Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

IN RE DBH LIMITED, INC., (W.D.Tenn. 2000)

United States District Court, W.D. Tennessee, Eastern Division.
Mar 17, 2000
ORDER AFFIRMING DECISION OF BANKRUPTCY COURT

JAMES TODD, Chief Judge, District

On May 16, 1997, three petitioning creditors, including AZUR-US, Inc. (AZUR), filed an involuntary chapter 7 bankruptcy petition against the Debtor, DBH Limited, Inc., in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of Tennessee. On July 7, 1997, the Debtor filed both a motion to dismiss the petition and a motion for a change of venue. On January 6, 1998, the bankruptcy court granted the motion for change of venue, and the case was transferred to the Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Tennessee, Eastern Division. The motion to dismiss the petition was renewed by the Debtor, and the Bankruptcy Court for the Western District granted the motion for dismissal on September 21, 1998.

AZUR-US appealed the dismissal of the petition to this court, which affirmed the bankruptcy court's decision on June 10, 1999. In re DBH Limited, Inc., #98-1303. An appeal is currently pending before the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

The Debtor filed a motion for attorney fees and costs pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 303(i) on October 23, 1998, which was opposed by AZUR. The Bankruptcy Court denied the motion on January 29, 1999. A motion for reconsideration was filed, which was denied on March 29, 1999. The Debtor then filed this appeal, and the record was transmitted to this Court on May 6, 1999.

The Debtor filed a brief pursuant to F.R.Bankr.P. 8009, but no brief was filed by AZUR within the allotted time period. On August 2, 1999, the Court remanded the case to the Bankruptcy Court for additional findings. The Court noted that in denying the motion for attorney's fees and costs, the Bankruptcy Court had relied, in part, upon the Debtor's failure to promptly provide AZUR with a list of creditors after having been ordered to do so. That statement appeared to be erroneous. However, as the Bankruptcy Court stated that the ruling was based upon the totality of the circumstances, the Court remanded for clarification as to what other circumstances were relied upon in the decision to deny the motion. The Bankruptcy Court issued its additional findings on August 11, 1999, and this Court then allowed both parties to file supplemental briefs.

Following the order of remand, Nader Baydoun, counsel for AZUR, contacted the court and advised that neither he nor his co-counsel had received a copy of the notice of appeal, or any other documents thereafter, including the Debtor's brief. Counsel for the Debtor, however, assured Mr. Baydoun that he had served copies of every filing on both Baydoun and his co-counsel, and did not know why they had not received them.

A district court should not overturn the factual findings of a bankruptcy court on appeal unless they are clearly erroneous. F.R.Bankr.P. 8013. See In re Southern Indus. Banking Corp., 809 F.2d 329, 331 (6th Cir. 1987); In re H S Transp. Co., 110 B.R. 827, 829 (Bankr. M.D. Tenn. 1990). Therefore, when a judge's inferences are reasonable and supported by the evidence, they will not be disturbed. Southern Indus., 809 F.2d at 829. However, questions of law are reviewed de novo. See In re Tudor Assocs., Ltd., 20 F.3d 115, 119 (4th Cir. 1994).

Following the dismissal of an involuntary petition, a bankruptcy court has the discretion to award the debtor costs and/or "a reasonable attorney's fee." 11 U.S.C. § 303(i)(1). A finding that the petition was filed in bad faith, while relevant, is not necessary for such an award, and the court should make its determination based on the totality of the circumstances. See In re Ross, 135 B.R. 230, 237 (Bankr. E.D. Pa. 1991); see also In re Scrap Metal Buyers of Tampa, Inc., 233 B.R. 162, 164-65 (Bankr. M.D. Fla. 1999); In re Gills Creek Parkway Assocs., L.P., 194 B.R. 59 (Bankr. D.S.C. 1995). There is no allegation that the petition in this case was filed in bad faith.

A determination that the petition was filed in bad faith is necessary under § 303(i)(2), which authorizes an award of compensatory and/or punitive damages. The Debtor did not seek such damages in this case.

As noted in the order of remand, the Bankruptcy Court stated, in the order initially denying the Debtor's motion for attorney's fees and costs:

the Court had to order the debtors to provide the petitioners with a list of creditors. The debtor drug its feet in so doing. As a result of this delay, the Court had to postpone the trial on the motion to dismiss. This continuance caused not only the debtors additional costs and fees but also the creditors. Had the debtor been forthright and provided the list when first requested, the case would have concluded more quickly and the fees and costs would have been substantially less.

In its additional findings of fact, the Bankruptcy Court stated:

At the original [May 20, 1998] setting for this motion [to dismiss], the attorney for the petitioners told the Court that their repeated requests for a list of DBH's creditors had gone unanswered. When the debtor's representatives began testifying, it became apparent that the petitioners' assertion was indeed true. As a result, the Court reset the hearing for June 24, 1998, and orally ordered DBH to turn over the list of creditors to the petitioners prior to that date.
At the June 24, 1998, hearing . . . the core issue in dispute was the number of creditors the debtor had at the time of the filing of the involuntary petition. It was established through the testimony at this hearing that, the debtors had seventeen creditors at the time of filing; however, the testimony also established that DBH selectively paid off several creditors during the pendency of the case, such that at the time the Court heard the motion to dismiss, there were less than twelve creditors.
At the hearing on DBH's motion for attorney's fees, the Court reviewed the entire history of the case prior to ruling on the motion. The Court considered the fact that had DBH cooperated and promptly provided an accurate list of creditors after the filing, the case probably would never have been transferred. Instead DBH chose to withhold the single most important item of evidence. The Court further considered the fact that at the time of filing, DBH was in fact insolvent and further that they were not paying their debts timely. The only dispute ever in the case was whether there needed to be one or three petitioning creditors and if three were needed, were the three who petitioned holding undisputed claims. This fact was not ascertainable until DBH finally provided the list of creditors, some thirteen (13) months after the case filing. (Emphasis added).

The complete transcript of the May 20, 1998, hearing has been made a part of the record in this appeal. The transcript shows that the Bankruptcy Court was concerned not with the Debtor's failure to provide a list of creditors at all, since it clearly had, but with the failure to provide a current list, along with the documentation that was needed to verify the accuracy of the list. The Bankruptcy Court noted that a discovery request for the necessary documentation had been made at least five months previously, but there had been no response from the Debtor. Instead, counsel attempted to introduce the documents at the trial without opposing counsel having had adequate time to examine them.

The Court: Mr. Teel, he has asked for these in discovery and didn't get them. How long ago did you ask for them, Mr. Baydoun?

Baydoun: Months, your honor.

The Court: This hearing in Nashville was in December, Mr. Teel. Now this is May, the end of May, five months, and now you want to give him five minutes. Do you think that is fair? Put yourself in his position. . . . I am going to give you a month. I want the documents copied and served to him like they were requested. It is even in here where he asked for them, in this transcript of the hearing to transfer this case. . . .
The Court: . . . There has been a request made for production of documents months ago, and now we come in here with them wrapped up in a rubber band saying, "Well, we didn't have a chance to give them to you." . . .
So I am telling you we are going to take this up on June the 24th, and I want the documents produced, I want any other documents produced. I want any other list of creditors. He asked for a list of creditors and now we are saying, well, we got creditors, we don't have creditors. I want to know where they are paid. I see on this list here of creditors, this DBH Attachments is shown as a creditor. Well, if they have been paid by foreclosure on the assets of this, they are not a creditor anymore. I want a current list provided to the petitioner of all of the creditors with addresses and amounts and copies of any invoices or any other related documents that they have. . . .

(Tr. Hrg., May 20, 1998, at 25-28).

Although the Bankruptcy Court perhaps misspoke when it implied that the Debtor had not provided a list of creditors at all, the Court went on to explain that it was the failure to provide an accurate list of creditors in a timely fashion that caused substantial delay in the disposition of the petition. In assessing the totality of the circumstances, the Bankruptcy Court relied upon this fact, along with the evidence that the Debtor was insolvent and was not paying its debts on time. The Bankruptcy Court also stated that it was established that the Debtor had transferred all of its assets to avoid paying the judgment that AZUR had obtained against it. In addition, the Debtor selectively paid off several of its creditors after the petition was filed, so that there were actually fewer than twelve creditors at the time the Court heard the motion to dismiss.

The Court concludes that the Bankruptcy Court's denial of the Debtor's motion for attorney's fees and costs was not based on factual findings that were clearly erroneous, and was not an abuse of discretion. Therefore, the decision of the Bankruptcy Court is AFFIRMED.

IT IS SO ORDERED.