- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
PFEIFFER v. TRANSPORT LEASING, INC
The action is in negligence and involved a head-on collision between plaintiff's automobile and a tractor-trailer owned by the corporate defendants and operated by the individual defendant, on a two-strip, straight and level concrete highway about seven o'clock on a very foggy morning. The only eye witnesses were the plaintiff and the defendant Lippert, operator of the tractor-trailer. Confronted with two versions of the cause of the collision, the jury has accepted the plaintiff's version. There is evidence from which the jury could have found that the heavily loaded vehicle of the defendants was proceeding in a heavy fog with only "marker" lights lighted, at a rate of speed of thirty to thirty-five miles per hour, and partially on the wrong side of the road. Plaintiff was proceeding in a westerly direction and the defendants' vehicle was proceeding in an easterly direction. Following the accident both vehicles came to rest off the north side of the road. The defendants lean heavily upon photographs which show tire marks allegedly made by the defendants' vehicle which were off the pavement on the south side of the road. However, it appears that plaintiff's car was dragged a considerable distance locked underneath a portion of defendants' vehicle. There is ample evidence from which the jury could have found that the tracks in question were made after the collision. A clear question of fact as to negligence and contributory negligence is presented by the evidence. Defendants also contend that the verdict of $30,000 is excessive. Plaintiff suffered special damages amounting to approximately $7,000. His injuries were serious and extensive and necessitated lengthy hospitalization and operative care, leaving him with substantial permanent disability. The jury's evaluation of his damages was not excessive. Judgment and order unanimously affirmed, with costs.
Alert