Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State v. Lopez

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Feb 2, 2025

Roberto Lopez - Applicant Defendant; Applying For Supervisory Writ, Parish of Jefferson, 24th Judicial District Court Number(s) 21-5762, Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit, Number(s) 25-K-38;

Writ application denied.

JLW

WJC

JBM

Hughes, J., would grant and assigns reasons.

When a witness first testifies, and is challenged, a prior consistent statement may be admissible. But when the witness is a juvenile, the specific statutory protections apply.

Knoll, J., dissents for the reasons assigned by Justice Guidry.

Griffin, J., concurs in the denial for reasons assigned by Judge Wicker.

Guidry, J., dissents and assigns reasons.

I respectfully dissent from the court's decision to deny exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction to review this matter. Louisiana Revised Statutes 15:440.5 provides constitutional safeguards for a defendant's right to confrontation with respect to the admission of videotaped statements of protected persons. State v. Luckey, 16-494, p. 18 n.2 (La.App. 5th Cir. 2/8/17), 212 So.3d 1220, 1233 n.2, writs denied, 17-0432, 17-0617 (La. 10/27/17), 228 So.3d 1225, 1234. Moreover, La. R.S. 15:440.5 is designed to ensure the reliability of a child's statement. See State v. Ledet, 96-0142, p. 10 (La.App. 1st Cir. 11/8/96), 694 So.2d 336, 342, writ denied, 96-3029 (La. 9/19/97), 701 So.2d 163. "Louisiana's provisions creating special arrangements for abused children contain strict requirements designed to ensure that these accommodations do not compromise the rights of defendants to confront adverse witnesses and test the reliability of their testimony." State v. Kennedy, 05-1981, p. 21 (La. 5/22/07), 957 So.2d 757, 773, rev'd on other grounds, 554 U.S. 407, 128 S.Ct. 2641, 171 L.Ed.2d 525 (2008). Hence, La. R.S. 15:440.5(A) provides eight requirements for the videotape to be admissible. State v. Eley, 15-1925, p. 6 (La.App. 1st Cir. 9/16/16), 203 So.3d 462, 470, writ denied, 16-1844 (La. 9/6/17), 224 So.3d 982.

Herein, the State had not provided an explanation for why it cannot comply with the sixth requirement of La. R.S. 15:440.5(A) that "[t]he person conducting or supervising the interview of the protected person in the recording is present at the proceeding and available to testify or be cross-examined by either party." Nevertheless, it seeks to introduce the videotape of the child victim pursuant to La. C.E. art. 801(D)(1)(b), which provides that a prior consistent statement is not hearsay and is admissible "to rebut an express or implied charge against [her] of recent fabrication or improper influence or motive." Agreeing, the trial court ruled that the videotape could be admitted without compliance with La. R.S. 15:440.5(A)(6).

The State contends that the video recorded statement is a prior consistent statement made by the victim and thus, pursuant to La. C.E. art. 801(D)(1)(b), is not hearsay and is admissible to rebut defendant's claim of fabrication. However, this argument conflicts with La. R.S. 15:440.3 and case law finding that the videotape is hearsay, but which may be admitted into evidence should the provisions of La. R.S. 15:440.4 and La. R.S. 15:440.5 be satisfied. Because La. R.S. 15:440.5 specifically governs the admissibility of such videotapes, the trial court abused its discretion by applying the more general law of La. C.E. art. 801(D)(1)(b) over the specific law contained in La. R.S. 15:440.5.

Therefore, I would grant defendant's writ application and, because the State failed to comply with the provisions of La. R.S. 15:440.5, would reverse the ruling of the trial court finding the videotape admissible.