MATTER OF CITY OF NEW YORK

Benjamin Catchings and Merle I. St. John for appellants. Albert Ottinger, Attorney-General ( Anson Getman and George S. Parsons of counsel), for the People. Albert B. Boardman and Edwin J. Freedman for Stapleton Dock and Warehouse Corporation, et al., respondents. A.S. Gilbert and Royal E.T. Riggs for Staten Island Railway Company, et al., respondents. Valentine Taylor for Consumers Coal and Ice Company, respondent. Francis P. O'Connor and Edward W. Murphy for Atlantic Mutual Insurance Company, et al., respondents. Charles Lamb for Hugo Jaburg, respondent.