Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Biro v. State

New York State Court of Claims
Nov 2, 2015

Alan C. Marin Alan C. Marin

Synopsis Case information

Defendant(s):

Third-party claimant(s):

Third-party defendant(s):

Claim number(s):

Signature date:

Official citation:

Appellate results:

See also (multicaptioned case)


UID:

2015-016-065

Claimant(s):

FRANCISKA BIRO

Claimant short name:

BIRO

Footnote (claimant name) :

THE STATE OF NEW YORK

Footnote (defendant name) :

126536

Motion number(s):

M-87140

Cross-motion number(s):

CM-87271

Judge:

Alan C. Marin

Claimant's attorney:

Law Offices of Michael S. Lamonsoff By: Stacey Haskel, Esq.

Defendant's attorney:

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General By: Joseph L. Paterno, AAG

Third-party defendant's attorney:

November 2, 2015

City:

New York

Comments:


Decision

Claimant Franciska Biro has moved for leave to file a late claim for a cause of action that she alleges arose from a malfunctioning elevator at a Department of Motor Vehicles office in Kings County on March 23, 2015: "Claimant Franciska Biro was walking into/out of one of the elevators when she was caused to be violently crushed as the elevator doors rapidly closed on her."

Claimant's Affirmation, exhibit A (paragraph 3 of the Claim).

The defendant State of New York opposes the late claim application and has moved to dismiss the original claim for untimeliness and lack of specificity. For a personal injury cause of action, section 11 (b) of the Court of Claims Act (the "Act") requires that the claim provide the time and place of occurrence, the nature of the claim and the items of damages or injuries alleged.

Both parties' submissions contain copies of the claim that were stamped as received on August 4, 2015 by the Office of the Attorney General, but both submissions have no date of accrual. In addition, there is a claim from Ms. Biro that was stamped as filed with the Court of Claims on August 3, 2015; this claim is identical to the claim appended to the parties' submissions, except that its second paragraph includes the phrase, "on March 23, 2015" for the date of accrual.

Exhibit A to claimant's Affirmation and exhibit A to defendant's Affirmation in Support of Cross Motion and in Opposition to Claimant's Motion (hereinafter "defendant's Affirmation")

The claims served on the Attorney General do not satisfy section 11(b), and the claim in either form was not served or filed within 90 days of March 23, 2015 (on or about Monday, June 22, 2015). These defects, which are jurisdictional in nature, can be remedied by applying for leave to file and serve a late claim under section 10 (6) of The Act.

The Court of Appeals has stated that "Because suits against the State are allowed only by the State's waiver of sovereign immunity and in derogation of the common law, statutory requirements conditioning suit must be strictly construed . . ." (Dreger v New York State Thruway Auth., 81 NY2d 721, 724 [1992]).

In deciding whether such request complies with section 10 (6), six factors must be considered, although the presence or absence of any particular one is not dispositive: whether (i) defendant had notice of the essential facts constituting the claim; (ii) defendant had an opportunity to investigate the circumstances underlying the claim; (iii) defendant was substantially prejudiced; (iv) the delay was excusable; (v) claimant has any other available remedy; and (vi) the claim appears to be meritorious.

See Bay Terrace Coop. Section IV v New York State Employees' Retirement Sys. Policemen's & Firemen's Retirement Sys., 55 NY2d 979 (1982); Scarver v State of New York, 233 AD2d 858 (4th Dept 1996).

The first three factors, notice, opportunity to investigate and prejudice, are closely linked and can be considered together. Ms. Biro has indicated that she filled out an incident report on March 23, 2015, but states that she has been unable to obtain a copy. The aforementioned August 3 and 4 dates of receipt would mean that defendant received notice (leaving aside the incident report) some 45 days beyond the 90-day statutory period. Such can prejudice a defendant and make an investigation difficult, but in its motion papers, defendant does not contend that it has been prejudiced or did not have an opportunity to investigate. However, defendant did note that the incident report may have been given to an employee of the Atlantic Center Mall (see below).

Brewer v State of New York, 176 Misc 2d 337 (Ct Cl 1998).

Paragraph 13 of defendant's Affirmation.

Defendant contends that claimant has failed to offer a reasonable excuse because her "surgery is alleged to have occurred on May 8, 2015 46 days after the alleged accident [and] the last day in which to serve a claim would have been June 22nd.." As for this factor, claimant cites three cases to the effect that failure to offer a valid excuse is not fatal to gaining permission to file a late claim. In any event, the facts here are not sufficient to show that Ms. Biro's delay in bringing the claim was excusable (see Goldstein v State of New York, 75 AD2d 613 [2d Dept 1980]).

Paragraph 9 of defendant's Affirmation.

The factors on appearance of merit and alternate available remedy will be considered together inasmuch as defendant argues that the correct defendant (or defendants) are non-State entities who must be sued in Supreme Court, not the Court of Claims.

The DMV office that Ms. Biro had entered on March 23, 2015 was located at 625 Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. The parties agree that this State agency was located in a building that was owned by the City of New York.

Defendant is not challenged in its explanation that the City of New York has leased the property to Atlantic Center Fort Greene Associates, L.P.; that clauses 11(C), 11(D), and 68 of the lease agreement give the building's tenants the right to use the passenger elevators; and that Atlantic Center Fort Greene Associates, the landlord, bears responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the elevators:

"Landlord may stop services of the elevators, escalators, plumbing, power systems or other services, if any, when necessary, by reason of accident or for repairs, alterations, replacements or improvements necessary or desirable in the judgment of Landlord for as long as may be reasonably required by reason thereof" (defendant's Affirmation, exhibit D [the lease], clause 68).


Ms. Biro in her claim calls the building the "Atlantic Terminal Mall"; defendant, the "Atlantic Center Mall." Defendant attached a one-page photo with a list of anchor tenants, which included the DMV, Pathmark, Marshalls, Old Navy, and Office Max, among others.

Claimant's Affirmation, exhibit A (paragraph 2 of the claim), and defendant's Affirmation, paragraph 13.

Exhibit C of defendant's Affirmation. The DMV office was apparently on the second floor; paragraph 2 of claimant's Affirmation states that the accident involved "the elevator leading from the second floor to the first floor."

Regarding late claim applications in the Court of Claims, the First Department has stated: "To be meritorious, a claim must not be patently groundless, frivolous or legally defective, and the record as a whole must give reasonable cause to believe that a valid cause of action exists (citation omitted)" (Sands v State of New York, 49 AD3d 444 [2008]).

In the Sands case, the "legally defective" language was part of its analysis of one of the six factors; but it is well established that it would be futile to grant an application under section 10 (6) if the proposed claim lacks a basis in law ( Prusack v State of New York, 117 AD2d 729 [2d Dept 1986]). Franciska Biro has pointed to no act or omission that would impute to the State, through its DMV office at the Atlantic Mall, any responsibility for her accident with the elevator: the claim thus lacks subject matter jurisdiction, and the Court of Claims is not the proper forum for Ms. Biro's suit.

* * *

In view of the foregoing, and having considered the parties' submissions, IT IS ORDERED that motion No. M-87140 is denied, cross motion No. CM-87271 is granted, and claim No. 126536 is dismissed.

The following were reviewed: from claimant - - a Notice of Motion and Affirmation (with exhibits A and B); from defendant - - a Notice of Cross Motion and an Affirmation in Support of Cross Motion and in Opposition to Claimant's Motion (with exhibits A through D).
--------

November 2, 2015

New York, New York

Alan C. Marin

Judge of the Court of Claims