ANTHONY O'BOYLE v. LOUIS W. DOYLE

John P. McGrath, Corporation Counsel, New York City, Joseph T. Caponigri, New York City, of counsel, for City of New York, respondent-impleaded-appellant. Frank G. Colgan, Brooklyn, N.Y., for Anthony O'Boyle, Inc., libellant-appellee. Alexander Ash, New York City, Edward Ash, New York City, of counsel, for Shamrock Towing Company, Inc., libellant-respondent-appellee. Hagen, Senecal Eidenbach, New York City, John F. Quarto, New York City, of counsel, for Sinram Bros., Inc., libellant-appellee. Macklin, Speer, Hanan McKernan, New York City, Leo F. Hanan, New York City, of counsel, for Reading Co., respondent-appellee. Hill, Rivkins Middleton, New York City, Thomas H. Middleton, New York City, of counsel, for Tully DiNapoli, Inc., respondent-appellee.