- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
UNITED STATES v. GILBERT ASSOCIATES
United States v. Gilbert Associates, Inc., No. 440 (Argued Mar. 11, 1953; Decided Apr. 6, 1953)
Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns which party — the Town of Walpole, New Hampshire, or the United States — had priority to a fund held by a state-court receiver for Gilbert Associates, Inc., an insolvent corporation. The Town had assessed ad valorem taxes on the corporation's machinery for tax years 1947 ($612.95) and 1948 ($690.85). The corporation was declared insolvent and a receiver was appointed (temporary August 12, 1949; permanent January 30, 1950). The Town conducted tax sales: on September 25, 1948, for 1947 taxes, and on September 24, 1949, for 1948 taxes. The record does not disclose the nature of the tax-sale proceedings, and the Town never took possession of the property; the property later was sold by the receiver, producing the disputed fund.
The United States asserted a lien for employment, withholding, and income taxes due between 1943 and June 30, 1948, totaling $3,171.97, and filed notice of that lien in the District Court clerk's office on August 6, 1948. The Supreme Court of New Hampshire held that the Town had priority because, under New Hampshire law, tax assessments are "in the nature of a judgment," making the Town a "judgment creditor" within the meaning of 26 U.S.C. § 3672. The United States obtained certiorari from this Court, which reversed the state-court judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Town of Walpole was a "judgment creditor" within the meaning of 26 U.S.C. § 3672 (Internal Revenue Code), such that the United States' tax lien — filed August 6, 1948 — would not be valid against the Town.
- If the Town was not a "judgment creditor" under § 3672, whether the United States is entitled to priority over the Town under R.S. § 3466 (31 U.S.C. § 191) when both the Town's and the United States' liens are general and the taxpayer is insolvent.
Arguments of the Parties
United States (as presented in the opinion)
- The words "judgment creditor" in § 3672 should be given their usual, conventional federal meaning: a creditor holding a judgment of a court of record. Congress intended a uniform federal meaning applicable in all States.
- The Town's tax assessments, even if characterized by New Hampshire as "in the nature of a judgment" for state purposes, are not the same as a judgment of a court of record and therefore do not make the Town a "judgment creditor" under § 3672.
- Both the Town and the United States held general liens on the taxpayer's property (the Town had not divested the taxpayer of title or possession). Where both liens are general and the taxpayer is insolvent, R.S. § 3466 gives priority to the United States.
- The Town did not perfect a specific lien by reducing the property to possession; mere attachment or a prior tax assessment does not suffice to defeat the federal lien where the taxpayer still retained title and possession.
Town of Walpole / New Hampshire Supreme Court position (as explained in the opinion)
- Under New Hampshire law, tax assessments are "in the nature of a judgment" (citing state cases), and therefore the Town should be treated as a "judgment creditor" within the meaning of § 3672.
- The Town asserted (as is common in such cases) that its lien was perfected and specific and thus should be impliedly excepted from the priority rule of R.S. § 3466.
Views expressed in the Dissenting Opinion (Justice Frankfurter, joined by Justice Reed)
- Section 3672 should be interpreted so that a creditor who, under state law, stands in the same position as a judgment creditor (i.e., the state procedure produces substantially the same effect as a court judgment) should be treated as a "judgment creditor" for purposes of § 3672; federal law should refer to state law to determine whether action taken by state taxing authorities has that effect.
- Federal uniformity does not require identical procedures in every State; it requires that creditors who occupy the same substantive position as holders of court judgments be treated alike.
- Given New Hampshire decisions describing assessments as having the normal attributes of a judgment, the dissenters would accept the state court's conclusion that the Town was a judgment creditor under § 3672.
- The dissent cautions against the majority deciding broader questions under § 3466 in the absence of a clear record on the nature of the lien or the effect of the tax-sale proceedings in this case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| United States v. Waddill Co., 323 U.S. 353 | States are free to interpret the nature and effect of their tax proceedings for state administrative purposes. | Used to acknowledge that New Hampshire may characterize its tax proceedings for state purposes without controlling federal interpretation of § 3672. |
| Howard v. Commissioners of Louisville Sinking Fund, 344 U.S. 624 | Discusses deference to state characterizations for state-law purposes. | Cited to support the proposition that the state is free to give its own interpretation for internal administration. |
| United States v. Security Trust Savings Bank, 340 U.S. 47 | Meaning of a federal statute is for the Supreme Court to decide. | Invoked to note that federal interpretation of "judgment creditor" is for this Court, even though state courts determine local effects. |
| United States v. Snyder, 149 U.S. 210 | Depicts the historical problem of secret federal tax liens being asserted against purchasers without notice. | Explains congressional purpose in enacting § 3672 to prevent the harsh consequences recognized in Snyder. |
| Boody v. Watson, 64 N.H. 162 | New Hampshire decision holding assessments are "in the nature of a judgment." | Cited as part of the state authorities that characterize tax assessments as judgments for certain state-law purposes. |
| Jaffrey v. Smith, 76 N.H. 168 | New Hampshire decision treating assessments as "in the nature of a judgment." | Used by the Court to note the New Hampshire line of cases on assessments' character. |
| Nottingham v. (Newmarket Mfg. Co.), 84 N.H. 419 | Another New Hampshire case treating assessments as akin to judgments. | Again cited to describe the state-law characterization the New Hampshire Supreme Court relied upon. |
| Automatic Sprinkler Corp. v. Marston, 94 N.H. 375 | New Hampshire decision referenced regarding assessment/judgment characterization. | Included among state decisions showing that in New Hampshire assessments may be treated as judgments for certain purposes. |
| People ex rel. Harding v. Hart, 332 Ill. 467 | Example of state authorities finding assessments to be judgments for certain purposes. | Cited in a footnote to show how other states have treated assessments in comparable contexts. |
| People ex rel. Glens Falls Ins. Co. v. Ferguson, 38 N.Y. 89 | State case treating assessments as judgments for particular procedural effects. | Cited in the footnote catalogue of decisions that have considered assessments "in the nature of a judgment." |
| Williams v. Weaver, 75 N.Y. 30 | New York authority on assessments' practical equivalence to judgments for some purposes. | Part of the list of state cases referenced by the Court. |
| State v. Georgia Co., 112 N.C. 34 | State decision showing another jurisdiction's approach to tax assessments. | Included in the footnote survey of how various states treat assessments. |
| Union Tanning Co. v. Commonwealth, 123 Va. 610 | Virginia case referenced among state rulings on assessments as judgments. | Used as an example of state-law treatment cited in the opinion's notes. |
| Hibbard v. Clark, 56 N.H. 155 | New Hampshire decision concluding an assessment is not a judgment. | Cited in the footnote to show a contrary New Hampshire authority. |
| Thelusson v. Smith, 2 Wheat. 396 | Principle that to perfect a specific lien by seizure requires reducing property to possession; absent possession a lien remains general. | Applied to hold the Town had not perfected a specific lien because it had not reduced the property to possession or divested title/possession from the taxpayer. |
| Illinois v. Campbell, 329 U.S. 362 | Discusses priority questions between state and federal claims and issues of lien perfection/specificity. | Used to support the statement that the Town had only a general, unperfected lien and to illustrate treatment of such conflicts. |
| United States v. Texas, 314 U.S. 480 | Interprets R.S. § 3466 to give priority to the United States where both claims are general and the debtor is insolvent. | Cited as controlling authority for the proposition that when both liens are general and the taxpayer is insolvent, the United States has priority under § 3466. |
| Conard v. Atlantic Ins. Co., 1 Pet. 386 | Referenced in relation to historical treatment of certain priority questions and § 3466 issues. | Mentioned by the dissent in context of long-standing reluctance of this Court to decide certain § 3466 issues; included in the dissenting discussion. |
| First National Bank of Remsen v. Hayes, 186 Iowa 892 | Example of state authorities for approaches to tax assessments. | Listed in a note illustrating states where taxing authorities are treated differently for purposes of judgment-creditor status. |
| Alexander v. Commonwealth, 137 Va. 477 | Virginia authority showing another state approach to taxing authority powers and assessment effects. | Cited among authorities in the opinion's notes about varying state treatments. |
| Weyerhaeuser Timber Co. v. Pierce County, 97 Wn. 534 | Washington case on taxing authorities and assessment effects. | Used in the opinion's notes as an example of jurisdictions where taxing authorities' actions may be considered judicial in effect. |
| Stimson Timber Co. v. Mason County, 112 Wn. 603 | Another Washington decision relating to county tax assessments and their effects. | Included in the catalogue of state approaches illustrating variation among states. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first framed the central statutory provision at issue: 26 U.S.C. § 3672, which provides that the United States' tax lien "shall not be valid as against any mortgagee, pledgee, purchaser, or judgment creditor until notice thereof has been filed" in the clerk's office of the federal district court. The New Hampshire Supreme Court had treated the Town's tax assessments as "in the nature of a judgment" and concluded the Town was a "judgment creditor" under § 3672 because its assessments predated the filing of the United States' notice (the federal notice was filed August 6, 1948; assessments were April 1, 1947 and April 1, 1948).
The majority began by recognizing two separate points: (1) a State may characterize its own tax proceedings for state purposes, and (2) the meaning of a federal statute is a question for this Court. Balancing those points, the Court concluded that Congress used the words "judgment creditor" in § 3672 in their "usual, conventional sense," i.e., a creditor holding a judgment of a court of record. The Court emphasized Congress' objective of uniformity in the federal tax scheme — a uniform federal rule is needed across the States — and therefore rejected the view that § 3672 should be read to include state tax-assessment procedures that, in some States, may produce results "in the nature of a judgment."
Applying that interpretive rule to the facts, the Court held that the Town of Walpole's proceedings did not make it a "judgment creditor" within the meaning of § 3672. Because the Town was not a judgment creditor under the federal statute, the United States' lien — valid as of August 6, 1948 — was not defeated by the earlier assessments alone.
The Court then considered priorities between the liens that remained: both the Town and the United States were general lienholders on all of the taxpayer's property (the Town had not divested the taxpayer of title or possession). The Court explained the concept of "specificity" — to be a perfected, specific lien (which might have different priority consequences) the lien must have attached to particular property by reducing it to possession or otherwise divesting the taxpayer of property in the manner required to create a specific lien. The Town had not reduced the property to possession, and the mere existence of prior assessments or the mere attachment of a tax lien did not constitute perfection by possession. Because both liens were general and the taxpayer was insolvent, the Court relied on R.S. § 3466 (31 U.S.C. § 191) and precedent (United States v. Texas) to hold that the United States has priority.
The Court observed that it need not decide whether tax liens that are perfected and specific are impliedly excepted from § 3466, because the Town's asserted lien in this record did not present a perfected specific lien question.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The judgment of the Supreme Court of New Hampshire is REVERSED. The United States is entitled to priority to the fund in the hands of the receiver.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The decision reverses the New Hampshire Supreme Court's holding and awards priority to the United States over the Town of Walpole with respect to the fund created by the receiver's sale of the property.
- Statutory interpretation: The Court interpreted "judgment creditor" in 26 U.S.C. § 3672 in the conventional federal sense — a holder of a judgment of a court of record — for purposes of applying § 3672 uniformly across the States. Accordingly, a state tax assessment that is "in the nature of a judgment" for state-law purposes does not automatically qualify the assessing municipality as a "judgment creditor" under § 3672 unless it meets the federal conventional meaning.
- Priority rule under insolvency: Where both the state taxing authority and the United States hold only general (unperfected) liens and the taxpayer is insolvent, R.S. § 3466 (31 U.S.C. § 191) gives priority to the United States.
- Limitations left open: The Court did not decide whether a state tax lien that has been perfected as a specific lien (e.g., by reducing property to possession or otherwise effecting the specific lien) would be implicitly excepted from § 3466; the Court found that issue unnecessary to decide on the present record.
Additional Notes
- The Court expressly recognized the New Hampshire decisions describing tax assessments as "in the nature of a judgment," but treated those state characterizations as relevant only to state-law effects, not determinative of the federal meaning of "judgment creditor" under § 3672. The dissent urged greater deference to state-law determinations of the practical effects of state procedures.
1. Under § 3672 of the Internal Revenue Code, which provides that the tax lien of the United States shall not be valid against any "judgment creditor" until the collector has filed the required notice, a New Hampshire town which had made an assessment of an ad valorem tax on certain property of a corporation was not a "judgment creditor," even though such tax assessments are, under New Hampshire law, "in the nature of a judgment." Pp. 362-365.
(a) In § 3672, Congress used the words "judgment creditor" in the usual, conventional sense of a judgment of a court of record. P. 364.
(b) The phrase "judgment creditor" does not extend to the action of taxing authorities who may be acting judicially, where the end result is something "in the nature of a judgment." P. 364.
2. Where the tax lien of a town and that of the United States are both general, and the taxpayer is insolvent, the United States is entitled to priority under R. S. § 3466. Pp. 365-366.
3. Here the town had only a general lien, because it had not divested the taxpayer of either title or possession. Pp. 365-366.
97 N. H. 411, 90 A.2d 499, reversed.
MR. JUSTICE MINTON delivered the opinion of the Court.
This case involves the question of whether the Town of Walpole, New Hampshire, or the Federal Government has the prior right to a fund in the hands of a state court receiver of the respondent-taxpayer, an insolvent corporation. The Supreme Court of New Hampshire held the Town was entitled to priority, 97 N. H. 411, 90 A.2d 499, and we granted certiorari, 344 U.S. 911.
The claims of both arise from tax liens. The Town's lien grew out of an assessment of an ad valorem tax upon certain machinery of Gilbert Associates, Inc., the respondent, for the years 1947 and 1948 in the amounts of $612.95 and $690.85, respectively. The corporation was thereafter declared insolvent, and a temporary receiver was appointed August 12, 1949, and made permanent January 30, 1950. The Town's taxes were assessed April 1, 1947, and April 1, 1948. On September 25, 1948, the Town sold the taxpayer's property at a tax sale to pay the taxes accrued for the year 1947. On September 24, 1949, the Town sold the same property at a tax sale for taxes accrued for the year 1948. The record does not disclose the nature of these tax-sale proceedings. We are informed that the Town bid in the property at its own sales. At least, the Town never took possession of the property, which was later sold by the receiver, creating the fund involved here. The Federal Government's lien was for employment, withholding, and income taxes that became due between 1943 and June 30, 1948, in the sum of $3,171.97. Notice of this lien was filed in the office of the Clerk of the United States District Court for the District of New Hampshire on August 6, 1948.
Under § 3672 of the Internal Revenue Code, 56 Stat. 798, 26 U.S.C. (1946 ed.) § 3672, the lien of the United States "shall not be valid as against any mortgagee, pledgee, purchaser, or judgment creditor until notice thereof has been filed by the collector — . . . In the office of the clerk of the United States district court for the judicial district in which the property subject to the lien is situated . . . ." The Supreme Court of New Hampshire held that since notice of the Government's lien was not filed until August 6, 1948, and the Town's taxes were assessed on April 1, 1947, and April 1, 1948, respectively, and such tax assessments are "in the nature of a judgment" under the law of New Hampshire, the Town was a judgment creditor within the meaning of § 3672, and the Government's lien was not valid as against the Town's.
Was the Town a judgment creditor within the meaning of § 3672? The New Hampshire Supreme Court in the instant case said:
"It is settled by our decisions that the assessment of a tax is in the nature of a judgment, enforced by a warrant instead of an execution. Boody v. Watson, 64 N. H. 162, 167; Jaffrey v. Smith, 76 N. H. 168, 171; Nottingham v. Company, 84 N. H. 419. See also, Automatic Sprinkler Corp. v. Marston, 94 N. H. 375." 97 N. H. 411, 414, 90 A.2d 499, 502.
We would not question or presume to say what the nature and effect of a tax proceeding is in New Hampshire. The state is free to give its own interpretation for the purpose of its own internal administration. United States v. Waddill Co., 323 U.S. 353. See also Howard v. Commissioners of Louisville Sinking Fund, 344 U.S. 624.
The Supreme Court of New Hampshire freely concedes, however, as it must, that the meaning of a federal statute is for this Court to decide. United States v. Security Trust Savings Bank, 340 U.S. 47. Congress enacted § 3672 to meet the harsh condition created by the holding in United States v. Snyder, 149 U.S. 210, when federal liens were few, that a secret federal tax lien was good against a purchaser for value without notice.
A cardinal principle of Congress in its tax scheme is uniformity, as far as may be. Therefore, a "judgment creditor" should have the same application in all the states. In this instance, we think Congress used the words "judgment creditor" in § 3672 in the usual, conventional sense of a judgment of a court of record, since all states have such courts. We do not think Congress had in mind the action of taxing authorities who may be acting judicially as in New Hampshire and some other states, where the end result is something "in the nature of a judgment," while in other states the taxing authorities act quasi-judicially and are considered administrative bodies.
See concurring opinion of MR. JUSTICE JACKSON in United States v. Security Trust Savings Bank, supra, at p. 52.
The decisions have arrived at the conclusion that assessments are judgments for purposes of preventing collateral attacks upon them, ascertaining rights to a hearing in connection with them, or deciding under local procedure on the applicable method of collecting them. These cases, prior to the instant decision, have never actually declared that the status of a technical judgment creditor has been created. People ex rel. Harding v. Hart, 332 Ill. 467, 163 N. F. 769; Nottingham v. Newmarket Mfg. Co., 84 N. H. 419, 151 A. 709; People ex rel. Glens Falls Ins. Co. v. Ferguson, 38 N.Y. 89, Williams v. Weaver, 75 N.Y. 30; State v. Georgia Co., 112 N.C. 34, 17 S.E. 10; Union Tanning Co. v. Commonwealth, 123 Va. 610, 96 S.E. 780. But see Hibbard v. Clark, 56 N. H. 155, holding that it is not a judgment. 1 Cooley, Taxation (4th ed., 1924), 91-92, points out that assessments, though they may be enough like judgments to definitely establish a demand for taxes, are not technical judgments.
First National Bank of Remsen v. Hayes, 186 Iowa 892, 171 N.W. 715; Alexander v. Commonwealth, 137 Va. 477, 120 S.E. 296; Weyerhaeuser Timber Co. v. Pierce County, 97 Wn. 534, 167 P. 35; Stimson Timber Co. v. Mason County, 112 Wn. 603, 192 P. 994.
We conclude that whatever the tax proceedings of the Town of Walpole may amount to for the purposes of the State of New Hampshire, they were not such proceedings as resulted in making the Town a judgment creditor within the meaning of § 3672.
While the Town was not a judgment creditor, it was the holder of a general lien on all the taxpayer's property. So was the United States a general lienholder on all the taxpayer's property. But since the taxpayer was insolvent, the United States claims the benefit of another statute to give it priority, § 3466 of the Revised Statutes, 31 U.S.C. (1946 ed.) § 191, the provisions of which are set forth in the margin.
"§ 3670. Property subject to lien. "If any person liable to pay any tax neglects or refuses to pay the same after demand, the amount (including any interest, penalty, additional amount, or addition to such tax, together with any costs that may accrue in addition thereto) shall be a lien in favor of the United States upon all property and rights to property, whether real or personal, belonging to such person." § 3670 I. R. C., 26 U.S.C. (1946 ed.) § 3670.
R. S. § 3466. "Whenever any person indebted to the United States is insolvent, or whenever the estate of any deceased debtor, in the hands of the executors or administrators, is insufficient to pay all the debts due from the deceased, the debts due to the United States shall be first satisfied; and the priority hereby established shall extend as well to cases in which a debtor, not having sufficient property to pay all his debts, makes a voluntary assignment thereof, or in which the estate and effects of an absconding, concealed, or absent debtor are attached by process of law, as to cases in which an act of bankruptcy is committed."
As is usual in cases like this, the Town asserts that its lien is a perfected and specific lien which is impliedly excepted from this statute. This Court has never actually held that there is such an exception. Once again, we find it unnecessary to meet this issue because the lien asserted here does not raise the question.
In claims of this type, "specificity" requires that the lien be attached to certain property by reducing it to possession, on the theory that the United States has no claim against property no longer in the possession of the debtor. Thelusson v. Smith, 2 Wheat. 396. Until such possession, it remains a general lien. There is no ground for the contention here that the Town had perfected its lien by reducing the property to possession. The record reveals no such action. The mere attachment of the Town's lien before the recording of the federal lien does not, contrary to the holding of the Supreme Court of New Hampshire, give the Town priority over the United States. The taxpayer had not been divested by the Town of either title or possession. The Town, therefore, had only a general, unperfected lien. United States v. Waddill Co., supra; Illinois v. Campbell, 329 U.S. 362, 370. Where the lien of the Town and that of the Federal Government are both general, and the taxpayer is insolvent, § 3466 clearly awards priority to the United States. United States v. Texas, 314 U.S. 480, 488.
The judgment of the Supreme Court of New Hampshire is
Reversed.
MR. JUSTICE FRANKFURTER, whom MR. JUSTICE REED joins, dissenting.
I cannot agree with the opinion of the Court insofar as it supposes that § 3672 of the Internal Revenue Code is to be read as requiring that certain procedures — and the same procedures — be complied with in each State before a creditor becomes the magic "judgment creditor." Section 3672 gives the United States priority over other creditors but not over judgment creditors. This is the rule of uniformity enacted by Congress. But it does not demand that the same procedure be followed in every State. Nor does it demand that any particular procedure be followed, that the creditor formally prosecute his claim in the courts and obtain judgment, or even that the common-law requirements be satisfied.
Of course, the State courts cannot by the wand of a label wave away the requirement, which I agree is a matter for federal interpretation, that a creditor be a "judgment creditor." But federal law does not insist on anything more than that the creditor be in the same position as a creditor who holds a judgment "in the usual, conventional sense." Federal law refers to State law, as it does in the closely comparable bankruptcy provisions, to determine whether action taken by a taxing authority of New Hampshire has substantially the same effect as would be given the judgment of a court of record, that is, whether the Town stands — along with creditors who have obtained judgment from a court of record — on a higher footing than those who have yet to establish their claims in court. If the assessment here has, as the New Hampshire Supreme Court informs us, the normal attributes of a judgment, I see no way of escaping the conclusion that the Town is a judgment creditor within the meaning of § 3672. In the light of the New Hampshire decisions, see Nottingham v. Newmarket Mfg. Co., 84 N. H. 419, 151 A. 709; Jaffrey v. Smith, 76 N. H. 168, 80 A. 504; cf. Automatic Sprinkler Corp. v. Marston, 94 N. H. 375, 376, 54 A.2d 154, 155, there is no reason for believing that the State ruling here simply applies a label and does not express the controlling law of the State unrelated to the implications of § 3672. Nothing more ought to be required.
In view of the Court's reluctance not only today but for almost a century and a half to decide the issues that may arise under § 3466 of the Revised Statutes, I do not think I ought to embarrass later consideration by the Court of these issues by speaking on them at this time. Compare Conard v. Atlantic Ins. Co., 1 Pet. 386, 441, 444, with United States v. Waddill Co., 323 U.S. 353, 355; see 56 Yale L. J. 1258. But cf. Illinois v. Campbell, 329 U.S. 362, 376 (dissenting opinion). It would be particularly inappropriate to do so in this case, because we are not told what kind of lien has arisen and what effect the tax sales may have in the circumstances of this case.
Alert