Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE CO. v. McCLOSKEY

United States District Court, N.D. Ohio, Eastern Division.
Jan 3, 2006
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

WILLIAM BAUGHMAN Jr., Magistrate Judge

I. Introduction

Metropolitan Life initiated this interpleader to determine the proper beneficiary of the life insurance policy of Ruth McCarty. Danette McCarty holds a share in the benefits of that policy under the beneficiary designation determined by this Court to be legally enforceable.

ECF # 1.

ECF # 57.

During the proceeding, this Court determined that Danette McCarty had a stake in this matter, was not represented, and was mentally incapable of protecting her interests. Consequently, pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 17(c), this Court appointed Kevin J.M. Senich her guardian ad litem.

ECF # 39.

Id.

Having determined the proper beneficiary, the Court must now address what arrangements should be made to protect Danette McCarty's award of benefits and how the guardian ad litem is to be compensated.

II. Facts and Applicable Law

The guardian ad litem here was appointed under the authority of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 17(c) which states, in part:

The court shall appoint a guardian ad litem for an infant or incompetent person not otherwise represented in an action or shall make such other order as it deems proper for the protection of the infant or incompetent person.
In his report and recommendation, the guardian ad litem stated:
The nature of Danette's disability strongly suggests that payment of an award to her directly would not be appropriate. Although she had a good general understanding of the nature of this action, she clearly had no understanding of simple, every day economics. The impression she left during the interview is that Danette has no appreciation of the value of any potential award. More disturbing is her relationship with her de facto guardian, McCloskey. McCloskey testified that his only source of income is Social Security income in the amount of some $525.00 per month. He also testified that he recently purchased from his ex-wife the home in which he and Danette reside. It strains credibility to suggest that he can operate a household budget and purchase a home without invading Danette's Social Security Disability income for his own use. Given the fact that Danette signs over to McCloskey each of her monthly disability checks, she would undoubtedly do the same with any award from this action. The conclusion is clear. As a practical consideration, any direct payment of an award to Danette would with virtual certainty result in a loss to her of some measure of the benefit of the award.

Further, the guardian ad litem reported that Danette McCarty currently has no legal guardian in Pennsylvania, where she resides. Accordingly, he recommended that any award to Danette be temporarily put into a controlled account, with withdrawals only by direct order of the Court, until a guardianship is established in the appropriate Pennsylvania court.

Id. at 4.

Id. at 5.

III. Analysis

This authority by which the guardian ad litem was appointed confers broad, but not plenary, powers on the Court. Specifically, the power to protect the interests of an incompetent party is restricted to that party's interest in the particular matter before the Court. There is no authority for the guardian ad litem to assume the role of a general guardian, since "such authority would interfere unduly with state probate and guardianship laws."

United States v. Maryans, 803 F. Supp. 1378, 1379 (N.D. Ind. 1992).

However, consistent with protecting an incompetent party's interest in a case properly before the court, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 17(c) provides that the court "shall make such order as it deems appropriate" for that party's protection.

Here, while the current guardian ad litem may not assume ongoing supervision of the affairs of Danette McCarty, it is clear that this case cannot conclude without the presence of a guardian for Danette McCarty to receive her proceeds from Ruth McCarty's insurance.

Inasmuch as the present guardian ad litem is aware of the facts and persons involved here, as well as of the appropriate court in Pennsylvania for initiating a guardianship action for Danette, it would be in Danette's interest to have the current guardian ad litem cause an action for permanent guardianship to be initiated in the appropriate state court in Pennsylvania. Resolution of such an action would then permit this case to be closed with the final payment of Danette's award under the policy to be made to Danette under the supervision of a permanent guardian.

Id.

Further, the Court finds that the authority to appoint a guardian ad litem here extends to determining the amount of any compensation due the guardian and how such amount due should be paid. The Court's determination of fees is within its discretion, and will not be overturned except for abuse.

Gaddis v. United States, 381 F.3d 444, 455 (5th Cir. 2004).

Kentucky Ass'n for Retarded Citizens, Inc. v. Conn, 674 F.2d 582, 585-86 (6th Cir. 1982).

Given that the beneficiary designation form found enforceable by this Court allocates benefits among Danette and her two brothers, Jerry and Andrew McCarty, the Court finds it appropriate that any fees owing to the guardian ad litem for his services in this matter be paid from the funds now being held by the Court before the balance is then disbursed according to the terms of the beneficiary designation form.

IV. Conclusion

Kevin J.M. Senich, Danette McCarty's guardian ad litem, is directed to take all necessary steps to commence an action for permanent guardianship of Danette McCarty in the appropriate court in Pennsylvania within thirty days.

Pending the establishment of such guardianship, all funds owing to the McCartys are to remain on deposit with this Court. No disbursements to any party will be made without an order of this Court pending establishment of that guardianship and payment of reasonable fees to the guardian ad litem.

Further, within fourteen days after the establishment of a guardianship for Danette McCarty in Pennsylvania, Kevin J.M. Senich is to file an application with this Court for reasonable fees incurred as guardian ad litem for Danette McCarty.

IT IS SO ORDERED.