Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Metz v. Saint Joseph Reg'l Med. Center-Plymouth Campus, Inc.

COURT OF APPEALS OF INDIANA
Nov 15, 2018

Tavitas, Judge.

MEMORANDUM DECISION

Pursuant to Ind. Appellate Rule 65(D), this Memorandum Decision shall not be regarded as precedent or cited before any court except for the purpose of establishing the defense of res judicata, collateral estoppel, or the law of the case. ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT David V. Miller
DVM Law, LLC
Newburgh, Indiana George C. Barnett, Jr.
Barnett Law, LLC
Evansville, Indiana ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE Kirk D. Bagrowski
Hammond, Indiana Appeal from the St. Joseph Circuit Court The Honorable John E. Broden, Judge Trial Court Cause No. 71C01-1705-CT-233 Tavitas, Judge.




Case Summary

[1] Amy Metz, as mother and next friend of Kiara Metz, an incapacitated minor, appeals the trial court's dismissal of her complaint against the Saint Joseph Regional Medical Center-Plymouth Campus, Inc.; Saint Joseph Regional Medical Center, Inc.; Joel Schumacher, M.D.; and Plymouth Family and Internal Medicine (collectively, "Medical Providers"). We affirm.

Issue

[2] Metz raises several issues, which we consolidate and restate as whether the trial court properly determined that the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act governs Metz's claims against Medical Providers.

Facts

[3] In May 2017, Metz filed a complaint against Medical Providers alleging negligence and requesting punitive damages. Metz alleged that her daughter, Kiara, was born on August 6, 2004, at Saint Joseph Regional Medical Center-Plymouth Campus ("Plymouth Hospital") and that Dr. Schumacher was engaged to provide services, "including but not limited to the timely review of TSH Test Results regarding infants born at the Plymouth Hospital, and the timely communication of those results to the appropriate hospital office and to the parents of the said newborn infants." Appellants' App. Vol. II pp. 18-19. Metz alleged that a blood sample was obtained from Kiara by the delivery team and was sent to the Indiana University Newborn Screening Laboratory [5] Medical Providers filed a motion to dismiss pursuant to Indiana Trial Rule 12(B)(1) and Indiana Trial Rule 12(B)(6). Medical Providers argued that the matter was barred by the statute of limitations set out in the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act ("MMA"). Medical Providers argued that the alleged acts and omissions constitute claims of medical negligence rather than general negligence, and thus, the MMA applies. According to Medical Providers, Metz failed to file a timely proposed complaint with the medical review panel and failed to file a claim before Kiara's eighth birthday as required by the MMA. [6] Metz responded by arguing that the MMA did not apply because Medical Providers "simply failed to perform an administrative duty to read and report the critical information in those letters." Id. at 76. Metz contended that the "MMA cannot, by any stretch of its statutory language, be interpreted to include the failure to perform a purely administrative act." Id. According to Metz, her claims "sound[] in common law negligence against the [Medical Providers]." Id. at 80. [7] In January 2018, the trial court granted Medical Providers' motion to dismiss pursuant to both Trial Rule 12(B)(1) and Trial Rule 12(B)(6) as follows:

11. [ ] [T]his court found the discursive analysis as set out in Terry v. Community Health Network, 17 N.E.3d 389 (Ind. Ct. App. 2014) and Robertson v. Anonymous Clinic, 63 N.E.3d 349 (Ind. Ct. App. 2016) to be most helpful. Both cases emphasized a focus on "whether the claim is based on the provider's behavior or practices while acting in his professional capacity as a provider of medical services." Terry, [17 N.E.3d] at 393 (citing

Madison Ctr
, Inc., v. R. R. K., 853 N.E.2d 1286, 1288 (Ind. Ct. App. 2006). Both cases then emphasized that the court's true focus must be on whether the issues are capable of resolution without referring to the medical standard of care; if so, the claims are not subject to the MMA. Robertson, [63 N.E.3d] at 360.
12. With that analysis in mind, the focus shifts to the actual text of the allegations in Plaintiff's Complaint and the contents of the designated evidence regarding the actual acts of alleged negligence. As discerned by this court, the acts of alleged negligence asserted by Plaintiff are as follows: A. Neither Dr. Schumacher nor any other named Defendant reported the abnormal TSH Test Results information to Plaintiff or anyone associated with Kiara's parents; B. Neither Dr. Schumacher nor any other named Defendant caused Kiara to be retested as required by the August 16 report; C. On or about August 20, 2004, Plaintiff was advised by a staff person of Dr. Schumacher that the results of Kiara's infant blood screen were all normal; D. Defendants failed to provide Plaintiff with a copy of or advise her of the contents of an August 31, 2004 letter from the IU Lab advising Defendants that the Lab had yet to receive a follow up blood sample as requested; E. Plaintiff was not made aware of the abnormal test result until September 25, 2004 when she received a letter from the IU Infant Screening Laboratory; F. Plaintiff did not receive an actual copy of the August 31, 2004 letter from the IU Lab until late September or early October of 2004; G. Plaintiff contends in paragraph 31 of her Complaint that these failures were purely the result of lack of proper attention and/or administrative or clerical failures, none of which involved the exercise of medical skill or judgment.

13. This court finds that the alleged acts of negligence set out above do have to do with the provider's behavior or practices while acting in his professional capacity as a provider of medical services. Further, there is a causal connection between the conduct complained of and the nature of the patient-health care provider relationship. The court also notes that the test involved revealed a "borderline abnormal" reading. Such a reading makes the medical issues more complicated and would involve an analysis of the medical standard of care and be outside the common knowledge of a lay juror. In the end, this court cannot conclude Defendants' alleged acts of negligence are demonstrably unrelated to the promotion of the Plaintiff's health or not involving the provider's exercise of professional expertise, skill, or judgment. Therefore, Plaintiff's claim is governed by the terms and provisions of the MMA.

Appellants' App. pp. 14-15.

Analysis

[8] Metz appeals the trial court's grant of Medical Providers' motion to dismiss pursuant to both Indiana Trial Rule 12(B)(1) and Indiana Trial Rule 12(B)(6). Trial Rule 12(B)(1) addresses the "[l]ack of jurisdiction over the subject matter." In reviewing a motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to Trial Rule 12(B)(1), the relevant question is whether the type of claim presented falls within the general scope of the authority conferred upon the court by constitution or statute. Robertson v. Anonymous Clinic, 63 N.E.3d 349, 356 (Ind. Ct. App. 2016), trans. denied. A motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction presents a threshold question with respect to a court's power [15] To be outside the MMA, "a health care provider's actions must be demonstrably unrelated to the promotion of the plaintiff's health or an exercise of the provider's professional expertise, skill, or judgment." Id. at 186. "[T]he test is whether the claim is based on the provider's behavior or practices while acting in his professional capacity as a provider of medical services.'" Robertson, 63 N.E.3d at 358 (quoting Madison Ctr., Inc. v. R.R.K., 853 N.E.2d 1286, 1288 (Ind. Ct. App. 2006), trans. denied). We have also noted that:

A case sounds in ordinary negligence [rather than medical negligence] where the factual issues are capable of resolution by a jury without application of the standard of care prevalent in the local medical community. By contrast, a claim falls under the [MMA] where there is a causal connection between the conduct complained of and the nature of the patient-health care provider relationship.

Id
. (quoting Terry v. Cmty. Health Network, Inc., 17 N.E.3d 389, 393 (Ind. Ct. App. 2014)) (internal citations omitted). [16] In support of her argument that the MMA does not apply, Metz relies on Preferred Prof. Insurance Co. v. West, 23 N.E.3d 716 (Ind. Ct. App. 2014), trans. denied. In West, the plaintiff sustained a workplace injury due to the actions of her coworker, who was taking narcotic pain medications. The plaintiff brought a claim against her coworker's medical providers, and the trial court determined that the MMA did not apply to the plaintiff's claims. On appeal, the plaintiff claimed that the medical provider's office failed to place a telephone message slip in his medical file and that her coworker's nurse did not provide him with the proper warnings and precautions regarding taking narcotic pain medications. [17] Regarding the message slip, we concluded:
[T]he essence of the claimed misconduct does not involve any exercise of professional medical judgment or skill by the medical provider. We have recognized that the text of the MMA indicates that the legislature intended to exclude from the MMA "conduct of a provider unrelated to the provider's exercise of judgment or skill." [ B. R. ex rel. Todd v. State, 1 N.E.3d 708, 716 (Ind. Ct. App. 2013) (quoting Collins v. Thakkar, 552 N.E.2d 507, 510-11 (Ind. Ct. App. 1990), trans. denied), trans. denied.] Indeed, there is no need for a medical review panel, the purpose of which "is to provide an expert determination on the question of whether a provider complied with the appropriate standard of care." Id. The issues surrounding the administrative matter of the filing of the message slip are within the understanding of the average lay juror. A jury would be capable of resolving factual issues without applying the standard of care prevalent in the local medical community, and jurors' common knowledge and experience would enable them to understand these circumstances. Accordingly, the trial court properly determined this claim was not within the scope of the MMA.
West, 23 N.E.3d at 728. [18] Regarding the nurse's failure to provide proper warnings to the coworker, we concluded:
The Wests' other claimed basis of negligence is that Nurse P allegedly failed to provide the proper warnings and instructions to Michael—because she was not trained properly on what to say, she negligently failed to follow procedure, or for some other

reason. In contrast to the administrative task of filing the message slip, which we found did not fall within the purview of the MMA, we find that the allegations that Nurse P failed to warn Michael present a set of facts that allege negligence "at the periphery of medical malpractice." [Eads v. Cmty. Hosp., 932 N.E.2d 1239, 1244 (Ind. 2010)]. It is one of those "grey areas on the fringe of the MMA[.]" Id. On one hand, there appears to be no allegation that a diagnosis was in error, that the prescribed medication was inappropriate for Michael's symptoms or condition, or that Dr. H did not prescribe the correct dosage. However, the claim that Nurse P failed to warn Michael at least potentially calls into question the degree of skill exercised by Michael's health care provider. As support for their position that the MMA does not apply to their claims, the Wests characterize Nurse P as a "non-medical employee," because she was a certified athletic trainer and not a licensed nurse, and that her alleged failure to communicate warnings to Michael was "clerical." Appellees' Wests' Br. at 8. However, Nurse P was Dr. M's assistant, was an employee of the medical provider, was considered the acting nurse, and was responsible for communicating with patients and physicians, including regarding medications. Therefore, under the facts of this case, we do not find the athletic trainer versus licensed nurse distinction to be legally dispositive. Assuming without deciding that the claimed failure to warn Michael about the effects and restrictions of the medication constitutes giving (or failing to give) medical care as considered by the MMA, our inquiry does not end there.

Id
. at 728-29. [19] We then went on to conclude that, regardless, the plaintiff was not a "patient" under the MMA, and the MMA was not "intended to cover claims by third parties having absolutely no relationship to the doctor or medical provider." Id. [23] Although we sympathize with Metz's situation, "[i]t is difficult to contemplate that [these services] fall[] outside the [MMA]." Id. Under the circumstances here, we conclude that the MMA applies to Metz's claim. Because Metz failed to present the claim to a medical review panel and failed to file the claim in a timely manner, the trial court properly dismissed Metz's complaint against Medical Providers.

In support of her argument, Metz relies on Bader v. Johnson, 732 N.E.2d 1212 (Ind. 2000), for the proposition that expert medical testimony is not required to prove that a health care worker should provide test results to a patient. Bader, however, was a medical malpractice action in which the health care providers failed to provide test results to the patient. Our supreme court noted that "expert medical testimony is usually required to determine whether a physician's conduct fell below the applicable standard of care." Bader, 732 N.E.2d at 1217. The court then held that, because the failure to provide test results is not a technical complex matter, expert medical testimony was probably not required to determine whether the health care providers breached their duty. Id. at 1218. Bader was decided in the context of determining breach of duty under the MMA, not whether the MMA applied at all. We do not find Bader persuasive here.

In support of her argument, Metz relies on H.D. v. BHC Meadows Hospital, Inc., 884 N.E.2d 849, 854-55 (Ind. Ct. App. 2008), trans. denied, in which this court held that a hospital's "negligent or reckless dissemination of a patient's confidential information to members of the general public" did not come within the purview of the MMA. The facts of H.D. are not comparable to the situation here, and H.D. is not applicable. --------

Conclusion

[24] The trial court properly dismissed Metz's complaint against Medical Providers pursuant to Trial Rule 12(B)(1) and Trial Rule 12(B)(6). We affirm. [25] Affirmed. Brown, J., and Altice, J., concur.