SARATOGA CTY. CHAMBER OF COMMERCE INC. v. PATAKI, 42 (N.Y. 6-12-2003)

Opinion by Judge Rosenblatt.

Order modified, with costs to plaintiffs, by vacating on the ground of mootness so much thereof as declared the May 27, 1999 amendment to the 1993 Tribal-State Gaming Compact void and unenforceable and, as so modified, affirmed.

Judge Smith concurs in part and dissents in part in an opinion, dissenting as to part VIII of Judge Rosenblatt's opinion.

Judge Read dissents and votes to dismiss the actions in an opinion in which Judges Wesley and Graffeo concur.