- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
McCABE v. FARMERS INSURANCE CO
B. LYNN WINMILL, Chief U.S. District Judge.
In accordance with the Memorandum Decision filed with this Judgment,
NOW THEREFORE IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED, that the Judgment (docket no. 66) previously entered in this case is hereby reaffirmed in its entirety, and amended by the addition of the following.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED, that the motion for attorney fees (docket no. 69) is hereby GRANTED, and the defendant shall have from the plaintiffs the sum of $75,173 for attorney fees.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED, that the motion to retax costs (docket no. 74) is hereby GRANTED, and that the sum of $329 be added to the award of costs, making a total award of costs in the amount of $1,834.91.
MEMORANDUM DECISION
The Court has before it Farmer's petition for attorney fees and its motion to re-tax costs. The Court will turn first to the petition for fees. Farmers seeks fees only against defendant Bernard McCabe on his breach of contract claim. Farmers has segregated those fees incurred in defending this claim from the fees incurred in defending his other claims and those of Carolyn McCabe.
The facts of this case have been set forth in prior decisions and will not be repeated here.
Farmers prevailed in this case. Under Idaho Code § 12-120(3), Farmers is entitled to fees against Bernard McCabe if Farmers can show that the gravamen of the claim it successfully defended was a claim for breach of a contract for services. Here, Bernard McCabe sued under both breach of contract and tortious interference theories. His breach of contract theory had two parts. First, he claimed that Farmers improperly terminated his Agency Appointment Agreement for cause when no cause existed. Second, be claimed that Farmers improperly refused to transfer the agency to his wife, Carolyn.
The Court dismissed this second part of the breach of contract claim after Bernard McCabe conceded at oral argument during a hearing on pending motions that he suffered no damage from that alleged breach. That left only McCabe's breach of contract claim that he had been wrongfully fired for cause under his Agency Appointment Agreement. That Agreement was clearly a contract for the provision of services. Thus, when Farmer's successfully defeated that claim, Farmers became entitled to the fees it incurred pursuant to I.C. § 12-120(3).
McCabe argues that the gravamen of his suit was his claim in tort for the failure of Farmers to transfer the agency to Carolyn. But McCabe also postured that claim as a breach of contract claim, and required Farmers to file a summary judgment motion on that claim after the end of discovery before conceding that he had no damages. McCabe then pursued his remaining breach of contract claim right through trial. In fact, the jury instructions he submitted left Carolyn as the sole plaintiff seeking to assert a tort claim. His only claim according to his proposed jury instructions was for breach of contract. Under these circumstances, the gravamen of Bernard McCabe's claim was for breach of contract.
McCabe argues next that he was an independent contractor, and thus his claim did not involve an employment agreement for services. Idaho Code § 12-120(3) discusses contracts for services; it makes no distinction between whether those services are performed by an employee or an independent contractor. The Court therefore finds this argument unpersuasive.
Finally, McCabe asserts that the fees sought are unreasonable, and that it was impossible for Farmer's to accurately segregate its fees to isolate only those fees incurred in defending his breach of contract claim. Farmers incurred total fees in the sum of $90,786, of which $75,173 were attributable to the breach of contract claims. This means that 83% of the fees incurred by Farmers were for defending the breach of contract claims. This accords with the Court's view of the case. In addition, the time sheets submitted by Farmers in its Verification show a high level of detail, allowing Farmers to segregate its fees according to the various claims. The level of detail in these time sheets was far greater than what the Court sees typically.
The Court therefore finds that Farmers is entitled to fees under I.C. § 12-120(3). The Court further finds that the hourly rates and sums sought are reasonable and in line with the community standards for fees. The Court will therefore award Farmers the sum of $75,173 in fees.
The Court also has before it a motion to re-tax costs filed by Farmers, seeking an additional $329 in costs. There was no objection filed to the motion, and the motion appears well-taken. The Court will therefore add $329 to the cost award. The Court will award these additional costs and the attorney fees in a separate Amended Judgment as required by Rule 58,
Alert