Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

PAHL v. ROBINSON

United States District Court, M.D. Georgia, Columbus Division.
Sep 1, 2009
ORDER

CLAY LAND, District Judge

Below are the rulings on Defendant's Amended Objections to Plaintiffs' Deposition Designations (Doc. 116). Designation Objection Ruling Aaron Bordeau — 11:13-20 Unresponsive Overruled Tyler Morris — 11:13-21 Unresponsive Overruled Tyler Morris — 16:5-16:24 Unresponsive Overruled Tyler Morris — 16:25-17:11 Hearsay Sustained Tyler Morris — 17:12-13 Unresponsive Overruled Tyler Morris — 31:8-23 Argumentative Overruled Larry Stages — 10:5-9 Speculative Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Larry Stages — 10:10-15 Speculative Overruled Larry Stages — 13:24-14:18 Speculative Overruled Larry Stages — 15:10-13 Leading Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Larry Stages — 15:18-23 Improper Opinion Overruled Larry Stages — 18:11-27:21 Speculative Overruled Larry Stages — 43:24-44:21 Leading Overruled Larry Stages — 44:22-25 Leading Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Larry Stages — 45:1-45:6 Leading Overruled Joseph Ceravolo — 17:22-20:25 Irrelevant Overruled Joseph Ceravolo — 28:24 Misleading Overruled but with Caveat Joseph Ceravolo — 39:21-41:15 Speculative Overruled Joseph Ceravolo — 51:5-21 Legal Conclusion Overruled Joseph Ceravolo — 51:22-52:7 Legal Conclusion Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Sean Collinsworth — 9:8-20 Irrelevant Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Sean Collinsworth — 32:7-33:19 Improper Opinion Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 33:20-34:5 Improper Opinion Sustained Sean Collinsworth — 88:20-89:5 Irrelevant Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 89:6-17 Irrelevant Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Sean Collinsworth — 89:18-90:3 Irrelevant Sustained Sean Collinsworth — 99:9-20 Improper Opinion Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 106:22-107:2 Improper Opinion Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 107:17-108:2 Improper Opinion Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 108:13-109:1 Improper Opinion Overruled Sean Collinsworth — 110:17-112:2 Irrelevant Sustained Sean Collinsworth — 113:3-7 Irrelevant Withdrawn by Plaintiffs Sean Collinsworth — 113:8-24 Irrelevant Overruled IT IS SO ORDERED.

The following depositions will not be read/played at trial: (1) Dr. Alluri Raju; (2) Thomas Buff; (3) Samantha Wessner; and (4) Paul Hanover. The parties had no objections to the deposition designations of John Cox.