Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arnold v. State

SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS
Dec 6, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellant Chris Anthony Arnold was charged with capital murder for the death of eighty-five-year-old Maureen Jones. On the morning after a Wednesday bible study, Maureen's friend Pauline discovered Maureen lying face down, partially clothed, with a feminine-hygiene pad between her legs. Emergency personnel pronounced Maureen dead at the scene. Officers observed bruising, blood, possible trauma to the face, a dark-colored scarf tied around the neck, undergarments nearby, and a chemical odor consistent with bleach. An autopsy determined the cause of death to be ligature strangulation. Investigators collected an off-white piece of a latex glove and a small blue piece of plastic from the scene.

Police interviewed Arnold, who admitted being at Maureen's home the prior night to fish from her boat and provided a statement describing events he claimed to have observed and his leaving when Maureen became "cranky." Laboratory testing showed Arnold's DNA on both of Maureen's hands and on the two objects recovered from the scene; the latex-glove piece yielded a single-source DNA profile consistent with Arnold, and the plastic yielded a mixture consistent with Maureen's and Arnold's DNA.

The State filed a felony information charging Arnold with capital murder on February 13, 2017. After a two-day jury trial in September 2017, the jury convicted Arnold of the lesser-included offense of first-degree murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. Arnold appealed, asserting the circuit court erred in denying his motion for directed verdict on grounds the evidence was insufficient to support the jury's verdict.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the circuit court erred in denying Arnold's motion for a directed verdict—i.e., whether the evidence was sufficient to support the jury's conviction for first-degree murder.
  2. Whether the DNA evidence admitted at trial was sufficient to establish Arnold's identity as the person who purposely caused Maureen's death (Arnold's challenge focused on the sufficiency of the DNA evidence and the circumstantial nature of that evidence).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Arnold contended the circuit court should have granted his motion for directed verdict because the State's evidence was insufficient to support a conviction for first-degree murder.
  • He conceded being at Maureen's home but argued the evidence was purely circumstantial: his DNA was found only on Maureen's hands and on two objects (a portion of a latex glove and a piece of plastic), which he claimed did not establish the time the DNA was deposited or exclude innocent explanations (for example, Pauline's testimony that her son had helped Maureen).
  • He argued the DNA evidence, by itself, did not exclude every other reasonable hypothesis of innocence and therefore was insufficient to prove he purposely caused Maureen's death.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Taffner v. State, 2018 Ark. 99, 541 S.W.3d 430 An appeal from the denial of a motion for directed verdict is treated as a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence. The court applied this rule to treat Arnold's appeal from the denial of his directed-verdict motion as a sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenge.
Howard v. State, 2016 Ark. 434, 506 S.W.3d 843 Standard for reviewing sufficiency: determine whether the verdict is supported by substantial evidence; substantial evidence defined. The court cited the standard and definition of substantial evidence and stated it would view the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, considering only evidence that supports the verdict.
Williams v. State, 338 Ark. 97, 991 S.W.2d 565 (1999) There is no distinction between circumstantial and direct evidence when reviewing for sufficiency of the evidence. The court relied on this principle to evaluate the circumstantial DNA evidence without giving it lesser weight solely because it was circumstantial.
Moore v. State, 372 Ark. 579, 279 S.W.3d 69 (2008) Circumstantial evidence may support a conviction but must be consistent with the defendant's guilt and inconsistent with any other reasonable conclusion; excluding every other hypothesis is for the jury. The court applied this rule to explain that the jury, not the court, determines whether the circumstantial evidence excludes every other reasonable hypothesis.
Engram v. State, 341 Ark. 196, 15 S.W.3d 678 (2000) DNA evidence is an accepted form of proof of guilt. The court cited Engram to support its acceptance of DNA evidence as probative and permissible proof linking Arnold to the victim and the objects at the scene.
Williams v. State, 2011 Ark. 432, 385 S.W.3d 157 The jury is responsible for assessing witness credibility and resolving conflicts or inconsistencies in the evidence. The court emphasized that credibility and conflict resolution were for the jury, which had weighed the testimony and resolved inconsistencies in this case.
Williams v. State, 347 Ark. 728, 67 S.W.3d 548 (2002) The jury alone determines what weight to give evidence and may accept or reject evidence in whole or in part. The court relied on this principle to affirm that the jury's weighing of evidence supported the conviction when viewed in the light most favorable to the State.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by framing the appeal as a sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenge pursuant to Taffner and applied the established standard from Howard: the court must determine whether the verdict is supported by substantial evidence, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the State and considering only evidence that supports the verdict.

The court noted it makes no distinction between circumstantial and direct evidence for sufficiency review (citing Williams (1999)) and recognized that circumstantial evidence may sustain a conviction if consistent with guilt and inconsistent with other reasonable conclusions (citing Moore). The court further reiterated that the jury is responsible for credibility determinations and resolving conflicts in the evidence (citing Williams (2011) and Williams (2002)). The court also observed that this court has consistently accepted DNA evidence as proof of guilt (citing Engram).

Applying those principles to the record, the court summarized the relevant evidence: (1) Pauline's testimony about the condition and discovery of the victim; (2) Arnold's admission that he had been at Maureen's home the night of the murder and his statement describing his observations and departure; (3) physical-scene observations including ligature around the neck, trauma, and a bleach-like odor; (4) autopsy finding of ligature strangulation; and (5) forensic testing showing Arnold's DNA on both of Maureen's hands and on the two objects recovered (a single-source profile on the glove fragment and a mixture on the plastic consistent with Maureen and Arnold).

The court addressed Arnold's contention that the DNA findings could reflect an innocent explanation (for example, that someone other than Arnold had assisted Maureen) and that the DNA on the objects did not establish timing. The court explained those are matters for the jury to assess in weighing credibility and resolving conflicting inferences. Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, the court concluded the evidence was of sufficient force and character to support the jury's conclusion and that the jury could reasonably find Arnold purposely caused Maureen's death.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court affirmed the conviction and sentence. The opinion's core ruling is AFFIRMED.

Implications: The direct effect is that Arnold's conviction for first-degree murder and his life sentence are upheld. The court found the evidence—particularly the DNA evidence in conjunction with the other factual and forensic evidence—sufficient as a matter of law to sustain the conviction. The opinion does not purport to announce any new legal precedent beyond applying existing sufficiency standards and precedent regarding DNA and circumstantial evidence. The court also stated, pursuant to Arkansas Supreme Court Rule 4-3(i), that the record was examined for any adverse rulings to appellant and no prejudicial error was found.

Show all summary ...

JOHN DAN KEMP, Chief Justice

APPEAL FROM THE PULASKI COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
[NO. 60CR-17-534] HONORABLE HERBERT WRIGHT, JUDGE AFFIRMED. JOHN DAN KEMP, Chief Justice

Appellant Chris Arnold appeals an order of the Pulaski County Circuit Court convicting him of the first-degree murder of eighty-five-year-old Maureen Jones ("Maureen") and sentencing him to a term of life imprisonment. For reversal, Arnold argues that the circuit court erred in denying his motion for directed verdict because substantial evidence did not support the jury's verdict that he committed the offense. We affirm.

For clarity, we refer to the victim and some witnesses by their first names.

I. Facts

Pauline Arnold ("Pauline"), Arnold's mother and Maureen's friend, regularly attended a bible study at Indianhead Baptist Church in Sherwood on Wednesday nights. Pauline stated that she and Maureen sat together at the bible study on Wednesday, November 30, 2016, and then Maureen headed home. The next morning, Pauline received a call from Lois Olsen ("Lois"), the church secretary, because Maureen had not attended a church breakfast meeting. Pauline proceeded to Maureen's home to check on her. When Pauline arrived at the residence, she entered through an unlocked back door and found Maureen in the hallway lying face down and partially clothed with a feminine-hygiene pad between her legs. Pauline stated that Maureen's body felt cold, and she called 911. Lois and Gary Brewer ("Gary") also entered the home. Pauline and Gary covered Maureen with a blanket because "she [wasn't] decent."

Officers from the Sherwood Police Department were dispatched to the victim's home to investigate a homicide. Detective Kisha Slaton testified at a pretrial hearing that Pauline stated, "Well, my son was just over here [at the house fishing] last night, and he didn't say there was anything wrong with her." Detective Slaton asked Pauline to call Arnold and then told Arnold to meet the officers at the police department for an interview. Emergency personnel later arrived and pronounced Maureen dead at the scene. Officers observed bruising, blood, and possible trauma to Maureen's face. A dark-colored scarf was tied around her neck, and her undergarments were found lying approximately five feet away. Officers also noticed a chemical odor consistent with bleach. They retrieved an off-white piece of a latex glove and a small blue piece of plastic and sent the two objects to the Arkansas State Crime Laboratory for testing. An autopsy revealed that Maureen's cause of death was ligature strangulation. Subsequent testing revealed that Arnold's DNA was present on both of Maureen's hands. Tests also confirmed the presence of Arnold's DNA on the pieces of latex glove and plastic.

Detective Slaton and Detective Frank Spence interviewed Arnold at the Sherwood Police Department. In a statement to police, Arnold related that Maureen had allowed him to use her flat-bottomed boat and that he had been fishing at her house on the night of the murder. Arnold stated that he had seen Maureen feed her cats and then fall down the back-porch steps. He also stated that her face was bleeding and that he picked her up, carried her onto the porch, and placed her in front of a chair so that she could sit down. He claimed that Maureen slapped him and said, "[Y]ou don't need to do this. I don't need help[.]" According to Arnold, Maureen walked into the house and began arguing with someone. He told the officer, "[S]he was arguing with somebody, I don't know who the hell it was. But I told Maureen I was getting the hell out of there because she was getting cranky."

On February 13, 2017, the State filed a felony information charging Arnold with one count of capital murder for Maureen's death. Following a two-day jury trial in September 2017, the jury convicted Arnold of the lesser-included offense of first-degree murder and sentenced him to a term of life imprisonment in the Arkansas Department of Correction. He timely filed his notice of appeal.

II. Sufficiency of the Evidence

Arnold's sole point on appeal is that the circuit court erred in denying his motion for directed verdict. Specifically, Arnold does not dispute the elements of the first-degree-murder offense, as defined in Arkansas Code Annotated section 5-10-102(a)(2) (Supp. 2017). He challenges the sufficiency of the DNA evidence that was used to prove his identity as the person who purposely caused Maureen's death. He concedes that he was at Maureen's home on the night of the murder but contends that the State's evidence was purely circumstantial because his DNA was only on the victim's hands and on the two objects found at the scene--a portion of a latex glove and a piece of plastic.

An appeal from the denial of a motion for a directed verdict is treated as a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence. Taffner v. State, 2018 Ark. 99, 541 S.W.3d 430. In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence, we determine whether the verdict is supported by substantial evidence. Howard v. State, 2016 Ark. 434, 506 S.W.3d 843. Substantial evidence is evidence that is of sufficient force and character that it will, with reasonable certainty, compel a conclusion one way or the other, without resorting to speculation or conjecture. Id. In reviewing a sufficiency challenge, we view the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, considering only evidence that supports the verdict. Id.

This court makes no distinction between circumstantial and direct evidence when reviewing for sufficiency of the evidence. Williams v. State, 338 Ark. 97, 991 S.W.2d 565 (1999). Circumstantial evidence may provide a basis to support a conviction, but it must be consistent with the defendant's guilt and inconsistent with any other reasonable conclusion. Moore v. State, 372 Ark. 579, 279 S.W.3d 69 (2008). Whether the evidence excludes every other hypothesis is left for the jury to decide. Id. Further, this court has consistently accepted DNA evidence as proof of guilt. Engram v. State, 341 Ark. 196, 15 S.W.3d 678 (2000).

In the case at bar, Pauline testified at trial that her son told her that he had picked up Maureen and helped her into the living room. Arnold asserts that "[t]his innocent explanation [explains] how the defendant's DNA was present on the victim's person" but that it does not exclude "every other reasonable hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused." He further contends that his DNA found on the glove and the plastic piece does not establish the time that his DNA was left on the objects.

On this issue, the jury also heard testimony from Jennifer Beaty, the DNA supervisor of the DNA section of the Arkansas State Crime Laboratory. Beaty testified that DNA found on Maureen's left and right hands was consistent with the DNA profile obtained from Arnold. Beaty also testified that she obtained a single-source DNA profile on the latex glove belonging to Arnold. She further stated that her testing on the blue piece of plastic revealed a DNA mixture consistent with both Maureen's and Arnold's DNA.

Beaty also testified that the tests on the Maureen's vaginal swabs were "all consistent with the DNA that was extracted from Maureen Jones" and that she did not discern foreign male DNA from the rectal swabs. Beaty did state that the tape lifts from the victim's underwear and pants contained DNA consistent with "more than one male," including Arnold. --------

This court has stated that it is the jury's responsibility to assess the credibility of the witnesses and to resolve any conflicts or inconsistencies in the evidence. Williams v. State, 2011 Ark. 432, 385 S.W.3d 157. The jury alone determines what weight to give the evidence and may reject it or accept all or any part of it that the jury believes to be true. Williams v. State, 347 Ark. 728, 67 S.W.3d 548 (2002). Here, the jury weighed the testimony of the witnesses and resolved any conflicts or inconsistencies presented. Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the State, we hold that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to sustain Arnold's first-degree murder conviction. Accordingly, we affirm.

VI. Rule 4-3(i)

In compliance with Arkansas Supreme Court Rule 4-3(i), the record has been examined for all objections, motions, and requests made by either party that were decided adversely to appellant, and no prejudicial error has been found.

Affirmed.

William R. Simpson, Jr., Public Defender, by: Clint Miller, Dep. Public Defender, for appellant.

Leslie Rutledge, Att'y Gen., by: Jason Michael Johnson, Ass't Att'y Gen., for appellee.