Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

JORDAN v. EPPS

United States District Court, S.D. Mississippi.
Aug 30, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

This opinion will be unpublished and may not be cited except as provided by Minn. Stat. § 480A.08, subd. 3 (2008).

UNPUBLISHED OPINION

JOHNSON, Judge

Lukas A. Czech was seriously injured when he fell through the ceiling of the second floor of a commercial building and dropped approximately 25 feet to the floor below. Czech alleges that his injuries were caused by the negligence of the building's tenant. The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the tenant. We conclude that summary judgment is appropriate because the tenant did not owe Czech a duty of care. Therefore, we affirm.

FACTS

In 1899, just before moving to New York City, architect Cass Gilbert designed four railroad depots for the Northern Pacific Railway, one of which was built in the city of Little Falls. The depot building now is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and is occupied by the Little Falls Chamber of Commerce. The building, which faces west, has a tall transverse gable in the two-story center section, flanked by one-story sections on the north and south ends of the building. On the north side of the gabled roof are two small dormers, which have wooden louvers to allow ventilation in the attic space at the peak of the gabled roof, above the two-story center section.

In June 2007, some of the louvers on one of the dormers were broken. The Chamber hired A.C. Construction to repair the broken louvers and to make additional repairs to the building that are not relevant to this case. Czech was employed as a full-time carpenter for A.C. Construction, which was owned by his father. Debora Boelz, the President and CEO of the Chamber, informed Czech's father that a small number of pigeons were in the attic space but that his workers should not be concerned with them and should simply replace the louvers, even if pigeons were trapped inside. Czech overheard this conversation between his father and Boelz. Czech's father later told Czech that Czech could perform all of the repair work from the outside of the dormer and should cause the pigeons to leave the attic by making noise from outside the dormer.

On June 26, 2007, Czech and another employee of A.C. Construction went to the depot building to perform the repairs. After arriving, Czech climbed a ladder to the roof, walked up the rooftop to the louvered dormer, and looked inside the attic space. He saw approximately 15 to 20 pigeons. He decided to install a screen on the inside of the louvers so that pigeons would not be able to enter the attic space again after he repaired the louvers. Czech later testified that he was "excited" to work on the building because of its historical significance and that he wanted "to make sure the job was done right" in order "to prevent it from happening again."

Czech and his coworker went to a hardware store, where Czech purchased materials for the screen and a dust mask. When they returned, Czech went inside the building with an extension ladder. He told Sylvia Ryden, the Chamber's receptionist, that there were more pigeons in the attic than he had anticipated and that he needed to get into the attic space to perform some repairs from the inside. Ryden showed Czech where to access the attic. Czech climbed his ladder and entered the attic space above the north wing of the building. Czech walked through the north part of the attic and then climbed a built-in ladder to enter the attic space in the center section of the building. Czech walked toward the center section on plywood planks and along a "catwalk," which apparently consists of wide wooden beams.

When Czech reached the area of the dormers in the attic above the center section of the building, he saw approximately 30 to 40 pigeons. He removed approximately 20 to 25 of the pigeons from the attic space by shooing them out or picking them up and setting them on the edge of the dormer. Czech estimates that he removed pigeons in this manner for approximately 30 minutes before he fell through the attic floor and the second-floor ceiling, apparently because he stepped between exposed floor joists. Czech has no recollection of the fall and does not know why or how he fell. Czech suffered numerous injuries, including an injury to his spinal cord at the level of his thoracic vertebrae, which has caused him to be paralyzed below his chest.

In January 2009, Czech and his wife commenced this negligence action against the Chamber. In October 2009, the Chamber moved for summary judgment. In opposition to the Chamber's motion, Czech submitted the affidavit of Philip Goodrich, an engineer who professes specialized knowledge concerning the safe interaction of humans and animals in livestock and poultry facilities. Goodrich's affidavit states that Czech fell because pigeon feces in the attic emitted high levels of noxious gases, such as ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, methane, and carbon dioxide, which caused Czech to lose consciousness. The district court granted the motion and entered summary judgment in favor of the Chamber. Czech appeals.

DECISION

Czech argues that the district court erred by granting the Chamber's motion for summary judgment. A district court must grant a motion for summary judgment "if the pleadings, depositions, answers to interrogatories, and admissions on file, together with the affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that either party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law." Minn. R. Civ. P. 56.03. A genuine issue of material fact exists if a rational trier of fact, considering the record as a whole, could find for the party against whom summary judgment was granted. Frieler v. Carlson Mktg. Grp., Inc., 751 N.W.2d 558, 564 (Minn. 2008). We apply a de novo standard of review to a grant of summary judgment, and we view the evidence in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. Osborne v. Twin Town Bowl, Inc., 749 N.W.2d 367, 371 (Minn. 2008); Molde v. CitiMortgage, Inc., 781 N.W.2d 36, 39 (Minn. App. 2010).

To prevail in a negligence action, a plaintiff must prove each of four elements: "(1) the existence of a duty of care, (2) a breach of that duty, (3) an injury, and (4) the breach of that duty being the proximate cause of the injury." Louis v. Louis, 636 N.W.2d 314, 318 (Minn. 2001). In a negligence action against a possessor of real property, the analysis "begins `with an inquiry into whether the [defendant] owed the entrant a duty.'" Foss v. Kincaid, 766 N.W.2d 317, 320 (Minn. 2009) (quoting Louis, 636 N.W.2d at 318). Whether the defendant owed a legal duty to the plaintiff is a question of law. Anderson v. State, Dep't of Natural Res., 693 N.W.2d 181, 186 (Minn. 2005); Funchess v. Cecil Newman Corp., 632 N.W.2d 666, 672 (Minn. 2001).

A possessor of real property "has a duty to use reasonable care to prevent persons from being injured by conditions on the property that represent foreseeable risk of injury." Rinn v. Minnesota State Agric. Soc'y, 611 N.W.2d 361, 364 (Minn. App. 2000) (citing Hanson v. Christensen, 275 Minn. 204, 213, 145 N.W.2d 868, 874 (1966)). "When determining whether a danger is foreseeable, we `look to whether the specific danger was objectively reasonable to expect, not simply whether it was within the realm of any conceivable possibility.'" Foss, 766 N.W.2d at 322 (quoting Whiteford ex rel. Whiteford v. Yamaha Motor Corp., 582 N.W.2d 916, 918 (Minn. 1998)). "The scope of the duty is defined by the probability or foreseeability of injury to the invitee." Gilmore v. Walgreen Co., 759 N.W.2d 433, 435 (Minn. App. 2009), review denied (Minn. Mar. 31, 2009). "Although in most cases the question of foreseeability is an issue for the jury, the foreseeability of harm can be decided by the court as a matter of law when the issue is clear." Foss, 766 N.W.2d at 322-23.

On appeal, Czech argues that the Chamber owed him a duty to make the property reasonably safe or to warn him about the hazards arising from the large number of pigeons in the attic. At oral argument, Czech made clear that his negligence claim is not based on the general risk of walking in an attic in which the floor joists are not completely covered by a flooring material. Rather, Czech's negligence claim is based on the risk of injury due to being present in such an attic with noxious gases emitted by pigeon feces. In light of Czech's theory of the case, the Goodrich affidavit is essential to the success of his claim. The district court did not adopt the facts stated in the Goodrich affidavit. The parties dispute whether the district court deemed the affidavit inadmissible or simply concluded that it did not create a genuine issue of material fact, and they make opposing arguments concerning whether the Goodrich affidavit should be part of the district court record. For purposes of this opinion, we assume without deciding that the Goodrich affidavit is admissible and, thus, part of the district court record.

The Chamber frames the duty issue by breaking it down into component parts. The Chamber contends that Czech cannot establish a duty of care unless he can establish each of the following: (1) that the Chamber knew that a large number of pigeons (rather than a few pigeons) were in the attic, (2) that the Chamber knew that a large quantity of pigeon feces would emit high levels of noxious gases that might cause a person to lose consciousness, and (3) that the Chamber could foresee that Czech would enter the attic despite the Chamber's statement that it was unnecessary to do so. We agree that this is a proper way to analyze the evidence. See Foss, 766 N.W.2d at 323 (analyzing knowledge and foreseeability based on case-specific facts). Ultimately, a plaintiff has the burden of proving "that the operator of the premises had actual knowledge of the defect causing the injury." Wolvert v. Gustafson, 275 Minn. 239, 241, 146 N.W.2d 172, 173 (1966).

With respect to the first part of the duty analysis, the evidence in the summary judgment record does not create a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the Chamber knew that a large number of pigeons (rather than a few pigeons) were in the attic. Boelz, the Chamber's President and CEO, testified that she had observed only four to six pigeons in the dormer. Czech's father testified that Boelz told him that there were only a few pigeons. Ryden testified that she had observed pigeons on the roof of the building and pigeons entering and exiting the dormer, but she was not specific about their number. The evidence establishes that Chamber employees knew about the presence of pigeons for more than 15 years before the accident, but that fact, by itself, does not establish that the Chamber knew the extent of the number of pigeons actually present.

With respect to the second part of the duty analysis, the evidence in the summary judgment record does not create a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the Chamber knew before the accident that a large quantity of pigeon feces would emit high levels of noxious gases that might cause a person to lose consciousness. Boelz testified that she never has been in the attic and that she had no knowledge about specific health hazards caused by accumulated pigeon feces. She also testified that none of the Chamber's employees had chronic coughs or any respiratory problems that might have indicated a health hazard. The facts stated in the Goodrich affidavit were not known to the Chamber before the accident.

With respect to the third part of the duty analysis, the evidence in the summary judgment record does not create a genuine issue of material fact as to whether it was foreseeable to Boelz that Czech would enter the attic. Boelz did not tell Czech's father that it was necessary for a worker to enter the attic. Czech's father testified that, consistent with Boelz's statements, he instructed Czech to cause the pigeons to leave the attic by yelling at them and tapping and beating the outside of the dormer, and to go ahead and perform the repair from the outside of the dormer, regardless of the number of pigeons that remained inside. Czech contends that his entry into the attic was foreseeable because he told Ryden that he was doing so. But Czech's intention to enter the attic became known to Ryden too late in time for the Chamber to take any action. If the risk of harm is not foreseeable, then no legal duty exists. See Foss, 766 N.W.2d at 322. "A harm which is not objectively reasonable to expect is too remote to create liability." Id.

In his reply brief, Czech contends that the Chamber had a duty to inspect the attic before Czech performed his repairs such that it should be deemed to have "constructive knowledge" of the condition of the attic and the risks present there. A duty of care may arise if a person in possession of real property "had actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition." Rinn, 611 N.W.2d at 365 (emphasis added) (citing Messner v. Red Owl Stores, 238 Minn. 411, 413, 57 N.W.2d 659, 661 (1953)). Regardless whether the Chamber had a duty to inspect generally, Czech's argument conflicts with the rule that a person in possession of land "does not have a `duty to inspect or to warn of a defect or danger the employee was engaged to correct.'" Presbrey v. James, 781 N.W.2d 13, 19 (Minn. App. 2010) (quoting Conover v. Northern States Power Co., 313 N.W.2d 397, 407 (Minn. 1981)). Before entering the attic, Czech informed Ryden that he "needed to go up . . . and do some repairs from the inside and chase some pigeons out." From Ryden's point of view, Czech was engaged, in part, to remove pigeons from the attic, which would preclude any duty of the Chamber to inspect the attic before allowing Czech to enter it. Without a duty to inspect, the Chamber cannot be charged with constructive knowledge of the condition of the attic. See Conover, 313 N.W.2d at 407.

To establish the existence of a duty of care, Czech has "the burden of proving either that [the Chamber] caused the dangerous condition or that it knew, or should have known, that the condition existed." Messner, 238 Minn. at 415, 57 N.W.2d at 662. Here, none of the evidence demonstrates that the Chamber had knowledge of the large number of pigeons in the attic or that noxious gases emitted from accumulated pigeon feces in the attic might cause a person to lose consciousness. In addition, the evidence shows that the Chamber did not foresee, and could not have foreseen, that Czech would enter the attic. Therefore, the Chamber did not owe Czech a duty to prevent the harm caused by the accident or to warn him of the hazards arising from the large number of pigeons in the attic. In light of this conclusion, we need not analyze whether the allegedly dangerous condition in the attic was open and obvious, whether the doctrine of assumption of the risk applies, or whether the pigeon feces was the proximate cause of Czech's injuries.

In sum, the district court did not err by granting the Chamber's motion for summary judgment. We respect Czech's high standards of craftsmanship, and we acknowledge the tragedy of his circumstances, but the law does not allow the conclusion that the Chamber is liable for his injuries.

Affirmed.

avior supports the theory that Jordan suffers from PTSD.

The only aberrant behavior exhibited by Jordan since his military service is the kidnaping and killing of Mrs. Marter. Dr. Wilson posits:

If Mr. Jordan did have PTSD at the time of the crime, it is likely that the offense was committed while Mr. Jordan was under the influence of extreme mental or emotional disturbance, and that his capacity to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of law was substantially impaired.

Dr. Zigelbaum states that he believes it is "entirely possible" that Jordan had "at least some manifestations of PTSD" at the time of the crime. However, other than Jordan's service in Vietnam, there is no indication that these experts reviewed the circumstances of Jordan's offense or his behavior before and after the murder in suggesting this diagnosis. Jordan himself admitted in an exchange with the trial court outside the presence of the jury that he never thought he suffered from PTSD. Absent more evidence of a connection between Jordan's actual behavior and the possibility that he has PTSD, this Court is not persuaded by these experts' affidavits that hiring additional mental health experts would have made a difference in Jordan's case. Goodwin v. Johnson, 132 F.3d 162, 189 (5th Cir. 1997).

Jordan also argues that other mental health experts would have exposed the deficiency in Dr. Maggio's evaluation of him as having antisocial personal disorder. Although this issue was raised in Jordan's post-conviction petition, the Mississippi Supreme Court did not address it in the context of ineffectiveness. In support of his argument here, Jordan argues that the diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder was inaccurate because it was based on "little or no evidentiary support," since Maggio spent little time with Jordan and sought no other information. Additionally, Jordan argues:

Dr. Maggio ultimately concluded that Mr. Jordan had antisocial personality disorder. However, according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual ("DSM-IV-TR), there must be some evidence of a conduct disorder prior to age 15, but in this case there was no such evidence. There is also little, if any, support for most of the other criteria for the antisocial personality disorder diagnosis. The relevant diagnostic criteria from the DSM were attached as Exhibit 40 to the state court petition,

The referenced exhibit is a single page that does contain the diagnostic criteria Jordan describes — evidence of Conduct Disorder with onset before age 15 years. However, there is no authentication of this page as having come from the DSM-IV. There is no validation of this diagnostic criteria as being effective at the time that Jordan was interviewed. No expert in mental health has opined that Maggio's diagnosis was fatally flawed in the absence of this finding. This Court is unwilling to find that counsel was ineffective in failing to obtain expert advice to refute this finding on the basis of an untitled page. Jordan has not provided evidence to demonstrate that he was prejudiced in this regard, and the failure of the Mississippi Supreme Court to vacate his death sentence on this issue is neither contrary to, nor an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law.

Ground L : The trial court denied petitioner's rights guaranteed by the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments by ordering the disclosure of mental health evaluation even though Petitioner did not intend to call the court-appointed evaluator as a witness.

Prior to trial, Jordan moved the court for a psychiatric examination and evaluation "to determine if there are possible mitigating factors that could be used as evidence on defendant's behalf at his sentencing hearing. There were difficulties in scheduling the motion for a hearing, and the transcript indicates that a hearing occurred with little notice to the parties to discuss whether the State was entitled to a copy of the examiner's report. For that reason, and in order to prevent delay, Jordan's counsel waived his presence at the hearing, on the court's assurance that the issue could be reconsidered at a time when Jordan was present.

Counsel reiterated at the hearing that the examination would be for the purpose of exploring possible mitigation factors. Jordan's attorney argued that, if his client could afford to hire an expert, he would not be required to provide a copy of his report to the State until he decided to use the expert at trial. He contended that it was a violation of due process to prejudice his client because he was indigent. The prosecutor argued that Rule 9.04 of Mississippi's Rules of Circuit and County Court Practice required disclosure of the report. Thus, although he had no objection to the examination, he argued that the State was entitled to the report. The judge ruled for the State, "unless there's a motion for rehearing with some authority otherwise. . . ."

Dr. Maggio was chosen as the expert, with no objection from Jordan's counsel. As discussed earlier, Maggio's report included information from Dr. Davis indicating that Jordan had been dishonorably discharged from the Army. Maggio concluded that Jordan had antisocial personality disorder. Maggio concluded:

[Jordan] actually appeared to be a danger to himself and others prior to being in the military, while he was being in the military, and after he got out of the military. He would portray himself as being a really fine, upstanding citizen who has been a good guy and helped people all of his life and would continue to do so if he got out of jail. The evidence seems to be quite the contrary. He is a self-proclaimed con artist, all of his life offers excuses for his behavior and does not take responsibility for his behavior. In addition, he seemed to show no remorse for the crime that he has committed. If, in fact, he is doing all of these good works while he's in jail, then that is a good thing for him to do but one is led to the conclusion that he's only doing it because he is in jail and to paint a good picture of himself.

This report was never offered into evidence. However, Richard King, a childhood friend of Jordan's, testified that Jordan was not a danger to society and that he would welcome Jordan into his home. During cross-examination, the prosecutor asked whether he was aware of several of the facts related in the report, including his military record, embezzling, the fact that Marter was killed because the FBI did not follow his instructions, and his comment to Dr. Davis, "Better luck next time."

Following King's testimony and that of another witness, Jordan's attorneys announced that they had intended to call two other witnesses, Dola Jones and Joseph Fairchild, but would not do so "in light of the Court's ruling as far as allowing them to be examined on the basis of the psychiatric reports. . . . We're not calling them for that reason only." Ultimately, the trial judge ruled that Maggio could not testify in rebuttal, unless Jordan testified to some matter that Maggio could rebut. After that ruling, Jordan's attorneys asked for a mistrial, based on the decision not to call Jones and Fairchild "for fear, actually being intimidated, that something might inadvertently come out of the witness' mouth to open the door to the use of this report. . . ." The motion was denied. Jordan declined to testify because of the potential that it would open the door to Maggio's testimony, after which the prosecutor stated that he would not call Maggio under any circumstances. Jordan conferred with his attorneys about that development, but still declined to testify.

Jordan argues now that the judge's interpretation of Rule 9.04 violated the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments. He contends that, by ordering Maggio's report to be simultaneously published to both sides, the trial court violated his right to due process. He also claims that he was disadvantaged because of his indigency, in violation of his right to equal protection. Jordan equated the compulsion to provide the State with Maggio's report to being required to share an expert, rather than being permitted an independent expert, in violation of Ake v. Oklahoma, 470 U.S. at 77. Citing Brooks v. Tennessee, 406 U.S. 605, 612 (1972), Jordan argues that the trial court's ruling violated the Fifth and Sixth Amendments by requiring him to provide assistance to the prosecution.

The Mississippi Supreme Court recognized that there are limitations on the use of psychiatric testimony where it has been ordered by the court. Jordan, 786 So. 2d at 1007-08; Estelle v. Smith, 451 U.S. 454, 462 (1981). However, it distinguished Jordan's case from the authorities that he cited, on grounds that he requested the examination and voluntarily subjected himself to it. Jordan, 786 So. 2d at 1008. According to that court, where the defendant requests such an evaluation or presents psychological evidence, the prosecution is entitled to rebut it. Id. (citing Buchanan v. Kentucky, 483 U.S. 402, 422-23 (1987)). The prosecution may resort to the reports of the defendant's expert to do so. Id. The court concluded:

We find that the State's cross-examination of King did not violate Jordan's privilege against self-incrimination. King testified that he had known Jordan most of his life; therefore it was reasonable for the State to ask King about Jordan's employment and his military career. King testified that he did not consider Jordan to be dangerous and that he had exhibited good behavior during his tenure at Parchman; therefore it was reasonable for the State to ask King about statements made by Jordan about the killing.
786 So. 2d at 1010. Additionally, the court noted that the substance of Maggio's report was never divulged to the jury.

Jordan argues that the Mississippi Supreme Court never reached any issue beyond his Fifth Amendment claim; therefore, his remaining claims may be reviewed de novo. He claims that the court's reliance on Estelle, and Buchanan was in error, as he did not present mental health or mental status testimony. Additionally, according to Jordan, the state court's opinion relied on a mistake of fact. In its opinion, the court states, "The basis of the State's questions was Dr. Davis' psychiatric report which was introduced into evidence when Dr. Davis testified during the guilt phase. See Jordan v. State, 365 So. 2d 1198, 1203 (Miss. 1978)." 786 So. 2d at 1010. As Jordan correctly avers, Davis did not testify during any trial. He was retained to examine Jordan to determine whether he was competent, and his only testimony occurred at a pretrial hearing. His report was never introduced into evidence. Thus, to the extent that the state court opinion permitted use of Davis's report on the assumption that a jury heard it during the guilt phase, that assumption was in error.

With regard to the first issue, this Court agrees with Respondents that the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision was not limited to his Fifth Amendment claim. The opinion states:

Even though Jordan claims his right to due process was violated, the issue, at its basis implicates the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution, the guarantee against self-incrimination. Jordan did not want the State to have copies of the psychiatric reports because they included statements made by Jordan and opinions based thereon which may have been damaging to his defense. Therefore, if it is determined that Jordan's Fifth Amendment rights were not violated, he has no due process claim.
786 So. 2d at 1007. As to the third issue, this Court agrees that the Mississippi Supreme Court made a factual error — Dr. Davis never testified before a jury in Jordan's case. However, the error does not mandate habeas relief, since the court's opinion is not reliant solely on the assumption that reference to Davis's report was proper because it had been introduced to the jury in the only trial on Jordan's guilt. Instead, the opinion went on to reason that reference to the report was proper to impeach King, particularly since its contents were never revealed to the jury. 786 So. 2d at 1010.

It is the second issue, whether requiring Dr. Maggio to provide his report to both the prosecution and the defense violated Jordan's constitutional rights, that is the primary issue here. The state court ruled that it did not, and this Court agrees. In Granviel v. Lynaugh, 881 F.2d 185 (5th Cir. 1989), the petitioner raised an insanity defense. In response. the State introduced testimony from two psychiatrists who had examined him earlier. Granviel argued that the admission of that testimony violated his Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights, both of which claims were rejected. Id. at 190. Additionally, Granviel attacked, on constitutional grounds, the state statute that permitted the appointment of a disinterested expert, but required that a copy of his report be provided to the court and opposing counsel. Id. at 191. Based on that statute, the trial court required that the report of one of the psychiatrists be disclosed to the State.

The court disposed of Granviel's Sixth Amendment claim on grounds that it was waived when his attorney requested that an expert be appointed. Id. Granviel had also alleged that he was denied the right to meaningfully defend himself by asserting an insanity defense, in contravention of Ake. The court denied that claim, stating, "Granviel's ability to uncover the truth concerning his sanity is not prejudiced by a court-appointed, neutral expert. . . . The state is not required to permit defendants to shop around for a favorable expert." 881 F.2d at 192. Thus, Granviel had been provided "the raw materials integral to the building of an effective defense." Ake, 470 U.S. at 77.

In a later case, White v. Johnson, 153 F.3d 197 (5th Cir. 1998), the petitioner, who had been convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death, had asked for the appointment of a psychiatrist to assist him in defending the State's claim of future dangerousness. The trial court gave him two options — a simultaneous, joint examination by psychiatrists for both sides or an examination by a court-appointed psychiatrist whose report would be made available to the court and counsel for each side. Id. at 200. Because White would not agree to either option, the court denied his motion. White contended that the trial court had violated his due process and equal protection rights, as well as his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.

The court first distinguished White's case from Granviel's, noting that Granviel had put his mental state at issue by pleading an insanity defense, while White sought expert assistance to counter a claim made by the State. Id. at 201 n. 2. Without deciding that the State erred in setting conditions for the appointment of a psychiatrist, the court determined that any error was harmless. To establish the standard of review, the court decided that failure to provide the services of a psychiatrist in this context was trial error, rather than structural error, and therefore, subject to harmless error analysis. In making that determination, the court noted that White's right to psychiatric assistance was contingent upon the State's introduction of evidence of future dangerousness. Absent the introduction of such evidence, White had no right to psychiatric assistance under Ake. Thus, the court reasoned, "if the state's admission of psychiatric testimony is subject to harmless-error analysis, then the purported Ake error is likewise subject to harmless-error analysis." Id. at 203. The court noted that the Supreme Court had held that the erroneous admission of psychiatric testimony is subject to harmless error analysis. Id. (citing Satterwhite v. Texas, 486 U.S. 249, 257-58 (1988)). That being so, the denial of psychiatric assistance to White was also subject to harmless error analysis.

White argued that it was error not to provide him with his own psychiatrist to counter the testimony of the state's expert, who testified that he considered White to be at the end of the spectrum in terms of danger to society, and that he considered him to be a high risk for future dangerousness. However, there was ample lay testimony to the same effect; e.g., officers testified that he bragged about the crime and showed no remorse; his ex-wife reported that he beat her, as well as other ex-wives; and family members who testified about his propensity for violence. Given this testimony, the court concluded that the psychiatrist's testimony likely did not affect the jury's finding the issue of future violence, particularly considering the effectiveness of the defense's cross-examination. The court further rejected White's claim that psychiatric testimony would have helped him in other areas of his case, since he did not include those areas in his request for expert assistance. For these reasons, it found that, if error was committed, it was harmless. Id. at 205-07.

Granviel continues to apply to cases in which the request for psychiatric expert assistance is made to support an issue raised by a criminal defendant. Long v. Johnson, No. 98-10994, 189 F.3d 469 (5th Cir. July 15, 1999). There, the petitioner argued that the state was obligated to appoint an independent psychiatrist, not merely a neutral one, to assess his claim of insanity. The court noted that other circuits had held that appointment of an expert who was neutral, but not independent, violated Ake. However, without ruling on that issue, the court noted, "[T]he trial court in this case would not have felt bound to apply these cases in the face of Granviel's binding precedent." Id. at n. 6. More recently, the Fifth Circuit again recognized the contrary opinions from other circuits, but held, in the absence of a clear precedent from the Supreme Court, a state court does not err in assuming that Graviel remains good law. Woodward v. Epps, 580 F.3d 318, 332 (5th Cir. 2009).

When Jordan raised this issue on direct appeal, it was couched as an attack on the trial court's interpretation of Rule 9.04, which Jordan contended was unconstitutional. His argument was that the Rule should be interpreted to compel production of an expert's report to the state only when a defendant intends to use the expert's opinion at trial. 786 So. 2d at 1007. The court analyzed the argument as a Fifth Amendment claim. "Jordan did not want the State to have copies of the psychiatric reports because they included statements made by Jordan and opinions based thereon which may have been damaging to his defense." Id. The court recognized that, where a defendant is ordered to participate in a mental health evaluation, a Fifth Amendment claim arises from the use of his statements at that evaluation. Id. at 1007-08 (citing Estelle v. Smith, 451 U.S. 454, 462 (1981)). The court also recognized, however, that the analysis changes when it is the defendant who seeks a psychiatric examination. Id. at 1008 (citing Buchanan v. Kentucky, 483 U.S. 402, 422-23). Even in that situation, however, use of expert testimony by the state is only appropriate where the defendant has "introduce[d] mental-status evidence that may be fairly be characterized as expert. . . ." Id. (citing Schneider v. Lynaugh, 835 F.2d 570, 576 (5th Cir. 1988)). Lay opinions on sanity were not "mental status evidence" for that purpose. Id. (citing Brown v. Butler, 876 F.2d 427 (5th Cir. 1989)). However, even if Maggio's report could not have been introduced to counter Jordan's witnesses' testimony, a lay witness may be confronted with a report from a mental health expert on cross-examination. Id. at 1009-10. Finding that Jordan's witness, Richard King, had made specific comments about Jordan's character, there was no error in having him silently read Maggio's report. Id. at 1010.

Based on the law announced by the Supreme Court in Ake and interpreted by the Fifth Circuit in Granviel and Woodward, the Mississippi Supreme Court's opinion was not contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law. Jordan requested the appointment of a psychiatrist to explore the possibility that he suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Given the vagueness of his assertion, Jordan's right to the appointment of a psychiatrist is dubious. Some threshold showing or reason for same is necessary. Caldwell v. Mississippi, 472 U.S. 320, 323 n. 1 (1985); Goodwin v. Johnson, 132 F.3d 162, 189-90 (5th Cir. 1997). In any event, under the law in this Circuit, Jordan did not have a right, under Ake to an independent psychiatrist, and the trial court's appointment of Maggio under the condition that his report be shared by both sides did not violate Jordan's constitutional rights. For this reason, he is not entitled to habeas relief on this issue.

Ground M : Petitioner was denied his rights guaranteed by the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the federal Constitution due to the lack of a knowing and intelligent waiver prior to cooperating with the court-appointed examiner. Ground N : Petitioner was denied the effective assistance guaranteed by the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the federal Constitution and Mississippi law by trial counsel's failure to ensure that he had the opportunity to make a knowing and intelligent waiver prior to cooperating with the court-appointed evaluation. Ground O : Petitioner did not knowingly, intelligently, or voluntarily waive his right to be present on numerous occasions, including at a hearing on his motion for appointment of a mitigation expert.

These issues are so interrelated that they may be discussed together. Prior to the trial, Jordan filed a pleading titled, "Assertion of right to be Present." The document asserted his right to be present at "all aspects of the case. . . ." Jordan specifically named the following events:

a. all pre-trial hearings, conferences or any other matters (save only telephone scheduling of proposed hearings or meetings between the attorneys);
b. all other pre-trial matters, including but not limited to the drawing of the jury pool;
c. all aspects of the trial, including but not limited to all voir dire, all bench conferences, and all charge conferences;
d. all other hearings and judicial proceedings of any kind which may influence whether he lives or dies.

Despite Jordan's assertion, he was not present at the pretrial conference where the trial judge ruled that Dr. Maggio's opinion would be shared by counsel for both sides. That hearing was held in the judge's chambers, with the prosecutor participating by telephone. At the beginning of the hearing, defense counsel waived Jordan's presence, noting:

I initially tried to get the motion set for the 25th or the 26th, and due to the Court's schedule I was unable to do so. Joe Sam advised us that he had a conflict this afternoon, and so I think that because of the nature of this motion for a psychiatric evaluation, and in order to not cause a possible delay or grounds for delay in the trial, I wanted to go forward with this because sometimes these things take a lot of time and I wanted to move quickly on it. For that reason I've waived Jordan's presence at this hearing.

Jordan argues that, because he was not present at the hearing, he was unaware that the judge had ordered the report of his psychiatric evaluation to be sent to the prosecution. He further contends that his attorneys did not advise him of that fact. According to Jordan, he declined to cooperate with an examination during earlier proceedings because this condition was imposed. Thus, he maintains, had he known that the report would be given to the prosecution, he would not have participated in it, and the prosecution would not have had the benefit of the unfavorable evidence it used against him.

This issue was raised on direct appeal, with reference to the hearing on Maggio's report, as well as other pretrial proceedings and bench conferences. While recognizing the general right of a criminal defendant to be present at "critical stages" of his trial, the court held that the conferences did not qualify, since the matters discussed therein were "purely legal, and the criminal defendant can do little to aid his defense." 786 So 2d at 1021-22. With regard to the hearing on Maggio's report, the court held that its ruling on the prosecution's entitlement to Maggio's report disposed of the matter. Id. at 1022.

The court addressed the issue again in its opinion on Jordan's post-conviction petition. There, it held, "This Court has already addressed similar issues related to Dr. Maggio's evaluation in its most recent opinion. [cite omitted] This claim is procedurally barred pursuant to Miss. Code Ann. § 99-39-21." 912 So. 2d at 816. The court went on, however, to "examine the merits of Jordan's claim." While not addressing the waiver issue as it related to Jordan's presence at the hearing, the court did address his argument that he did not knowingly and intelligently give a waiver "with respect to the use of those statements at the sentencing proceedings." Id. Distinguishing the cases cited by Jordan to show that he should have been fully apprised of the potential use of the examination at trial, the court stated that those cases involved court-ordered examinations, rather than examinations requested by the defendant. "Because Jordan's counsel requested the psychiatric examination, he was well aware, and even intended, that statements he gave be used at the resentencing trial." Id. at 817. Moreover, since Maggio was not "a state actor," the warnings were unnecessary. Id. Finally, the court held that, since the only use made of Maggio's report was in cross-examination of a witness, any error was harmless. Id.

Jordan's claim is three-fold, and the relationship between these issues has not been specifically addressed by the state court. He claims: (1) he did not waive his right to be present at the hearing where the ruling on Maggio's report was made; (2) he did not waive his right to refuse to cooperate in providing incriminating information to the prosecution because he was unaware that Maggio's report would be provided to the prosecutors; and (3) his attorneys were ineffective in failing to communicate the court's ruling to him. As to the first issue, it is clear that Jordan wanted to be present at all pretrial hearings, and this hearing was included in his request. (Although he

excluded some telephonic hearings from his request, those were hearings related purely to scheduling issues.) It is equally clear from the record that his attorney waived his right to be present.

A criminal defendant has a due process right "to be present in his own person whenever his presence has a relation, reasonably substantial, to the fulness of his opportunity to defend against the charge." Snyder v. Massachusetts, 291 U.S. 97, 105, 106 (1934). In Snyder, the Court suggested that a different standard governed the analysis where the defendant was not present at a pretrial proceeding:

Many motions before trial are heard in the defendant's absence, and many motions after trial or in the prosecution of appeals. [cite omitted] Confusion of thought will result if we fail to mark the distinction between requirements in respect of presence that have their source in the common law, and requirements that have their source, either expressly or by implication, in the Federal Constitution.
Id. at 107. As more recently restated by the Supreme Court, the right extends to "any stage of the criminal proceeding that is critical to its outcome if his presence would contribute to the fairness of the procedure." Kentucky v. Stincer, 482 U.S. 730, 745 (1987). Thus, the right to be present at trial extends to certain pretrial proceedings, particularly where testimony would be taken at the proceedings, and the defendant's right to confront witnesses is involved. Id.

It appears that the state court distinguished the Maggio hearing from the other proceedings that Jordan did not attend. By reaching the issue of waiver, the court implicitly ruled that Jordan had a due process right to attend the Maggio hearing. That ruling is entitled to deferential treatment under the AEDPA. Santellan v. Cockrell, 271 F.3d 190, 193 (5th Cir. 2001). See also Packer v. Early, 537 U.S. 3, 8 (2003). There being no case from the United States Supreme Court that gives a clear answer on this issue, the state court cannot have unreasonably applied clearly established federal law. Wright v. Van Patten, 552 U.S. 120, 126 (2008). Thus, this Court must defer to the state court's judgment that Jordan had a due process right to attend the Maggio conference.

The Mississippi Supreme Court also found that Jordan's counsel had waived his right to attend the motion hearing. Many rights may be waived by counsel on a client's behalf in a criminal case. Taylor v. Illinois, 484 U.S. 400, 417-18 (1988). Other rights, however, cannot be waived "without the fully informed and publicly acknowledged consent of the client." Id. Those include the right to be present at trial. Id. at n. 24. See also Winters v. Cook, 489 F.2d 174, 179 (5th Cir. 1973) (fundamental rights that cannot be waived by an attorney include the right to plead guilty, the right to waive trial by jury, the right to waive appellate review, and the right to testify personally). The question of whether an attorney can waive his client's right to attend a pretrial motion hearing at which no testimony or evidence was received by the court has not been addressed by the Supreme Court. Again, there being no clearly established federal law to the contrary, this Court must accept the state court's decision that the right was waived.

Jordan argues that, because he did not know that Maggio's report would be sent to the prosecutor, he could not knowingly waive his right to refuse to cooperate with Maggio's evaluation. The Mississippi Supreme Court addressed this issue in its post-conviction opinion. Jordan argued that existing precedent required a pre-examination warning, based on the Fifth and Sixth Amendments. Estelle v. Smith, 451 U.S. 454 (1981); Gardner v. Johnson, 247 F.3d 551 (5th Cir, 2001). The court held those cases inapposite to Jordan's, noting that in neither of those cases had the examination been requested by the defendant. The court went on to discount Jordan's claim that he did not realize that Dr. Maggio's report would be shared with the prosecution, stating that he "was well aware, and even intended, that statements he gave be used at the resentencing trial." 912 So. 2d at 817. Finally, the court held that no warning was necessary because Maggio was not a "state actor." Id.

As noted in the earlier discussion, this Court cannot conclude that the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision that Jordan had no constitutional right to prevent disclosure of the information in Maggio's report runs afoul of clearly established federal law. That being so, the Court must likewise defer to the state court's finding that Jordan had no constitutional right to waive; therefore, his knowledge of the trial court's ruling prior to the examination has no constitutional implications. Clearly, Jordan had the right to refuse to talk to Maggio, but that right is not derived from the Constitution of the United States.

This Court must likewise defer to the state court's finding that Jordan was aware that Maggio's report would be used at trial, as it is not unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the evidence. Jordan addressed the trial court during an argument on Maggio's report and asserted that he was unaware, at the time of the examination, that Maggio's report would be provided to the State. His attorneys, however, never confirmed that they failed to inform Jordan of the trial court's ruling, either during argument at trial or in the affidavit given in support of his post-conviction petition. Additionally, the content of the report indicates that Jordan's intent was to provide a wealth of information to be used as mitigation evidence. Only a small portion of the examination was dedicated to a discussion of possible post-traumatic stress. In contrast, the majority of the report contains self-aggrandizing statements made by Jordan to demonstrate his good behavior. The only bad information in the report came from Davis's report and the comparison of the statements made therein with the statements made to Maggio. Finally, Jordan's prior counsel stated that the same conditions would have been imposed on Maggio's report if Jordan had been examined by him in earlier proceedings. Based on that requirement, his former counsel stated, "We determined that it would be advisable for Mr. Jordan not to cooperate with an evaluation if the results of that evaluation were to be disclosed to the prosecution." Jordan, then, was likely aware of the possibility that Maggio's report would be shared with the State. A defendant's experience with the criminal justice system is a factor in determining whether that defendant knowingly and intelligently waived constitutional rights. Parke v. Raley, 506 U.S. 20, 37 (1992); Marshall v. Lonberger, 459 U.S. 422, 437 (1983). For all of these reasons, this Court is of the opinion that the Mississippi Supreme Court's determination that Jordan's conversation with Maggio was conducted with full awareness of its ramifications was not unreasonable in light of the evidence. Thus, the waiver issue has no merit.

Jordan also argues that his trial counsel was ineffective for failing to inform him of the trial court's ruling with regard to Maggio's report; however, Respondents contend that this issue was defaulted in state court and therefore never discussed by the Mississippi Supreme Court. Jordan disagrees and directs this Court's attention to his post-conviction petition. The entirety of his argument on this issue is as follows:

XXII PETITIONER WAS DENIED THE EFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE GUARANTEED BY THE SIXTH, EIGHTH, AND FOURTEENTH AMENDMENTS TO THE FEDERAL CONSTITUTION AND MISSISSIPPI LAW BY TRIAL COUNSEL'S FAILURE TO ENSURE THAT HE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A KNOWING AND INTELLIGENT WAIVER PRIOR TO COOPERATING WITH THE COURT-APPOINTED EVALUATION.
257. Petitioner incorporates all facts alleged in Grounds XVIII — XXI.
258. Trial counsel filed a motion requesting that Petitioner be allowed to be present at all hearings. Although the trial court granted that motion, counsel waived Mr. Jordan's presence at a conference with respect to the appointment of a mental health evaluator. Although the Mississippi Supreme Court addressed whether Mr. Jordan had a due process right to be present at the hearing, Jordan v. State, 786 So. 2d 987, 1022 (Miss. 2001), it did not have reason to address the distinct question as to whether trial counsel adequately informed Mr. Jordan about the purpose of the evaluation and whether anything that he said to Dr. Maggio could be used against him. Exhibit 36.
259. By not ensuring that their client was aware of the ramifications of cooperating with the evaluation, Mr. Jordan could not make a knowing and intelligent waiver of his rights prior to meeting with 76 Cal.App.4th at p. 1293), demonstrate that the court's order granting the HOA's motion finally disposed of the litigation. There was nothing left for the court to do other than enforce its order, and the HOA, notwithstanding its urging that the order is not final, identifies no further matters to be determined in the case. The Second District Court of Appeal (Div. Three), recently addressing similar circumstances, held: "The court here granted the motion [to enforce settlement] under Code of Civil Procedure section 664.6, but failed to enter a formal judgment. Absent a formal entry of judgment, an appellate court may amend an order to include a judgment if the effect of the order is to finally determine the rights of the parties in the action. [Citation.] We conclude that the effect of the order here was to finally determine the rights of the parties in this action by enforcing the settlement agreement. Accordingly, we will amend the order to include an appealable judgment so as to expedite appellate review." ( Hines v. Lukes, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1183, citing Griset, supra, 25 Cal.4th at pp. 698-700.)

We therefore conclude that, although it would have been preferable for the court to have disposed of the HOA's motion by entering judgment as specified in section 664.6, the order here finally determined the rights of the parties. Therefore, "we will amend the order to include an appealable judgment so as to expedite appellate review." ( Hines v. Lukes, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1183.)

II. Motions to Enforce Settlement Under Section 664.6

The Second District Court of Appeal, Division Two, has succinctly described the nature of motions brought pursuant to section 664.6: "Section 664.6 was enacted to provide a summary procedure for specifically enforcing a settlement contract without the need for a new lawsuit. [Citations.] . . . Although a judge hearing a section 664.6 motion may receive evidence, determine disputed facts, and enter the terms of a settlement agreement as a judgment [citations], nothing in section 664.6 authorizes a judge to create the material terms of a settlement, as opposed to deciding what terms the parties themselves have previously agreed upon." ( Weddington Productions, Inc. v. Flick (1998) 60 Cal.App.4th 793, 809-810 [ 71 Cal.Rptr.2d 265]; see also Terry v. Conlan (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 1445 [ 33 Cal.Rptr.3d 603] [court erred in granting § 664.6 motion where record demonstrated no meeting of minds concerning material terms of settlement].)

The trial court's factual findings on a motion to enforce a settlement under section 664.6 "are subject to limited appellate review and will not be disturbed if supported by substantial evidence." ( Williams v. Saunders (1997) 55 Cal.App.4th 1158, 1162 [ 64 Cal.Rptr.2d 571].) In instances involving questions of law, including the construction and application of the statute, the trial court's decision is not entitled to deference and will be subject to independent review. ( Ibid.) For example, where the principal claim of error "raises a question of law concerning the construction and application of section 664.6[, . . .] it requires independent review. [Citations.]" ( Gauss v. GAF Corp. (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 1110, 1116 [ 127 Cal.Rptr.2d 370], fn. omitted ( Gauss).)

III. Whether Purported Settlement Is Enforceable Under Section 664.6

The record discloses that when the Settlement was recited on the record on January 30, 2008, two of the five parties did not personally give their consent to it. Because this raises a serious question as to whether the statutory requirements of enforcing a settlement under section 664.6 were satisfied, we address the issue below. Additionally, in view of the fact that the apparent absence of the parties' personal consent to the oral Settlement was not a focal point of either the Critzers' opposition to the motion below or of their appeal, we also address below whether any enforceability argument should be deemed forfeited.

Both parties acknowledged in their briefs that not all parties gave their formal consent at the time to the oral Settlement, but they did not elaborate on the potential legal effect of this circumstance upon the enforceability of the Settlement under section 664.6. Accordingly, we requested that the parties submit supplemental letter briefs on both the substantive issue and on whether the question should be deemed forfeited. We have considered those supplemental briefs in reaching our conclusions in this opinion.

A. Enforceability of Purported Settlement

Section 664.6 provides as follows: "If parties to pending litigation stipulate, in a writing signed by the parties outside the presence of the court or orally before the court, for settlement of the case, or part thereof, the court, upon motion, may enter judgment pursuant to the terms of the settlement. If requested by the parties, the court may retain jurisdiction over the parties to enforce the settlement until performance in full of the terms of the settlement."

The Supreme Court has addressed the meaning of the term "parties" in the context of whether a section 664.6 motion may be brought to enforce a settlement for which there was a purported written agreement that was not signed by all litigants themselves, but was signed by attorneys on behalf of their clients. (See Levy v. Superior Court (1995) 10 Cal.4th 578 [ 41 Cal.Rptr.2d 878, 896 P.2d 171] ( Levy).) After observing that the statute requires a stipulation by the "parties" to pending litigation, the court concluded the term "parties" must be interpreted literally to mean the litigants themselves. ( Id. at p. 586.) Although the term "party" is recognized in other contexts as including the litigant's attorney of record (e.g., § 437c), the court determined the Legislature intended "a narrower meaning" for the word, "namely the specific person or entity by or against whom legal proceedings are brought. [Citations.]" ( Levy, supra, at p. 583.) The court reasoned that, unlike other steps an attorney takes in managing a lawsuit, settlement ends the lawsuit and is thus "such a serious step that it requires the client's knowledge and express consent. [Citation.]" ( Ibid.) In holding that enforcement of a settlement pursuant to section 664.6 requires the personal assent of the litigants themselves, the court reasoned: "[I]n 1981 [,] . . . the Legislature enacted section 664.6, which created a summary, expedited procedure to enforce settlement agreements when certain requirements that decrease the likelihood of misunderstandings are met. Thus the statute requires the `parties' to stipulate in writing or orally before the court that they have settled the case. The litigants' direct participation tends to ensure that the settlement is the result of their mature reflection and deliberate assent. This protects the parties against hasty and improvident settlement agreements by impressing upon them the seriousness and finality of the decision to settle, and minimizes the possibility of conflicting interpretations of the settlement. [Citations.] It also protects parties from impairment of their substantial rights without their knowledge and consent. [Citation.]" ( Levy, at p. 585, fn. omitted.) Because one of the parties in Levy did not personally sign the settlement agreement, the Supreme Court concluded that the purported settlement agreement confirmed in writing by the parties' attorneys could not be enforced under the procedural mechanism of section 664.6. ( Levy, at p. 586.) Johnson v. Department of Corrections (1995) 38 Cal.App.4th 1700 [45

In so holding, the court observed that there are procedural devices other than a motion under section 664.6, such as summary judgment or a separate action, that may be available for the enforcement of a settlement. ( Levy, supra, 10 Cal.4th at p. 586, fn. 5.)

Cal.Rptr.2d 740] ( Johnson) addressed whether the Levy requirement under section 664.6 of the parties' personal approval of a written settlement agreement applied equally to oral settlements recited before the court. In Johnson, after the case was assigned out to trial, a settlement was recited on the record with counsel present. ( Johnson, at pp. 1703-1704.) Because the purported oral settlement was never acknowledged on the record by the plaintiff himself, the court, following Levy, held that the trial court erred in enforcing it under section 664.6, reasoning: "Settlement negotiations were handled by the parties' attorneys and the court. While the attorneys orally agreed to the settlement during judicially supervised negotiations, and thus orally stipulated to the agreement `before the court' [citations], [the] plaintiff never personally informed the court that he accepted the terms of this agreement. Absent this personal involvement, the agreement is not enforceable under section 664.6." ( Johnson, at pp. 1707-1708.) In so holding, the court rejected the defendants' argument that Levy applied only to written settlement agreements for which enforcement under section 664.6 was sought, and did not apply to oral settlements recited in open court. ( Johnson, at p. 1708; see also Wackeen v. Malis (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 429, 440 [ 118 Cal.Rptr.2d 502] [§ 664.6 requires oral consent in court or the signatures of the parties themselves; consent by attorneys or spouses insufficient].)

Similarly, in Murphy v. Padilla (1996) 42 Cal.App.4th 707 [ 49 Cal.Rptr.2d 722] ( Murphy), we rejected the argument that an oral settlement agreement ratified by the party's attorney, acting as the party's agent, was enforceable under section 664.6. "The Levy and Johnson opinions appear to reject traditional agency analysis, which holds that ` "the client as principal is bound by the acts of the attorney-agent within the scope of his actual authority (express or implied) or his apparent or ostensible authority; or by unauthorized acts ratified by the client."` [Citation.] [¶] . . . [¶] In the underlying case, Levy and Johnson prevent respondents from relying on agency principles to satisfy the requirements of section 664.6. Accordingly, if appellant did not personally agree to the alleged oral settlement before Judge Bonney, an additional ground exists for concluding that enforcement under section 664.6 was improper." ( 42 Cal.App.4th at p. 716, fn. omitted.)

Since Levy, several cases have addressed the question of whether all parties must personally assent to a settlement in order for it to be enforceable under section 664.6, or whether it is sufficient that the party against whom the settlement is being enforced need to have personally assented. In Harris v. Rudin, Richman Appel (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 299, 303 [ 87 Cal.Rptr.2d 822] ( Harris), the plaintiff in a legal malpractice suit against a law firm and five individuals sought to enforce a purported written settlement agreement that consisted of a letter of counsel which two of the individual defendants had signed "under a notation reading `[a]ccepted and agreed.'" The letter agreement was not signed by the plaintiff or by the other defendants. ( Ibid.) The trial court denied the plaintiff's motion to enforce the settlement because "the statutory prerequisites of section 664.6 had not been satisfied . . . [in that] not all of the parties in the action [had] signed the [l]etter." ( Ibid.) The court in Harris affirmed. In so holding, the court rejected the plaintiffs arguments that "[(1)] the statute's requirement of a `writing signed by the parties' does not expressly require all the parties in the action to sign the settlement agreement [and (2)] . . . section 664.6 [is similar] to the statute of frauds requiring only the `part[ies] to be charged' to sign the writing. (See Civ. Code, § 1624.)" ( Id. at p. 304.) The Harris court held: "We read the statute's requirement of a writing `signed by the parties' to require the signatures of the parties seeking to enforce the agreement under section 664.6 and against whom the agreement is sought to be enforced. Although there is no direct authority interpreting the term `parties' in such a way, such an interpretation is consistent with our Supreme Court's opinion in Levy[, supra,] 10 Cal.4th [at p.] 585 " ( Id. at p. 305.)

Similarly, in Sully-Miller Contracting Co. v. Gledson/Cashman Construction, Inc. (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 30 [ 126 Cal.Rptr.2d 400] ( Sully-Miller), a purported written settlement agreement was signed by the plaintiffs; however, because they did not receive the contemplated consideration in a timely manner, they revoked their offer to settle, and the trial court granted the remaining parties' motion to enforce the purported settlement. ( Id. at pp. 33-35.) The appellate court concluded that this was error. Citing Harris, supra, 74 Cal.App.4th at pages 304-306, it observed that the provisions of section 664.6 could be invoked to enforce a written settlement agreement only if it has been signed by all parties. ( Sully-Miller, at p. 37.) "We conclude that a party cannot satisfy section 664.6's signature requirement simply by adding its signature to a document that does not call for it. The purpose of section 664.6's signed writing requirement — to provide unequivocal proof of the parties' intent to enter a binding settlement — would be frustrated if courts enforced written agreements pursuant to that section where, as here, the agreement only contemplates the signature of one party. Section 664.6 requires the parties' signatures because `settlement is such a serious step that it requires the client's knowledge and express consent. [Citation.]' [Citation.] A party's signature fails to convey such knowledge and consent unless it is contained in a document that was clearly intended by that party to be a binding settlement agreement. [¶] Because of its summary nature, strict compliance with the requirements of section 664.6 is prerequisite to invoking the power of the court to impose a settlement agreement. The ad hoc addition of a party's signature that was neither contemplated in the original document nor bargained for is simply insufficient to render the document enforceable under section 664.6." ( Ibid.)

Finally, in Gauss, supra, 103 Cal.App.4th 1110, the defendant in consolidated appeals argued that the trial court had erred in granting section 664.6 motions to enforce settlement because the defendant had not personally signed the settlement agreements; rather, they were signed by the defendant's agent, its attorney. ( Gauss, at pp. 1112-1113.) The appellate court — citing, inter alia, Levy, supra, 10 Cal.4th 578, Harris, supra, 74 Cal.App.4th 299, Sully-Miller, supra, 103 Cal.App.4th 30, and Murphy, supra, 42 Cal.App.4th 707 — concluded that because there was no writing indicating the defendant's consent to settle, the purported written settlement was not enforceable under section 664.6. ( Gauss, at pp. 1116-1121.)

Here, the record demonstrates that the oral Settlement the HOA sought to enforce was recited in open court on the record on January 30, 2008. The previous day, the court recited the terms of a settlement on the record, and the Critzers' attorney and Tung's attorney each added clarifications to the recital. No party voiced his/her/its assent on the record on January 29. On January 30, after the HOA's attorney recited the terms of the Settlement, and after a clarification from Tung's counsel, the court obtained the consent of David Critzer, Margaret Critzer, and Tung. The court indicated that Enos was not present, but Enos's attorney, Frank Jelinch, indicated that he had authority for his client, had spoken with him, and Enos was "agreeable." There was no consent to the Settlement given by the HOA; indeed, the record does not reflect whether a representative of the HOA was present at the January 30 hearing.

The HOA's motion to enforce settlement pursuant to section 664.6 brought in August 2008 contained the assertion that the parties had settled the case on January 30, 2008, and recited the terms of the Settlement by reference to the matters contained in the reporter's transcript. The motion clearly indicated that the Settlement was reached on January 30 and that it was enforceable under section 664.6. We therefore conclude that — addressing the issue without reference to whether the contention may have been forfeited (see pt. III.B., post) — the oral Settlement was not enforceable under section 664.6. Plainly, there was no personal consent to the recited terms of the Settlement by two of the five parties, the HOA and Enos. Any claim that the Settlement was nonetheless effective because it was expressly consented to by Enos's agent (Jelinch), and perhaps impliedly consented to by the HOA's agent (Attorney Mark Shem, who recited the terms of the Settlement), lacks merit. Under Levy, supra, 10 Cal.4th 578, in order for a settlement to be enforceable under section 664.6, the consent to settlement must have been given by the party, personally, and courts have rejected agency arguments posed to circumvent the party-consent requirement. (See Gauss, supra, 103 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1118-1119; Murphy, supra, 42 Cal.App.4th at p. 716 fn. 7.) Additionally, the fact that the Critzers gave their personal consent to the terms of the oral Settlement — as the parties against whom the Settlement is being enforced — does not obviate the necessity of the personal consent of the remaining parties, including the HOA and Enos. ( Harris, supra, 74 Cal.App.4th at pp. 304-305.) Moreover, there is no basis for making a distinction between oral settlements and written settlements: Both forms of settlements, in order to be enforceable under section 664.6, require the personal consent of all parties. ( Johnson, supra, 38 Cal.App.4th at p. 1708.)

The HOA claims — in both its brief and supplemental letter brief (see fn. 10, ante) — that under Elyaoudayan v. Hoffman (2003) 104 Cal.App.4th 1421 [ 129 Cal.Rptr.2d 41] ( Elyaoudayan), the oral Settlement was enforceable because it was later formally agreed to by the HOA and Enos when a draft agreement was prepared by the HOA's counsel and signed separately by the HOA and Enos. Elyaoudayan is distinguishable and does not support the HOA's argument. There, an oral settlement was recited on the record and was personally consented to by some, but not all, of the parties. ( 104 Cal.App.4th at p. 1426.) The two parties who did not give their consent at the hearing later signed a stipulation attaching the transcript of the court proceedings in which the settlement was recited. ( Ibid.) The Elyaoudayan court held that because "[a]ll parties agreed to the settlement in one form or the other or both" ( id. at p. 1432), it was immaterial that some of the parties merely signed the agreement attaching the court transcript while others gave their oral consent in court.

The respondent's brief filed by the HOA is noncompliant in that it fails to contain any proper citations to the appellate record — either the clerk's or reporter's transcript — supporting matters referred to in the court below. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(1)(C) [matters referenced from the record in appellate briefs must be supported "by a citation to the volume and page number of the record where the matter appears"].) In instances where an appellate briefs noncompliance with this rule is substantial, the court may order the brief stricken. ( Doppes v. Bentley Motors, Inc. (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 967, 990 [ 94 Cal.Rptr.3d 802].) We have nonetheless overlooked this noncompliance and have considered the contentions and factual assertions made by the HOA in its brief.

Here, neither the HOA nor Enos orally consented at the hearing to the Settlement. Likewise, neither the HOA nor Enos gave its or his subsequent written consent by signing a writing attaching the reporter's transcript (reciting the Settlement terms). The fact that a representative of the HOA — some three and one-half months after the oral Settlement — signed a formal document prepared by its counsel (entitled "Mutual Release of All Claims and Settlement Agreement and Covenant Not to Sue") — does not alter the circumstances that, unlike in Elyaoudayan, the HOA neither orally agreed to the Settlement at the time nor agreed in writing by signing a document attaching the court transcript reciting the terms of the Settlement. Similarly, the fact that Enos signed a version of a written settlement agreement on a date unknown — which version apparently differed from the version signed by the HOA — does not change the fact that Enos neither orally consented to the Settlement on January 30 nor signed a document attaching the court transcript that contained a recital of its terms.

Moreover, we reject the HOA's assertion in its supplemental letter brief that Elyaoudayan is controlling because by signing the written settlement agreement, the HOA and Enos agreed in writing to the same terms that were recited in court on the record and orally agreed to months earlier by the Critzers and Tung. While in a superficial sense, this argument may seem plausible — because the later written agreement incorporated the essential terms that were recited in January and in some sense merely represented the formalized agreement that often follows after the parties reach an oral settlement of a case at a settlement conference — there are very real differences between the written agreement and the prior oral Settlement agreed to by three of the parties. These include the following provisions found in the written agreement that are not in the oral Settlement: (1) the release does not apply to a related civil writ action; and (2) any ambiguity or dispute about the interpretation of the agreement is to be construed to the fullest extent possible as effecting a release of the Critzers' claims (i.e., a clause favoring defendants). Also, the provision in the written agreement concerning Judge Kleinberg retaining continuing jurisdiction is significantly broader than what was recited in the oral Settlement. Accordingly, because there were differences between the oral Settlement and the terms of the written settlement agreement later signed by the HOA and Enos, unlike the circumstances in Elyaoudayan "[a]ll parties [did not] agree[] to the settlement in one form or the other or both." ( Elyaoudayan, supra, 104 Cal.App.4th at p. 1432.)

In the oral Settlement, it was recited: "In the event there is a dispute as to the opaqueness and design of the window, it will be referred to [Y]our Honor for final adjudication on that issue." It was further recited: "The Court again will retain jurisdiction to effectuate the terms of the settlement, again, on the issues of the opacity of the glass as well as the design if there is a dispute." The written agreement signed by the HOA and Enos, on the other hand, provided: "The Santa Clara County Superior Court, the Honorable James Kleinberg, shall have continuing jurisdiction over the parties and this litigation to finalize, execute and enforce the terms and conditions of this release. Further, the court shall retain jurisdiction to decide any issues regarding the opaqueness of the proposed glazing for the awning window to be installed and the design of such glazing should the parties be unable to reach an agreement. The Court shall also retain jurisdiction to resolve any disputes on the type of lattice tresses through noticed motion."

Finally, the HOA argues in its supplemental letter brief that the HOA's personal consent was not needed to enforce the settlement because the HOA was being defended under a general liability insurance policy, and it is generally the case that "the named party does not have the right to consent to any settlement made on its/his/her behalf." In support of this position, the HOA cites Fiege v. Cooke (2004) 125 Cal.App.4th 1350 [ 23 Cal.Rptr.3d 496] ( Fiege). There, the court, relying extensively on Robertson v. Chen (1996) 44 Cal.App.4th 1290, 1293-1296 [ 52 Cal.Rptr.2d 264], held that where the settlement was orally agreed to by the plaintiff and the defendants' insurers (but not the insureds), and the policies provided that the insurers could settle without the insureds' consent and could bind the insureds to the settlement, the plaintiff could not thereafter escape from the settlement being enforced under section 664.6 because of the absence of the insureds' oral consent. ( Fiege, at pp. 1353-1355.) The HOA argues that "[s]ince defense counsel indicated [the HOA's] approval of the settlement on the record, pursuant to Fiege, [the HOA] party approved of the settlement in open court."

There are three problems with this argument. First, the HOA does not cite to any portion of the record that demonstrates that the HOA was being defended under a general liability insurance policy under which the HOA gave its insurer the right to settle without the HOA's consent and the right to bind the insured to the settlement. Second, the record from the Settlement recited on January 30, 2008, does not reflect the agreement of the insurer (let alone the insured, HOA) to its terms. It is unclear whether the insurer was even present in court when the terms were recited. Thus, even were the record to have demonstrated that the HOA was insured under an insurance policy that permitted settlement by the insurer alone, there was no consent by the insurer. (Cf. Fiege, supra, 125 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1355-1356 [concluding that insurer agreed to oral settlement when its representatives were in court, heard the settlement recited, and did not object after the court asked if anyone had addenda or disagreements with its terms].) Third, even if Fiege applied here to eliminate the problem of the absence of the HOA's personal consent, the HOA's argument does not address the problem of the absence of Enos's personal consent to the oral settlement.

We therefore conclude that the oral Settlement recited in court on January 30, 2008, could not be enforced under section 664.6 because it was not personally consented to by two of the parties.

B. Possible Forfeiture of Contention

The absence of all parties' consent to the Settlement and the consequent enforceability issue notwithstanding, we must consider whether any challenge that the Critzers may raise to the court's order on this basis is forfeited. This requires a review of the Critzers' arguments both below and on appeal.

In their written opposition to the HOA's motion to enforce below, the Critzers did not argue that the Settlement was unenforceable because of the absence of consent by the HOA and Enos. Their opposition was to the effect that (a) the proposed settlement language in the formal settlement documents prepared by the HOA's counsel after January 30 were heavily slanted toward defendants; (b) the court should not enforce a settlement that contains terms that are unjust to the Critzers; and (c) if the court could not resolve the parties' disputes concerning settlement language, the court should enforce the Settlement terms as limited to what was recited on the record on January 30. At the hearing, the Critzers' counsel, A.K. Abraham, argued principally that there were a number of matters that had been inserted in the draft settlement agreement that had not been part of the Settlement recited in court. Abraham, however, noted that not all of the parties had given their assent when the Settlement was recited on the record and raised a question as to whether the matters recited in court were subject to enforcement under section 664.6. Abraham argued: "The difficulty is that had we articulated the entire settlement terms on the record. [ Sic.] And had the record been truly a 664.6 settlement, which it was not inasmuch as the HOA's representative was not there to affirm the terms, that would have been one thing. Rather, what the Court and the parties did . . . was to give the broad strokes of a settlement agreement and allow the parties then time to work out primarily boilerplate issues. . . ."

On appeal, the Critzers observe in passing that "[n]either Enos nor the HOA were [ sic] present at the time of the January 30, 2008 hearing. . . . Nor did the HOA consent to all of the terms at that time through its counsel, but rather agreed to have its [b]oard of [directors consider some of the terms for approval at a later meeting. . . . Both the HOA and Enos subsequently signed off on the enlarged written settlement agreement which the court directed the HOA's attorney to draft. . . ." Further, although the Critzers' position here is that the January 30 Settlement was "skeletal" and that the parties all contemplated that further "specific terms and conditions [needed] to be fleshed out by counsel in subsequent discussions," they do not address frontally the issue that we have discussed above: namely, whether the failure of all parties to consent to the terms of the Settlement, of itself, precludes enforcement under section 664.6. But the Critzers do note: "Moreover, because two of the defendants were not present and thus never stipulated to the settlement read into the court record — but later signed a document containing numerous additional terms — they cannot be said to have agreed to the same provisions as the other parties. . . . Since the parties here did not all agree to the same terms, [section] 664.6 is, as a matter of law, inapplicable to the `agreement' which defendants seek to enforce. . . ."

It is a fundamental proposition that "`[a]n appellate court will ordinarily not consider procedural defects or erroneous rulings, in connection with relief sought or defenses asserted, where an objection could have been but was not presented to the lower court by some appropriate method. . . .' [Citation.]" ( Doers v. Golden Gate Bridge etc. Dist. (1979) 23 Cal.3d 180, 184-185, fn. 1 [ 151 Cal.Rptr. 837, 588 P.2d 1261].) Likewise, an appellant's failure to raise an issue on appeal may result in a forfeiture of the issue. ( Children's Hospital Medical Center v. Bonta (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 740, 777 [ 118 Cal.Rptr.2d 629].)

Here, although the Critzers could have been more expansive in their discussion of whether the absence of consent by all parties precluded enforcement of the Settlement under section 664.6, we conclude that they raised the issue sufficiently below and before this court to preclude its forfeiture. Moreover, "when the issue involves undisputed evidence and raises a pure question of law, we may consider it for the first time. [Citation.]" ( Burckhard v. Del Monte Corp. (1996) 48 Cal.App.4th 1912, 1918 [ 56 Cal.Rptr.2d 569] [court addresses legal question of whether absence of party's signature on writings confirming settlements precluded enforcement under § 664.6, despite party's failure to raise issue at trial].) We therefore conclude that it is appropriate to consider whether the oral Settlement is enforceable under section 664.6 despite the absence of the personal consent of the HOA and Enos.

C. Conclusion

The fact that not all of the parties gave their personal consent to the Settlement precluded the court from granting a motion to enforce under section 664.6, even though the Critzers themselves personally consented to the oral Settlement. ( Harris, supra, 74 Cal.App.4th at p. 303; Johnson, supra, 38 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1707-1708.) While on the surface, this result may seem to exalt form over substance, the statute is clear and "[b]ecause of its summary nature, strict compliance with the requirements of section 664.6 is prerequisite to invoking the power of the court to impose a settlement agreement." ( Sully-Miller, supra, 103 Cal.App.4th at p. 37.) Moreover, "[t]he litigants' direct participation tends to ensure that the settlement is the result of their mature reflection and deliberate assent. This protects the parties against hasty and improvident settlement agreements by impressing upon them the seriousness and finality of the decision to settle, and minimizes the possibility of conflicting interpretations of the settlement. [Citations.] It also protects parties from impairment of their substantial rights without their knowledge and consent. [Citation.]" ( Levy, supra, 10 Cal.4th at p. 585, fn. omitted.) The controversy here in which the parties have differing views on the substance of the actual settlement exemplifies the rationale for requiring the personal consent of all parties for an enforcement proceeding under section 664.6, as explained in Levy.

We summarily deny the HOA's separate motion for sanctions pursuant to California Rules of Court, rule 8.276, in which the HOA contends that the Critzers and their counsel are pursuing an appeal that is frivolous. In light of our conclusion that the matter must be reversed, the appeal herein is not frivolous.

DISPOSITION

The order granting the motion to enforce settlement pursuant to section 664.6, amended to constitute a final appealable judgment ( Hines v. Lukes, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1183), is reversed.

Rushing, P. J., and Elia, J., concurred.

Dr. Maggio. See Estelle, supra. Therefore, Petitioner is entitled to post-conviction relief.

All applicants seeking federal habeas relief under § 2254 are required to exhaust all claims in state court prior to requesting federal collateral relief. See Edwards v. Carpenter, 529 U.S. 446 (2000); Coleman v. Thompson, 501 U.S. 722, 729-55 (1991); Whitehead v. Johnson, 157 F.3d 384, 387 (5th Cir. 1998). The exhaustion requirement is satisfied when the substance of the federal habeas claim has been fairly presented to the highest state court in a manner that adequately developed the factual basis for the claim. Williams v. Taylor, 529 U.S. 420, 429-30 (2000). That presentation must also alert the state court as to the legal basis for the claim. Baldwin v. Reese, 541 U.S. 27, 29 (2004).

In his post-conviction brief to the Mississippi Supreme Court, Jordan informed the state court that he was bringing an ineffectiveness claim under the Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the federal Constitution. However, the sum total of his discussion on that claim was the bare reference in the heading; in no part of the discussion on the issue does he address Strickland or the requirements for an ineffectiveness claim. Not surprisingly, the Mississippi Supreme Court failed to address this issue in its opinion.

The Respondents argue that Jordan completely defaulted this claim; it appears that the more appropriate question is whether he failed to "fairly present" it. The law requires Jordan to present to the state court the "controlling legal principles" that he believes apply to the facts of his case. Picard v. Connor, 404 U.S. 270, 277 (1971). In the habeas context, most cases involving exhaustion deal with state court pleadings that described the relevant claim in terms of state law, with no mention of federal law. Thus, in Picard, the petitioner's Fourteenth Amendment equal protection claim was defaulted because his state court claims were based on state law, with only a passing reference to the Fifth Amendment. Later, in Anderson v. Harless, the Court dismissed a habeas claim on the constitutionality of a malice instruction given at trial. 459 U.S. 4, 7 (1982). Because the petitioner had only argued his claim under state law in state court, he could not make a due process claim under federal law in his habeas pleadings. But see Howell v. Mississippi, 543 U.S. 440, 444 (2005) (refusing to excuse default because a litigant could raise a federal issue by simply labeling the claim "federal"); Baldwin v. Reese, 541 U.S. 27, 32 (2004).

In other cases, the petitioner has raised a federal claim in state court, but seeks to add a different federal claim for habeas review. In such a case, the Fifth Circuit has barred a habeas claim of ineffective assistance of counsel where the petitioner argued ineffectiveness at the mitigation stage of his trial to the state courts, but added a claim of ineffectiveness during voir dire and closing to his habeas petition. Ries v. Quarterman, 522 F.3d 517, 524-26 (5th Cir. 2008). See also Wilder v. Cockrell, 274 F.3d 255, 261-62 (5th Cir. 2001) (holding that a brief reference to Chambers v. Mississippi, 410 U.S. 284 (1973), in a discussion on ineffectiveness did not exhaust Chambers claim).

Jordan's situation is a little different. He has mentioned the appropriate constitutional provisions under which his claim arose; however, he did so only in a heading in his brief, with no further discussion or citation to relevant cases. "The general rule is that arguments not raised before the district court are waived on appeal." Balentine v. Thaler, No. 09-70026, ___ F.3d ___, 2010 WL 2433243 at *4 (5th Cir. June 18, 2010) (holding, in a case with the opposite situation, that the errant heading of a section of the argument was not dispositive of the issue raised, where the argument sufficiently set out the grounds for relief). The Supreme Court addressed a similar issue in Dye v. Hofbauer, 546 U.S. 1, 4 (2005) (per curiam). There, the state court pleading contained the following heading to the relevant argument: "The Prosecutor Denied Defendant Due Process of Law and Fair Trial by Numerous Instances of Misconduct." After outlining the specific instances of misconduct complained of, the petitioner included in the text citations to the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United States. He further cited several federal cases concerning alleged violations of federal due process rights in the context of prosecutorial misconduct. The Court found that the state court brief "was clear that the prosecutorial misconduct claim was based, at least in part, on a federal right."

The issue is close. Certainly, Jordan did not do nearly as much as the petitioners in the cases in the preceding paragraph to notify the state court of his claim. Still, he did something, and the language of Howell suggests that he need not do much. Based on this authority, this Court concludes that Jordan adequately raised his federal claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, and the issue has not been defaulted.

As has been already recognized in this Opinion, the standard for determining the effectiveness of counsel during trial is the two-prong test set forth by the Supreme Court in Strickland, 466 U.S. 668. A defendant must show that counsel's representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, and that there is "`a reasonable probability that, but for counsel's unprofessional errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different.'" Id. at 694. Although the state court did not rule on the issue of ineffectiveness, it did hold that the use of Maggio's report, if error, was harmless. 912 So. 2d 800, 817.

In a habeas case, a state court's determination that an error was harmless must be reviewed under the standard set forth in Brecht v. Abrahamson, 507 U.S. 619, 637 (1993) ("whether the error `had a substantial and injurious effect or influence in determining the jury's verdict.'") (quoting Kotteakos v. United States, 328 U.S. 750, 776 (1946)). Thus, even if the state court found an error harmless, this Court's review does not rely on § 2254 to determine whether that finding was unreasonable, but analyzes the alleged error under Brecht. Fry v. Pliler, 551 U.S. 112, 121 (2007); Westbrook v. Thaler, 585 F.3d 245, 255 (5th Cir. 2009). The harmless error analysis under Brecht relies on a higher standard than that recognized under Strickland; in other words, if an error has been found not to violate the Brecht standard for harmlessness, it cannot meet the standard for prejudice under Strickland. Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419, 435-36 (1995); White v. Johnson, 153 F.3d 197, 208 (5th Cir. 1998).

Here, Jordan argues that Maggio's report caused him harm in two ways — diminishing the credibility and effect of Richard King's testimony and preventing two other witnesses from testifying. With regard to Mr. King, who testified as a mitigation witness, the report was used as follows:

Q. Mr. King, I'm to resume with my questioning. I believe you told this jury that, in effect, that Richard Gerald Jordan was not a dangerous person and you would welcome him into your house? A. Yes, sir, I did. Q. I want to hand you a document and ask you to read to yourself, please, this paragraph right here. BY MR. OWEN: May it please the court, on behalf of the record I'm handing him the 2-23-76 evaluation. [Done by Dr. Davis, not Dr. Maggio] A. This one right here? Q. Right here what I had already read to you? [During an earlier proffer] A. Yes, sir. I have read it. Q. Did you know that Richard Gerald Jordan blamed the FBI? A. Not until you showed me that piece of paper, sir. That's what you're saying. Q. Well, that's what is contained in this report, is it not? A. Yes, sir. Q. Did you know that? A. No, sir. Q. Did you know that Richard Gerald Jordan also said, as reflected by this report, that he's sorry that she was killed, but then he shrugged his shoulders and said, "better luck next time." A. No, sir. Not until I saw that. Q. What does better luck next time mean? A. Just what it says, better luck next time is the way I understand it. Q. Maybe next time he will have better luck and won't get caught? A. That wouldn't be my interpretation. No, sir. Q. I'm sorry. A. That would not be my interpretation. Q. Well, I'm not going to spend a great deal of time arguing with you, but to make sure we're together here. He blamed the FBI for the death of Edwina Marter because the FBI blundered the job in not following instructions. He comments that he's sorry that she was killed, but then he shrugged this off by saying, "better luck next time." You see that, don't you? . . . . Q. Did he tell you anything about his discharge from the military? A. No, sir. Q. Do you know if he received a discharge from the military? A. No, sir. I have never seen a piece of paper. . . . . Q. Did he tell you anything about why he left that fertilizer company? A. No, sir. Q. Let me hand you this report of 2-23-76 [Dr. Davis's report]. I'm going to ask you only to read this to yourself okay. If I may stand by the witness. BY THE COURT: All right. Q. Starting with the word when, ending with the word company. Starting there, please. Stop right there. Did you read that? A. Just a minute. Okay. Q. Now don't say anything about it, but were you aware of that event? A. No, sir. . . . . Q. I'm going to hand you this document. For the record this is the Maggio report, Judge, and — if I might stand by the witness. I'll invite your attention to where it starts with two, the issue of dangerousness, and ask you to read that sentence? A. Okay. Q. Do you agree with that? (Objection overruled.) Q. Mr. King, was Richard Jordan a danger to himself when he was in the military? A. Repeat that question. A danger to himself when he was in the military? Q. Right. . . . . A. I was not in the military with him. He was in the Army and I was in the Marine Corps. Q. If you don't know all you have to say is that you don't know? A. I don't know. Q. Was he a danger to others prior to going into the military? A. No, sir. Q. In your opinion he was not? A. In my opinion, no, sir. Q. And after he got out of the military he was not a danger to anyone, was he? A. I didn't see him except at the class reunion. In my opinion, no, sir. Q. Well we know he was a danger to one person anyway, don't we? A. Yes, sir. Q. Edwina Marter? As can be seen from this excerpt of trial testimony, the majority of the questioning about which Jordan complains was predicated upon the 1976 report of Dr. Davis, not Dr. Maggio's report. Dr. Davis's report was already in the prosecution's possession, and its genesis is not at issue in this matter. This Court is of the opinion that this limited use of Dr. Maggio's report did not have a substantial and injurious effect or influence in determining the jury's verdict.

In addition to the cross-examination of Mr. King, Jordan complains that he was compelled to exclude two other mitigation witnesses from testifying. The harm or prejudice that the exclusion of this testimony caused to Jordan's case is unclear, since he did not proffer the witnesses' testimony to the court. In the absence of such evidence, this Court must conclude that the exclusion of these witnesses was harmless. Allen v. Hardy, 478 U.S. 255, 261 n. 4 (1986); Brown v. Butler, 876 F.2d 427, 431 (5th Cir. 1989) (citing Buchanan v. Kentucky, 483 U.S. 402, 425 (1987)); see also Barkat v. Gonzales, 207 F. App'x 451, 452 (5th Cir. 2006); Martin v. Maggio, 739 F.2d 184, 187 (5th Cir. 1984). Cf. Luce v. United States, 469 U.S. 38, 42-43 (1984) (holding, in the context of a motion in limine at a federal criminal trial to exclude evidence of the defendant's prior conviction, harmless error analysis requires that the defendant testify to preserve the error). Thus, the exclusion of these witnesses does not change the conclusion reached above as to the use of Maggio's report.

The effect of the limited use of Maggio's report being, at most, harmless error, it cannot be prejudicial within the meaning of Strickland. That being the case, Jordan cannot establish that its use resulted from ineffectiveness on the part of his trial counsel. Additionally, as shown above, the Mississippi Supreme Court's determination that Jordan had no constitutional rights to assert with regard to the use of Maggio's report is neither contrary to, nor an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law. Thus, Jordan cannot establish a claim to habeas relief based on the use of Dr. Maggio's report at trial.

Ground P : The trial court's ruling precluding petitioner from presenting certain mitigating evidence violated Petitioner's Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendment rights.

Jordan argues that he was prevented from presenting certain mitigation evidence because the trial court sustained the prosecution's objections to the testimony of some of his witnesses. This issue was raised in Jordan's direct appeal and considered by the Mississippi Supreme Court. The particulars of Jordan's complaint and the state court rulings on each claim are set out below:

Issue No. 1:

[T]he trial court sustained the special prosecutor's objections to testimony by Parchman official Estelle Denley that while he never had any problems with Mr. Jordan he did have problems with other inmates.

The Mississippi Supreme Court considered this issue and ruled, "Evidence of the behavior of other inmates was irrelevant, and the State's objection thereto was properly sustained." Jordan v. State, 786 So. 2d at 1020.

Issue No. 2:

[I]n the transcript of the testimony of Homer Jordan, Mr. Jordan's father, the trial court sustained the prosecutor's objection to defendant's question whether his father ever saw Mr. Jordan's children.

On this issue, the state court made the following ruling:

Evidence of a criminal defendant's death and the effect it would have on the life of his family is not relevant and is properly excluded since such evidence does not impact on the defendant's character, the record, or the circumstances of the crime. Wilcher v. State, 697 So. 2d 1123, 1133-34 (Miss. 1997).
Id.

Issue No. 3:

During the testimony via transcript of Ms. Shirley Thames, Mr. Jordan's cousin, the trial court sustained the prosecutor's objections to testimony about the problems that Mr. Jordan's offense has created for his family; about Mr. Jordan's relationship to his wife; about Mr. Jordan's religious background; about Mr. Jordan's reputation for peace or violence prior to 1976; and about the circumstances under which Mr. Jordan and his wife separated.

With regard to Ms. Thames's testimony, the court made the following decision:

Similarly the testimony of Jordan's cousin, Shirley Thames, was properly excluded for the same reason. Thames proposed to testify about the problems that Jordan's crime created for his family and for his relationship with his wife. Such testimony is not allowed under Wilcher. Also, Thames wanted to testify to Jordan's reputation in the community prior to 1976. This testimony was properly excluded since she did not live in the same community at that time.
After Thames testified that Jordan was "brought up in the church by his parents," the State objected on the basis of hearsay, and the court sustained the objection. Thames could not so testify from personal knowledge, so the testimony was properly excluded. See M.R.E. 602.
Id. The court went on to note that Jordan was not prejudiced by the exclusion of this testimony because his brother testified at length about Jordan's affiliation with the church, both during their childhood and as an adult. Id.

Jordan argues that the state court's decision abrogated the decisions by the United States Supreme Court as to the wide range of evidence that may be offered in mitigation, citing Tennard v. Dretke, 542 U.S. 274 (2004); Hitchcock v. Duggar, 481 U.S. 393, 394 (1987); Skipper v. South Carolina, 476 U.S. 1 (1986); Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 U.S. 104 (1982); and Jurek v. Texas, 428 U.S. 262, 271 (1976). He also cites to the Mississippi Supreme Court's earlier decision remanding Jordan's case for a new sentencing hearing on grounds that proper mitigation evidence was excluded. Jordan v. State, 518 So. 2d 1186, 1188-89 (Miss. 1988). He claims that the evidence excluded was similar to the evidence that constituted reversible error in his earlier case. He also contends that the trial court improperly excluded evidence of "good character and redeeming qualities," citing Williams v. Taylor, 529 U.S. 362, 416 (2000). With respect to the determination that the testimony involved hearsay, Jordan argues that the hearsay rule is relaxed in mitigation hearings. Green v. Georgia, 442 U.S. 95, 96 (1979). Finally, he maintains that the error was not harmless, stating that at least one juror might have reconsidered the death sentence if he had heard that "Jordan had been a religious person in the past, and had resumed his religion in prison, that he had a good record in jail, and that he had enjoyed a reputation for peace and non-violence prior to the murder. . . ."

With regard to the first issue, the testimony of Mr. Denley, Respondents argue that the complete transcript of his testimony shows that he was able to describe Jordan as an inmate, saying "It is hard to describe it. You just don't really remember that. you remember the people that caused you trouble, and I never had any trouble out of Mr. Jordan." Defense counsel followed up by asking "So he never caused you any trouble?" Denley answered, "Never did." The objection came to the following question, "Did other prisoners cause trouble?" Before the objection was made and sustained, Denley actually answered "Yes. Some." That answer was not stricken.

The Mississippi Supreme Court found that the objectionable question sought information that was not relevant. Jordan argues, "[T]he trial court sustained the special prosecutor's objections to testimony by Parchman official Estelle Denley that while he never had any problems with Mr. Jordan he did have problems with other inmates." This argument is somewhat disingenuous. Denley was able to testify that he never had any problems with Mr. Jordan. He was simply not permitted to testify that he had problems with other inmates.

Under certain conditions, the exclusion of evidence during a sentencing trial, even though proper under state evidentiary rules, may constitute a violation of the Due Process Clause. Green v. Georgia, 442 U.S. 95, 97 (1979) ( per curiam); Eddings v. Oklahoma, 455 U.S. 104, 111 (1982); Chambers v. Mississippi, 410 U.S. 284, 302 (1973). However, in this Circuit, Green is "limited to its facts, and certainly did not federalize the law of evidence." Barefoot v. Estelle, 697 F.2d 593, 597 (5th Cir. 1983); see also McGinnis v. Johnson, 181 F.3d 686, 693 (5th Cir. 1999); Edwards v. Scroggy, 849 F.2d 204, 212 (5th Cir. 1988). Instead, Green has been interpreted to recognize that "certain egregious evidentiary errors may be redressed by the due process clause." Barefoot, 697 F.2d at 597. However, the evidence at issue must be "highly relevant to a critical issue in the punishment phase of the trial, and substantial reasons existed to assume its reliability." Green, 442 U.S. at 97. In other words, the restriction on testimony must not be "unnecessarily limiting," nor can it render the trial "fundamentally unfair." Edwards, 849 F.2d at 212. Denley's excluded testimony about the behavior of other inmates was not "highly relevant to a critical issue in the punishment phase" — it was not even marginally relevant. The Mississippi Supreme Court's opinion that the exclusion of this testimony as irrelevant was proper did not offend clearly established federal law, and habeas relief is not appropriate with regard to this issue.

Jordan also complains about the exclusion of testimony from his father, Homer Jordan, about whether he ever saw Jordan's children. The Mississippi Supreme Court found that the testimony was offered to show the effect that Jordan's execution would have on his family and held that the exclusion was proper. Respondents argue that the testimony sought was irrelevant, and, in light of Homer Jordan's extensive testimony about Jordan's life and character, the exclusion was harmless.

This testimony was actually given during the 1983 trial. The transcript of that trial reflects the following exchange on direct examination: Q. Now he [Jordan] had three children? A. Three children; that's correct. Q. Do you ever see those three children? BY MR. NECAISE: We object to that, if it please the Court, as being immaterial. BY THE COURT: Sustained. Q. Since your son has been in jail, have you had a chance to see him? Defense counsel did not present argument on the objection; neither did he proffer Homer Jordan's answer to that question. This issue was not raised in the appeal of the 1983 trial. No claim of procedural bar has been raised with respect to this issue, and the Mississippi Supreme Court reviewed it on the merits. In any event, the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision is not contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law.

As the cases that Jordan cites establish, a defendant facing the death penalty is entitled to present "any aspect of a defendant's character or record and any of the circumstances of the offense that the defendant proffers as a basis for a sentence less than death." Lockett v Ohio, 438 U.S. 586, 604 (1978). However, the Supreme Court has never included "execution impact" testimony as a category of mitigating evidence that must be admitted. Jackson v. Dretke, 450 F.3d 614, 618 (5th Cir. 2006). Thus, the state court's decision was not contrary to the law on mitigation evidence, as established by Supreme Court precedent. Id. at 617. Likewise, since that type of evidence does not reflect on Jordan's background, character, or the circumstances of his crime, the Mississippi Supreme Court's was not unreasonable in failing to extend the precedent to this situation. Habeas relief is unavailable on this issue.

Similarly, Ms. Thames's testimony from the 1983 trial was read to the jury in the 1998 proceeding. Jordan contends that he was impermissibly restricted in presenting mitigation testimony regarding "the problems that Mr. Jordan's offense has created for his family; about Mr. Jordan's relationship to his wife; about Mr. Jordan's religious background; about Mr. Jordan's reputation for peace or violence prior to 1976; and about the circumstances under which Mr. Jordan and his wife separated." As to the first and second issues — the problems that Jordan's offense has created for his family and his relationship with his wife — the Mississippi Supreme Court ruled that this testimony was improper for the same reason that Jordan's father's testimony was excluded. Based on the discussion of that issue above, this Court is of the opinion that it cannot grant habeas relief on this issue.

With regard to Ms. Thames's testimony on Jordan's religious background, the transcript of the 1983 trial contains the following colloquy: Q. Do you know anything about his [Jordan's] religious background? A. Yes, I do. Q. What is that? A. Gerald was brought up in church by his parents. I can't recall being in service with Gerald at any time. BY MR. NECAISE: Then, if the court please, we are going to object to it as being hearsay. BY THE COURT: Sustained. BY MR. HUDSON: Judge, I think the religious background can be a lot broader. BY THE COURT: Well, I think you ought to go ahead and ask another question. The Mississippi Supreme Court held that the objection to this testimony was proper, because it was not based on Ms. Thames's personal knowledge. 786 So. 2d at 1020. As stated above, the testimony was properly excluded as hearsay, so long as it was not "highly relevant to a critical issue" and its exclusion did not make the sentencing proceedings fundamentally unfair. Green, 442 U.S. at 97; Edwards, 849 F.2d at 212. The testimony was relevant to the issue of Jordan's character; however, in light of other testimony given, the exclusion was not unfair. As noted by the Mississippi Supreme Court, Jordan's brother offered extensive testimony about Jordan's church involvement. Id. Additionally, both his father and his mother testified that Jordan regularly attended church, both as a child and as an adult. It was proper to exclude this testimony.

Jordan also complains that Thames's testimony was improperly limited when she was not permitted to testify as to his reputation for peace or violence prior to 1976. The Mississippi Supreme Court held that the testimony "was properly excluded, since she did not live in the same community at that time." Id. Again, the exclusion was proper, so long as the sentencing trial was not made fundamentally unfair without this evidence. Moreover, in addition to the requirement that excluded evidence be "highly relevant to a critical issue," Green requires that substantial reasons exist to assume that the excluded evidence is reliable. 442 U.S. at 97. Thames's opinion of Jordan's reputation in the community for peace or violence could not have been reliable if she did not live in that community. Furthermore, at the end of her direct testimony, defense counsel asked her about Jordan's "acts of kindness." She responded:

He was very friendly and he was considerate. He was lovable. When I was around him, he acted like he was proud to see us. And he was proud to be a part of the family. And he was a family man. He loved his children. You know, he was proud to show off his children to the family when he would come to visit us and bring the children. He was just kind to everybody. He just wanted to be nice to everybody.

The jury did hear, therefore, indirect evidence of Jordan's character from Thames, and the exclusion of her unreliable, hearsay opinion did not make Jordan's trial fundamentally unfair. This Court is of the opinion that the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision was not an unreasonable application of, or contrary to, clearly established federal law on this issue. Jordan was not improperly restricted in his ability to present a mitigation case by these rulings, under clearly established federal law. Therefore, he is not entitled to habeas relief on these issues.

Ground Q : The State's repeated failures to provide Petitioner with a constitutionally sound capital sentencing trial ultimately prevented him from developing all relevant mitigating evidence, thereby violating his Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment rights guaranteed by the federal Constitution and Mississippi law; in the alternative, counsel were ineffective for not objecting to their inability to present all relevant mitigating evidence due to the State's repeated inability to provide Petitioner with a legally sound sentencing proceeding.

Jordan's argument on this issue is based on the nature of the testimony he was compelled to present in the 1998 trial, which occurred fifteen years after the previous trial and twenty two years after the crime.. During that time, many of the witnesses for both sides had died, including Jordan's parents. As a result, he was forced to present them to the jury through reading their testimony in the previous trial. Jordan argues that this presentation could not "convey the emotion or evoke the jury's sympathy in a way that a parent could." Jordan argues that the delay was the result of the State's failure, on three previous occasions, to afford him a proper trial. He further argues that his attorneys were ineffective for failing to object to the trial court on this basis.

Part of the delay between the third and fourth trials can be attributed to Jordan's stopping the appeal process of his habeas petition and pleading to a sentence of life without parole in 1991. He revoked the agreement in 1994 in an attempt to be re-sentenced to life with parole, thereby necessitating legal proceedings that culminated in the Mississippi Supreme Court's vacating his sentence and remanding his case in 1997.

Of primary concern to Jordan is the inability to present convincing testimony that he suffered from post traumatic stress disorder, resulting from his service in Vietnam. He argues that his father's earlier testimony on that issue could not have been persuasive because so little was known about the disease at that time. Thus, he argues, he was prevented from effectively presenting important mitigating evidence, in contravention of Lockett, 438 U.S. 586, and Jurek, 428 U.S. 262. In actuality, it was his brother, Robert, and not his father, Homer, who testified on the issue of Jordan's change in behavior after returning from Vietnam, and Jordan's attorney has admitted the misidentification. Robert's 1983 testimony was also read to the jury at the 1998 trial. According to Respondents, Robert was still alive at that time, but could not attend the trial due to illness.

This issue was presented to the Mississippi Supreme Court in Jordan's petition for post-conviction relief. That court ruled:

Jordan has had the benefit of all of the mitigating evidence that was available the first time he was convicted and sentenced to death. Although the form of some of the evidence is not the same as it was in the original presentation, it is still available and has been utilized to the best extent possible by defense counsel. Likewise, Jordan was convicted and sentenced to death in his very first trial in 1976 when, ostensibly, all of his mitigation witnesses were alive and well. Therefore, we find that Jordan fails to demonstrate any actual prejudice from the unavailability of his parents' live testimony. This claim has no merit.
912 So. 2d at 822. This Court views Jordan's claim as two-fold: (1) he argues that the mitigation testimony from his parents lost its emotional effect when read to the jury; and (2) he argues that he was prevented from effectively presenting evidence of PTSD because no witness who could testify to that issue testified live at his last trial.

Jordan does not cite any case requiring that mitigation evidence be put before the jury in the particular manner that is most likely to engender sympathy, and this Court is not aware of any. The cases that he does cite hold that he should be able to present for consideration all relevant mitigating evidence. Eddings, 455 U.S. at 113-15; Lockett, 438 U.S. at 604. These cases say nothing, however, about the form that this evidence should take. Jordan essentially insists that the Mississippi Supreme Court should have extended that law to his situation to hold that the Eighth Amendment requires that the substance of his mitigation evidence be presented in the form most likely to appeal to the jury's emotions. The Mississippi Supreme Court declined his invitation, and this Court does, as well.

In Saffle v. Parks, 494 U.S. 484, 492 (1990), the Court rejected an argument condemning the anti-sympathy instruction given during the sentencing proceedings in a death penalty case. In so doing, the Court recognized that the state may "insist that `the individualized assessment of the appropriateness of the death penalty [be] a moral inquiry into the culpability of the defendant, and not an emotional response to the mitigating evidence.'" Id. (quoting Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153, 189-95 (1976)). Since "capital sentencing must be reliable, accurate, and nonarbitrary," the jury should be required to consider mitigating evidence in the form of a "`reasoned moral response,'" rather than an emotional one. Saffle, 494 U.S. at 493 (quoting California v. Brown, 479 U.S. 538, 544 (1987). Given this clearly established federal precedent, this Court believes that the law requiring that defendants be permitted to present their mitigation evidence should not be extended to requiring that they be able to present it in the most emotionally appealing manner. Thus, the Mississippi Supreme Court's opinion was neither contrary to, nor an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law.

As the Court has discussed earlier, Jordan has simply not presented credible evidence to convince this Court that he has been unconstitutionally denied the right to present mitigating evidence to the jury regarding PTSD. The affidavits he has presented from experts in the field are not based on an actual examination of Jordan, but merely suggest the possibility that he suffers from this disorder because he served in Vietnam. His behavior in prison does not reflect any of the symptoms described by those experts. Finally, during trial, Jordan addressed the court (outside the presence of the jurors) about his interview with Maggio and stated, "If I had been aware that this could be used against me then I would have restricted myself specifically to whether I was [sic] post-traumatic disorder, which frankly I didn't think I was, but, you know, that was something that we had to look into."

The Mississippi Supreme Court found that Jordan was not prejudiced by the presentation of his parents' testimony by reading the transcripts. This Court agrees. Jordan has not established that the state court's decision abrogates clearly established federal precedent on this issue; therefore, he is not entitled to habeas relief. Accordingly, his claim that his counsel was ineffective is likewise unavailing. Paredes v. Quarterman, 574 F.3d 281, 291 n. 13 (5th Cir. 2009) (citing United States v. Kimler, 167 F.3d 889, 893 (5th Cir. 1993) ("An attorney's failure to raise a meritless argument . . . cannot form the basis of a successful ineffective assistance of counsel claim because the result of the proceeding would not have been different had the attorney raised the issue.").

Ground R : Petitioner's rights guaranteed by the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments were violated by the constitutionally impermissible instructions regarding the "especially heinous, atrocious or cruel" aggravating circumstance.

Jordan complains about the first two of the seven instructions that were given to the jury at the conclusion of his trial. The first instruction sets out the findings that must be made and considered in determining whether the death penalty was the appropriate punishment. The second instruction defined the term "heinous, atrocious or cruel." In Part B of the first instruction, the court set out the aggravating and mitigation circumstances, as follows:

Next to return the death penalty, you must find that the mitigating circumstances, those which tend to warrant the less severe penalty of life imprisonment, do not outweigh the aggravating circumstances, those which tend to warrant the death penalty.
Consider the following elements of aggravation in determining whether the death penalty should be imposed:
1. Whether Richard Jordan committed the capital murder while engaged in the crime of kidnaping Edwina Marter;
2. Whether Richard Jordan committed the capital murder for pecuniary gain, that is, whether Richard Jordan demanded $25,000.00 and did in fact obtain $25,000.00 from Charles Marter; and
3. Whether Richard Jordan committed a capital offense which was especially heinous, atrocious and cruel and whether the murder was conscienceless and pitiless. In support of this circumstance the State claims that Edwina Marter was murdered in execution style and that she was subjected to extreme mental torture caused by her abduction from the home wherein she was forced to abandon her unattended three year old child and removed to a wooded area at which time she was shot in the back of the head by Jordan.
. . . .
If one or more of the above aggravating circumstances is found to exist beyond a reasonable doubt, then each of you must consider whether there are mitigating circumstances which outweigh the aggravating circumstance(s). You are not required to find mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt. Consider the following elements of mitigation in determining whether the death penalty should not be imposed:
1) Participated in church and school activities and sports while growing up;
2) Military service including Vietnam;
3) He confessed to crime and cooperated with police;
4) Since being in custody he has established a good prison record by working and not causing problems;
5) Has attempted to make positive contributions by writing short stories and invention of wind tunnel:
6) Attempted to maintain contact with family and friends and to assist them.
If you find from the evidence that one or more of the preceding elements of mitigation exists, then you must consider whether it (or they) outweigh(s) or overcome(s) the aggravating circumstance(s) you previously found. In the event that you find that the mitigating circumstance(s) do not outweigh or overcome the aggravating circumstance(s), you may impose the death sentence. Should you find that the mitigating circumstance(s) outweigh or overcome the aggravating circumstance(s), you shall not impose the death sentence.

Instruction No. 2 read:

In considering whether the capital offense was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, you are instructed that heinous means extremely wicked or shockingly evil; atrocious means outrageously wicked and vile; and cruel means designed to inflict a high degree of pain with indifference to, or even enjoyment of the suffering of others.
An especially heinous, atrocious or cruel capital offense is one accompanied by such additional acts as to set the crime apart from the norm of capital murders — the conscienceless or pitiless crime which is unnecessarily torturous to the victim. If you find from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that Richard Jordan utilized a method of killing that inflicted physical or mental pain upon Edwina Marter before her death, that there was mental torture and aggravation before death, then you may find this aggravating circumstance exist [sic].

The jury's verdict read:

We, the jury, unanimously find from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the following facts existed at the time of the commission of the capital murder.
1) That the defendant actually killed Edwina Marter.
Next, we, the jury, unanimously find that the aggravating circumstances of:
1) Richard Jordan committed the capital murder while engaged in the crime of kidnaping Edwina Marter.
2) Richard Jordan committed the capital murder for pecuniary gain.
3) Richard Jordan committed a capital offense which was especially heinous, atrocious cruel whether the murder was conscienceless pitiless. In support of this circumstance the State claims that Edwina Marter was murdered in execution style that she was subjected to extreme mental torture caused by her abduction from the home wherein she was forced to abandon her unattended three year old child removed to a wooded area at which time she was shot in the back of the head by Jordan.
exist beyond a reasonable doubt are sufficient to us to impose the death penalty and that there are insufficient mitigating circumstances to out weigh the aggravating circumstances and we further find unanimously that the defendant should suffer death.

Jordan argues that the instructions were flawed for several reasons. First, he argues that the inclusion of the State's theory of why the crime was heinous was unfair, as it singled out the prosecution's theory that Marter was killed in execution style while failing to provide the defense's theory that she was killed accidentally. He further argues that this language relieved the State of its burden of proof on this issue. Jordan claims that both instructions were vague and overbroad, but that the combination of the two instructions would have been particularly confusing for the jury. Additionally, according to Jordan, there was insufficient evidence to support a finding beyond a reasonable doubt that the offense was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel. Finally, Jordan contends that the cumulative effect of these issues also violated his constitutional rights.

Jordan has withdrawn one of his arguments based on the State's response.

Respondents first argue that this entire issue is procedurally barred from review for failure of counsel to object to the instructions at trial. The Mississippi Supreme Court addressed this issue on direct appeal and found that "all of the issues raised concerning the heinous, atrocious, and cruel aggravator instructions are procedurally barred" because Jordan did not object to the instructions at trial. The court went on to say:

Jordan argues that we will overlook a procedural bar where there are matters of fundamental constitutional significance at stake. "When the circuit court grants instructions clearly erroneous and which deny the accused a fair and objective evaluation of the evidence by the jury, we will reverse, even though there was no objection by defense counsel." Duvall v. State, 634 So. 2d 524, 526 (Miss. 1994). See also Booker v. State, 699 So. 2d 132, 135 (Miss. 1997) (citing line of cases excepting from procedural bars issues concerning limiting instructions concerning the heinous, atrocious, and cruel aggravator). Out of an abundance of caution, we will address Jordan's claim on the merits.
786 So. 2d at 1002. Jordan argues, as he did on his claim of prosecutorial misconduct during closing argument, that the phrase "out of an abundance of caution" suggests that the court excused the default because his was a death penalty case and determined the merits of his claim. Respondents disagree.

For the reasons discussed in the earlier section on prosecutorial misconduct, this Court is of the opinion that the phrase "out of an abundance of caution" does not signal that a substantive ruling was being made in place of the decision that an issue is procedurally barred. Likewise, the mention in the opinion that the state court has excused the bar and reached the merits of certain claims involving fundamental constitutional rights does not change this Court's opinion. Jordan correctly notes that Booker v. State, 699 So. 2d 132, 135 (Miss. 1997), lists several cases in which the court reached past a procedural bar to consider the merits of claim involving an instruction on the "especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel" aggravating circumstance. However, those cases involved a specific issue — whether such an instruction was over broad and vague in the absence of a limiting instruction offering a definition of that aggravator. Maynard v. Cartwright, 486 U.S. 356 (1988) held that such an instruction was improper. Clemons v. Mississippi, 494 U.S. 738 (1990), held that, in a case where an invalid instruction was given, a state reviewing court could either reweigh the aggravating and mitigating circumstances or perform harmless error analysis. Under the authority of Maynard and Clemons, the Mississippi Supreme Court has consistently excepted cases involving the failure to provide a limiting instruction for that aggravator from procedural bars.

Duvall v. State, 634 So. 2d 524, 525-26 (Miss. 1994), involved an instruction that the Mississippi Supreme Court had specifically rejected in an earlier case. Given that unambiguous precedent, the court later held, "the trial court and prosecutor . . . had ample notice that [the] instruction . . . was clearly erroneous." Fears v. State, 779 So. 2d 1125, 1128 (Miss. 2000). In such a circumstance, the trial judge has an obligation to insure that the jury is properly instructed. 634 So. 2d at 526. However, where there is not a prior decision clearly condemning an instruction, trial counsel's failure to object will constitute a default that bars review. 779 So. 2d at 1128.

These cases excused default in specific situations that are not applicable to Jordan's case. This Court does not interpret the Mississippi Supreme Court's mention of them as an indication that it would excuse the failure to object to the instructions about which Jordan now complains. For that reason, this Court is of the opinion that the state clearly and unmistakably relied on its routine practice of refusing to review claimed trial errors where no contemporaneous objection was made to them.

This issue is barred from habeas review.

Alternatively, the claims regarding these instructions have no merit. Jordan's first argues that it was improper for the trial court to include the State's theory as to why the jury should find that the crime was especially heinous atrocious and cruel. Respondents offer another reason that this particular claim should be barred — Jordan failed to argue a federal claim in his state court appeal. He only asserted that his "rights under the Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution and the corresponding provisions of the Mississippi Constitution" were violated. Jordan responds that the citation to the federal constitution was enough. For the reasons more fully explained in the court's discussion of Jordan's ineffectiveness claim in Section XXII of this Opinion, the Court finds that this reference is marginally sufficient to entitle Jordan to habeas review of this claim.

The Mississippi Supreme Court found that this inclusion was not error because Jordan had not offered his own theory as to why the crime did not fit that category. Reviewing the evidence that Jordan offered at trial, the court stated:

Trial strategy is a better reason Jordan chose not to attempt to put "his" theory in writing in Instruction No. 1. To say that Jordan exercised compassion by leaving a three-year-old unattended in the Marter home or that by shooting Edwina only once in the back of the head defies logic.
786 So. 2d at 1002. The court continued, "Regardless, the State certainly had every right to offer an instruction which outlined its theory of the case. The instruction complained of by Jordan was fairly supported by the evidence and was properly given. See Wall v. State, 718 So. 2d 1107, 1111 (Miss. 1998)."

Jordan's first argument is that the inclusion of the State's contention into the instruction unfairly highlighted the State's theory without presenting Jordan's. The Mississippi Supreme Court interpreted this argument as suggesting that the defense should have insisted on including the theory that those actions were not heinous, atrocious, or cruel. This Court construes the argument somewhat differently. Much of the State's theory was not in dispute — Marter's kidnaping, the forced abandonment of her young child and the gunshot to the back of her head. At issue was whether Marter was shot "execution style" by Jordan or whether her murder was an accident that occurred as she tried to escape. Thus, this Court concludes that Jordan's actual argument is that the instruction should have included his contention that he accidentally shot Marter while attempting to fire over her head to prevent an escape.

Federal habeas review can result in the granting of relief on a jury instruction that is ambiguous, inconsistent or deficient only where there is "`a reasonable likelihood' that the jury applied the instruction in a way that relieved the State of its burden of proving every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt." Waddington v. Sarausad, ___ U.S. ___, 129 S.ct. 823, 831 (2009) (quoting Estelle v. McGuire, 502 U.S. 62, 72 (1991)). The instruction must be judged "in the context of the instructions as a whole and the trial record." Estelle, 502 U.S. at 72. Relief is warranted when the instruction "`so infected the entire trial that the resulting conviction violates due process.'" Waddington, 129 S.ct. at 832 (quoting Cupp v. Naughten, 414 U.S. 141, 147 (1973)).

This Court finds that the inclusion of the State's theory did not amount to a due process violation, because the record in this case indicates clearly that the jury was informed as the Jordan's theory. Both of Jordan's initial statements to law enforcement included his claim that he shot Marter accidentally while she was trying to escape. He presented an expert witness to refute the State's experts as to the nature of Marter's wound and what it indicated about her position when she was shot. Finally, in closing argument, defense counsel made the following comments:

[T]here is one thing that I do want to spend a little bit of time on, is one of the aggravating circumstances that the State says that exist. And that is the States's theory that this was an execution style killing.
And in addressing this issue I want to be perfectly clear that I think the crime itself is horrible enough as it is. And there's a lot of undisputed evidence that makes it a horrible crime. But I just don't believe that there is sufficient evidence for you to conclude that it was an execution style killing.
And the Court, in its instructions, has told you not to be swayed by conjecture, and that's what this theory is, it's conjecture.

Defense counsel then summarized Dr. Riddick's testimony regarding the autopsy report and continued:

Now this theory about Mrs. Marter being on her knees when she was shot poses some problems in my mind because this mannequin depicts the trajectory of the bullet as entering the lower part of her skull in the rear and exiting in the front upper to the left. That means that the projectile was following an upward trajectory. Now if she were on her knees and her head was in an upright position and he fired downward it seems like the trajectory would have been going downward. If she had her head bent forward then it seems that the trajectory would have — could have followed the upward path and the bullet would have landed in the grass near her body. But there wasn't any bullet. They never found any bullet.
I asked Dr. Atchison about that and he said the bullet could have ricocheted. Well how does a bullet ricochet off of dirt? And I just wanted to respond to that. I don't want to make — as I said, whether he shot Mrs. Marter standing up, running away, kneeling down, I think it's horrible enough in and of itself without trying to make it just a little bit worse on conjecture. And that's what the State — I mean the Court has told you not to do is base your opinion on conjecture.

In this context, the Court finds that the failure to include Jordan's theory of the murder in the instruction did not so affect his trial as to amount to a due process violation. The jury was well aware of his argument on this issue, and it is not grounds for habeas relief.

Jordan also argues that the inclusion of the State's theory of Marter's killing relieved the State of its burden of proof on this aggravating circumstance. In essence, he believes that the instruction permitted the jury to find that the killing was heinous, atrocious, or cruel, as well as conscienceless and pitiless, if the jurors simply believed the State's theory, without requiring them to make the further finding that the theory satisfied the definition of that aggravator. In other words, Jordan argues that the instruction allows the jury, if they believed the State's theory that the murder was execution style, to automatically conclude that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel, and conscienceless and pitiless, without making an express determination to that effect.

In ruling on this issue, the Mississippi Supreme Court initially held that he failed to contemporaneously object to the instructions about which he complained, so he was barred from raising them for review. 786 So. 2d at 1024. The court continued, "Nevertheless, we will address the merits of his claim." Id. For the reasons earlier expressed on this subject, this Court holds that the discussion of the merits was an alternative holding, and the state court clearly and expressly relied on an independent state ground in reaching this decision, thus barring habeas relief. In any event, Jordan could not succeed on the merits.

The state court's opinion on this issue on direct appeal was brief: "As Jordan himself points out, we have considered and denied such arguments in approving a similarly-worded jury instruction to the one at issue in Evans v. State, 725 So. 2d at 694-96. Therefore, this issue is without merit." 786 So. 2d at 1026. In its post-conviction opinion, the court once more found the issue barred, but alternatively addressed the merits thusly:

There was sufficient evidence for the jury to find that Edwina's murder was heinous, atrocious, cruel, conscienceless and pitiless. There was no unconstitutional burden-shifting in the jury instructions or evidentiary shortcuts for the jury. Nor were the instructions unconstitutionally vague or overly broad. The instructions properly limits [sic] the jury's discretion, advising them that they may find the aggravating factor only if they find that Jordan `utilized a method of killing that inflicted physical or mental pain upon Edwina Marter before her death, and there was mental torture and aggravation before death." This claim is without merit.
912 So. 2d at 819.

The portion of the instruction about which Jordan complains instructs the jury to determine whether the instruction was heinous, atrocious, or cruel. It goes on to say, " In support of this circumstance the State claims that Edwina Marter was murdered in execution style. . . ." This Court believes that the language indicated to the jury that the State's "claim" was its argument in support of a finding that the aggravator existed, not a presumption that the aggravator existed if the State's theory was adopted. Moreover, that language was followed by the admonition: "You must unanimously find beyond a reasonable doubt that one or more of the preceding aggravating circumstances exists in this case to return the death penalty." The prosecution's closing argument underscored the necessary finding. In his initial argument, he said:

The aggravating circumstances have been proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The three aggravating circumstances are the commission of a murder or the crime of murder during the commission of a kidnaping; the crime was for pecuniary gain; and that it was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel. All you have to do is find one beyond a reasonable doubt. . . .

Later, in his final argument to the jury, the prosecutor reminded the jury that, in order to sentence Jordan to death:

You also have to list under B the aggravating circumstances. There's three of them. The murder in the commission of kidnaping, pecuniary gain, which means obtaining money, and that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel. you don't have to find all three of them. As long as you find one beyond a reasonable doubt.

When combined with the instruction, this language effectively communicated to the jury that the actual finding it had to make was not that the murder occurred execution style, but that it was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel.

Jordan argues that Respondents err in contending "so long as the jury was instructed at some point that it had to find the aggravating circumstance beyond a reasonable doubt, the instructions pass constitutional muster. However, that is not the law." He then compares his case to two Supreme Court cases in which improper burden-shifting was found. However, those cases are distinguishable. In Sandstrom v. Montana, 442 U.S. 510, 513 (1979), the jury was given an affirmative instruction that "[t]he law presumes that a person intends the ordinary consequences of his voluntary acts." This was a statement of the law directing the jury's consideration of the evidence, and it conflicted with the state's burden to prove all of the elements of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Id. Because a reasonable jury could have construed that instruction as mandating an affirmative finding on the element of intent, or as shifting the burden to the defendant to disprove intent, it was an improper burden-shifting instruction that denied the defendant due process. Id. at 517-18, 524.

In Francis v. Franklin, 471 U.S. 307, 310-11 (1985), the defendant argued, as does Jordan, that he killed the victim accidentally. The jury was instructed as follows:

The acts of a person of sound mind and discretion are presumed to be the product of the person's will, but the presumption may be rebutted. A person of sound mind and discretion is presumed to intend the natural and probable consequences of his acts but the presumption may be rebutted.
Id. at 311. The Supreme Court condemned the instruction, noting that the Due Process Clause "prohibits the State from using evidentiary presumptions in a jury charge that have the effect of relieving the State of its burden of persuasion beyond a reasonable doubt of every essential element of a crime." Id. at 313. Francis explained the distinction between mandatory and permissive instructions: "A mandatory presumption instructs the jury that it must infer the presumed fact if the State proves certain predicate facts. A permissive inference suggests to the jury a possible conclusion to be drawn if the State proves predicate facts, but does not require the jury to draw that conclusion." Id. at 314. Because the language of the instruction at issue was "cast in the language of command," it was a mandatory presumption that shifted the burden of proof to the defendant and thereby violated the Due Process Clause. Id. at 317-18. General instructions on the burden of proof did not legitimize the offending instruction. Id. at 319.

The language of the instruction in Jordan's case did not tell the jury that, if they found that Marter was killed "in execution style," they were to presume that the aggravating circumstance was established. At most, the instruction created a permissive inference, telling the jury that they could find the aggravating circumstance satisfied by a finding that Marter was executed. In the absence of any language specifically linking the finding on execution to the finding on the aggravator, this Court does not believe that the instruction created any presumption at all. However, if a permissive presumption had been created, it only denied Jordan due process "if the suggested conclusion is not one that reason and common sense justify in light of the proven facts before the jury." Id. at 314-15 (citing Ulster County Court v. Allen, 442 U.S. 140, 147-63 (1979). Reason and common sense would justify the conclusion that the murder was heinous, atrocious, and cruel if Marter was executed as she kneeled before her killer. Thus, the guarantee of due process was not violated by this instruction, and the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision was neither contrary to, nor an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law.

Jordan argues that Instructions 1 and 2 were vague and overbroad, both individually and in concert. He claims that the finding that Marter was killed execution style was at odds with the definition of "heinous, atrocious, and cruel," as "[a]n execution method of killing is the least likely method of killing to cause `physical pain' and `mental pain.'" He argues that the first paragraph of Instruction 2 is vague and overbroad within the interpretation given in Shell v. Mississippi, 498 U.S. 1 (1990), and that the second paragraph is infirm because it omitted reference to mutilation, dismemberment or a lingering or torturous death. Respondents argue that the instructions mirrored language approved in earlier state court cases, as well as the recent case of Bell v. Cone, 543 U.S. 447 (2005).

The Mississippi Supreme Court also addressed the merits of this claim as an alternative holding, after finding that it had been defaulted. With respect to the claim of vagueness and overbreadth, the court stated:

Instruction No. 1 does state that the jury could find that the crime was especially heinous because Edwina was murdered in execution style, but it goes on to say, " and that she was subjected to extreme mental torture caused by her abduction from the home wherein she was forced to abandon her unattended three year old child and removed to a wooded area at which time she was shot in the back of the head by Jordan." Today we will not decide whether a straightforward execution style killing, without more, constitutes "heinous atrocious or cruel," but we do find that the execution style killing, in addition to the circumstances listed above, did constitute "heinous, atrocious or cruel."
We have approved of Instruction No. 2 as a proper limiting instruction concerning the "especially heinous" aggravator. See, e.g., Edwards v. State, 737 So. 2d 275, 315 (Miss. 1999); Puckett v. State, 737 So. 2d 322, 359-61 (Miss. 1999). Therefore, Jordan's claim is without merit.
786 So. 2d at 1004.

In Shell v. Mississippi, 498 U.S. 1, 2-3 (1990), the Supreme Court addressed an instruction containing only the language of the first paragraph of Instruction 2. The Court held that it was constitutionally deficient, noting that "the phrases "extremely wicked or shockingly evil" and "outrageously wicked and vile" could be used by "`[a] person of ordinary sensibility [to] fairly characterize almost every murder.'" Id. (quoting Maynard v. Cartwright, 486 U.S. 356, 363 (1988); Godfrey v. Georgia, 446 U.S. 420, 428-29 (1988). States using some form of this language in their statutory definition of aggravating circumstances continued to refine it. In Walton v. Arizona, 497 U.S. 639 (1990), the Court affirmed a death sentence in a state that permitted the imposition of the death sentence by the trial judge, rather than by a jury. One of the statutory circumstances that could be used as an aggravator was whether the offense was committed in a manner that was "heinous, cruel, or depraved." In affirming the sentence, the Court held that Arizona state courts had sufficiently narrowed that language in their construction of the statute, and it was presumed that the trial judge applied that construction. Id. at 653. It then set out the analysis to be performed by a federal court reviewing the application of a statutory aggravating or mitigating circumstance:

Walton was subsequently overruled by Ring v. Arizona, 536 U.S. 584 (2002), but only to the extent that a jury must now find that aggravating factors exist.

[I]t must first determine whether the statutory language defining the circumstance is itself too vague to provide any guidance to the sentencer. If so, then the federal court must attempt to determine whether the state courts have further defined the vague terms, and if they have done so, whether those definitions are constitutionally sufficient, i.e., whether they provide some guidance to the sentencer. In this case there is no serious argument that Arizona's "especially heinous, cruel or depraved" aggravating factor is not facially vague. But the Arizona Supreme Court has sought to give substance to the operative terms, and we find that its construction meets constitutional requirements.
Id. at 654.

In Maynard, the Court had suggested that it would approve a definition of the aggravator that would limit it to murders involving torture or physical abuse. 486 U.S. at 364-65. In Walton, the Court approved the limiting definition used by the Arizona Supreme Court, which held that a murder was especially cruel when accompanied by mental anguish, including the victim's uncertainty as to his fate or physical abuse. 497 U.S. at 654. It also approved the state court's construction of the term "depraved," which was established when the murderer "relishes the murder, evidencing debasement or perversion" or "shows an indifference to the suffering of the victim and evidences a sense of pleasure in the killing." Id. at 655.

In Cone, the Court considered a statutory aggravating circumstance permitting the death penalty if the murder "was especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel in that it involved torture or depravity of mind." 543 U.S. at 448 n. 1. A limiting instruction given by the Tennessee court defined "heinous, atrocious or cruel" in the following manner: "`Heinous' means extremely wicked or shockingly evil. `Atrocious' means outrageously wicked and vile. `Cruel' means designed to inflict a high degree of pain, utter indifference to, or enjoyment of, the suffering of others, pitiless." Id. at 452 n. 4.

In Cone, the victims were an elderly couple who had been beaten to death in their home by the petitioner. Blood was spattered throughout the house, and the victims' injuries indicated that they had tried to resist. On direct appeal, the Tennessee Supreme Court had affirmed the finding that the crime was especially heinous, atrocious and cruel after reciting the facts of the case and concluding, "The deaths of the victims were not instantaneous, and obviously one had to be killed before the other. The terror, fright and horror that these elderly helpless citizens must have endured was certainly something that the jury could have taken into account in finding this aggravating circumstance." State v. Cone, 665 S.W.2d 87, 95 (Tenn. 1984).

Cone petitioned for habeas relief, which was ultimately granted by the Sixth Circuit. Cone v. Bell, 359 F.3d 785 (6th Cir. 2004). After reviewing the Supreme Court precedent discussed above, that court concluded that, while no case considered exactly the same language used in the Tennessee statute, similar instructions had been held to be unconstitutionally vague. It then considered whether the Tennessee Supreme Court had "saved" the instruction by applying a narrowing construction to it. Id. at 796-97. In an earlier case, the Tennessee court had applied language approved by the Supreme Court in Proffitt v. Florida, 428 U.S. 242, 255-56 (1976), to hold that the aggravator was "directed at `the conscienceless or pitiless crime which is unnecessarily torturous to the victim.'" State v. Dicks, 615 S.W.2d 126, 132 (1981) (quoting State v. Dixon, 283 So. 2d 1, 9 (Fla. 1973)). The Sixth Circuit recognized that the state court had explicitly reviewed the facts supporting the finding of that aggravator, but it had not specifically applied, or even mentioned, the Dicks decision. Thus, it held, no narrowing interpretation was applied to the unconstitutional instruction, and the state court's decision was therefore an unreasonable application of federal law. Cone, 359 F.3d at 797.

The Supreme Court reversed, holding, "Federal courts are not free to presume that a state court did not comply with constitutional dictates on the basis of nothing more than a lack of citation." Cone, 543 U.S. at 455 (citing Mitchell v. Esparza, 540 U.S. 12, 16 (2003); Early v. Packer, 537 U.S. 3, 8 (2002)). Finding no express refusal to apply its limiting construction, particularly where the Tennessee court had earlier recognized that it was constitutionally compelled and regularly applied it, the Supreme Court presumed that the Tennessee court had applied it to Cone's case. The Court also reviewed the facts in the state court opinion and found them to be similar to facts recited in cases where the limiting construction had been expressly applied. Id. at 456. Reviewing the limiting construction applied by Dicks and other cases from the Tennessee Supreme Court, the Supreme Court held that, even if the statutory aggravating circumstance was facially vague, "[W]e are satisfied that the State's aggravating circumstance, as construed by the Tennessee Supreme Court, ensured that there was a `principled basis' for distinguishing between those cases in which the death penalty was assessed and those cases in which it was not." Cone, 543 U.S. at 459 (citing Arave v. Creech, 507 U.S. 463, 474 (1993)).

Although the Supreme Court has not considered the exact language of Jordan's instruction, its clearly established precedent has generally held that states may present additional language to the jury that defines the heinous, atrocious or cruel aggravating circumstance. Moreover, even if this instruction were facially overbroad, it could be saved by appropriate appellate review by the state court. Cone, 543 U.S. at 456; Proffitt v. Florida, 428 U.S. 242, 255 (1976). The Mississippi Supreme Court routinely reviews this aggravating circumstance to determine whether the facts of each case fit within its guidelines for determining whether the crime was heinous, atrocious or cruel. For example, a murder committed after a kidnaping, sexual assault and a rape also exhibited those qualities and justified the same finding. Woodward v. State, 726 So. 2d 524, 538-39 (Miss. 1997). The seriousness with which the court conducts that review was evidenced by its declaration that the aggravator was improperly found in a case where the victim was strangled, where there was "no evidence of any `additional acts' to set the crime apart from the norm of capital felonies as conscienceless, pitiless or unnecessarily torturous." Taylor v. State, 672 So. 2d 1246, 1276 (Miss. 1996). On the other hand, the evidence was sufficient to support the aggravator where it showed that the victim was kidnaped from her home, forced to "walk to her impending doom on nerve damaged feet, all the while leaving her to ponder how, when, why and in what manner she would be executed," and, once arriving at the "chosen execution site," the defendant "ordered Mrs. Harris to kneel before him. He then stood a couple of feet away, and savagely fired four shots into her fragile body." Underwood v. State, 708 So. 2d 18, 39 (Miss. 1998).

The Mississippi Supreme Court has reviewed the revised instruction on numerous occasions, and it has never suggested that a bare finding of physical or mental pain would mandate a finding of that aggravating circumstance. Instead, the cases indicate that the state court considers the last sentence of that instruction as further refining and limiting the imposition of the death penalty to cases where there was "mental torture" or "barbarity." The state court's intention was made clear in Jenkins v. State, 607 So. 2d 1171, 1181-82 (Miss. 1992), where the court re-affirmed its intention that the aggravating circumstance be applied to only a limited class of murders. There, the court analyzed an instruction similar to Jordan's Instruction 2 and found it to be proper. In specifically addressing the last sentence, the court noted that it was taken from Pinkney v. State, 538 So. 2d 329, 357 (Miss. 1988), vacated on other grounds, 494 U.S. 1075 (1990), where the court "expressed the desire to see that `our capital sentencing juries . . . be more specifically instructed on the meaning of `especially heinous, atrocious or cruel.'" Jenkins, 607 So. 2d at 1181 (quoting Pinkney, 538 So. 2d at 357). In Conner v. State, 632 So. 2d 1239, 1270-71 (Miss. 1993), overruled on other grounds by Weatherspoon v. State, 732 So. 2d 158 (Miss. 1999), the court analyzed the instruction and held that, while the first sentence standing alone was unconstitutionally vague, "The second and third sentences, however, provide additional specificity and detail sufficient to meet the demands of the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution." Id. at 1271; see also Watts v. State, 733 So. 2d 214, 238-39 (Miss. 1999).

Finally, Jordan claims that the instruction was faulty because it was not the complete instruction, patterned after the statute, that had been approved by the Mississippi Supreme Court. King v. State, 784 So. 2d 884, 891 (Miss. 2001). Thus, he argues that the omission of references to mutilation, dismemberment, or a lingering or torturous death "substantially watered down the State's burden and left the jury free to find this aggravating circumstance even in the absence of anything that would set this crime apart from other capital murders." This argument was raised by Jordan in his post-conviction brief, but it was not addressed by the state court.

Jordan is correct in asserting that King recommended use of an instruction it had approved in an earlier case, and that instruction would have included the language omitted at Jordan's trial. Id. at 890-92. However, the court went on to state, "The definition which we have previously established as an acceptable instruction is certainly not the only acceptable instruction." Id. at 891. After remand, the Mississippi Supreme Court revisited King's conviction and sentence, noting that the sentencing instruction that had been used in the second trial still did not quote the approved instruction. King v. State, 960 So. 2d 413, 440-41 (Miss. 2007). Again cautioning courts "from giving different instructions other than the specific one that this Court has directed the court to use," the court found this instruction "conforms to the minimum standard" and further relief was unnecessary. Id. King was the only authority cited in this part of Jordan's argument, If his contention is that the instruction was incomplete under state law, that is not a cognizable habeas claim. Estelle v. McGuire, 502 U.S. 62, 71-72 (1991). The question for this Court on habeas review is "whether the ailing instruction by itself so infected the entire trial that the resulting conviction violates due process." Cupp v. Naughten, 414 U.S. 141, 147 (1973). The language omitted from Jordan's instruction were merely two additional situations that would support a finding that the aggravator existed. All of those situations are listed in the disjunctive:

If you find from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant utilized a method of killing which caused serious mutilation, that there was dismemberment of the body prior to death, that the defendant inflicted physical or mental pain before death, or that a lingering of torturous death was suffered by the victim, then you may find this aggravating circumstance.

It has long been the law that, where a statute is written in the disjunctive to include alternate acts that would amount to guilt, "it is enough to prove either." Crain v. United States, 162 U.S. 625, 624 (1896). Thus, an indictment may re-write such a statute to include all of the acts in the conjunctive, but the conviction will be valid on a showing of any one of them. Griffin v. United States, 502 U.S. 46, 51 (1991) (citing Crain). Here, the problem is with the omission of two acts that would establish an aggravating circumstance. In the context of habeas review, this omission must be shown to have "An omission, or an incomplete instruction, is less likely to be prejudicial than a misstatement of the law." Henderson v. Kibbe, 431 U.S. 145, 155 (1977).

Neither of the omitted acts would have been supported by the evidence, and it was not necessary to prove their existence to support a finding that the murder was especially heinous atrocious or cruel, where there was another act, supported by the evidence, that could sustain the jury's finding. Cf. Schad v. Arizona, 501 U.S. 624, 636 (1991) (holding that, where state provides alternative acts for committing an offense, federal courts "are not at liberty to ignore that determination and conclude that the alternatives are, in fact, independent elements under state law."); see also Richardson v. United States, 526 U.S. 813, 817 (1999) (explaining the difference between an "element" of a crime and an "underlying fact."). Jordan has not shown how he was prejudiced by their omission, so it cannot be said that the omission had a substantial effect on the jury's verdict. In fact, a more persuasive argument could have been made by that the inclusion of these acts would have been prejudicial. Mississippi trial judges are encouraged to tailor jury instructions to the facts of the case. Mackbee v. State, 575 So. 2d 16, 34 (Miss. 1990). Inclusion of terms like "torture" and "dismemberment" that were extraneous to the facts could have had a much worse effect on the jury than their omission had. For these reasons, the Court is of the opinion that Jordan has not shown a constitutional injury here that would justify habeas relief.

Jordan's arguments rely on his belief that an execution style murder could not be heinous, atrocious, or cruel because of its quickness. Clearly, the events that occurred prior to the murder support a finding that Jordan inflicted mental pain before death. The events that occurred after the murder demonstrate that the crime was conscienceless and pitiless and inflicted with indifference to the suffering of others. Even if this Court agreed with Jordan's interpretation, it could not find that the state court's construction unreasonably applied clearly established federal law. Moreover, the instruction in question has been reviewed numerous times in state court, and a review of those cases shows that the Mississippi Supreme Court has applied a limiting construction of it that appropriately narrows the class of persons eligible for the death penalty under this aggravator. For these reasons, the language of the instructions, either singly or in combination, offers no basis for habeas relief. For the same reasons, Jordan's argument that the evidence was insufficient to support the jury's finding on this aggravator is likewise unpersuasive.

Finding no error in the instructions on the heinous, atrocious, or cruel aggravating circumstances, the Court cannot conclude that there was cumulative error that entitles Jordan to relief. Turner v. Quarterman, 481 F.3d 292, 301 (5th Cir. 2007). (Where individual allegations of error do not constitute error, there is nothing to "cumulate.'").

Ground S : Petitioner was denied his right to the effective assistance of counsel guaranteed by the Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments due to trial counsel's failure to raise objections to instructions pertaining to the especially heinous, atrocious or cruel aggravator.

This Court has found that the instructions given on the especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel aggravator were proper. That finding precludes a conclusion that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to object to them. Paredes v. Quarterman, 574 F.3d 281, 291 n. 13 (5th Cir. 2009) (citing United States v. Kimler, 167 F.3d 889, 893 (5th Cir. 1993) ("An attorney's failure to raise a meritless argument . . . cannot form the basis of a successful ineffective assistance of counsel claim because the result of the proceeding would not have been different had the attorney raised the issue.") Ground T : At the penalty phase, Petitioner was denied his rights guaranteed by the Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the federal Constitution due to the trial court's instructions to the jurors that they were not to rely on sympathy; in the alternative, trial counsel were ineffective for not objecting to the trial court's mistaken and prejudicial statements concerning sympathy.

Jordan claims that the trial court erred by giving Instruction No. C-1, in that it informed the jury, "You should not be influenced by bias, sympathy, or prejudice. Your verdict should be based on the evidence and not upon speculation, guesswork or conjecture." Jordan claims that, in preluding the jury from considering sympathy, the trial court violated his Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment rights to a have the use a "reasoned moral response" to determine the appropriate punishment.

Respondents first argue that the issue is barred from review because Jordan did not make a contemporaneous objection to the instruction at trial. The Mississippi Supreme Court agreed in Jordan's opinion on direct appeal; "[n]evertheless, we will address the merits of his claim." 786 So. 2d at 1024. As has been held earlier, this language does not suggest that the state court intends to rule on the merits of the claim, and the opinion provides clear evidence that the court was relying on the separate and independent state law that provides that the failure to make a contemporaneous objection to jury instructions waives the right to argue them on review. The state court's alternative ruling on the merits rejected Jordan's claim, which it noted was an issue earlier resolved in Holland v. State, 705 So. 2d 307, 351 (Miss. 1997). Jordan, 786 So. 2d at 1025. The court continued, "In Holland, we found that such an instruction does not mean that the jury should totally disregard sympathy and is, therefore, permissible." Id.

Jordan's argument heavily relies on the case of Parks v. Brown, 860 F.2d 1545, 1553-55 (10th Cir. 1988), which held that an "anti-sympathy" instruction violated the petitioner's right to individualized consideration of the mitigating circumstances. Citing several Supreme Court cases, the Tenth Circuit determined that sympathy was a mitigating factor entitled to consideration. Id. at 1559. A year later, the same court set aside another death penalty for the same reason, relying on the earlier decision in Parks. Davis v. Maynard, 869 F.2d 1401, 1411-12 (10th Cir. 1989). Shortly thereafter, the Supreme Court reversed Parks, holding that its precedent did not dictate the result reached by the Tenth Circuit. Saffle v. Parks, 494 U.S. 484, 489-90 (1990). Thus, it held, the Tenth Circuit had created a new rule, which would not be applied retroactively to his case. Id. at 487-89, citing Teague v. Lane, 489 U.S. 288, 299-301 (1989). As the Court explained:

The objectives of fairness and accuracy are more likely to be threatened than promoted by a rule allowing the sentence to turn not on whether the defendant, in the eyes of the community, is morally deserving of the death sentence, but on whether the defendant can strike an emotional chord in a juror.
Saffle, 494 U.S. at 495. Shortly after it decided Saffle, the Court also vacated the judgment in Davis and remanded it for further review in light of the Saffle decision. Saffle v. Davis, 494 U.S. 1050 (1990). The Mississippi Supreme Court's decision on this issue is fully in accord with Saffle.

Jordan has asked this Court, if it finds that this issue is barred for lack of a contemporaneous objection, to find that his attorney was ineffective in failing to properly raise it. As it has been established that the claim is meritless, and for the reasons earlier expressed, his attorney was not ineffective for failing to raise it. Jordan cannot receive habeas relief on this issue.

Ground U : Petitioner's rights under the Fifth, Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution were violated when the trial court gave sentencing instruction No. 1; in the alternative, trial counsel was ineffective for not preserving issues relative to this instruction.

Jordan has withdrawn this issue as grounds for relief.

Ground V : The trial court erred by overruling in part Defendant's motion requesting that trial court question the potential jurors about whether (I) they would automatically vote for the death penalty; (ii) their feelings in support of the death penalty would prevent them from considering or substantially impair their ability to consider a life sentence for defendant; and (iii) they deem any of the mitigating factors Defendant intends to prove irrelevant to their sentencing decision.

Jordan complains that the trial court improperly restricted his counsel from adequately questioning potential jurors about whether:

(1) they would automatically vote for the death penalty; (2) their feelings in support of the death penalty would prevent them from considering or substantially impair their ability to consider a life sentence for the defendant; and (3) they deem any of the mitigating factors defendant intended to prove irrelevant to their sentencing decision.

In so doing, Jordan contends, the trial court violated Morgan v. Illinois, 504 U.S. 719, 729 (1992). Respondents maintain that the transcript of the voir dire shows that the trial court permitted all of the questioning that Morgan deemed necessary.

Prior to trial, Jordan filed a motion requesting that the court voir dire the jurors on the three issues listed above. The transcript shows that the judge and trial counsel discussed this motion during a pretrial hearing, in which the judge told the attorneys that he would follow the law as it existed at the time of trial, which would likely permit the first question. The court and counsel conferred on this matter again on the first day of voir dire, after the jury had been dismissed for the night. The judge informed the lawyers as follows, "Mr. Sumrall, the rule is, and, Mr. Owen, that you cannot ask a hypothetical question involving one of the aggravating, mitigating factors." He went on to note that the prohibition did not include "their philosophical views on the death penalty or life imprisonment. I'm saying on specific mitigating, mitigating factors that y'all anticipate that are going to be coming up." Defense counsel responded, "I don't plan to. No, sir."

Jordan argues that the trial court violated his constitutional rights by failing to permit defense counsel to voir dire the jury on the second and third issues in his motion. Specifically, he contends that Morgan v. Illinois, 504 U.S. 719, 728-29 (1992), mandates that he be allowed to ask those questions. Respondents counter that Morgan is not as far-reaching as Jordan claims and that its dictates were followed in this matter. The Mississippi Supreme Court considered this issue on direct appeal and held:

Jordan can show no prejudice from the trial judge's refusal to follow Jordan's proposed voir dire questions. He merely reworded the Witt [ Witt v. Wainwright, 470 U.S. 1039 (1985)] question to follow the ruling in that case. As to the question whether the jury members would believe that his mitigating evidence was irrelevant, defense counsel may not use hypothetical questions to secure a commitment from the jurors concerning the verdict they will render. Evans v. State, 725 So. 2d at 650. Here, the trial judge cautioned defense counsel concerning Evans, but told defense counsel that he would not prohibit the asking of philosophical questions concerning their beliefs on the death penalty or life imprisonment. The trial judge's instructions and questions were within the confines of our precedent, and it cannot be said that he abused his discretion or prevented Jordan's counsel from fully inquiring into the potential jurors beliefs concerning the death penalty.
786 So. 2d at 1023.

In Morgan, all of the jurors were asked, "Would you automatically vote against the death penalty no matter what the facts of the case were." 504 U.S. at 723. However, the trial court refused to permit defense counsel to ask jurors, "If you found Derrick Morgan guilty, would you automatically vote to impose the death penalty no matter what the facts are?" The trial court's refusal was based on the belief that the substance of the question had already been asked. Id. Later, the jurors were asked whether they could be fair and impartial and whether they could follow the court's instructions.

The Supreme Court held that it was error not to permit the questioning sought by the defendant, holding that its prior cases established "that a juror who in no case would vote for capital punishment, regardless of his or her instructions, is not an impartial juror and must be removed for cause." Id. at 728. Conversely, "[a] juror who will automatically vote for the death penalty in every case will fail in good faith to consider the evidence of aggravating and mitigating circumstances as the instructions require him to do." Id. Such a juror is likewise not fair and impartial and should be removed. The fact that the jurors had responded affirmatively to questions about their fairness made no difference. Id. at 730-35. The Court went on to note, "Any juror to whom mitigating factors are likewise irrelevant should be disqualified for cause, for that juror has formed an opinion concerning the merits of the case without basis in the evidence developed at trial." Id. at 739.

The Fifth Circuit has held, " Morgan only `involves the narrow question of whether, in a capital case, jurors must be asked whether they would automatically impose the death penalty upon conviction of the defendant." Trevino v. Johnson, 168 F.3d 173, 183 (5th Cir. 1999) (quoting United States v. Greer, 968 F.2d 433, 437 n. 7 (5th Cir. 1992)). Thus, Morgan should not be extended to require habeas review of a claim that a defendant was prohibited to ask whether jurors would consider specific mitigating factors, such as, in Trevino's case, youth. Id. The Fifth Circuit has demonstrated no intent to change that position. See Crawford v. Epps, 353 F. App'x. 977, 985 (5th Cir. 2009).

The United States Supreme Court has not directly ruled that a defendant should be permitted to ask jurors whether their feelings about the death penalty would prevent or substantially impair the consideration of a life sentence or whether they deemed Jordan's mitigation factors to be irrelevant. Morgan does not extend to those issues. Fifth Circuit precedent does not construe any other Supreme Court cases as necessarily applicable to that issue. There being no clearly established federal law on this subject, the Mississippi Supreme Court's decision cannot have offended § 2254, and Jordan cannot obtain habeas relief on this issue.

Ground W : Petitioner is entitled to habeas corpus relief due to the cumulative effect of the errors at his resentencing trial.

This claim was raised on direct appeal, where it was denied by the Mississippi Supreme Court, which held, "Since we did not find reversible error in any of Jordan's issues, this claim is without merit." 786 So. 2d at 987. The claim was raised again in Jordan's post-conviction petition, where the court discussed the claim at greater length:

Where there are no individual errors, there can be no cumulative error. Foster v. State, 639 So. 2d 1263, 1303 (Miss. 1994). This Court has previously recognized that "[w]here there is no reversible error in any part, . . . . there is no reversible error to the whole." Doss v. State, 709 So. 2d 369, 401 (Miss. 1996) (quoting McFee v. State, 511 So. 2d 130, 136 (Miss. 1987)). This Court has further noted, "A criminal defendant is not entitled to a perfect trial, only a fair trial." McGilberry v. State, 741 So. 2d 894, 924 (Miss. 1999), citing Sand v. State, 467 So. 2d 907, 911 (Miss. 1985). The record indicates that Jordan received a fair trial. This issue is without merit.
912 So. 2d at 823.

Jordan cannot show that these decisions were contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly establish federal law set forth by the United States Supreme Court. There is no Supreme Court case on this issue, although the Court has been called upon in other cases to set a standard for cumulative error review. The Fifth Circuit in Derden v. McNeel, 978 F.2d 1453 (5th Cir. 1992) (en banc), cert. denied, 508 U.S. 960 (1993), adopted a rigorous standard for cumulative error analysis: "[W]e now hold that federal habeas corpus relief may only be granted for cumulative errors in the conduct of a state trial where (1) the individual errors involved matters of constitutional dimension rather than mere violations of state law; (2) the errors were not procedurally defaulted for habeas purposes; and (3) the errors "so infected the entire trial that the resulting conviction violates due process." 978 F.2d at 1456 (quoting Cupp v. Naughten, 414 U.S. 141, 147 (1973)). Derden continues to be followed in the Fifth Circuit. See, e.g., Turner v. Quarterman, 481 F.3d 292, 301 (5th Cir. 2007). (Repeating the language from Derden quoted above and stating, "As is apparent from this standard and as this court has stated explicitly, where individual allegations of error are not of constitutional stature or are not errors, there is `nothing to cumulate.'"). Because this Court has found no error of constitutional dimension in this matter, there is nothing for Jordan to "cumulate." Therefore, he is not entitled to habeas relief on grounds of cumulative error.

CONCLUSION

Having reviewed each of Jordan's claims for habeas corpus relief under the deferential standard of review required by 28 U.S.C. § 2254(d), it appears that none possesses sufficient merit to warrant issuance of the writ. The Court finds no part of the Mississippi Supreme Court's opinions to be contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law or an unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the evidence presented. It is the Court's opinion that Richard Jordan is not entitled to habeas corpus relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2254.

IT IS, THEREFORE, ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Richard Jordan's Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2254 is hereby DENIED. IT IS, FURTHER, ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that this action is hereby dismissed with prejudice. A separate final judgment dismissing this action with prejudice shall be entered in accordance with FED. R. CIV. P. 58.