- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
BROOKSIDE AGRA v. SPECIAL NUTRIENTS, INC., (N.D.Iowa 1999)
Michael J. Melloy, United States District Court Chief Judge.
IntroductionThis matter involves a claim for damages by the plaintiff, Brookside Agra, L.C., against the defendants, Special Nutrients, Inc., and Fernando Tamames II, one of Special Nutrients' officers. The plaintiff originally filed this lawsuit in state court, alleging that it shipped certain goods and materials to Special Nutrients but was not paid. The plaintiff seeks $167,587.50 in damages from Special Nutrients under breach of contract and open account theories (Counts I and II) or from Tamames II under a personal guarantee theory (Count III).
The defendants removed this case to federal court, on the basis of diversity of citizenship under 28 U.S.C. § 1332. This case now comes before the court on the defendants' motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction under Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)(2). The defendants, based in Florida and doing business in Florida, argue they do not have sufficient minimum contacts with Iowa for this court to exercise jurisdiction.
The court will deny the defendants' request for oral argument which they submitted with their reply brief. (Doc. #22). The court finds that this matter is fully and adequately briefed, and the defendants have not shown cause to support their request for oral argument. See Local Rule 7.1(c).
Standard of ReviewOn a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, the court must determine whether the non-moving party has set forth a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction, viewing the facts in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. Vandelune v. 4B Elevator Components Unltd., 148 F.3d 943, 948 (8th Cir. 1998); Digi-Tel Holdings v. Proteq Telecommunications (PTE), Ltd., 89 F.3d 519, 522 (8th Cir. 1996); Radaszewski by Radaszewski v. Telecom Corp., 981 F.2d 305, 309-10 (8th Cir. 1992) (where, as here, the parties submit affidavits in support of their positions, the district court should apply the standards of Fed.R.Civ.P. 56), cert. denied, 508 U.S. 908 (1993).
Factual Background
Main Participants. Because the facts of this case are somewhat complicated, the court will first set forth the main participants in this case:
• The plaintiff, Brookside Agra, L.C., is an Iowa Limited Liability Company. Brookside is in the business of distributing animal feed additives. One of the products which Brookside distributes is Flo-Bond, a calcium sodium aluminosilicate clay used in animal feed.
• The defendant, Special Nutrients, Inc., is a Florida company doing business in Florida. Special Nutrients is in the business of distributing animal feed additives internationally. From 1994 to 1998, Special Nutrients distributed Flo-Bond to Latin America under the trade name Myco-Ad, pursuant to a distribution and sales agreement with Brookside.
• The defendant, Fernando Tamames II, is an officer of Special Nutrients. Brookside alleges that Tamames II made a personal guarantee of payment on shipments made for Special Nutrients.
• Fernando Tamames III, the son of Tamames II, is an officer for both Special Nutrients and Citrex, Inc.
• Citrex, Inc., is a producer of animal feed additives. Tamames III claims that Citrex, Inc., is "wholly separate" from Special Nutrients. Brookside claims that Citrex, Inc., and Special Nutrients are "related companies with identical ownership."
• Don Riesenberg is an Illinois resident who owns 30% of Brookside Agra, L.C. Riesenberg has identified himself as Brookside's president. Riesenberg works out of Brookside's office in Highland, Illinois, which is located in southern Illinois near East St. Louis.
• Agra Partners is an Iowa company which owns 70% of Brookside.
• Randy Brunson is an Iowa resident who owns 50% of Agra Partners. Brunson also owns Wholesale Feeds, Inc., located in Cedar Rapids and Marion, Iowa.
• David Patee is an Iowa resident who owns the other 50% of Agra Partners. Patee also owns Consumers Supply Distributing Company located in Sioux City, Iowa.Initial Contacts. The key participants in this lawsuit had contacts with each other as early as 1992, but not necessarily involving Brookside Agra, L.C., or Special Nutrients. The record shows that Citrex was originally contacted by "Brookside Agra Corporation" in early 1992. Don Riesenberg, who at the time represented himself as president of "Brookside Agra Corporation," with addresses in Highland, Illinois, and Sumas, Washington, contacted Tamames III at Citrex in March of 1992 to promote various products, including Milbond TX, a calcium sodium aluminosilicate clay which Brookside later re-named Flo-Bond. (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 5-6, Ex. A). In the letter, Riesenberg stated he would be in Florida and would like to meet with Tamames III. ( Id.). The record reflects that Tamames II, Tamames III, and Riesenberg met at least once in Miami to discuss the sale of clay. (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶ 7).
On many factual matters, Fernando Tamames II and Fernando Tamames III have submitted virtually identical affidavits, and both have prepared multiple affidavits. To simplify the record, the court will generally cite for any proposition to a single affidavit submitted by the defendants.
According to Tamames III, Brookside Agra Corporation was a Canadian company owned by Riesenberg. (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶ 5). It was not until some time after Special Nutrients began buying Flo-Bond from Brookside Agra Corporation, that the corporation dissolved and Riesenberg began doing business of behalf of the plaintiff, Brookside Agra, L.C. ( Id. ¶ 10).
Tamames III claims that Special Nutrients was unaware that Brookside Agra, L.C., was incorporated in Iowa until this lawsuit was commenced. ( Id.). However, Patee states in his affidavit that Special Nutrients was aware that Brookside was an Iowa company from the original negotiations in which Patee was involved. (Patee Aff. ¶ 6).
Special Nutrients claims that it was not "introduced" to Patee and Brunson until "some time after the initiation of the business relationship" with Brookside Agra, L.C. (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶ 11). Clearly, however, Tamames III knew Patee from his work for Citrex before 1994. The record shows that Patee, representing Agra Partners, was involved in negotiations with Tamames III in his capacity as a representative of Citrex, Inc., in 1993 and 1994. (Plf. Exs. 35-38; Tamames III 2/11/99 Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 20-26). These negotiations involved a two-day trip by Tamames III to Des Moines to meet with Patee in 1993. ( Id.). Although the record does not reveal how Patee and Riesenberg became partners in Brookside Agra, L.C., a letter from Patee to Tamames III at Citrex in December of 1993 references the fact that Patee and Riesenberg were talking to each other about their dealings with Citrex. (Plf. Ex. 35).
Special Nutrients contends that the negotiations between Citrex and Agra Partners do not constitute a contact between Special Nutrients and Iowa because Citrex and Special Nutrients were "wholly separate," because Citrex was owned by companies in Brazil and Canada which did not own Special Nutrients, and because the negotiations between Citrex and Agra Partners were not related to Flo-Bond. (Tamames III 2/11/99 Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 2, 22-26; Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 37-38). Brookside disputes this evidence on the basis that Patee understood Citrex and Special Nutrients were "related companies with identical ownership and officers." (Patee Aff. ¶ 9).
The parties also dispute who made the initial contact between Brookside Agra and Special Nutrients. Brookside claims that in late 1993, Tamames II initiated the relationship between Brookside Agra and Special Nutrients by proposing to Riesenberg that Special Nutrients buy Flo-Bond from Brookside and resell it overseas. (Riesenberg Aff. ¶ 3; Patee Aff. ¶ 5). Tamames II states that Riesenberg initiated the contact. (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 3-4).
Negotiations/Distribution and Sales Agreement. However the initial contact between Special Nutrients and Brookside Agra, L.C., was made, Patee states that he became involved in the negotiations leading to the formation of the business relationship between the two companies. (Patee Aff. ¶ 6). Patee describes the negotiations as follows:
These negotiations included numerous telephone calls, correspondence, and faxes. I was physically located in Iowa during the vast majority of these negotiations and communications. Many of the phone calls were placed by Tamames II and Tamames III to me in Iowa. Many of the correspondence [sic] and faxes were sent by Tamames II and Tamames III to me at my Iowa office to my Iowa fax machine. At all times, Tamames II and Tamames III were aware that I was located in Iowa, that they were sending communications to me in Iowa, and that Brookside was an Iowa company.
(Patee Aff. ¶ 6). Patee states that these negotiations led to an agreement in May of 1994 under which "Special Nutrients agreed to buy Flo-Bond from Brookside Agra and resell it to overseas customers." (Patee Aff. ¶ 6).
Although Special Nutrients disputes that Patee was involved in these initial negotiations with Special Nutrients, (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 8-9, 11; Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 8-9, 11), the court must accept Patee's affidavit as true under the applicable standard of review.
Special Nutrients contends, however, that the agreement between Special Nutrients and Brookside did not involve significant Iowa contacts. As evidence, Special Nutrients has submitted a copy of an "Exclusive Distribution and Sales Agreement," dated May 27, 1994, signed by Riesenberg as "President" of Brookside Agra. (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶ 12, Ex. B). Tamames II states that Riesenberg traveled to Miami for the signing of this agreement. ( Id.). Brookside has not produced any evidence to call into question the validity of this agreement or Riesenberg's signature on the agreement. Under the agreement, Special Nutrients received the exclusive rights to sell Flo-Bond "in any country in Latin America and Caribbean with the exception of Trinidad." (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶ 12, Ex. B). In return, Special Nutrients promised to use its best efforts to promote, market, and sell Flo-Bond in those countries under the trade name Myco-Ad. ( Id.). The agreement states it was made "under the laws of the State of Florida." ( Id.). The contract identified Brookside Agra, L.C., as "a U.S.A. corporation" and Special Nutrients as "a Florida corporation." ( Id.). The contract did not make any mention or reference to Iowa. ( Id.).
On December 7, 1995, Tamames II purported to give a personal guarantee on any payments owed to Brookside by Special Nutrients. (Plf. Ex. 1). This personal guarantee was given by Tamames II in a letter to Brookside Agra, L.C., in Highland, Illinois, with the notation "Attn: Mr. Donald Riesenberg, President." ( Id.).
Ongoing Business Relationship. Under the agreement, Special Nutrients ordered Flo-Bond from Brookside, typically through Brookside's office in Highland, Illinois, which then arranged for the shipment of Flo-Bond from Texas to international purchasers under the trade name Myco-Ad. (Patee Aff. ¶ 10; Riesenberg Aff. ¶ 6; Brunson Aff. ¶ 7).
Nonetheless, Brookside claims that Special Nutrients had extensive contacts with it in Iowa during the performance of the contract. Patee states that he "was primarily responsible for negotiating the terms of the [ongoing] business relationship between Brookside and Special Nutrients," including price negotiations. (Patee Aff. ¶ 8). Patee conducted most of these negotiations from his Consumers Supply offices in Sioux City, Iowa. (Patee Aff. ¶ 7). Patee estimates he spoke by telephone with Tamames II about Special Nutrients approximately 8-10 times per year, or a total of 40-50 calls, and exchanged approximately the same number of faxes related to Special Nutrients. (Patee Aff. ¶ 8). Documentary evidence in the record shows that Special Nutrients contacted Patee in Iowa about pricing and other issues under the Brookside-Special Nutrients agreement. (Plf. Exs. 4, 12, 13, 20, 21). In addition, Patee was copied on various correspondence to Riesenberg. (Plf. Exs. 10, 22). Other documents show that Patee contacted Special Nutrients out of his Consumers Supply office in Sioux City about pricing and other issues under the Brookside-Special Nutrients agreement. (Plf. Exs. 5, 8, 11).
Although Special Nutrients claims that most of its contacts were with Don Riesenberg in Highland, Illinois, the defendants acknowledge that Patee began to handle price issues for Brookside beginning in 1996 and that "occasionally, it was necessary for Special Nutrients to contact Patee directly by fax, telephone, or mail." (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 16-18).
Brunson states he handled invoicing and accounting for Brookside Agra, L.C., out of his Wholesale Feeds offices in Cedar Rapids and Marion, Iowa. (Brunson Aff. ¶¶ 6, 8). Specifically, Brunson states his office was responsible for communicating with Special Nutrients about billing and payment issues. (Brunson Aff. ¶ 9). Brunson estimates his office communicated with Special Nutrients about billing and payment issues once or twice per month from 1994 to 1998, about half of the contacts initiated by his office and half initiated by Special Nutrients. (Brunson Aff. ¶ 9). Some of Special Nutrients' correspondence to Brookside was copied to Brunson. (Plf. Ex. 10). In addition, in a letter from Riesenberg to Special Nutrients on November 6, 1998, Riesenberg noted that accounts were being handled in Marion, Iowa. (Plf. Ex. 24).
Although Tamames III contends that Brookside sent all invoices from Illinois and that Special Nutrients sent all purchase orders to Illinois, (Tamames III 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 14-15, 21), Special Nutrients acknowledges that Brookside directed all invoices to be paid to a post office box, and later a bank account, in Iowa. ( Id. ¶ 20).
1998 Price Negotiations. On December 3 and 4, 1997, Tamames II and Tamames III traveled to Cedar Rapids, Iowa, to meet with Brunson, and Riesenberg. Patee did not attend this meeting. Brunson states that the purpose of the meeting was to negotiate an agreement on prices for 1998 in addition to hearing Special Nutrients' proposal that Brookside buy out Special Nutrients over a period of years. (Brunson Aff. ¶ 10). Brunson contends that the 1998 price agreement was "negotiated into in Iowa and entered into in Iowa." (Brunson Aff. ¶ 11).
In internal correspondence before the meeting, dated November 28, 1997, Riesenberg wrote to Brunson:
The topics that will be planned for discussion will be marketing, sales, bags, technical information about both products. In addition, Fernando II has indicated that he may want to explore the possibility of Brookside buying out Special Nutrients. In Fernando II's words, he wants to think about retiring and or slowing down. He does not feel that he has anyone in their business who can actually operate the day to day business. . . .
Please let Dave [Patee] know that the meeting is firmed up, and that if possible he should attend, in lieu [sic] of the discussion on a possible acquisition or some business arrangement.
(Plf. Ex. 15). Similarly, a facsimile from Special Nutrients to Riesenberg, Patee, and Brunson, dated November 13, 1997, stated that "some of the subjects" for the meeting were "How can we work together in the future," "What objectives will the company have for `98 and `99," and "Method of evaluating stock." (Plf. Ex. 14). At the meeting, the parties entered a confidentiality agreement about information exchanged "for the sole purpose of examining the feasibility of the consolidation of Special Nutrients, Inc., with Brookside Agra, L.C." (Plf. Ex. 16).
Exhibit 14 is a copy of a handwritten facsimile. Parts of the exhibit are illegible, but do not appear to address pricing issues.
The agreement was written on Brookside letterhead, with a Highland, Illinois, address, and signed by Riesenberg as Brookside's "President." ( Id.).
Tamames II states that sole purpose of the two-day visit to Iowa in December, 1997, was to discuss with Brookside the possibility of establishing a joint venture, and that pricing was not discussed. (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 24-28). Tamames II states that pricing arrangements for 1998 were negotiated in an exchange of correspondence between himself and Patee between December 12, 1997, and December 29, 1997. ( Id. ¶¶ 30-35, Exs. D-H). In a letter dated December 19, 1997, faxed from "David Patee/Brookside" on a Consumers Supply "fax form" to Tamames II, Patee referred to negotiations "last week" and "yesterday," but did not mention the meeting in Cedar Rapids. (Ex. F). The pricing agreement was finally signed in Florida by Special Nutrients on December 31, 1997. (Tamames II 3/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 26, 35).
Final Breakdown. The relationship between Brookside and Special Nutrients ended in November of 1998. On November 6, 1998, Tamames II wrote to Riesenberg that, based on sales volumes, Special Nutrients was entitled to a volume rebate of $330,720 for sales from 1995, 1996, and 1997. Tamames II sent an invoice for that amount. In his letter, Tamames II asked for a response by November 20, 1998. (Plf. Exs. 25, 26).
On November 20, 1998, Tamames II again wrote to Riesenberg asking for a response. (Plf. Ex. 27). Tamames II sent a copy of this letter to Patee and Brunson, noting that a copy had been hand delivered to Riesenberg in Germany. (Plf. Ex. 28). Tamames II said this was his third request for a reply. ( Id.).
On November 24, 1998, Patee faxed a letter to Tamames II offering pricing for Flo-Bond for 1999. (Plf. Ex. 29). Tamames II responded with a fax to Patee, addressed to Brookside Agra in Highland, Illinois, complaining that Patee's letter did not address Tamames II's demand for a $330,720 rebate. (Plf. Ex. 31). On November 25, 1998, Patee responded with a letter which stated:
It seems that every November we have to exchange a series of semi-threatening letters before we can go on to another year[']s business. Every year I can look forward to letters with thinly veiled threats, meaningless self imposed deadlines and requests for large sums of money to satisfy claims that don't exist.
When you brought up the 1994 claim last year we told you that it had no merit whatsoever. We agreed last year when we made significant price concessions that we wouldn't have to hear about any old business real or imagined from years past. But, here we go again.
I know you have discussed the details of why you have no claim with Don Riesenberg. But, for the record, I will state our opinion one more time. We recognize no claim based on previous pricing and will not consider any payments to Special Nutrients that have to do with such a claim by you.
I think we need to move on once and for all. You have in hand our offer for clay pricing starting 1-1-1999. We will need a signed copy faxed to us by 5:00 p.m. CST November 25, 1998 or our offer of pricing at these rates is withdrawn.
(Plf. Ex. 30). On November 30, 1998, Tamames II wrote to Patee and Riesenberg at the Highland, Illinois office that Special Nutrients considered its claim legitimate and that it had debited Brookside's account, leaving Brookside with an unpaid balance of $163,131.50 ($330,720.00 less $167,588.50, the amount which Special Nutrients owed Brookside). (Plf. Ex. 32).
Apparently, Riesenberg wrote to Tamames on November 26, 1998, but this correspondence does not appear in the record.
Brookside filed this lawsuit on December 28, 1998, alleging that between October 7, 1998, and November 30, 1998, Brookside delivered $167,587.50 in goods and materials to Special Nutrients, for which Brookside was not paid and was told it would not be paid within the 90 days required by their agreement. (Pet. ¶¶ 6, 8, 12, 19).
After this lawsuit was commenced, Don Riesenberg wrote to international distributors who sold Myco-Ad supplied by Special Nutrients to offer them Flo-Bond "directly." (Tamames III 4/15/99 3rd Supp. Aff. ¶ 3, Exs. B-D). In these letters, Riesenberg represented himself as "president" of "Brookside Agra, of Highland, Illinois (USA)." (Tamames III 4/15/99 3rd Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 6-7, Exs. B-D).
Special Nutrients has also filed suit against Brookside in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida alleging breach of contract. In that lawsuit, Brookside has filed a counterclaim substantially similar to its claims in this court. (Tamames III 4/15/99 3rd Supp. Aff. ¶ 3, Ex. A).
Analysis
In deciding whether this court has personal jurisdiction over the defendants, the court must address (1) whether Iowa would allow a state court to exercise jurisdiction over them and (2) whether the exercise of jurisdiction would violate the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Guinness Import Co. v. Mark VII Distributors, Inc., 153 F.3d 607, 613 (8th Cir. 1998). Because Iowa allows personal jurisdiction to the fullest extent allowed by the Constitution, Bell v. Fischer, 887 F. Supp. 1269, 1277 (N.D. Iowa 1995) (Bennett, J.) (citing Larsen v. Scholl, 296 N.W.2d 785, 788 (1980)), the question is whether exercising jurisdiction over the defendants in Iowa is consistent with due process under the circumstances of this case.
Due process prohibits the exercise of jurisdiction over a nonresident defendant unless the defendant has "`minimum contacts' with the forum state such that the maintenance of a suit against that defendant does not offend `traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.'" Guinness Import, 153 F.3d at 613-14 (quoting International Shoe v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 316 (1945)) (internal quotations omitted). "Minimum contacts" requires "`some act by which the defendant purposely avails itself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum State, thus invoking the benefits and protections of its laws.'" Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz, 471 U.S. 462, 475 (1985) (quoting Hanson v. Deckla, 357 U.S. 235, 253 (1958)).
The Supreme Court has developed two theories for evaluating minimum contacts: general jurisdiction and specific jurisdiction. Under the doctrine of general jurisdiction, a court may hear a lawsuit against a defendant who has "continuous and systematic" contacts with the forum state, even if the injuries at issue in the lawsuit did not arise out of the defendant's activities directed at the forum. Helicopteros Nacionales de Columbia, S.A. v. Hall, 466 U.S. 408, 416 (1984); Perkins v. Benquet Consolidated Mining Co., 342 U.S. 437, 445-47 (1952); Morris v. Barkbuster, Inc., 923 F.2d 1277, 1280-81 (8th Cir. 1991). Under the doctrine of specific jurisdiction, however, the plaintiff needs to show only that "`the defendant has purposely directed its activities at forum residents, and the litigation results from injuries arising out of, or relating to, those activities.'" Guinness Import, 153 F.3d at 614 (quoting Burlington Indus., Inc. v. Maples Indus., 97 F.3d 1100, 1102 (8th Cir. 1996)); Dean v. Olibas, 129 F.3d 1001, 1004 (8th Cir. 1997) (same); see also Burger King, 471 U.S. at 472-73.
"Once it has been decided that a defendant purposefully established minimum contacts with the forum state, these contacts may be considered in light of other factors to determine whether the assertion of personal jurisdiction would comport with `fair play and substantial justice.'" Burger King, 471 U.S. at 476. These factors include the burden on the defendant, the interests of the forum state, the plaintiff's interests, judicial economy, and multi-state public policy concerns. Id. at 477 (citing World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, 444 U.S. 286, 292 (1980)). Thus, as the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has explained, five main factors control the personal jurisdictional inquiry: (1) the nature and quality of the defendant's contacts with the forum state; (2) quantity of contacts; (3) source and connection of the cause of action with those contacts; (4) the interests of the forum state; and (5) the convenience of the parties. Guinness Import, 153 F.3d at 614; Burlington Indus. v. Maples Indus., 97 F.3d 1100, 1102 (8th Cir. 1996). Of these five factors, the last two — the interests of the forum state and convenience of the parties — are of secondary importance. Digi-Tel Holdings, 89 F.3d at 523.
Applying these factors in this case, the court finds that Brookside has submitted sufficient evidence to create a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction over the defendants. Although largely disputed by the defendants, the record reveals a number of contacts, some of which are of high quality and are related to the cause of action. As stated above, the court must view the record in the light most favorable to Brookside and give Brookside the benefit of all reasonable inferences. Viewed in this manner, the record shows that:
• In 1993, Tamames III traveled to Iowa on behalf of Citrex to meet with Patee in his capacity as 50% owner of Agra Partners. At some point, however, Tamames III told Patee that he also represented Special Nutrients, just as Patee later gave the impression that he was working with Riesenberg.
• In 1994, Patee was actively involved in negotiations between Brookside and Special Nutrients. The negotiations involved frequent contact with Patee's offices in Sioux City, Iowa, via telephone and facsimile.
• In May of 1994, Special Nutrients and Brookside entered an exclusive distribution and sales agreement. Although the agreement did not expressly mention Iowa, Special Nutrients knew that Brookside was an Iowa company and that, based on the course of negotiations, Patee was an active owner of Brookside who would have an ongoing role.
• During the relationship, Patee was primarily responsible for negotiating prices and other ongoing terms of the relationship. As a result, Special Nutrients contacted Patee in Iowa via telephone and facsimile as many as ten times a year for more than four years.
• During the relationship, payments were sent to Iowa and questions regarding billing and payment issues were handled by Brunson out of his offices in Cedar Rapids and Marion, Iowa.
• In December, 1997, Tamames II and Tamames III traveled to Iowa to meet with Brunson and Riesenberg for two days. Although the record is clear that this meeting did not focus exclusively on price issues for 1998, the meeting did address aspects of the relationship between Brookside and Special Nutrients other than Tamames II's proposal to sell Special Nutrients to Brookside.
• In December, 1997, Tamames II in Florida and Patee in Iowa negotiated via telephone and facsimile over 1998 prices.
• In November, 1998, Tamames II solicited a response from Patee and Brunson in Iowa about Special Nutrients' claim for $330,720 by sending them copies of his correspondence with Riesenberg, and actually received a response from Patee.
These contacts, if proved, would be sufficient to establish this court's jurisdiction over the defendants under the doctrine of specific jurisdiction. In Burger King, the Supreme Court held that Florida could exercise specific jurisdiction over a nonresident defendant who owned and operated a franchise in Michigan for a restaurant chain based in Florida. Although the franchisee had never traveled to Florida, the franchisee's contacts with Florida included (1) negotiating with a Florida corporation, (2) entering a contract which called for a 20-year relationship with the Florida corporation, (3) sending payments to Florida, and (4) reporting franchise information to Florida. 471 U.S. at 479-81. The Court reasoned that the mere existence of a contract with a Florida corporation was not enough to subject the defendant to personal jurisdiction in Florida, but the negotiation of the contract and the expected performance under the contract showed that the defendant had sufficient contacts with Florida to support personal jurisdiction. Id.
Because the court concludes that Brookside has set forth a prima facie case of specific jurisdiction, there is no need for the court to address the question of general jurisdiction. As the defendants point out, however, Special Nutrients does not do business, sell products, ship products, maintain an office, maintain a bank account, employ a distributor, employ a business agent, own any property, or advertise in any manner directed specifically at Iowa. (Tamames II 2/11/99 Aff. ¶¶ 12-16). Therefore, the court doubts that the plaintiff could establish a prima facie case of general jurisdiction over the defendants.
In this case, like Burger King, there is evidence that Special Nutrients and Tamames II negotiated with an Iowa company, knowing it was an Iowa company. Although the contract did not expressly call for a long-term relationship with Iowa, that was in fact what was contemplated by the parties and what actually happened. Viewed in the light most favorable to Brookside, the record shows that Special Nutrients knew Patee was a full participant in the company and that Special Nutrients actually negotiated price and other issues with Patee in Sioux City and sent payments to a post office box and bank in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. Although the letters and facsimiles which Special Nutrients sent to Iowa, by themselves, are not enough to establish personal jurisdiction, see Northrup King, 51 F.3d at 1388, the fact that Tamames II and Tamames III traveled to Cedar Rapids in 1997 to discuss important aspects of the business relationship — when combined with the letters, facsimiles, payments, negotiations, and telephone calls — shows that Special Nutrients purposely availed itself of conducting activities within Iowa in connection with its distribution and sales agreement with Brookside.
The court's conclusion that the plaintiffs have set forth a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction is bolstered by the fact that Tamames III traveled to Iowa in 1993, as a representative of Citrex, but led Patee to believe that Citrex and Special Nutrients were related companies with identical ownership. Although the contours of when one party's conduct may be attributed to another for purposes of personal jurisdiction has not been firmly defined by the Supreme Court, the Court has recognized that some conduct may be attributed to other party's for purposes of determining minimum contacts with the forum state. Burger King, 471 U.S. at 479 n. 22. Viewing the record in the light most favorable to Brookside, it appears that the 1993 visit by Tamames III could be seen as being directed by or for the primary benefit of Special Nutrients and Tamames II, and therefore, would support the exercise of personal jurisdiction over the defendants. Digi-Tel Holdings, 89 F.3d at 523-24.
The other "secondary" factors do not alter or undermine this conclusion. Iowa has an obvious interest in providing a local forum for its resident corporations. See Digi-Tel Holdings, 89 F.3d at 525. The convenience of the parties does not favor either party: it will be as inconvenient for Special Nutrients to litigate in Iowa as it would be for Brookside to litigate in Florida. See id.
The court recognizes that there is substantial evidence in the record that both Special Nutrients and Brookside treated Riesenberg's office in Highland, Illinois as Brookside's headquarters. (Plf. Exs. 1, 7, 15, 16, 22, 23, 26, 27, 31, 32; Tamames III 4/15/99 3rd Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 6-7, Exs. B-D). In Burger King, the court held that jurisdiction in Florida was not defeated by the fact that Burger King maintained a regional district office in Birmingham, Michigan. 471 U.S. at 480-81. The Court reasoned that the parties' course of dealing showed that the franchisee often had to contact Florida for certain decisions to be resolved. Id. Similarly, Brookside claims that price and other issues were negotiated by Patee in Iowa. To meet with Brookside, Tamames II and Tamames III traveled to Iowa. Furthermore, Tamames II sent copies of the key correspondence in November of 1998 to Patee and Brunson and received Brookside's response from Patee. The fact that Special Nutrients believed Brookside's headquarters was Highland, Illinois, weighs against jurisdiction in this court, but at this stage of proceedings and with the current record, it is not enough to defeat jurisdiction in Iowa.
The defendants also argue that the original contract was signed in Florida and states that it was made "under the laws of the State of Florida." It is true that, in Burger King, the Court upheld personal jurisdiction in Florida over the nonresident franchisee based in part on the fact that the franchise agreement contained a choice of law provision which provided that Florida law governed the construction and application of the contract. 471 U.S. at 481-82. However, "a choice of law provision standing alone cannot . . . defeat jurisdiction," so long as there are sufficient minimum contacts with another jurisdiction to support personal jurisdiction. E.g., McDonald's Corp. v. Bukele, 960 F. Supp. 1311, 1315 (N.D. Ill. 1997). In this case, Brookside has made a prima facie showing of sufficient minimum contacts to exercise jurisdiction in Iowa.
Finally, the defendants rely on Sybaritic, Inc. v. Interport Int'l, Inc., 957 F.2d 522 (8th Cir. 1992), to contend that their visits to Iowa were too few in number and too slight in quality to confer jurisdiction over them in this court. Although there are similarities between Sybaritic and this case, Sybaritic is distinguishable. In Sybaritic, the only contacts with the forum state were a single preliminary visit by the president of the non-resident corporation and a few months of communication between the parties. Id. at 523. The contract which gave rise to the lawsuit was ultimately negotiated, drafted, and allegedly executed in Japan. Id. The court concluded that the contacts with the forum state were "too few in number and too attenuated from the cause of action to support jurisdiction." Id. at 525. In this case, by contrast, the parties established a business relationship that involved the forum state for more than four years, including some contacts that are directly related to the cause of action (i.e., price negotiations with Patee and Patee's rejection of Special Nutrients' claim for $330,720). Therefore, the court concludes that Brookside has established a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction.
ORDER
For the foregoing reasons, the defendants' motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction (Doc. #8) is DENIED.
Alert