FIRST PRES'N C. OF YORK v. YORK DEPOSITORY et al

Messrs. Hart Moss, of York, S.C. Counsel for Appellant, cite: As to Appellant being a "third person" within meaning of Sec. 8804, Code of 1932, under facts of case at Bar: Code of S.C. 1932, Secs. 8804, 8875; Code of S.C. 1932, Sec. 8873; Spears' Eq., 159; 192 S.C. 429, 7 S.E.2d 63; Code of S.C. 1932, Sec. 7042; Bouvier's Law Dict.; 1 Mart. (N.S.), La., 384; 130 Mich., 347, 90 N.W., 32; 10 Minn., 50; 28 R.I. 319, 67 A., 326; 64 Wis. 173, 24 N.W., 874. As to Whether Section 8804, Code of S.C. 1932, Was Repealed By Not Being Adopted as Part of Code of 1942; And if Repealed are "vested rights" retroactively divested?: Sec. 8804, Code of S.C. 1932; Sec. 8804, Code of S.C. 1942; Secs. 1 and 2 of Act Adopting Code of 1942, Approved Sept. 26, 1942; 55 S.C. 295, 33 S.E., 372; 87 S.C. 270, 69 S.E., 391, Affirmed in 60 L.Ed., 658; 91 S.C. 344, 74 S.E., 1010; 6 R.C.L., at p. 305 and 306; 25 R.C.L., at p. 785, and p. 795; 165 S.C. 219, 163 S.E., 653; 169 S.C. 436, 169 S.E., 174; 5 S.C. 125; 1 S.C. 152. Mr. R.B. Hildebrand, of York, S.C. Counsel for Respondent, cites: As to History of Section 8804, Code of S.C. 1932: St. At L., Vol. VI, p. 67; Corbin's St. At L., (1872) p. 433; Rev. St., Vol. I, (1893) p. 658; Sec. 2414, Vol. I, Code of S.C. 1902; Sec. 3500, Vol. I, Code of S.C. 1912; Sec. 5270, Vol. III, Code of S.C. 1922; Sec. 8804, Vol. III, Code of S.C. 1932; Sec. 8804, Code of S.C. 1942; 1 Bail., 315 (1829); Speer's Eq., 159 (1843); 192 S.C. 420, 7 S.E.2d 63. As to Plaintiff being "a third person" under meaning of Sec. 8804: 16 A.J., Sec. 32, p. 797, also p. 799, Sec. 33; Id., Sec., 34, p. 801; 32 A.J., Sec., 95, p. 103; 146 S.C. 225, 143 S.E., 796; 2 Mill Const., 18; 2 Bail. L. (18 S.C.L.), 554; 25 R.C.L., Sec. 289, p. 1065; 25 R.C.L., Sec., 292, p. 1067; 23 R.C. L., Sec. 25, p. 171; 23 R.C.L., Sec. 24, p. 170; 189 S.C. 463, 1 S.E.2d 624; 23 R.C.L., Sec. 95, p. 230; 25 R.C.L., Sec. 285, p. 1061; 83 S.C. 427, 65 S.E., 433; 71 S.C. 992. As to Repeal of Sec. 8804, Code of S.C. 1932: Const. of S.C. 1895, Art. VI, Sec. 5; 148 S.C. 118, 145 S.E., 695; 155 S.C. 520, 152 S.E., 700., 162 S.C. 52, 160 S.E., 144; 96 S.C. 313, 80 S.C. 599; 2 Rich. Eq., 43; 59 C.J., Sec. 717, p. 1181; 50 C.J., Sec. 718; 2 McC. Eq., 171; 4 McCord, 476; 4 McCord, 442; 1 Hill Eq., 265.