- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
In re Lawyer-Legislator Prot.
John W. Kittredge, Chief Justice
ORDER
John W. Kittredge, Chief Justice
This administrative order is issued pursuant to Article V, Section 4 of the South Carolina Constitution and addresses lawyer-legislator protection.
Consistent with the practice established by my predecessors, I reaffirm that lawyers who have been elected by the citizens of South Carolina to serve as members of the General Assembly provide a great service to the State. While discharging their lawyer-legislative duties, I find there is a need for lawyer-legislators to be protected from trials, court hearings, and other lawyer-related responsibilities. However, in extending protection to lawyer-legislators, a careful and thoughtful balance must be struck. While consideration must be afforded to lawyer-legislators in the discharge of their legislative service and duties, court hearings also must proceed in the normal course as much as is practicable. This is especially true for a matter deemed an emergency where substantial rights of the parties will be irreparably damaged by a delay. Striking the proper balance is a challenging task given the valid, competing interests on both sides. Nonetheless, as Chief Justice, I must do my best to formulate a realistic and workable process for providing legislative protection for practicing lawyers who serve in the General Assembly, while simultaneously ensuring the fair and orderly operation of the state court system.
In my judgment, a distinction must be made between the protection afforded for trials and that afforded for motions hearings and other matters relating to the practice of law. Trials generally do not present emergencies and can be scheduled from August 1 to December 31. Therefore, for the time period outlined below, and subject to certain limited exceptions, a lawyer-legislator is granted absolute protection from trials in the Courts of this State, unless the lawyer-legislator elects to waive this protection. For motions hearings and all other aspects of litigation, lawyer-legislator protection is not absolute. The lawyer-legislator must attend to matters that are deemed an emergency by the court. I find this balancing of interests appropriate because the designation of an emergency denotes that exigent circumstances exist, and in those matters substantial rights of litigants may be irreparably damaged if the hearing is delayed beyond the legislative session.
A legislator's waiver of protection in a particular case shall not be construed as waiver in any other case.
I emphasize that the designation of an emergency must be made solely by the court-the chief administrative judge or presiding judge-and not by a party or counsel in the case caption or through any conclusory allegations in a pleading or motion.
I.
TRIAL PROTECTION
With the limited exception noted below, lawyer-legislators are hereby granted absolute protection from all trials: (1) from January 1 through July 31; and (2) for any specially-called legislative session on or after August 1 to address the completion of gubernatorial vetoes on the General Appropriations Act; and (3) for any additionally called legislative session or instances in which the lawyer-legislator is performing official legislative duties as convened by the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House, or the Chairperson of a committee.
The exception to the grant of absolute protection for trials arises in civil and family court cases where the lawyer-legislator is retained to represent a client who has been a party to a case for eighteen months or more, and in criminal cases where the lawyer-legislator is retained to represent a defendant for a criminal charge that is two-years old or older. In these instances, the lawyer-legislator is not entitled to lawyer-legislator protection, and no continuance may be granted on the basis of lawyer-legislator protection. This exception to the rule for absolute trial protection ensures that older cases will not languish for excessive periods of time.
Where a civil or family court case is administratively struck from the docket, the eighteen-month period will be calculated from the filing of the original complaint.
II.
HEARINGS AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING TO THE PRACTICE OF LAW
(a) Presumptive Protection.
For motions hearings and other matters within the practice of law, lawyer-legislators are hereby presumptively granted protection as follows: (1) from January 1 through July 31; and (2) for any specially-called legislative session on or after August 1 to address the completion of gubernatorial vetoes on the General Appropriations Act; and (3) for any additionally called legislative session or instances in which the lawyer-legislator is performing official legislative duties as convened by the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House, or the Chairperson of a committee.
The phrase "other matters within the practice of law" includes the wide range of responsibilities that are commonly associated with the practice of law, including but not limited to, attending depositions and attending status conferences.
(b) Emergency Hearings.
This presumptive protection for lawyer-legislators is not absolute. When the chief administrative judge or presiding judge determines that an emergency exists and circumstances require a motion hearing to proceed without undue delay, the hearing shall not be continued until the end of the legislative session. Rather, in such a situation, the hearing shall either proceed as scheduled or be promptly rescheduled, preferably to a Monday or Friday. Regrettably, too often in the past the issue of lawyer-legislator protection has been myopically approached as a binary choice, as if a scheduled hearing must either go forward precisely at the scheduled time or be delayed until the end of the legislative session. The wise exercise of discretion is a hallmark of a properly managed trial court docket. This judicial discretion concerning the scheduling of court hearings is embedded throughout our justice system, and there is no valid reason to exempt lawyer-legislator protection from the exercise of judicial discretion with a rigid, categorical approach granting or denying blanket lawyer-legislator immunity.
Accordingly, if the chief administrative judge or presiding judge determines that a brief continuance of a hearing involving urgent and compelling circumstances is appropriate, the matter may be continued briefly and rescheduled. To that end, the chief administrative judge or presiding judge may order interim relief during the period of brief delay if necessary to preserve the status quo and protect the rights of the parties.
Of course, if the matter does not involve urgent and compelling circumstances, the presumptive grant of protection from all hearings and other matters within the practice of law shall control as described above. In sum, it is the presence or absence of urgent and compelling circumstances, as determined by the chief administrative judge or presiding judge, that will determine how the request for lawyer-legislator protection will be handled and resolved.
(c) Scheduling Considerations for Emergency Matters for Hearings and Other Emergency Matters Relating to the Practice of Law.
For clarification, I present two situations where lawyer-legislator protection shall not be granted. First, after a Complaint and Answer have been filed, if a hearing or other matter within the practice of law is scheduled, and that matter is deemed an emergency, a lawyer-legislator may not thereafter become counsel of record and invoke his or her status as a lawyer-legislator as the basis to have the hearing continued beyond the legislative session. Second, where the lawyer-legislator is not lead counsel, and other counsel of record are able to represent the party's interest at the emergency motion hearing or other matter within the practice of law, lawyerlegislator protection during the legislative session shall not be granted. In either of these scenarios, a continuance may be granted, as standard judicial discretion is not foreclosed, but a delay or continuance shall not be granted through the end of the legislative session on the basis of lawyer-legislator protection.
I additionally note that many courts schedule hearings or other matters within the practice of law for lawyer-legislators on Mondays and Fridays during weeks when the Legislature is in session. This practice shall continue for emergency matters. This practice accommodates the need for a prompt hearing while allowing the lawyer-legislator to serve in the Legislature Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday when the Legislature is in session. I order chief administrative judges and presiding judges to move emergency hearings involving lawyer-legislators when the Legislature is in session to a Monday or Friday, even if the rescheduling results in the matter being heard prior to the originally scheduled date. By way of example, special circumstances may warrant requiring a lawyer-legislator to attend a hearing (such as one involving a bond revocation motion, family court motion, or motion to compel discovery) on a Monday or Friday when the Legislature is in session. Today's order fits well with, and by design follows, the order issued by former Chief Justice Toal (filed May 17, 2001) wherein she granted protection to lawyerlegislators from being called to court:
When the Legislature is in recess and not in session, emergency hearings may be scheduled on any weekday.
A motion to compel discovery may or may not require immediate attention, depending on the circumstances. In some situations, discovery comes to a standstill until the motion to compel is resolved. The chief administrative judge or presiding judge shall determine if a motion to compel discovery requires prompt resolution.
[E]xcept in extraordinary circumstances, where substantial rights of the parties to the litigation will be defeated or severely abridged by the delay, or where the litigation involves emergency relief and irreparable damage.
It is perhaps helpful to note that trials and hearings are often continued for a host of reasons. Those reasons may include: illness of a party, witness, or attorney; the unavailability of a material witness, such as an expert; incomplete discovery; and other factors. When all the reasons for continuing and rescheduling a trial or hearing are considered, lawyer-legislator protection is one of the least invoked reasons.
The success of achieving the proper balance between lawyer-legislator protection and the fair and orderly operation of the state court system depends on the good faith cooperation of all participants. I will monitor compliance and provide guidance as warranted.
The order today supersedes all prior administrative orders respecting the subject of lawyer-legislator protection. This order takes effect immediately and remains in effect unless rescinded or amended by the Chief Justice.
Alert