- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Reynolds v. Quantlab Trading Partners US
Charles A. Spain Justice
On Appeal from the 152nd District Court Harris County, Texas
Trial Court Cause No. 2017-83411
While I concur that the trial court erred in dismissing all of Wilma Reynolds's claims, that the trial court's final judgment should be reversed, and that the case should be remanded for further proceedings, I cannot join the majority opinion to the extent that it suggests the trial court's decision denying her motions to compel should be reversed separately and apart from the trial court's final judgment, and I dissent to the portion of this court's judgment which explicitly treats the motions to compel as not merged into the trial court's final judgment.
The court thinks that the denial of the motions to compel is an order separate from the trial court's final judgment, although both the order and the final judgment were signed on the same day. By doing so, the court unnecessarily injects significant uncertainty into a day that the law necessarily presumes to be considered as whole and not divisible—judgment day.
The majority opinion states (1) that it reverses the judgment and remands for further proceedings and (2) that it reverses both the judgment and the denial order and remands for further proceedings. To the extent that the opinion is not clear, the judgment expressly states: "We therefore REVERSE the judgment of the court below and the order denying appellant's motions to compel and REMAND the cause for proceedings in accordance with the court's opinion."
Judgment day in this case was August 21, 2018. On that day, the trial court signed a take-nothing judgment that contained Lehmann v. Har-Con Corp. unambiguous finality language. See 39 S.W.3d 191, 206 (Tex. 2001). On judgment day, the trial court also signed an order denying appellant Wilma Reynolds's (1) May 4, 2018 motion to compel discovery from the three Quantlab Defendants and (2) July 9, 2018 motion to compel discovery from David Reynolds. The trial court did not note the hour, minute, or further subdivision of time it signed either the final judgment or the discovery order, and there is no indication in the two orders that the trial court either signed them in a specific sequence or had any intention that they were anything other than orders signed on judgment day.
The final judgment and the order denying the motions to compel do bear file marks from the district clerk: "8/10/2019 4:02 PM" for the final judgment and "8/9/2019 6:42 PM" for the order denying the motions to compel. Obviously, these file marks have nothing to do with the timing of the trial judge signing the final judgment and the order, and the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure do not require a clerk to file mark judgments and orders. Even if they were file marked after the trial judge signed them, those file marks would not necessarily reflect the timing of the trial judge's signature.
This court's opinion suggests—with no discussion or citation to authority— that the timing or sequence of signing of orders on judgment day has independent legal significance, creating, perhaps unintentionally, the new concepts of "judgment hour," "judgment minute," and so on. I not only generally believe these temporal subdivisions of judgment day have no meaning as legally significant concepts, but also think that creating them and engaging in linear temporal analysis in interpreting the final judgment is error.
Put another way, I believe the trial judge's actions on judgment day should be reviewed as if the trial judge were writing from the third-person omniscient point of view—everything the trial judge signs on judgment day should, if possible, be construed to be part of the one final judgment signed on that day.
Jurisprudence in Texas and in its Spanish, Mexican, and English antecedents predates precise timekeeping. The fact that standard time is easy to ascertain today does not mean that it was easy in the nineteenth century. People did know the day, however, and the idea that the hour and minute, much less the second, on judgment day had independent legal significance is certainly not reflected in procedural statutes and court rules. The fact that today anyone with a mobile phone can easily find the current Coordinated Universal Time (www.time.gov) does not change the underlying principle that the relevant time for a final judgment is the day.
The current Texas Rules of Civil Procedure and Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure rarely use "time" to refer to a specific portion of a day. Nowhere do they define "judgment day." What is important for a judgment under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 306a is that it be signed and dated:
See, e.g., Tex. R. Civ. P. 16 ("Every officer or authorized person shall endorse on all process and precepts coming to his hand the day and hour on which he received them, the manner in which he executed them, and the time and place the process was served and shall sign the returns officially."); 21(f)(5) ("Unless a document must be filed by a certain time of day, a document is considered timely filed if it is electronically filed at any time before midnight (in the court's time zone) on the filing deadline."); 24 ("When a petition is filed with the clerk he shall indorse thereon the file number, the day on which it was filed and the time of filing, and sign his name officially thereto."); 67 ("When issues not raised by the pleadings are tried by express or implied consent of the parties, they shall be treated in all respects as if they had been raised in the pleadings. In such case such amendment of the pleadings as may be necessary to cause them to conform to the evidence and to raise these issues may be made by leave of court upon motion of any party at any time up to the submission of the case to the Court or jury, but failure so to amend shall not affect the result of the trial of these issues; provided that written pleadings, before the time of submission, shall be necessary to the submission of questions, as is provided in Rules 277 and 279."); 74 ("The filing of pleadings, other papers and exhibits as required by these rules shall be made by filing them with the clerk of the court, except that the judge may permit the papers to be filed with him, in which event he shall note thereon the filing date and time and forthwith transmit them to the office of the clerk."); 107 ("The return, together with any documents to which it is attached, must include the following information: . . . (4) the date and time the process was received for service . . . ."); 114 ("If issued from the district or county court, the citation shall command such parties to appear and answer at or before 10 o'clock a.m. of the first Monday after the expiration of 42 days from the date of issuance thereof, specifying the day of the week, the day of the month, and the time of day the defendant is required to answer. If issued from the justice of the peace court, such citation shall command such parties to appear and answer on or before the first day of the first term of court which convenes after the expiration of 42 days from the date of issue thereof, specifying the day of the week, and the day of the month, that such term will meet."); 162 ("At any time before the plaintiff has introduced all of his evidence other than rebuttal evidence, the plaintiff may dismiss a case, or take a non-suit, which shall be entered in the minutes."); 166a(a) ("A party seeking to recover upon a claim, counterclaim, or cross-claim or to obtain a declaratory judgment may, at any time after the adverse party has appeared or answered, move with or without supporting affidavits for a summary judgment in his favor upon all or any part thereof."); 166a(b) ("A party against whom a claim, counterclaim, or cross-claim is asserted or a declaratory judgment is sought may, at any time, move with or without supporting affidavits for a summary judgment in his favor as to all or any part thereof."); 239 ("Upon such call of the docket, or at any time after a defendant is required to answer, the plaintiff may in term time take judgment by default against such defendant if he has not previously filed an answer, and provided that the return of service shall have been on file with the clerk for the length of time required by Rule 107."); 279 ("When a ground of recovery or defense consists of more than one element, if one or more of such elements necessary to sustain such ground of recovery or defense, and necessarily referable thereto, are submitted to and found by the jury, and one or more of such elements are omitted from the charge, without request or objection, and there is factually sufficient evidence to support a finding thereon, the trial court, at the request of either party, may after notice and hearing and at any time before the judgment is rendered, make and file written findings on such omitted element or elements in support of the judgment.") (emphases added).
See, e.g., Tex. R. App. P. 4.3(a) ("If a judgment is modified in any respect while the trial court retains plenary power, a period that, under these rules, runs from the date when the judgment is signed will run from the date when the modified judgment is signed."); 4.3(b) ("If the trial court corrects or reforms the judgment under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 316 after expiration of the trial court's plenary power, all periods provided in these rules that run from the date the judgment is signed run from the date the corrected judgment is signed for complaints that would not apply to the original judgment."); 9.2(a)(2) ("A document is filed in an appellate court by delivering it to: (1) the clerk of the court in which the document is to be filed; or (2) a justice or judge of that court who is willing to accept delivery. A justice or judge who accepts delivery must note on the document the date and time of delivery, which will be considered the time of filing, and must promptly send it to the clerk."); 9.2(c)(4) ("Unless a document must be filed by a certain time of day, a document is considered timely filed if it is electronically filed at any time before midnight (in the court's time zone) on the filing deadline."); 10.1(b) ("A party may file a response to a motion at any time before the court rules on the motion or by any deadline set by the court."); 34.5(b)(1) ("At any time before the clerk's record is prepared, any party may file with the trial court clerk a written designation specifying items to be included in the record."); 34.6(b)(1) ("At or before the time for perfecting the appeal, the appellant must request in writing that the official reporter prepare the reporter's record."); 42.2(a) ("At any time before the appellate court's decision, the appellate court may dismiss the appeal upon the appellant's motion."); 42.3 ("Dismissal or affirmance may occur if the appeal is subject to dismissal: . . . (c) because the appellant has failed to comply with a requirement of these rules, a court order, or a notice from the clerk requiring a response or other action within a specified time.") (emphases added).
1. Beginning of Periods. The date of judgment or order is signed as shown of record shall determine the beginning of the periods prescribed by these rules for the court's plenary power to grant a new trial or to vacate, modify, correct or reform a judgment or order and for filing in the trial court the various documents that these rules authorize a party to file within such periods including, but not limited to, motions for new trial, motions to modify judgment, motions to reinstate a case dismissed for want of prosecution, motions to vacate judgment and requests for findings of fact and conclusions of law; but this rule shall not determine what constitutes rendition of a judgment or order for any other purpose.Reading together Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 301, 305, and 306a, there should be one final judgment, typically in a single document prepared by the parties and signed by the trial judge with the date of signing stated in the judgment. Rule 306a does not require anything more specific than the date, and that date of judgment, or "judgment day"—not the specific time of day—determines the timing of post-judgment proceedings in the trial court and perfection of an appeal. Tex. R. Civ. P. 306a; Tex. R. App. P. 25.1, 26.1.
2. Date to Be Shown. Judges, attorneys and clerks are directed to use their best efforts to cause all judgments, decisions and orders of any kind to be reduced to writing and signed by the trial judge with the date of signing stated therein. If the date of signing is not recited in the judgment or order, it may be shown in the record by a certificate of the judge or otherwise; provided, however, that the absence of a showing of the date in the record shall not invalidate any judgment or order.
The adoption of Rule 306a marked a significant change in civil procedure, and the rule still reflects a cautionary statement that oral rendition of judgment in open court is still relevant for some purposes.
The court cites no authority that restricts the scope of the final judgment signed on August 21, 2018 from merging all actions taken in the case before and on that judgment day into the final judgment. If such authority were to exist, what would it do to the legal principles of merger and bar other than create chaos on a day designed to bring closure?
See Bonsmara Nat. Beef Co., LLC v. Hart of Tex. Cattle Feeders, LLC, 603 S.W.3d 385 (Tex. 2020) ("[O]ur rule has long been that 'a party against whom an interlocutory [order] has been rendered will have his right of appeal when . . . the same is merged in a final judgment disposing of the whole case.'" (citing Teer v. Duddlesten, 664 S.W.2d 702, 704 (Tex. 1984))). --------
Governments create courts to provide for the pacific resolution of disputes and to bring an end to those disputes. While courts cannot provide perfection, they can provide finality. That finality is critical to the maintenance of an orderly society. People have other things to do in life besides engaging in endless litigation. Or at least I hope they do. Accordingly, few things in civil law are more fundamental than the final judgment signed on judgment day.
Today this court without explanation muddles the law of merger and bar, creating needless confusion for those who read and cite our opinions. Justice Calvert admonished judges to take great care in drafting judgments. We should.
/s/ Charles A. Spain
Justice Panel consists of Justices Christopher, Spain, and Poissant. (Poissant, J., majority). (Spain, J., concurring and dissenting).
Alert