- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
CAROZZA v. N.Y
After an adjudication that petitioners had been wrongfully disqualified retroactively from consideration for promotion by reason of having just been placed in new job titles ( see Matter of Carozza v City of New York, 10 AD3d 488), they were placed on promotion eligibility lists just one month before those lists expired. They immediately brought this proceeding seeking the creation of a special eligible list for them, pursuant to Civil Service Law § 56 (3), which would remain open for one year.
Petitioners' successful challenge to their disqualification was not based on a finding that an error had caused a flaw in the entire promotional process, resulting in a list that did not accurately measure the merit and fitness of those appearing thereon. Accordingly, the remedy sought herein does not comport with article V, § 6 of the New York State Constitution. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the original lists had no legal existence and thus could not have expired ( see Matter of City of New York v New York State Div. of Human Rights, 93 NY2d 768, 774-775; Matter of Deas v Levitt, 73 NY2d 525, cert denied 493 US 933 [1989]; compare Matter of Pena v New York City Civ. Serv. Commn., 27 AD3d 293, lv denied 7 NY3d 705).
Alert