- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
In re S.C. State Senators Appearing in Magistrates Courts
John W. Kittredge Chief Justice of South Carolina
ORDER
John W. Kittredge Chief Justice of South Carolina
This administrative order is issued pursuant to the provisions of Article V, Section 4 of the South Carolina Constitution to address issues that may arise if a State Senator appears before a magistrate that the Senator recommended for appointment to the Governor of South Carolina.
Article V, Section 26 of the South Carolina Constitution provides that "The Governor, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate, shall appoint a number of magistrates for each county as provided by law." The historical practice has been for the Senator in the applicable district to recommend a magistrate to the Governor. If approved, the Governor nominates the magistrate to the full Senate for confirmation.
South Carolina State Senators who are also lawyers have a dual responsibility. State Senators participate in the legislative process and have an important role representing the interests of the citizens of South Carolina who elected the State Senator to the Legislature. As part of that duty to the citizens of South Carolina, a Senator may recommend a magistrate to the Governor for appointment. However, in addition to the role of legislator, the lawyer State Senator, like all lawyers, is an advocate and has the duty to zealously represent clients. This dual responsibility may lead the public to question the impartiality of the magistrate. Public confidence in the judiciary is paramount. Our justice system must not only provide equal justice to all, the public must believe in the integrity of our justice system. State Senators also recognize that appearances matter in our justice system. This order sets forth the general rule that a magistrate may not hear any contested matter involving a state Senator, as a party or attorney, who has direct authority to recommend the magistrate for appointment to the Governor.
See Rule 1.3, Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 407, SCACR.
(a) Application. This Order applies to any Senator who appears as a lawyer or party before a magistrate that the Senator has direct authority in his or her Senate District to recommend for appointment or reappointment to the Governor (hereinafter "Recommending Senator"). There are local variations in the practice of recommending a magistrate judge applicant to the Governor. For example, in some counties, the Senator directly responsible for the recommendation to the Governor will notify fellow members of the legislative delegation as a matter of courtesy of the potential magistrate appointment. A legislator who merely receives a courtesy notification is not affected by this Order. Similarly, it is customary for the transmittal letter to the Governor to be signed by the entire Senatorial or legislative delegation. Again, only the Recommending Senator is affected by this Order
(b) Disqualification. Except as provided in paragraph (c) below, the disqualification also applies to any member of the Senator's family and law firm. Notwithstanding the foregoing, where the Recommending Senator is a practicing lawyer, the vicarious disqualification of members of his or her law firm does not apply when a lawyer associated with the Recommending Senator's law firm serves in a different and independent capacity. For example, a lawyer may serve as a part-time public defender or as a part-time prosecutor, or similar service not directly connected to the Recommending Senator's law firm.
(c) Exceptions.
(1) Setting of Bonds and Preliminary Hearings. Because hearings involving the setting of bonds and preliminary hearings must continue in the usual fashion, such hearings are exempted from this Order. These hearings are subject to statutory time constraints, and delays would likely result in the scheduling of such matters beyond the timeframe provided by law.
(2) Uncontested Matters. The prohibition against a Recommending Senator (or a member of his or her law firm) appearing applies only to contested trials and hearings. There are a number of uncontested and administrative matters that occur in magistrates courts, and this Order shall not apply in those situations. Examples of exempted hearings and matters include, but are not limited to, status hearings where the court merely directs whether the case will be assigned to a trial docket or a plea docket, whether the case will be assigned to a jury or non-jury docket, hearings in which a party appears to plead guilty to a citation with the officer consenting, interpleader actions and hearings where the parties have reached an agreement and the matter is amicably resolved. These kinds of uncontested and procedural hearings are routine in magistrates court, and they must continue in the normal course.
(3) Waiver. A disqualification may be waived pursuant to the remittal of disqualification procedure in Section 3(F) of the Code of Judicial Conduct. Rule 501, SCACR. In the absence of waiver, the contested case must be assigned to a conflict-free magistrate.
(d) Assignment of Substitute Magistrate. Where a Recommending Senator is a party or an attorney in a contested matter in a magistrate's court proceeding, and the conflict is not waived, the Chief Magistrate shall assign the case to a conflict-free magistrate. If a conflict-free magistrate judge is not readily available, the Chief Magistrate in the county will contact Court Administration. Court Administration will ensure the prompt appointment of a magistrate to hear the matter. When the appointed magistrate resides and serves in another county, the appointed magistrate shall be granted jurisdiction over the matter in the county in which the case is pending.
This order is effective immediately and shall remain in effect until amended or rescinded by the Chief Justice.
Alert