- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chaudhry v. Aragon
KATZMANN, JUDGE
Argued and Submitted March 7, 2023 San Francisco, California
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California Stanley A. Boone, Magistrate Judge, Presiding D.C. No. 1:16-cv-01243- SAB
Thornton Davidson (argued), Thornton Davidson P.C., Fresno, California, for Plaintiffs-Appellants.
Diana Esquivel, Deputy Attorney General; Catherine Woodbridge, Supervising Deputy Attorney General; Danielle F. O'Bannon, Senior Assistant Attorney General; Rob Bonta, Attorney General of California; Office of the California Attorney General; Sacramento, California; for Defendant-Appellees.
Before: Michelle T. Friedland and Ryan D. Nelson, Circuit Judges, and Gary S. Katzmann, [**] Judge.
SUMMARY [***]
Civil Rights
The panel affirmed the district court's dismissal, following a five-day bench trial, of an action brought pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against present or former employees of the California Department of Public Health alleging a "stigma-plus" due process claim on the grounds that defendants violated Dr. Chaudry's and Valley Cardiac Surgery Medical Group's Fourteenth Amendment rights by denying Dr. Chaudhry an opportunity to be heard before publishing a purportedly erroneous investigative report on an unsuccessful cardiac surgery.
Following an investigation of the surgery, the Department published on its website a combined Statement of Deficiencies and Plan of Correction. The district court concluded, among other things, that plaintiffs Dr. Chaudhry and Valley Cardiac Surgery Medical Group failed to establish the requisite causation element for a "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983. The district court assessed that it was the tragic events surrounding patient Silvino Perez's surgery and Dr. Chaudhry's violations of certain hospital policies-and not the ostensibly stigmatizing Statement of Deficiencies-that were the causes of plaintiffs' alleged deprivations.
The panel held that the district court's negative causation finding was plausible in light of record evidence establishing, inter alia: the timing and conclusions of the hospital's internal investigations; the independent actions of a hospital employee to alert the Perez family to potential malfeasance by Dr. Chaudhry; the Perez family and estate's pursuit of legal action; the accounts of key percipient witnesses to the Perez surgery as part of the Perez malpractice case; and the sizable malpractice judgment awarded against Dr. Chaudhry. The panel thus sustained the district court's determination that plaintiffs failed to prove that defendants' conduct was the actionable cause of the claimed injury and concluded that, at a minimum, plaintiffs failed to establish the requisite causation element of their "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983.
OPINION
KATZMANN, JUDGE
Plaintiffs Dr. Pervaiz A. Chaudhry and Valley Cardiac Surgery Medical Group bring suit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against Defendants Tomas Aragon, Shirley Campbell, and Steven Lopez-each present or former employees of the California Department of Public Health-on the grounds that Defendants acted under color of state law to deprive Plaintiffs of certain rights secured by the United States Constitution. Specifically, Plaintiffs allege a "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983 on the grounds that Defendants violated their Fourteenth Amendment rights by denying Dr. Chaudhry an opportunity to be heard before publishing a purportedly erroneous investigative report on an unsuccessful cardiac surgery. They contend that the publication of this report caused Plaintiffs to be deprived of protected employment-related interests. After a five-day bench trial, the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California concluded that Plaintiffs failed to establish several necessary elements of their claim and, thus, dismissed the action in its entirety; Plaintiffs challenge each of the district court's negative elemental findings before this court.
Because we conclude that, at a minimum, Plaintiffs failed to establish the requisite causation element of their "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983, we affirm the district court's dismissal of Plaintiffs' action in its entirety.
I. BACKGROUND
A. Factual Background
Plaintiff Dr. Chaudhry was a cardiothoracic surgeon and a practitioner with substantial financial and leadership interests in Plaintiff Valley Cardiac Surgery Medical Group ("Valley Cardiac"). On April 2, 2012, Dr. Chaudhry performed open-heart surgery on patient Silvino Perez at Community Regional Medical Center ("the Hospital"), a private hospital in Fresno, California. The relevant individuals who were present in the operating room for the surgery were Dr. Chaudhry, Kalwant Dhillon, M.D. (assistant surgeon), Ashwin Bhatt, M.D. (anesthesiologist), Bella Albakova (physician assistant, or "PA"), and Aaron Schreur (perfusionist). The parties dispute whether Dr. Chaudhry left the operating room: (1) before the surgery was complete; (2) before Perez's chest had been closed and sutured; and/or (3) when Perez was unstable.
Soon after Dr. Chaudhry left, Perez experienced ventricular fibrillation and Dr. Chaudhry was called back to the hospital to attend to him. Despite intervention, Perez suffered hypoxic brain injury. On April 2, 2012-the same day as the Perez surgery-the Hospital began an internal investigation into the events of the operation and on April 12, the Hospital's Medical Executive Committee resolved to have the Perez case independently reviewed by an outside cardiovascular surgeon.
Meanwhile, on April 11, the California Department of Public Health ("CDPH")-a state agency-received an anonymous phone call alleging that Dr. Chaudhry left the operating room while Perez's chest was still open, and then left the hospital while his PA Albakova and assistant surgeon Dhillon finished the surgery. Because the California Health and Safety Code requires onsite investigations if CDPH receives a written or oral complaint indicating "an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm," see Cal. Health &Safety Code § 1279.2(a)(1), CDPH initiated an investigation of the Hospital.
Accordingly, from around April 16 to 19, 2012, a surveyor for CDPH conducted the onsite investigation of the Hospital on behalf of the state. During his investigation, the surveyor did not interview Dr. Chaudhry, Dr. Dhillon, Dr. Bhatt, or PA Albakova. Defendant Steven Lopez-then a Health Facilities Evaluator Supervisor for CDPH-verified and supervised the state investigation.
CDPH, like many other state agencies, has an agreement with the federal government to conduct validation surveys of hospitals that participate in Medicare and Medicaid to ensure compliance with minimum health and safety standards. See 42 C.F.R. § 488.10(a)(1), (c). As part of these hospital surveys, CDPH surveyors document assessed violations, otherwise known as "deficiencies," which are ultimately presented to the surveyed facility in a "Statement of Deficiencies." 42 C.F.R. § 401.133(a). When CDPH conducts both state and federal investigations of a single hospital, it produces separate Statements of Deficiencies for each survey. Once the investigated facility receives a Statement of Deficiencies-whether state or federal-the hospital must create and submit for approval a Plan of Correction to address the assessed violations. See 42 C.F.R. § 488.424; Cal. Health &Safety Code § 1280(b).
From July 13 to 17, 2012, Defendant Shirley Campbell-then a Health Facilities Evaluator Manager I for CDPH, now retired-along with another CDPH employee, now deceased, conducted an onsite investigation of the Hospital on behalf of the Centers for Medicare &Medicaid Services ("CMS"), a division of the United States Department of Health and Human Services. Defendant Campbell interviewed Dr. Chaudhry as part of this federal investigation. Here too, Defendant Lopez of CDPH verified and supervised the federal investigation.
As a result of these hospital surveys, CDPH surveyors produced two Statements of Deficiencies: one on behalf of the state, and one on behalf of the federal entity.
On July 27, 2012, after receiving the preliminary federal findings from CMS, the President and Chief Executive Officer of the Hospital sent a letter requesting that Dr. Chaudhry immediately step down as Medical Director of Cardiac Surgery and Thoracic Services. On August 8, 2012, CMS transmitted the formal federal Statement of Deficiencies to the Hospital.
Dr. Chaudhry appeared before the Hospital's Medical Executive Committee on August 15, 2012, and on August 21, he received a fourteen-day medical staff membership and clinical privileges suspension via letter from the President of the Hospital's Medical Staff. This letter explained that after reviewing the findings of the outside peer reviewer, the Medical Executive Committee concluded the following:
• There is evidence that the patient [Perez] was unstable following the conclusion of surgery; . . .
• In leaving the [operating room] and the hospital, [Dr. Chaudhry] failed to designate another physician qualified to provide the necessary coverage or care for this patient;
• As a result of [Dr. Chaudhry's] failure, there was an untimely response to the patient's deteriorating condition;
...
• [Dr. Chaudhry] ha[d] already been directed to remain in the [operating room] until the patient's chest is closed; and
• Therefore, a fourteen-day (14) medical staff membership and clinical privileges suspension is imposed and shall be served within three (3) months of August 16, 2012.
On August 23, 2012, the Hospital submitted to CMS its Plan of Correction-prepared by the Hospital's Risk Manager, Laura McComb-in response to the federal Statement of Deficiencies. Thereafter, on January 28, 2013, CDPH-specifically Defendant Campbell-transmitted the state Statement of Deficiencies to the Hospital. The Hospital submitted to CDPH its Plan of Correction-also prepared by McComb-in response to the state Statement of Deficiencies on February 14, 2013. Defendant Lopez reviewed and signed the Hospital's federal and state Plans of Correction.
On June 14, 2013, the Hospital declined to renew a Consultant Services Agreement with Dr. Chaudhry.
On October 10, 2013, CDPH published on its website the combined state Statement of Deficiencies and Plan of Correction. This state Statement of Deficiencies did not mention Dr. Chaudhry or any other individual by name, but it referred to Dr. Chaudhry as "CVS 1." Importantly, the October-published state Statement of Deficiencies "found" among other things, that: (1) "CVS 1 left the [operating room] at 11:45 a.m. PA 1 and MD 1 sutured the chest closed with metallic wire at approximately 12:00 p.m. and then left the [operating room]" (footnotes not in original); and (2) "CVS 1 left the open heart surgery on Patient 1 prior to closing of the chest and prior to stabilization in violation of hospital medical staff bylaws." Neither CDPH nor CMS made available to the general public the federal Statement of Deficiencies and Plan of Correction. Only the Hospital- and not Dr. Chaudhry-had a right to appeal the state Statement of Deficiencies to CDPH or the federal Statement of Deficiencies to CMS. See Cal. Health &Safety Code § 1280(c)(1); 42 C.F.R. § 488.331(a)(2).
On November 13, 2013, the Hospital declined to renew a Call Coverage Agreement with Valley Cardiac.
On December 23, 2013, after being alerted to the potential malfeasance of Dr. Chaudhry by Hospital employee James Robillard, the family of Perez filed a malpractice lawsuit against Dr. Chaudhry and others in Fresno County Superior Court. See Arteaga v. Fresno Cmty. Reg'l Med. Ctr., No. 13CECG03906 (Cal. Super. Ct. filed Dec. 23, 2013) ("Perez Malpractice Case"). Robillard supervised Schreur, who was the perfusionist during the surgery, and asked Schreur to write up the events of the surgery within days of it taking place; Robillard learned of the events of the surgery from Schreur, and not from the CDPH investigation.
On November 25, 2014, more than a year after publication on CDPH's website, CDPH amended the state Statement of Deficiencies to account for certain discrepancies revealed by "information from [the Hospital's] risk manager interview and comparison with clinical hospital records." Specifically, the state Statement of Deficiencies was revised to "find" that CVS 1 (Dr. Chaudhry) left the operating room at 12:15 p.m. on the day of the Perez surgery. The amended state Statement of Deficiencies, which was published on CDPH's website, retained statements that CVS 1 left an unqualified and unsupervised staff in charge of the operating room while the patient was unstable.
Following publication of the state Statement of Deficiencies, the Medical Board of California began investigating Dr. Chaudhry. In December 2014, the Medical Board of California determined that it would take no action against Dr. Chaudhry. As a result, Dr. Chaudhry remains licensed to practice medicine in California.
Dr. Chaudhry performed his last surgery at the Hospital in January 2018. By February 2018, Dr. Chaudhry had at least five other malpractice lawsuits pending against him in addition to the Perez Malpractice Case. Per Dr. Chaudhry's own assessment, as a result of these lawsuits, his professional liability insurer, Norcal, terminated his policy. Although other companies remained willing to insure him, Dr. Chaudhry determined that he could not afford such policies. In March 2018, a California jury awarded the Perez family damages in excess of $60 million against Dr. Chaudhry and the Hospital.
Dr. Chaudhry is no longer practicing medicine in the United States but continues to practice in his home country of Pakistan at a reduced income.
B. Procedural Background
Plaintiffs filed suit in Fresno County Superior Court, and Defendants timely removed to federal court. Plaintiffs' Complaint asserts a two-count "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983 on the grounds that the state's "blatantly false report" deprived Plaintiffs of protected employment-related interests without the due process of law ensured by the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution. Importantly, Plaintiffs' Complaint alleges that it is only the state Statement of Deficiencies-and not the federal Statement of Deficiencies-that is the source of their claim.
Plaintiffs' first count against the Director of CDPH in his official capacity seeks declaratory and injunctive relief in the form of a court order requiring the Director to withdraw the state Statement of Deficiencies and replace it with a new report "vindicating Dr. Chaudhry[] and his medical group." Plaintiffs' second count against Defendants Lopez, Campbell, and Eric Creer-in their personal capacities- seeks money damages for their roles in "falsifying [the] CDPH report, and then refusing to correct said report" in derogation of Plaintiffs' due process rights.
All Defendants filed a motion for summary judgment on the grounds that they are immune from liability. United States Chief District Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill granted summary judgment to Defendant Creer and denied summary judgment to all other Defendants. This action was then assigned, pursuant to parties' consent, to Magistrate Judge Stanley A. Boone for all purposes, including trial and entry of final judgment.
After a five-day bench trial, the district court entered judgment in favor of Defendants on the grounds that Plaintiffs did not successfully prove several of the requisite elements of their "stigma-plus" due process claim under § 1983; accordingly, the district court dismissed Plaintiffs' action in its entirety on the merits with prejudice. In so ruling, the district court denied Plaintiffs' motion to admit certain prior testimony of McComb from the Perez Malpractice Case. Plaintiffs timely filed their notice of appeal.
C. Legal Background
Alert