LYLES et al. v. COLLINS

Messrs. Johnson Johnson, for appellant, cite: When counterclaim allowed: 10 S.C. 464; 21 S.C. 290; 43 S.C. 65; 55 S.C. 528. As to demurrer: 49 C.J., 362; 83 Va., 26; 1 S.E., 395; 52 S.E., 454; 150 S.C. 476; 148 S.E., 476; 149 S.C. 163; 146 S.E., 818; 148 S.C. 446; 146 S.E., 420; 144 S.C. 205; 142 S.E., 496; 93 S.C. 467; 77 S.E., 51; Ann Cas., 1914-C, 989; 27 S.C. 107; 2 S.E., 846; 13 A.S.R., 628; 4 S.C.L., 451. Messrs. Osborne Butler, for respondents, cite: Where persons contract jointly they must be sued jointly: 55 S.C. 535; 3 Brevard, 261; 13 C.J., 573; 6 R.C.L., 878, 875; 57 C.J., 455; 55 S.C. 540.