- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Silvels v. State
NICHOLAS V. MIDEY
SynopsisClaimant's motion seeking to "consolidate" an unfiled cause of action in bailment with a previously filed claim was denied. Case information
UID: 2012-009-020 Claimant(s): MILTON SILVELS Claimant short name: SILVELS Footnote (claimant name) : Defendant(s): THE STATE OF NEW YORK Footnote (defendant name) : Third-party claimant(s): Third-party defendant(s): Claim number(s): 111199 Motion number(s): M-81886 Cross-motion number(s): Judge: NICHOLAS V. MIDEY JR. Claimant's attorney: MILTON SILVELS, Pro Se HON. ERIC T. SCHNEIDERMAN Defendant's attorney: Attorney General (No appearance). Third-party defendant's attorney: Signature date: December 3, 2012 City: Syracuse Comments: Official citation: Appellate results: See also (multicaptioned case) Decision
Claimant has brought this motion seeking to "consolidate" a cause of action sounding in bailment with his previously filed Claim No. 111199.
The following papers were considered by the Court in connection with this motion:
Notice of Motion of Consolidation, Affidavit in Support, with Exhibits 1, 2
Correspondence dated July 6, 2012 from the Oneida County Department of Law 3
Filed Papers: Claim.
On July 28, 2005, claimant filed a claim (Claim No. 111199) with the Clerk of the Court of Claims seeking damages based upon allegations of illegal confinement and the failure to properly examine and treat a head injury suffered by him. This claim is still pending.
In the instant motion, claimant seeks to "consolidate" a cause of action, sounding in bailment, with Claim No. 111199. This cause of action allegedly accrued in January 2012 at Mid-State Correctional Facility. As set forth in his motion, claimant seeks damages in the amount of $24.40 for the loss of certain items of personal property, as well as additional damages for the loss of 96 family photographs. The Court notes that no claim for these alleged damages has been filed with the Clerk of the Court of Claims.
Claimant apparently relies upon CPLR 602, which provides that "[w]hen actions involving a common question of law or fact are pending before a court, the court, upon motion, may order a joint trial of any or all the matters in issue, [and] may order the actions consolidated".
In this particular matter, the Court does not find that the bailment action accruing in 2012 involves any question of law or fact which is common to any of the causes of action asserted in Claim No. 111199.
In addition, there is only one action pending before this Court at this time, that being Claim No. 111199, filed in July 2005. As noted, the bailment cause of action described in claimant's instant motion papers has not been asserted in any filed claim.
It therefore appears to this Court that by attempting to "consolidate" this bailment cause of action with his previously filed claim, claimant is either seeking to avoid the payment of a filing fee on his bailment claim, or is attempting to circumvent the time restrictions for the service and filing of an inmate bailment claim imposed by Court of Claims Act ยง 10 (9). In either event, and based upon the foregoing, claimant's reliance on CPLR 602 is misplaced.
Additionally, CPLR 601, which permits a party to "join as many claims as he may have against an adverse party" is similarly inapplicable, as there exists only one filed claim pertinent to this motion.
Accordingly, Motion No. M-81886 is hereby DENIED.
December 3, 2012
Syracuse, New York
NICHOLAS V. MIDEY JR.
Judge of the Court of Claims
Alert