- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
U.S. v. HOWARD
Upon consideration of the record and the Disciplinary Board's Report and Recommendation for the Reinstatement of Thomas R. LePage to the Practice of Law, it appears Petitioner LePage has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, rehabilitation, fitness to practice law, competence, compliance with applicable disciplinary orders and rules, and compliance with all requirements imposed by this court, as required by Rule 2.17(b) of the Rules of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawai'i. Therefore,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Petitioner LePage is reinstated to the practice of law in this jurisdiction.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that upon payment of all required dues and registration fees, the Clerk shall restore Petitioner LePage to the roll of attorneys eligible to practice in the State of Hawai'i.
IT IS FINALLY ORDERED that the restraining order entered by this court on November 5, 2001 is vacated.
ontainer
The court stated to counsel prior to argument on the motion that it did not read the portion of the motion regarding the details of the plea deal because if the defendant were convicted of noncapital crimes it would be the sentencing court.
The court addressed the motion prior to the start of evidence. The court observed that the defendant was "looking a little surprised that . . . somebody thinks he's not competent." The court further observed that the defendant looked "as always, intelligent and competent to me, but I'm not an expert." The court thereafter canvassed the defendant as follows:
"The Court: Do you understand what we're doing here today?
"[The Defendant]: My understanding is that he want me to plead —
"The Court: Yes, but don't tell me the deal.
"[The Defendant]: Okay.
"The Court: And you don't want to plead.
"[The Defendant]: No.
"The Court: Okay. Do you understand that the state has the burden of proof to prove guilt, if it can, by evidence beyond a reasonable doubt?
"[The Defendant]: Yes.
"The Court: And you want your trial.
"[The Defendant]: Yes.
"The Court: Okay. Do you have a sense as to what it is that my job is?
"[The Defendant]: Yeah.
"The Court: What is it?
"[The Defendant]: Your job is, you the judge, so —
"The Court: I know, but say a little more.
"[The Defendant]: Well, you the one to oversee what's going on here in this court —
"The Court: Okay.
"[The Defendant]: — do I get a fair trial.
"The Court: Very good. Okay. The motion for an order to evaluate the defendant's competence is denied."
When asked if he had anything further to say, defense counsel noted that the court's inquiry did not address the reasons why defense counsel believed that the defendant was not competent. Defense counsel argued that the defendant believes in God and believes that he could not have committed the crimes because he loves his daughters. Further, he argued that the defendant believes that divine intervention can occur at trial so as to produce evidence of his innocence. Defense counsel noted that in his opinion, the defendant's belief in divine intervention was a "delusion. . . ."
The court noted that the test for competency is whether the accused is able to understand the nature of the proceedings against him, participate meaningfully in his own defense and cooperate with counsel. The court stated: "I've ordered a lot of competency evaluations, and I've talked to a lot of people whose competency was clearly questionable, but [the defendant] is not one of those people." The court reiterated that the motion was denied.
"As a matter of constitutional law, it is undisputed that the guilty plea and subsequent conviction of an accused person who is not legally competent to stand trial violates the due process of law guaranteed by the state and federal constitutions. . . . This constitutional mandate is codified in our state law by [General Statutes] § 54-56d (a), which provides that [a] defendant shall not be tried, convicted or sentenced while he is not competent. For the purposes of this section, a defendant is not competent if he is unable to understand the proceedings against him or to assist in his own defense. . . . General Statutes § 54-56d (b), however, posits a presumption in favor of a defendant's competence." (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Monk, 88 Conn. App. 543, 548, 869 A.2d 1281 (2005). Every criminal defendant is presumed to be competent. General Statutes § 54-56d (b). During the course of the criminal proceedings, however, if it appears that the defendant is not competent, either party or the court may request an examination to determine the defendant's competency. General Statutes § 54-56d (c).
"The provisions of § 54-56d state that if it appears that the defendant is not competent, and if the trial court finds that a request for a competency evaluation is justified, the court must order a competency examination. We have interpreted this standard as requiring a competency evaluation any time a reasonable doubt is raised regarding the defendant's competency. . . . To establish such reasonable doubt, the defendant must present substantial evidence, not merely allegations, that he is incompetent. . . . Substantial evidence is a term of art. Evidence encompasses all information properly before the court, whether it is in the form of testimony or exhibits formally admitted or it is in the form of medical reports or other kinds of reports that have been filed with the court. Evidence is substantial if it raises a reasonable doubt about the defendant's competency. . . ." (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Ross, 269 Conn. 213, 272, 849 A.2d 648 (2004).
We review the court's ruling on a motion for a competency evaluation under the abuse of discretion standard. State v. Collazo, 113 Conn. App. 651, 662, 967 A.2d 597, cert. denied, 293 Conn. 904, 976 A.2d 705 (2009). "In determining whether the trial court [has] abused its discretion, this court must make every reasonable presumption in favor of [the correctness of] its action. . . . Our review of a trial court's exercise of the legal discretion vested in it is limited to the questions of whether the trial court correctly applied the law and could reasonably have reached the conclusion that it did." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Williams, 65 Conn. App. 59, 84, 782 A.2d 149, cert. denied, 258 Conn. 923, 782 A.2d 1251 (2001).
The court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant's motion for a competency evaluation because it was reasonable for it to have concluded that the defendant had failed to raise a reasonable doubt about his competency. After defense counsel brought his § 54-56d motion, the court canvassed the defendant about his understanding of the proceedings against him and his understanding of the plea bargain. The canvass revealed that the defendant understood that defense counsel wanted him to plead guilty but that the defendant wanted a jury trial. It also revealed that he understood that the state had the burden of proving his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The court was not required to conduct a more extensive colloquy. The canvass supported a finding of competency. "Connecticut appellate courts have repeatedly held that a trial court may not be required to order a competency examination when the defendant's canvass supports a finding of competency. " State v. Silva, 65 Conn. App. 234, 249, 783 A.2d 7, cert. denied, 258 Conn. 929, 783 A.2d 1031 (2001).
The defendant's decision to proceed to trial, despite defense counsel's belief that to do so was not in the defendant's best interest, is not evidence of incompetence. See Jarrett v. Commissioner of Correction, 108 Conn. App. 59, 73, 947 A.2d 395 ("courts may not construe a defendant's decision to proceed to trial as evidence of incompetence merely because others conclude the decision is not in the defendant's best interest"), cert. denied, 288 Conn. 910, 953 A.2d 653 (2008).
To the extent that the defendant also is claiming that the court should have conducted an evidentiary hearing, his claim fails because he did not present substantial evidence of mental impairment. "[T]he rule of Pate v. Robinson [ 383 U.S. 375, 86 S. Ct. 836, 15 L. Ed. 2d 815 (1966)] imposes a constitutional obligation, under the due process clause, to undertake an independent judicial inquiry, in appropriate circumstances, into a defendant's competency to stand trial. . . . When a Pate inquiry is required, a court may not rely on the defendant's subjective appraisal of his own capacity or on the court's personal observations of the defendant but must hold an evidentiary hearing into the defendant's competence. . . . Competence to stand trial is a legal question, which must ultimately be determined by the trial court. . . . The decision to grant [an evidentiary] hearing [into a defendant's competence] requires the exercise of sound judicial discretion." (Citation omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Cuesta, 68 Conn. App. 470, 481-82, 791 A.2d 686, cert. denied, 260 Conn. 914, 796 A.2d 559 (2002). "The trial court should carefully weigh the need for a hearing in each case, but this is not to say that a hearing should be available on demand. The decision whether to grant a hearing requires the exercise of sound judicial discretion." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Johnson, 253 Conn. 1, 22, 751 A.2d 298 (2000).
The defendant argues, however, that the court's canvass failed to address the defendant's firmly held "delusion" that divine intervention would occur during trial and that it would come to light that he was innocent. He contends that the court should have ordered a competency evaluation because the defendant's "delusion" raised a reasonable doubt regarding his competency. Following the canvass, defense counsel discussed with the court the issue that the defendant believed that divine intervention would occur during trial. The court noted that it was defense counsel's "opinion" that the defendant's belief in divine intervention was a "delusion. . . ." The court further noted that it has ordered many competency evaluations and "talked to a lot of people whose competency was clearly questionable, but [the defendant] is not one of those people." The court apparently determined that the defendant's belief in divine intervention did not create a reasonable doubt as to the defendant's competency. In this case, such a determination cannot be said to be an abuse of discretion. See Higgenbottom v. United States, 923 A.2d 891, 897 n. 4 (D.C. 2007) (defendant's belief in divine intervention consistent with that of many competent persons).
The record shows only that the defendant's attorney urged that the defendant hoped for or was expecting "divine intervention." Even if we were to agree, in this secular age, that divine intervention was not a realistic prospect, the functional difference between a hope for divine intervention in itself and a hope for an improbable result is minimal. A defendant may hope for a favorable verdict contrary to a mass of evidence and not be incompetent solely by virtue of the hope. Competent people can make choices that turn out to be poor.
The defendant draws attention to the fact that approximately two weeks prior to his making the motion, the court was made aware of his mental health history. On December 19, 2006, the court and counsel engaged in a discussion regarding one of the defendant's proposed mitigating factors: "an underlying mental health condition that cannot be diagnosed at this time." During this discussion, defense counsel noted that the defendant had been seen by mental health professionals within the department of correction. The defendant did not raise this issue when arguing his motion for a competency hearing or offer any additional insight into any underlying mental health condition. Even if true, the fact that the defendant had seen mental health professionals but has not been diagnosed does not necessarily raise a reasonable doubt as to the defendant's competency. See State v. Ross, supra, 269 Conn. 272 (to establish reasonable doubt defendant must present substantial evidence, not merely allegations of incompetence). Indeed, the suggestion that the defendant had seen a mental health professional and the concomitant failure to produce evidence from the professional do not raise a reasonable doubt regarding competence to stand trial. The defendant has not met his burden of showing that, at the time of the denial of his motion for a competency examination, the court had before it specific factual allegations that, if true, would constitute substantial evidence of mental impairment. See State v. Johnson, 22 Conn. App. 477, 488, 578 A.2d 1085 (discussing defendant's burden), cert. denied, 216 Conn. 817, 580 A.2d 63 (1990). The record reveals no abuse of the court's discretion.
III
The defendant next claims that the court improperly denied his claim that the state, during jury selection, exercised two peremptory challenges in a racially discriminatory manner. He argues that the court improperly permitted the state to exercise two of its peremptory challenges to remove two African-American venirepersons, G.C. and B.D., from the jury, thereby depriving him of a fair trial in violation of Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712, 90 L. Ed. 2d 69 (1986). We are not persuaded.
References to venirepersons will be made by use of initials to protect their legitimate privacy interests. See, e.g., State v. Wright, 86 Conn. App. 86, 88 n. 3, 860 A.2d 278 (2004).
We begin by setting forth the relevant legal principles and the standard of review. "In Batson [v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712, 90 L. Ed. 2d 69 (1986)] the United States Supreme Court recognized that a claim of purposeful racial discrimination on the part of the prosecution in selecting a jury raises constitutional questions of the utmost seriousness, not only for the integrity of a particular trial but also for the perceived fairness of the judicial system as a whole. . . . The court concluded that [a]lthough a prosecutor ordinarily is entitled to exercise permitted peremptory challenges for any reason at all, as long as that reason is related to his [or her] view concerning the outcome of the case to be tried . . . the Equal Protection Clause forbids the prosecutor to challenge potential jurors solely on account of their race. . . .
"Under Connecticut law, [o]nce a [party] asserts a Batson claim, the [opposing party] must advance a neutral explanation for the venireperson's removal. . . . The [party asserting the Batson claim] is then afforded the opportunity to demonstrate that the [opposing party's] articulated reasons are insufficient or pretextual. . . . [T]he trial court then [has] the duty to determine if the [party asserting the Batson claim] has established purposeful discrimination. . . . The [party asserting the Batson claim] carries the ultimate burden of persuading the trial court, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the jury selection process in his or her particular case was tainted by purposeful discrimination. . . .
"We have identified several specific factors that may indicate that [a party's removal] of a venireperson through a peremptory challenge was . . . motivated [by race or gender]. These include, but are not limited to: (1) [t]he reasons given for the challenge were not related to the trial of the case . . . (2) the [party exercising the peremptory strike] failed to question the challenged juror or only questioned him or her in a perfunctory manner . . . (3) prospective jurors of one race [or gender] were asked a question to elicit a particular response that was not asked of the other jurors . . . (4) persons with the same or similar characteristics but not the same race [or gender] as the challenged juror were not struck . . . (5) the [party exercising the peremptory strike] advanced an explanation based on a group bias where the group trait is not shown to apply to the challenged juror specifically . . . and (6) the [party exercising the peremptory strike] used a disproportionate number of peremptory challenges to exclude members of one race [or gender]. . . .
"In assessing the reasons proffered in support of the use of a peremptory challenge . . . [a]n explanation . . . need not . . . be pigeon-holed as wholly acceptable or wholly unacceptable . . . and even where the acceptability of a particular explanation is doubtful, the inquiry is not at an end. In deciding the ultimate issue of discriminatory intent, the judicial officer is entitled to assess each explanation in light of all the other evidence relevant to prosecutorial intent. . . . As with most inquiries into state of mind, the ultimate determination depends on an aggregate assessment of all the circumstances. . . .
"Finally, the trial court's decision on the question of discriminatory intent represents a finding of fact that will necessarily turn on the court's evaluation of the demeanor and credibility of the attorney of the party exercising the peremptory challenge. . . . Accordingly, a trial court's determination that there has or has not been intentional discrimination is afforded great deference and will not be disturbed unless it is clearly erroneous. . . . A finding of fact is clearly erroneous when there is no evidence in the record to support it . . . or when although there is evidence to support it, the reviewing court on the entire evidence is left with the definite and firm conviction that a mistake has been committed." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Holloway, 116 Conn. App. 818, 822-24, 977 A.2d 750, cert. denied, 294 Conn. 902, 982 A.2d 646 (2009).
A
During voir dire, B.D. revealed that she had a bachelor's degree in chemistry, lived with her mother and had worked at a CVS pharmacy for approximately seven years. She also stated that her boyfriend recently had been arrested and was in jail for possessing a revolver, which crime she believed he did not commit. She further revealed that her cousin was murdered in North Carolina when he was seventeen. The murderer was never found.
The state exercised a peremptory challenge excusing B.D. The defendant objected. The court recognized that B.D. had indicated on her questionnaire that she was African-American. The state then gave the following reasons in support of its use of a peremptory challenge as to B.D.: she was only twenty-three years of age and demonstrated an extreme lack of maturity; her boyfriend had a pending criminal charge against him involving the use of a weapon; and, the state added, the murder of her cousin in North Carolina remained unsolved. Defense counsel argued that despite her age, B.D. had worked for the past seven years and had substantial career plans, and that although the issue with B.D.'s boyfriend could have formed a neutral reason for the state to excuse her, B.D. believed that she could keep that factor separate from the case. The court found the state's reasons for its peremptory challenge to be race neutral. The court noted that the difference in the maturity level of B.D. as compared to similarly aged jurors was "startling."
We conclude that the court's rejection of the defendant's Batson challenge was not clearly erroneous. One of the reasons given by the state was lack of maturity. B.D. was twenty-three years old. Despite being a college graduate, she had worked at only one place and lived at home with her mother. Lack of maturity is a race neutral reason. State v. McDougal, 241 Conn. 502, 512-20, 699 A.2d 872 (1997) (peremptory challenges based on youth permissible); see also State v. Hodge, 248 Conn. 207, 257, 726 A.2d 531, cert. denied, 528 U.S. 969, 120 S. Ct. 409, 145 L. Ed. 2d 319 (1999). A second reason given by the state was that B.D.'s boyfriend had a pending criminal case against him, which involved possession of a weapon. B.D. believed her boyfriend to be innocent. "Courts consistently have upheld the use of peremptory challenges to excuse a venireperson with a close relative who has been prosecuted because of the real possibility that the venireperson may harbor resentment against prosecuting authorities generally." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Jackson, 95 Conn. App. 400, 410, 896 A.2d 137, cert. denied, 279 Conn. 904, 901 A.2d 1226 (2006). Another reason given by the state was the unsolved murder of B.D.'s cousin. This was a race neutral ground for excusing her. "Prosecutors commonly seek to exclude from juries all individuals, whatever their race, who have had negative encounters with the police because they fear that such people will be biased against the government." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Kalican, 110 Conn. App. 743, 759, 955 A.2d 1261, cert. denied, 289 Conn. 949, 960 A.2d 1038 (2008). These reasons individually and collectively support the state's peremptory challenge of B.D.
In further support of his claim that the state discriminated against B.D. because of her race, the defendant argues that persons with similar characteristics but not the same race as B.D. were not struck. In response, the state argues, citing State v. Hodge, supra, 248 Conn. 207, that the defendant's argument fails because the failure "to strike a white juror who shares some traits with a struck black juror does not itself automatically prove the existence of discrimination." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) Id., 237. In his reply brief, the defendant argues that the state's reliance on this holding in Hodge is misplaced because the recent United States Supreme Court case of Snyder v. Louisiana, 552 U.S. 472, 128 S. Ct. 1203, 170 L. Ed. 2d 175 (2008), overrules cases such as State v. Hodge, supra, 207.
The defendant also relies on Miller-El v. Dretke, 545 U.S. 231, 125 S. Ct. 2317, 162 L. Ed. 2d 196 (2005) (prosecutor's race neutral reasons for strikes pretextual where reasons at odds with evidence, prosecutor struck ten of eleven qualified black venire members and selection process replete with evidence that prosecutor rejected jurors on the basis of race), and Johnson v. California, 545 U.S. 162, 125 S. Ct. 2410, 162 L. Ed. 2d 129 (2005) (holding California's "more likely than not" standard inappropriate as to Batson's first prong to measure sufficiency of prima facie case of purposeful discrimination), to support his claim. Neither of these cases changes our analysis in this case.
In Snyder, the court held that the prosecutor's proffered explanation for striking the venireperson at issue — scheduling conflicts — was suspicious because serving on a jury would not have interfered seriously with the venireperson's other obligations and was implausible because the prosecutor accepted white jurors who disclosed conflicting obligations that appeared to have been at least as serious as those of the venireperson at issue. Snyder v. Louisiana, supra, 552 U.S. 479-86. The court stated that "[t]he prosecution's proffer of this pretextual explanation naturally gives rise to an inference of discriminatory intent." Id., 485. The court further noted that in light of the fact that the trial judge made no findings regarding the prosecutor's other proffered explanation — the venireperson's nervousness — the record did not show that the prosecution would have preemptively challenged the venireperson at issue based on his nervousness alone. Id. This case is not at odds with our Supreme Court's holding in State v. Hodge, supra, 248 Conn. 237, that the failure "to strike a white juror who shares some traits with a struck black juror does not itself automatically prove the existence of discrimination." (Internal quotation marks omitted.)
In Snyder, the Supreme Court made comparisons between one of the stricken minority venirepersons and several nonminority venirepersons who were accepted and concluded that based on the comparison, the state's race neutral reason was pretextual. The prosecutor offered two race neutral reasons for using a peremptory challenge on venireperson Brooks, a college senior who was attempting to fulfill his student-teaching obligation, in response to defense counsel's Batson challenge. Snyder v. Louisiana, supra, 552 U.S. 477-78. Because of a lack of factual findings by the trial court regarding the state's first explanation, nervousness, the court focused on the state's second explanation. Id., 479. The second proffered explanation was that Brooks, as a student teacher, might be inclined to come back with a lesser verdict so as to avoid a penalty phase and thus return home quickly. Id., 478. When Brooks' schedule conflict became apparent during voir dire, the court instructed a law clerk to telephone a dean of the university Brooks was attending. Id., 481. The telephone call revealed that the dean would work with Brooks and did not foresee a problem so long as it was just for that week. Id. Because the prosecutor anticipated, during voir dire, that the trial would be brief and thus serving on a jury would not have seriously interfered with Brooks' student teaching obligation, the United States Supreme Court noted that the proffered explanation was suspicious. Id., 482-83. The court noted that the "implausibility of [the prosecutor's second] explanation is reinforced by the prosecutor's acceptance of white jurors who disclosed conflicting obligations that appear to have been at least as serious as . . . Brooks'." Id., 483. The court stated that "[t]he prosecution's proffer of this pretextual explanation naturally gives rise to an inference of discriminatory intent." Id., 485. The court reversed on this basis. Id., 485-86.
In the present case, the defendant argues that the state's discriminatory intent is demonstrated by the fact that the state had accepted venireperson C.R., a non-black juror, despite her having been arrested. C.R. indicated that it was a misdemeanor offense for which she received accelerated rehabilitation. C.R.'s offense was not of a serious nature, but the offense involving B.D.'s boyfriend involved a weapons charge, of which B.D. believed that her boyfriend was innocent. In light of the fact that the defendant was charged with three fatal shootings, it would be reasonable for the prosecutor to have been concerned that the charges against B.D.'s boyfriend could affect her ability to be a fair and impartial juror. The defendant also argues that the state's contention that B.D. lacked maturity is pretextual because the state accepted as jurors J.B. and E.G., who were twenty-six and twenty-three years old, respectively. The court compared B.D.'s maturity level with the twenty-six and twenty-three year old jurors and noted that the difference in maturity level was "startling."
Accordingly, we conclude that the court's rejection of the defendant's Batson challenge was not clearly erroneous. "[T]he fact-bound determination concerning the propriety of the use of peremptory challenges is a matter that necessarily must be entrusted to the sound judgment of the trial court, which, unlike an appellate court, can observe the attorney and the venireperson and assess the attorney's proffered reasons in light of all the relevant circumstances." State v. Hodge, supra, 248 Conn. 261. Here, the court determined that the reasons offered by the prosecutor for striking B.D. were race neutral. We conclude that the court properly determined that the state had not exercised its peremptory challenge in a racially discriminatory manner.
B
During the state's questioning of G.C. on voir dire, G.C. revealed that he had worked with the department of correction (department) for approximately twelve years as a correction officer and had worked with death row inmates. He declined to discuss why he left the department, citing a nondisclosure agreement. G.C. also revealed that his niece and three of his brothers have been incarcerated. The state twice asked G.C. if he would be able to follow the court's instructions even if he were to disagree with them. Both times, G.C. answered that he "would have to go with [his] feelings." When the state asked if he would hold the state to a burden of proof that is higher than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard because this is a capital felony case, G.C. responded affirmatively. In both instances, the court rehabilitated G.C.
Following defense counsel's questioning of G.C., the state exercised a peremptory challenge to remove G.C. Defense counsel raised a Batson challenge. The state then articulated, inter alia, the following reasons in support of its peremptory challenge: G.C. was a correction officer who had worked with death row inmates but was not permitted to discuss why he left because of a nondisclosure agreement; three of G.C.'s brothers and his niece had been incarcerated; and G.C., prior to rehabilitation, indicated that he would not necessarily follow the court's instructions and that he would hold the state to a higher burden of proof than legally required. In response, defense counsel argued that the state spent more time questioning G.C. about his personal life experiences than it had with other jurors it had accepted and that G.C.'s responses were reasonable.
The court found that the state's reasons for exercising the peremptory challenge were "completely race neutral." The court noted that the reason for the length of the state's voir dire of G.C. was due to the court's rehabilitating him and G.C.'s "voluminous answers." The court observed that the state's questions were the same as it had used for other venirepersons. The court further noted that G.C.'s nondisclosure agreement with the department of correction was "remarkable." The court summarized that G.C. was a correctional officer who left after twelve years with a nondisclosure agreement regarding the reasons for the departure, has three siblings and a niece incarcerated and initially gave troublesome answers to questions regarding the burden of proof and following the court's instructions. The court concluded that "[a]ll of those reasons are race neutral . . . and I find that . . . there is no racial motive to the challenge that has been exercised."
We conclude that the court's rejection of the defendant's Batson challenge was not clearly erroneous. G.C. had worked for the department for twelve years and had worked with death row inmates during that time. Due to a nondisclosure agreement, which the court found "remarkable," G.C. refused to reveal any details regarding his work as a correctional officer or his reasons for leaving. This reason alone was a constitutionally acceptable ground for his excusal. "[P]eremptory challenges based on employment reasons have been upheld." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Collazo, 115 Conn. App. 752, 764, 974 A.2d 729 (2009), cert. denied, 294 Conn. 929, 986 A.2d 1057 (2010). Additionally, the state reasoned that G.C. had three brothers and a niece who had been incarcerated. "[C]ourts consistently have upheld the use of peremptory challenges to excuse a venireperson with a close relative who has been prosecuted because of the real possibility that the venireperson may harbor resentment against the prosecuting authorities generally." (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Kalican, supra, 110 Conn. App. 759. Last, when the state asked if he would follow the court's instructions even if he disagreed with them, G.C. indicated that he "would have to go with [his] feelings." He also indicated that he would hold the state to a higher burden of proof because this was a capital felony case and would require absolute certainty. Although the court rehabilitated G.C. on both issues, "a prosecutor is not bound to accept the venireperson's reassurances but, rather, is entitled to rely on his or her own experience, judgment and intuition in such matters. . . . [E]quivocation with respect to holding the state to a higher burden of proof than proof beyond a reasonable doubt . . . [is a] valid, nondiscriminatory [reason] for excusing [the venireperson]." (Citation omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Acosta, 119 Conn. App. 174, 186, 988 A.2d 305, cert. denied, 295 Conn. 923, 991 A.2d 568 (2010).
The defendant further argues that the state's discriminatory intent is demonstrated by the fact that the state has accepted venirepersons who had former or pending charges against themselves or relatives. As to the latter, the fact that the state accepted other venirepersons who were not black and who shared a similar trait with G.C., does not automatically prove the existence of discrimination. See State v. Hodge, supra, 248 Conn. 237 (failure to strike white juror who shares some traits with struck black juror does not automatically prove existence of discrimination). Furthermore, the state also accepted an alternate venireperson, who in the opinion of the court was African-American, who had been arrested for breach of the peace and who had a brother who had been arrested for rape. This undercuts the defendant's claim of purposeful discrimination. See id., 260.
The defendant also argues that state's discriminatory intent is demonstrated by the fact that the state accepted at least two venirepersons who had connections to the department: one whose husband and son had worked for the department and another whose husband worked for the department. G.C. was unique in that despite having worked for the department for twelve years and having worked with death row inmates, he was unable to reveal any details regarding his work as a correctional officer or his reasons for leaving due to a nondisclosure agreement. The court noted that such an agreement was "remarkable."
We conclude that the court's rejection of the defendant's Batson claim with respect to G.C. was not clearly erroneous.
IVThe defendant next claims that the court erred in admitting into evidence certain hearsay statements of a deceased person under the spontaneous utterance exception to the hearsay rule. We disagree.
Anglin testified during direct examination by the state that Adam Alston, her maternal grandfather, was "banging" on her door in the early morning hours of December 13, 2003. She observed that Adam Alston was wearing a thermal undershirt, unzipped pants and no shoes, despite the cold weather. She further observed that he "was shaking . . . crying [and] seemed very upset, in shock. He wasn't himself." When the state asked Anglin what Adam Alston then said to her, defense counsel objected, and the jury was excused. Anglin noted, when asked by the court, that Adam Alston had repeated the phrase: "Oh, Lord, oh, Lord, Michael done shot Mona and the kids and caught them on fire." Adam Alston died prior to trial. The state sought to introduce the statements Adam Alston had made shortly after the homicides under the spontaneous utterance exception to the hearsay rule. Defense counsel argued that the spontaneous utterance exception did not apply because the state had failed to establish that Adam Alston had an opportunity to observe anything other than the aftermath of what had occurred. The state noted that Adam Alston had told Anglin that he had seen one of his granddaughters crawling on the floor and then saw the defendant light her on fire and shoot her and that he had to step over his granddaughter's burning body to come down the stairs. The court overruled the defendant's objection and concluded that it was a reasonable inference that Adam Alston had witnessed what he had reported.
Anglin thereafter testified that when Adam Alston arrived at her door, he stated: "Oh, Lord, oh, Lord, Michael done shot Mona and the kids and caught them on fire." She additionally testified that Adam Alston said that he had heard several popping sounds, saw one of his granddaughters crawling on the floor and saw the defendant set her on fire and shoot her. According to Anglin, Adam Alston said that to exit Ramona's apartment and get help, he had to climb over the burning body of one of his granddaughters.
"The excited utterance exception is well established. Hearsay statements, otherwise inadmissible, may be admitted into evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted therein when (1) the declaration follows a startling occurrence, (2) the declaration refers to that occurrence, (3) the declarant observed the occurrence, and (4) the declaration is made under circumstances that negate the opportunity for deliberation and fabrication by the declarant. . . . Whether an utterance is spontaneous and made under circumstances that would preclude contrivance and misrepresentation is a preliminary question of fact to be decided by the trial judge. . . . The trial court has broad discretion in making that factual determination, which will not be disturbed on appeal absent an unreasonable exercise of discretion." (Citation omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Davis, 109 Conn. App. 187, 193, 951 A.2d 31, cert. denied, 289 Conn. 929, 958 A.2d 160 (2008); see also Conn. Code Evid. § 8-3 (2). "[T]he state is not required to establish such personal observation by the declarant beyond any possible doubt. Rather, the question for the trial court is whether a reasonable inference may be drawn that the declarant had personal knowledge of the facts that are the subject of his or her statement. . . . Consequently, [d]irect proof of observation is not necessary; if the circumstances appear consistent with opportunity [to observe] by the declarant, the requirement is met." (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Wargo, 255 Conn. 113, 128-29, 763 A.2d 1 (2000).
The defendant challenges the third requirement and argues that the state failed to establish that Adam Alston had the opportunity to observe the occurrence. He further argues that Adam Alston's statement to the police suggested that he had not seen the defendant shoot the victims or ignite their bodies but, rather, that he left without seeing the shootings. He further notes that the medical examiner, who conducted an autopsy on the victim found in the hallway, Alexis Kendall, testified that because the victim had no soot or carbon monoxide in her lungs, the best explanation would be that the victim died before the fire was set or very rapidly afterward.
Adam Alston's statement to the police, which was admitted as a full exhibit at trial states in part: "On [December 12, 2003], I went to bed about eight p.m. At this time, Ramona [Kendall], [the defendant], Kayla [Kendall], and Alexis [Kendall] were all home. Between four a.m. and five am., I woke up and went to the bathroom. I returned to my room and closed the door. I then heard loud popping noises, and one of the kids say, `Oh, Daddy.' I thought someone was shooting a gun outside the house. I put my pants on. I opened my bedroom door, and I saw one of the kids on the floor in the hallway. I walked into the hallway, and I suddenly saw that the child in the hallway was on fire. I began to walk down the stairs, and I called for [the defendant]. I went out the front door, and I walked to my granddaughter Kiana Alston's house, and I told her the house was on fire."
The court reasonably could have determined that the state adduced sufficient evidence to demonstrate that Adam Alston's statements logically could have resulted from his firsthand observations of the incident. According to Anglin, Adam Alston was "banging" on her door on the morning in question. He appeared disheveled with unzipped pants and without shoes and appeared very upset. He said that he had seen one of his granddaughters crawling on the floor, saw the defendant set her on fire and shoot her, and further explained that he had to climb over the burning body of one of his granddaughters to exit the apartment. A reasonable inference may be drawn that Adam Alston had personal knowledge of the facts that are the subject of his statement. See State v. Wargo, supra, 255 Conn. 129. The defendant's argument that Adam Alston did not have firsthand knowledge of the events because his statements to Anglin contradict his statement to the police and the medical examiner's testimony is unavailing. The fact that his spontaneous utterances may be inconsistent with other testimony affects the weight of Adam Alston's statements, not their admissibility.
There may be some situations in which incontrovertible extrinsic evidence renders direct observation by the declarant impossible. This is not such a situation. Even if the extrinsic evidence is fully credited, then Adam Alston was mistaken in some details. The extrinsic evidence is not necessarily inconsistent with Adam Alston's presence at the scene or with his ability to make firsthand observations.
The defendant additionally argues that the court improperly admitted Adam Alston's statements to Anglin because the prejudicial impact of the statements outweighs the probative value. He argues that Adam Alston's descriptions that one of the victims was on her hands and knees when the defendant first shot her and lit her on fire unnecessarily aroused the emotions of the jury particularly in light of the fact that Adam Alston was not available for cross-examination. We are not persuaded.
"[R]elevant . . . evidence may be excluded by the trial court if the court determines that the prejudicial effect of the evidence outweighs its probative value. . . . [B]ecause of the difficulties inherent in this balancing process . . . every reasonable presumption should be given in favor of the trial court's ruling. . . . Of course, [a]ll adverse evidence is damaging to one's case, but it is inadmissible only if it creates undue prejudice so that it threatens an injustice were it to be admitted. . . . [Accordingly] [t]he test for determining whether evidence is unduly prejudicial is not whether it is damaging to the [party against whom the evidence is offered] but whether it will improperly arouse the emotions of the jur[ors]." (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Sandoval, 263 Conn. 524, 544, 821 A.2d 247 (2003); see also Conn. Code Evid. § 4-3.
Adam Alston's statements were relevant to establish the events that occurred on the night in question. He was the only living eyewitness, other than the perpetrator, after the incident occurred. The defendant was able to cross-examine Ellen Stoldt, the detective who took Adam Alston's statement, and Anglin regarding the circumstances surrounding Adam Alston's statements to them. Although we do not doubt that Adam Alston's statements were damaging to the defendant, we cannot say that that evidence was unfairly prejudicial such that the court lacked discretion to admit it.
V
The defendant, who testified at trial, claims that the court erred in instructing the jury on the credibility of witnesses by indicating that the defendant's interest in the outcome of the case could be considered in evaluating his testimony. The defendant seeks review pursuant to State v. Golding, supra, 213 Conn. 239-40, of his unpreserved claim. The defendant's claim is reviewable under Golding because the record is adequate for review and the claim is of constitutional magnitude. See State v. Mack, 197 Conn. 629, 637, 500 A.2d 1303 (1985).
The court instructed the jury in relevant part: "[T]he defendant in this case took the [witness] stand and testified. In weighing the testimony of an accused person, you should apply the same principles by which the testimony of other witnesses is tested, and that necessarily involves a consideration of [the defendant's] interest in the outcome of the case. You will consider the importance to him of the outcome of the trial. An accused person, having taken the witness stand, stands before you, then, just like any other witness, and is entitled to the same consideration and must have his testimony measured in the same way as any other witness, including his interest in the verdict you're about to render."
State v. Golding, supra, 213 Conn. 239-40, holds that "a defendant can prevail on a claim of constitutional error not preserved at trial only if all of the following conditions are met: (1) the record is adequate to review the alleged claim of error; (2) the claim is of constitutional magnitude alleging the violation of a fundamental right; (3) the alleged constitutional violation clearly exists and clearly deprived the defendant of a fair trial; and (4) if subject to harmless error analysis, the state has failed to demonstrate harmlessness of the alleged constitutional violation beyond a reasonable doubt." (Emphasis in original.)
"Connecticut appellate courts repeatedly have held that a court's instruction that the jury evaluate the defendant's testimony in the same manner as that of any other witness after pointing out the defendant's interest in the outcome is neither improper nor transcends the bounds of evenhandedness." State v. Mann, 119 Conn. App. 626, 637, 988 A.2d 918 (2010). "[Our Supreme Court in State v. Williams, 220 Conn. 385, 396-97, 599 A.2d 1053 (1991)], relying on its precedent in State v. Mack, [supra, 197 Conn. 629], and State v. Avcollie, 188 Conn. 626, 453 A.2d 418 (1982), cert. denied, 461 U.S. 928, 103 S. Ct. 2088, 77 L. Ed. 2d 299 (1983), held that the trial court's reference to the defendant's interest in the outcome of the trial did not deprive him of a fair trial." State v. Elson, 116 Conn. App. 196, 221, 975 A.2d 678 (2009).
In his brief, which originally was filed in the Supreme Court prior to the case being transferred to this court, the defendant essentially seeks to have this precedent overruled on the basis of several federal and out-of-state cases. At oral argument, the defendant noted that although he was not waiving this claim, he nevertheless recognized that we, as an intermediate appellate court, are bound by the decisions of our Supreme Court and are not at liberty to contradict those decisions. See State v. Colon, 71 Conn. App. 217, 245-46, 800 A.2d 1268 ("[w]e are not at liberty to overrule or discard the decisions of our Supreme Court but are bound by them" [internal quotation marks omitted]), cert. denied, 261 Conn. 934, 806 A.2d 1067 (2002). In light of Williams and its progeny, the defendant's claim fails under the third prong of Golding. It was not improper for the court to mention in its charge the defendant's interest in the outcome of the case and it did not unduly emphasize the defendant's interest. Accordingly, the defendant's claim fails under the third prong of Golding.
VIThe defendant next claims that the court erred in refusing to charge the jury on diminished capacity. We disagree.
"A fundamental element of due process is the right of a defendant charged with a crime to establish a defense. . . . [A] defendant is entitled to have the court present instructions to the jury relating to any theory of the defense for which there is any foundation in the evidence, even if weak or incredible. . . . We must consider the evidence presented at trial in the light most favorable to supporting the defendant's request to charge. . . . An instruction on a legally recognized theory of defense, however, is warranted only if the evidence indicates the availability of that defense. . . . The trial court should not submit an issue to the jury that is unsupported by the facts in evidence." (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Adams, 225 Conn. 270, 283, 623 A.2d 42 (1993).
Following the filing of defendant's request to charge on diminished capacity, the court, at the charging conference, "decline[d] the defense request to charge on diminished capacity because there [was] no evidence of diminished capacity."
In his request to charge, the defendant did not state what evidence had been presented at trial to support his request. We note that in failing to cite to any evidence in his request to charge, the defendant did not comply with Practice Book § 42-18 (a), which provides in relevant part: "When there are several requests, they shall be in separate and numbered paragraphs, each containing a single proposition of law clearly and concisely stated with the citation of authority upon which it is based, and the evidence to which the proposition would apply. . . ." To the extent that the court's decision could be construed to mean that it denied the defendant's request on this basis, it would not have been an abuse of discretion for the court to have done so. See State v. Bettini, 11 Conn. App. 684, 690, 528 A.2d 1180 ("[i]n the absence of compliance with the rules of practice, the trial court is entitled to deny a request to charge"), cert. denied, 205 Conn. 804, 531 A.2d 937 (1987).
The defendant filed the following request to charge on diminished capacity: "Evidence has been presented during the trial from which you could conclude that the [d]efendant's behavior at and after the incident indicated a diminished mental capacity at the time of the incident. You may consider this in deciding whether the [d]efendant was mentally capable of forming the specific intent necessary to constitute the crimes charged, as I have previously defined the required specific intent for you. If you have a reasonable doubt as to whether the [d]efendant acted with the specific intent necessary to constitute the crimes charged you must find him not guilty of those crimes. State v. Hines, 187 Conn. 199 [ 445 A.2d 314] (1982); State v. Thurman, 10 Conn. App. 302 [ 523 A.2d 891, cert. denied, 204 Conn. 805, 528 A.2d 1152] (1987)."
We note that to the extent that there is any ambiguity in the court's ruling, it is the defendant's responsibility to provide us with an adequate record for review, and we read an ambiguous record to support rather than to undermine a court's determination. See, e.g., State v. Reynolds, 264 Conn. 1, 30 n. 21, 836 A.2d 224 (2003), cert. denied, 541 U.S. 908, 124 S. Ct. 1614, 158 L. Ed. 2d 254 (2004).
Furthermore, even if we were to review this claim on the basis of the evidence the defendant claims on appeal supports the charge, we would conclude, nonetheless, that the court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant's request to charge. In his appellate brief, the defendant argues that his testimony during cross-examination and redirect examination that he was out of his mind on the night in question provided sufficient foundation to warrant a charge on diminished capacity. On cross-examination the defendant testified that on the night of the fire, he saw someone lying at the top of the stairs, did not stop to identify the person, grabbed a gun and did not call for help. The prosecutor asked: "You fled, didn't you?" The defendant responded: "I ran because I was out of my mind." On redirect examination, defense counsel asked: "[C]an you say what you were thinking when you ran up the stairs of your house on the morning of December 13 [2003]?" After the court overruled the prosecutor's objection, the defendant answered: "I know I wasn't in my right mind, that's for sure." The court reasonably could have concluded that the defendant's testimony had nothing to do with his state of mind at the time of the crimes but, rather, was offered to explain his flight from the crime scene. Accordingly, the defendant's claim is without merit.
We need not reach the question whether a witness' statement that he was out of his mind at the time of the crime would be sufficient, in itself, to require an instruction on diminished capacity.
The judgment is affirmed.
In this opinion SCHALLER, J., concurred.
FLYNN, J., concurring.
I concur in the result reached and that the defendant's conviction should be affirmed. There was overwhelming evidence of the defendant's guilt. This evidence is pointed out in the majority opinion and needs no repetition. Its weight under the Williams factors militates against reversal. See State v. Pereira, 72 Conn. App. 545, 563-67, 805 A.2d 787 (2002), cert. denied, 262 Conn. 931, 815 A.2d 135 (2003).
I disagree with part I of the opinion holding that there was no impropriety. It has been said that nothing exceeds like excess. Several of the prosecutor's questions were excessively sarcastic. Injection of sarcasm into a cross-examination is improper. State v. Spiegelmann, 81 Conn. App. 441, 457, 840 A.2d 69, cert. denied, 268 Conn. 921, 846 A.2d 882 (2004). The question before the jury was whether the defendant shot his wife and two daughters and then burned their bodies, intentionally causing their death. Despite the horror of the defendant's crime, the jury's deliberation could have been better able to proceed without the mocking, caustic tone inviting ridicule that the cross-examination of the defendant took.
Howard responds by contending that, because he was personally seized in a forceful manner indicative of an arrest, the officers' conduct during his detention exceeded the scope of a valid Terry investigation. But this argument misses the point. The question is not whether the officers' conduct amounted to an arrest of Howard; the district court in fact resolved this issue in Howard's favor. Rather, the question is whether Titan's alert was the result of the unlawful arrest. See United States v. Bentley, 29 F.3d 1073, 1075-76 (6th Cir. 1994) (concluding that, even though the defendant was arrested prematurely, the police had reasonable suspicion to detain him, and evidence observed in plain view constituted an independent basis to justify the subsequent search of the defendant's vehicle).
In this regard, the present case is strikingly similar to Garcia, where this court reasoned:
[The defendant] contends that his arrest during the stop of the Suburban is the prior illegality that tainted the subsequent search warrant for the Suburban. According to [the defendant's] argument, because the illegal arrest allowed the officers to execute a canine narcotics sniff and because the results of the ca-nine sniff were included in the supporting affidavit, the search warrant is a fruit of his `illegal arrest and is thus invalid. [The defendant's] argument erroneously equates the investigatory stop of the Suburban with his allegedly illegal arrest. Even assuming he was illegally arrested at the time the Suburban was stopped, it was the investigatory stop — and not the illegal arrest — that produced the canine narcotics sniff and the resulting search warrant. So long as the officers acted properly in stopping the vehicle and executing the canine sniff, the resulting search warrant was not tainted by a prior illegality.Garcia, 496 F.3d at 503. Tellingly, Howard did not even attempt to distinguish Garcia in his brief.
The manner in which Howard was detained did rise to the level of an arrest, but the officers' display of authority and use of force to detain him did not create the circumstances that led to Titan sniffing the Suburban. Instead, Lieutenant Quinn, who had neither participated in the arrest of Howard nor spoken to Howard after the arrest, instructed Detective Choate to bring Titan to the scene to perform a sniff of the Suburban before the officers searched the vehicle. Detective Choate complied with Lieutenant Quinn's command, which made Titan's deployment entirely independent of Howard's arrest.
3. Probable cause for the search of the Suburban
We now turn to the question of whether Titan's alert established probable cause to search Howard's Suburban. This court has defined probable cause as "reasonable grounds for belief, supported by less than prima facie proof but more than mere suspicion, and is said to exist when there is a fair probability, given the totality of the circumstances, that contraband or evidence of a crime will be found in a particular place." United States v. Lattner, 385 F.3d 947, 951 (6th Cir. 2004) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). As explained above, the alert of a properly trained and reliable drug dog "is sufficient to establish probable cause for the presence of a controlled substance." United States v. Diaz, 25 F.3d 392, 393-94 (6th Cir. 1994).
Titan's handler, Detective Choate, testified at two suppression hearings (in March 2006 and January 2007) concerning Titan's certification, training, and reliability. Significantly, Howard did not object to the magistrate judge's determination after the first suppression hearing that Detective Choate's testimony was credible.
At the first hearing, Detective Choate said that he began working in the drug enforcement unit of the Bradley County Sheriffs Office in October 2004. He acquired Titan, a German Shepherd, in January 2005, and went with Titan to training school shortly thereafter in Franklin, Tennessee. This training lasted three and a half to four weeks, concluding in early March 2005. Both Detective Choate and Titan were then certified by the National Narcotic Detector Dog Association (NNDDA). Detective Choate said that most of the canine units that he has encountered certify with this organization. Certification lasts for one year, and the dog and handler have to be recertified once every twelve months in order to maintain that status. Detective Choate and Titan had already been recertified for 2006.
In accordance with the policy of the Bradley County Sheriffs Office, Detective Choate testified that he and Titan participate in ten recorded hours of training every month. Detective Choate acknowledged on cross-examination, however, that this time includes preparation of the training location and transportation to and from the site. But he also explained that he works with his dog on a daily basis and does not record all of such time because he is limited to ten hours of training per month pursuant to the Sheriffs policy that limits the extra pay that he receives for such training. In addition, Titan has been deployed "numerous" times in the field and has always performed accurately.
The district court concluded that Detective Choate's testimony demonstrated that Titan's alert was sufficiently reliable. Specifically, the court reasoned:
Detective Choate offered credible testimony his dog was both certified and reliable. Detective Choate testified Titan was certified by the National Narcotic Detector Dog Association. The Government submitted copies of the certificates and the detective indicated Titan had recently been recertified. Titan also had continuing training in compliance with departmental policy. Choate testified, to his knowledge, Titan had not yet alerted on a false positive (Titan had never alerted when no drugs were present). Defendant offered no evidence and could offer no evidence contrary to this. Defendant was never in a position to refute or challenge this testimony. Even the expert Defendant wished to hire could offer no testimony to refute Detective Choate's.
Additionally, Defendant's fixation on certification is misplaced. Certification, much like a college or legal degree is, in the end, simply a statement by an institution that an individual has satisfactorily completed a particular course of study. The officer's testimony as well as the records show Titan had been deployed numerous times, and when Titan alerted on an object or location it was uniformly when drugs had been present. That alone, if credited, is sufficient to show Titan was reliable, and the alert was sufficient to create probable cause to search Defendant's Suburban. The magistrate judge credited Choate's testimony and explanation of the records; this Court, on the record, sees no reason to disagree with that determination.
When considering whether probable cause exists a court looks at the totality of the circumstances. Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 230-31, 103 S.Ct. 2317, 76 L.Ed.2d 527 (1983). So the question is not so narrow as whether Titan's `hit' constituted probable cause, rather, the question is whether Titan's `hit' along with all the other facts known to the officers at the time constituted probable cause. Along with Titan's `hit' the officers knew Cornwell claimed to be the girlfriend of Benitez, who possessed five kilograms of cocaine in a hidden compartment of his car. After Renner told her Benitez had been in an accident, his "girlfriend" drove down in two days without asking about Benitez's health or location after at least 13 conversations with Renner. After this, Titan alerted on the vehicle. The dog sniff provided the best reason to believe contraband might be found in the Suburban, but combined with a dubious story by individuals connected to a car which contained five kilograms of cocaine a man of reasonable prudence would be warranted "in the belief that contraband or evidence of a crime" would be found in the Suburban. Ornelas v. United States, 517 U.S. 690, 696, 116 S.Ct. 1657, 134 L.Ed.2d 911 (1996).
(Footnote and record citation omitted.) We adopt this sound reasoning and conclude that Titan's alert established probable cause to search Howard's Suburban.
Because the search of the Suburban was supported by probable cause, independent of Howard's unlawful arrest, the cash contained inside of the vehicle was properly seized. See Arizona v. Gant, ___ U.S. ___, ___, 129 S.Ct. 1710, 1721, 173 L.Ed.2d 485 (2009) (explaining that an automobile search is sustainable "[i]f there is probable cause to believe a vehicle contains evidence of criminal activity"). The district court thus did not err in denying Howard's motion to suppress the cash found in Howard's Suburban.
4. Probable cause for the search of the Carlisle Road property
In addition to arguing that evidence of the cash discovered in the Suburban should have been suppressed, Howard contends that the district court should have disallowed any mention of the digital scales and the electronic money counter found in the second mobile home on the Carlisle Road property. He claims that Agent Hardcorn's search-warrant affidavit was fatally flawed because it referenced the seizure of the $95,000 in cash from the Suburban — the purported "poisonous fruit" of his unlawful arrest. But, as explained in Part II.B.3. above, this argument is without merit.
Howard also asserts that, even if the cash seizure was properly included in the search-warrant affidavit (which it was), the affidavit fails to establish probable cause. To establish probable cause, this court has explained that "the circumstances must indicate why evidence of illegal activity will be found in a particular place. There must, in other words, be a nexus between the place to be searched and the evidence sought." United States v. Carpenter, 360 F.3d 591, 594 (6th Cir. 2004) (en banc) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted).
Agent Hardcorn's affidavit set forth the following facts: (1) Tennessee law enforcement agents had discovered five kilograms of cocaine in the hidden compartment of a car driven by Antonio Bautista-Benitez, (2) the agents then made several controlled calls to a number listed at 15712 Carlisle Road, during which they spoke with persons who wished to pick up the car that Bautista-Benitez had been driving, (3) Cornwell and Howard drove to Tennessee to pick up Bautista-Benitez's car in a vehicle that was registered to Howard at 15712 Carlisle Road, (4) the agents discovered $95,000 in cash in Howard's vehicle, (5) Cornwell advised law enforcement that Bautista-Benitez stayed at Howard's residence about once a month for the past year and a half, and (6) Howard had several prior drug arrests, as well as a conviction for manufacturing methamphetamine at 15712 Carlisle Road. These facts are more than sufficient to establish probable cause that criminal activity was taking place at the Carlisle Road property. Howard's argument to the contrary is largely perfunctory and, in any event, meritless.
5. Description of the Carlisle Road property in the search warrant
As still another ground to suppress the evidence discovered in the second mobile home, Howard argues that the search warrant for the Carlisle Road property failed to sufficiently describe the property as required by the Fourth Amendment. This court has established a two-factor test for "determining whether a warrant describes with sufficient particularity the place to be searched." Knott v. Sullivan, 418 F.3d 561, 568 (6th Cir. 2005). The court considers
(1) whether the place to be searched is described with sufficient particularity as to enable the executing officers to locate and identify the premises with reasonable effort; and (2) whether there is reasonable probability that some other premises may be mistakenly searched.Id. (citation omitted). Minor, technical in-accuracies in the description will not render the search warrant unconstitutional. Id. at 568-69.
The warrant in the present case contained one such minor, technical inaccuracy. It described Howard's property as a single parcel with an address of 15712 Carlisle Road, when in fact the property is made up of two parcels: 15712 Carlisle Road and 15690 Carlisle Road. The digital scales and the electronic money counter were found in the second mobile home that was actually located at the 15690 Carlisle Road address.
Nevertheless, the second mobile home was described in the search warrant as part of the property that was to be searched. It was admittedly described as being "located on the property of 15712 Carlisle Road," which was technically inaccurate. But this minor misstatement does not render the warrant invalid, particularly due to the fact that the Carlisle Road property was otherwise described with reasonable accuracy. See United States v. Pelayo-Landero, 285 F.3d 491, 496-97 (6th Cir. 2002) (holding that the warrant that listed an incorrect address but otherwise accurately described the property was valid); United States v. Durk, 149 F.3d 464, 465-66 (6th Cir. 1998) (same). Because the second mobile home was listed in the search warrant as a building subject to search, and because both mobile homes were accessed by a common driveway from Carlisle Road and shared a single mailbox that bore the 15712 address, the district court properly declined to suppress the evidence discovered inside the second mobile home.
C. Cross-examination of Bautista-Benitez
We now turn to Howard's arguments concerning errors that purportedly occurred during his trial. His first such claim is that the district court erroneously limited his counsel's cross-examination of Bautista-Benitez, in violation of the Sixth Amendment's Confrontation Clause.
A criminal defendant has the constitutional right "to confront the witnesses against him," but "this right is not absolute." United States v. Davis, 430 F.3d 345, 360 (6th Cir. 2005). The Supreme Court has explained that "trial judges retain wide latitude insofar as the Confrontation Clause is concerned to impose reasonable limits on such cross-examination based on concerns about, among other things, harassment, prejudice, confusion of the issues, the witness' safety, or interrogation that is repetitive or only marginally relevant." Delaware v. Van Arsdall, 475 U.S. 673, 679, 106 S.Ct. 1431, 89 L.Ed.2d 674 (1986). We review a district court's decision to limit the scope of cross-examination under the abuse-of-discretion standard. United States v. Kone, 307 F.3d 430, 436 (6th Cir. 2002).
Howard's counsel attempted to cross-examine Bautista-Benitez about a motion to suppress that Bautista-Benitez had filed prior to entering a plea of guilty with regard to the transportation of the cocaine discovered in the Passat. Specifically, he asked: "Mr. Bautista, did you file a motion to try to exclude the evidence in your case?" The government objected to this question on relevance grounds. Howard's counsel responded that he was trying to attack Bautista-Benitez's credibility by showing that Bautista-Benitez had sought to avoid responsibility for his actions before he eventually pled guilty. The district court sustained the government's objection, ruling that Howard's intended use of the testimony improperly punished Bautista-Benitez for exercising his constitutional right to challenge the legality of the evidence against him. Howard argues on appeal that this reasoning is "misplaced."
The government asserts in its brief that "[i]t would be generous to characterize evidence about whether a witness's attorney filed a motion in the witness's case as even marginally relevant to the witness's credibility. It would certainly have been confusing to the jury." We agree. Howard's question was far more likely to confuse the issues than to constitute an identifiable attack on Bautista-Benitez's credibility. See Fed.R.Evid. 403 ("Although relevant, evidence may be excluded if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of . . . confusion of the issues. . . ."). Moreover, Howard's counsel had already shown that Bautista-Benitez did not initially accept responsibility for his actions by eliciting testimony from him that he lied to the police about having drugs in the Passat when he was first stopped on Interstate 75. The district court therefore did not abuse its discretion when it sustained the government's objection to the question put to Bautista-Benitez, even though the reason given in support of the court's ruling was indeed "misplaced." See Dixon v. Clem, 492 F.3d 665, 673 (6th Cir. 2007) (explaining that this court "may affirm on any grounds supported by the record even if different from the reasons of the district court" (citation omitted)).
D. Testimony of Agent Rolfson
Howard next argues that the district court abused its discretion by permitting the government to question Agent Rolfson about his 2003 encounter with Howard on the Carlisle Road property. According to Howard, this testimony should have been excluded under Rule 403 of the Federal Rules of Evidence.
Rule 403 provides in part that relevant evidence "may be excluded if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice." This court has explained that "[u]nfair prejudice does not mean the damage to a defendant's case that results from the legitimate probative force of the evidence; rather it refers to evidence which tends to suggest [a] decision on an improper basis." United States v. Bonds, 12 F.3d 540, 567 (6th Cir. 1993) (citation and internal quotation marks omitted). In reviewing a district court's decision to exclude evidence under Rule 403, we "view[] the excluded evidence in the light most favorable to the proponent." Kovacevich v. Kent State Univ., 224 F.3d 806, 831-32 (6th Cir. 2000). Balancing under Rule 403 is "highly discretionary" and, therefore, "the district court's decision is afforded great deference." United States v. Bell, 516 F.3d 432, 445 (6th Cir. 2008). Thus, "a decision will not be disturbed if substantial injustice did not result." Kovacevich, 224 F.3d at 832.
Prior to eliciting testimony on the matter, the government asked the district court for permission to introduce evidence of Agent Rolfson's 2003 encounter with Howard. This encounter was part of a drug strike-force investigation that culminated in Howard's conviction for the manufacture of methamphetamine. The government reasoned that Howard had put his connection to the Carlisle Road property into question. It therefore wanted to recall Agent Rolfson as a witness so that he could testify that he had previously been on the property during a drug strike-force investigation and had encountered Howard, who at first denied living there. Agent Rolfson was also prepared to testify that Howard eventually admitted that he lived there when the officers found a key to the property on his person. The government argued that a jury could infer from this evidence that Howard was still living at the Carlisle Road property when it was searched in December 2005.
On the other hand, as Howard pointed out, a jury might draw improper inferences from this proffered testimony about Howard's propensity to commit crime. The district court acknowledged Howard's point when it suggested that the parties could obviate the need for this testimony and avoid the problem entirely by stipulating to Howard's residence on the Carlisle Road property. But the parties never offered any such stipulation (even though there was a break in the court proceedings for lunch before Agent Rolfson was recalled to testify).
The district court allowed the government to recall Agent Rolfson on this matter. Specifically, the court determined that Agent Rolfson could testify that he and other agents had previously been to the Carlisle Road property and had encountered Howard there. The court reasoned that such testimony would not be unfairly prejudicial because "the jury has already been told by, I believe, more than one officer that there was some familiarity with this defendant and the property." We agree with this analysis.
In addition, the district court ruled that the government could introduce evidence that Howard had a key to the property on his person in 2003. Such evidence, the court said, "would tend to counter" the "suggestion that this defendant had no responsibility for the property." And the fact that the property was legally comprised of two separate parcels did not detract from the relevance of this testimony because the entire property was locked by a single gate, and the key to this gate was discovered on Howard's person.
We agree that Agent Rolfson's testimony tended to demonstrate Howard's connection to the Carlisle property as a whole, and thus was relevant to the issue of whether Howard had possession of the incriminating items found in the second mobile home. Accordingly, we conclude that the district court did not abuse its discretion in allowing the government to recall Agent Rolfson to testify about his 2003 encounter with Howard.
E. Motion for mistrial
When Agent Rolfson was recalled as a witness, he testified that he and other agents from the drug strike force came to Howard's residence in April 2003 "in reference to an investigation." Howard immediately objected and moved for a mistrial. He argued that he did not "think the jury can draw anything but a negative inference from" Agent Rolfson's testimony that the drug strike force was previously at the Carlisle Road property. The district court denied the motion.
We review a district court's denial of a motion for a mistrial under the abuse-of-discretion standard. United States v. Wimbley, 553 F.3d 455, 460 (6th Cir. 2009). Where a defendant argues that the district court should have granted a mistrial due to improper testimony, such as in the present case, we must first consider whether the challenged testimony was in fact improper. See United States v. Peatross, No. 07-2410, 2010 WL 1924707, at *13 (6th Cir. May 13, 2010) (unpublished) ("Implied in the determination of whether a court abused its discretion in denying a motion for a mistrial on the basis of improper testimony is, obviously, that the evidence at issue was somehow improper. If the district court did not err in admitting the evidence, then the district court could not have abused its discretion in denying the motion for a mistrial." (citation omitted)).
Next, if we conclude that the testimony was improper, then we must determine whether the challenged testimony "was so clearly improper and prejudicial to the defendants that the harm could not be erased by any instruction which the court might give." United States v. Smith, 601 F.3d 530, 538 (6th Cir. 2010). The five factors that we consider in making this determination are as follows:
(1) whether the remark was unsolicited, (2) whether the government's line of questioning was reasonable, (3) whether the limiting instruction was immediate, clear, and forceful, (4) whether any bad faith was evidenced by the government, and (5) whether the remark was only a small part of the evidence against the defendant.Zuern v. Tate, 336 F.3d 478, 485 (6th Cir. 2003).
In the present case, Howard's argument fails at the threshold inquiry because he is unable to demonstrate that Agent Rolfson's testimony was improper. When the district court allowed the government to recall Agent Rolfson, its ruling was ambiguous as to whether Agent Rolfson was permitted to testify that he had been at the Carlisle Road property in 2003 as part of a drug strike-force investigation. Howard's methamphetamine conviction was clearly excluded, and the fact that Agent Rolfson had encountered Howard on the property was clearly permitted, but the fact of the drug strike-force investigation was not clearly excluded or permitted.
Turning to Agent Rolfson's actual testimony, we conclude that Howard has failed to show that it was unfairly prejudicial. The fact that Agent Rolfson was on the property as part of a drug strike-force investigation was fairly obvious from his prior testimony that he was on the drug strike force and was familiar with Howard and the Carlisle Road property. And the district court had ruled that Agent Rolfson could testify that he encountered Howard on the property in 2003. His allegedly improper statement simply provided back-ground information for this expressly permitted testimony — it explained why Agent Rolfson was there.
Moreover, Agent Rolfson's choice of words minimized whatever unfair prejudice Howard might have suffered as a result of the testimony. Agent Rolfson did not say that the investigation targeted either Howard or the property; he simply said that he came to the address "in reference to an investigation." Significantly, Howard did not move the court to strike this testimony, nor did he request a curative jury instruction. The district court therefore did not abuse its discretion in denying Howard's motion for a mistrial.
F. Sufficiency of the Evidence
Howard's final argument on appeal is that the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to support his conviction. He contends that the district court thus erred in denying his post-trial motion for a judgment of acquittal filed pursuant to Rule 29 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.
We "review de novo a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence supporting a criminal conviction." United States v. Carson, 560 F.3d 566, 579 (6th Cir. 2009). This requires us to determine "whether, after viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, any rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt." Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 319, 99 S.Ct. 2781, 61 L.Ed.2d 560 (1979) (emphasis in original). "In undertaking this analysis, this court neither independently weighs the evidence, nor judges the credibility of witnesses who testified at trial." United States v. Talley, 164 F.3d 989, 996 (6th Cir. 1999).
Howard argues that the evidence was insufficient to show that he was anything more than an innocent bystander who "was merely the means by which Amy Cornwell used to retrieve the vehicle in which the cocaine was discovered." He further contends that "the government tried to establish Mr. Howard's involvement in the drug conspiracy through the testimony of Ms. Cornwell and Mr. Bautista," but that this testimony contained "glaring inconsistencies."
Howard is essentially attempting to recast a challenge to the credibility of Bautista-Benitez and Cornwell as a sufficiency-of-the-evidence claim. But as this court has explained, "it is well-settled that on appeal, there is no place for arguments regarding a government witness's lack of credibility. Indeed, it is for jurors and not for appellate courts to say that a particular witness spoke the truth or fabricated a cock-and-bull story." Talley, 164 F.3d at 996 (brackets, citations, ellipses, and internal quotation marks omitted). We therefore reject Howard's argument. The evidence presented at Howard's trial, as fully detailed in Part I.B.2. above, was more than sufficient to sustain Howard's convictions for conspiring to possess and distribute at least five kilograms of cocaine and for attempting to possess and distribute the drug.
III. CONCLUSION
For all of the reasons set forth above, we AFFIRM the judgment of the district court.
Alert