covering the first thirty days of claimant's employment. While employer praised claimant in many areas, it found her legal skills wanting and discharged her at the end of the thirty-day trial period.

The hearing officer explained that under 21 V.S.A. § 1344(a)(1)(A), an individual is disqualified for benefits if the person "has been discharged by the individual's last employing unit for misconduct connected with the individual's work." "To be disqualified from unemployment compensation benefits, an individual must act in substantial disregard of his employer's interests, either wilfully or with culpable negligence," Favreau v. Dep't of Emp. & Training, 151 Vt. 170, 174-75 (1989), and the employer bears the burden of proof on this question, Johnson v. Dep't of Emp. Sec., 138 Vt. 554, 555 (1980). Here, employer alleged that claimant misrepresented her abilities by referring to herself as a "litigation paralegal" on her resume. The hearing officer found that, while the title may have been overly optimistic, it was the title bestowed upon her by her prior employer. The hearing officer found no disqualifying conduct here, even if employer could have reasonably decided to discharge claimant. The Board adopted the hearing officer's findings and conclusions as its own. It reiterated the applicable legal standard referenced above. It agreed with the hearing officer that employer failed to meet its burden of establishing disqualifying misconduct. It found that claimant did not

1

2

misrepresent her experience and competency by identifying her prior job title as "litigation paralegal." That was in fact her job title and it was not false for her to include that title on her resume. See In re Gray, 127 Vt. 303, 305 (1968) (holding that misrepresentations on claimant's job application that were not motivated by intent to misrepresent, conceal, or falsify did not constitute disqualifying misconduct). The Board noted that employer had imposed a thirty-day trial period for claimant, which suggested that employer was unsure of claimant's skills and wanted to assess them, and employer assigned claimant a job title of "Legal Assistant," not

"paralegal." Finally, the Board observed that Vermont did not impose any license requirements or otherwise regulate the profession of paralegals and claimant did not hold herself out as a member of a profession requiring certification that she did not possess. She did not demonstrate any intent to conceal, falsify, or misrepresent her previous experience on her resume. Employer decided to discharge claimant based on her performance, and its decision to do so may have been reasonable and justified. This nonetheless did not meet the standard necessary to disqualify her for benefits. Employer now appeals.

Our review of the Board's decision is "highly deferential." 863 To Go, Inc. v. Dep't of Labor, 2014 VT 61, ¶ 8, 196 Vt. 551. The Board's factual findings will stand "unless clearly erroneous," and we will uphold the Board's "conclusions if reasonably supported by the findings." Id. We presume that "[d]ecisions within the Board's expertise are . . . correct unless there is a clear showing to the contrary." Id.

Employer provides its version of the evidence. It argues that the Board should have found that claimant misrepresented her paralegal skills, apparently by indicating that she was a

"Litigation Paralegal" at her prior job. Employer argues that this inaccurate representation along with its dissatisfaction with claimant's performance constitutes misconduct. The Board was unpersuaded by employer's arguments as set forth above. It found that claimant accurately stated her prior job title and that employer's dissatisfaction with her performance did not demonstrate misconduct. Essentially, employer asks this Court to reweigh the evidence, which is not our role. "The weight to be given the testimony and the inferences to be drawn therefrom are matters properly for the Board, not for this Court." Frost v. Dep't of Emp. Sec., 135 Vt. 39, 40 (1977). The Board's conclusion is supported by its findings, which are in turn supported by the evidence. We thus affirm its decision.

Affirmed.

BY THE COURT:

Paul L. Reiber, Chief Justice Harold E. Eaton, Jr., Associate Justice Nancy J. Waples, Associate Justice