- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Duff v. State
CHRISTOPHER J. McCARTHY
SynopsisCourt finds claimant failed to prove by a preponderance of the credible evidence that he was assaulted by defendant's employees. Case information
UID: 2012-040-098 Claimant(s): WILLIAM DUFF Claimant short name: DUFF Footnote (claimant name) : Defendant(s): THE STATE OF NEW YORK Footnote (defendant name) : Third-party claimant(s): Third-party defendant(s): Claim number(s): 113954 Motion number(s): Cross-motion number(s): Judge: CHRISTOPHER J. McCARTHY Claimant's attorney: William Duff, Pro Se ERIC T. SCHNEIDERMAN Defendant's attorney: Attorney General of the State of New York By: Michael C. Rizzo, Esq., AAG Third-party defendant's attorney: Signature date: December 3, 2012 City: Albany Comments: Official citation: Appellate results: See also (multicaptioned case) Decision
Pro se Claimant, William Duff, failed to establish by a preponderance of the credible evidence that Defendant was liable in connection with his Claim. The trial of this Claim was held by video conference on September 5, 2012, with the parties at Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, New York, and the Judge at the Court of Claims in Saratoga Springs, New York.
At trial, Claimant submitted into evidence, without objection, 11 documents including his Amended Claim, which he refers to as an Amended Complaint (Ex. 2). The State also submitted seven exhibits into evidence. Claimant testified on his own behalf and Defendant called four witnesses to testify: Correction Officers ("CO"s) Emanuel Coupal, Michael Dumas and Sergeant ("Sgt.") Joseph Seymour and Nurse Jerre White.
Claimant testified that, on April 19, 2007, he was incarcerated at Franklin Correctional Facility located in Malone, New York ("Franklin"); he stated that, while he was sitting on the floor for a few seconds, CO Coupal walked into the day room and said something to Claimant, but Claimant was unable to respond because he was feeling lightheaded. He stated that, when he regained his composure a few seconds later, he staggered to his feet and began to walk to his cube from the day room, in compliance with CO Coupal's direction. While Claimant was walking to his dorm, CO Coupal ordered him to step into the foyer area and the officer crossed in front of Claimant, causing Claimant and the officer to bump into each other. Claimant was then ordered to assume a pat-frisk position. Claimant stated he complied with the order.
Claimant further testified that, upon completion of the pat frisk, CO Coupal asked "what if I slapped you?" and Claimant replied: "I would have to contact Derek Champagne," the District Attorney of Franklin County. CO Coupal then paged Sgt. McClatchie. When the sergeant arrived, the CO related his version of the incident. Claimant advised the sergeant that CO Coupal's story was fabricated. Claimant further testified that CO Coupal then slapped Claimant in the back of the head and told him to be quiet.
Claimant testified that CO Dumas arrived and handcuffed Claimant's hands behind his back and escorted Claimant to a transport vehicle. Claimant told CO Dumas that CO Coupal's version of the incident was not true. CO Dumas then slapped Claimant and told him to be quiet. Claimant was transported to the facility infirmary and was taken to the first room on the right and remained handcuffed. Claimant stated that, while he was in that examination room, he was assaulted by Sgt. McClatchie, who punched Claimant in the face and pushed him backward onto a metal cart. He also said that CO Dumas and another officer also punched him in the face. Claimant testified that Nurse White and Sgt. Gates witnessed the assault and did not intervene. Claimant was then escorted to building 16, special housing unit ("SHU"), strip frisked and admitted (see Ex. 4).
On April 20, 2007, Claimant was issued a misbehavior report, charging him with violating facility rules §§ 102.10 (threats), 106.10 (direct order), 107.10 (interference with employee) and 115.10 (frisk search) (see Ex. 2, ¶ 22).
A Superintendent's Hearing was commenced on April 25, 2007 and was adjourned to May 1, 2007. On May 1, 2007, Claimant was found guilty and was sentenced to 90 days in SHU (see id., ¶ 23).
On or about May 6, 2007, Claimant was escorted to the facility infirmary room. Nine photographs were taken of Claimant's body, and Nurse White asked Claimant to write a brief statement and sign a medical form.
Claimant asserts that he suffered physical pain and mental anguish as a result of the assault.
CO Coupal stated that he is employed by the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision ("DOCCS") as a CO at Franklin and has been employed there for almost 14 years. He recalled the April 19, 2007 incident with Claimant. The witness stated that he was the J dorm housing officer that day. He said that Claimant was sitting on the floor in the day room and he entered the room and told Claimant that he either had to stand or sit on a chair. He stated that inmates are not allowed to sit on the floor. He said that, as Claimant exited the room, Claimant walked in such a way as to make physical contact with him. CO Coupal testified that Claimant made contact with him twice. CO Coupal advised Claimant to stand against the wall in a pat-frisk position. He performed a pat frisk and issued Claimant a misbehavior report. The witness made a call to have an area sergeant come to the J dorm. He said that a sergeant and an escort officer arrived. After explaining the situation to the sergeant, the two officers took control of Claimant and escorted him to the infirmary. CO Coupal did not see Claimant again. The witness testified that he did not threaten or strike Claimant and he did not witness either of the two other officers threaten or strike Claimant. Exhibit B is a copy of a May 4, 2007 memorandum the witness sent to Lieutenant ("Lt.") Dragoon in response to Claimant's complaint that he had been assaulted.
On cross-examination, CO Coupal stated that Claimant did not appear disoriented on April 19, 2007. He appeared to be watching television. The witness denied that he caused the initial contact with Claimant and reiterated that he did not see anyone strike or threaten Claimant.
CO Dumas stated that he has been employed by DOCCS for 19 years and that, on April 19, 2007, he was working at Franklin. He was the escort officer on that date. He stated that he did not observe CO Coupal strike Claimant. Neither the witness nor Sgt. McClatchie had any physical interaction with Claimant. Exhibit C is a copy of a May 3, 2007 memorandum the witness sent to Lt. Dragoon in response to Claimant's complaint that he had been assaulted.
Sgt. Seymour testified that he has been employed by DOCCS since 1989 and was working at Franklin as a correction officer in April 2007. He was promoted to sergeant in late 2007. Sgt. Seymour did not escort Claimant to the infirmary or to SHU on April 19, 2007. He stated that he does not know Claimant. He stated that he did not strike Claimant on April 19, 2007 or witness any other staff member strike Claimant on that date (see Ex. H).
Ms. White testified that she is a registered nurse ("RN") in New York State and has been since 1994. She is employed by DOCCS as an RN and has been working at Franklin for approximately six and one-half years. The witness identified Exhibit F as an April 19, 2007 entry in Claimant's Ambulatory Health Record ("AHR"), which she prepared in SHU prior to Claimant's admission there. She examined Claimant and recorded that Claimant denied he had any injuries, and she did not see any sign of injuries. The witness testified that, on April 19, 2007, she never saw Claimant being assaulted by any staff member at Franklin. Exhibit G is a copy of a May 3, 2007 memorandum the witness sent to Sgt. Deshane in response to Claimant's allegations that he had been assaulted, wherein the witness states that she did not see Claimant being assaulted on April 19, 2007.
"In situations involving inmate allegations of excessive force by a C.O., such as here, the credibility of the respective witnesses is often the dispositive factor" (Clark v State of New York, UID No. 2003-029-272 [Ct Cl, Mignano, J., April 4, 2003]; see Shirvanion v State of New York, 64 AD3d 1113, 1114 [3d Dept 2009]; Bush v State of New York, 57 AD3d 1066, 1067 [3d Dept 2008]). The Court has considered the evidence, including a review of the exhibits, listening to the witnesses testify and observing their demeanor as they did so. The Court credits the testimony of the State's witnesses that they did not threaten or strike Claimant, nor did they witness anyone threaten or strike Claimant. The Court also credits Exhibits B, C, D, G and H, the various memoranda from Franklin staff, reporting that they did not strike or threaten Claimant nor did they see anyone threaten or strike Claimant.
Therefore, based upon the foregoing, the Court concludes that Claimant failed to establish by a preponderance of the credible evidence that he was assaulted or threatened on April 19, 2007, and the Claim is hereby dismissed. The Court notes that the Amended Claim alleges that certain items of Claimant's property were lost when he was transferred following the April 19, 2007 incident. Claimant offered no evidence on this cause of action at trial and this cause of action is also dismissed.
All motions made at trial upon which the Court reserved decision are now denied.
The Chief Clerk is directed to enter judgment accordingly.
December 3, 2012
Albany, New York
CHRISTOPHER J. McCARTHY
Judge of the Court of Claims
Alert