- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
T.H. v. JEFFERSON DEPT. OF HUMAN RESOURCES
CHARLES SIMPSON III, District Judge
Defendant Frederick Kemen, M.D., has filed a motion for summary judgment (DN 27). Plaintiff has responded. The matter being ripe, the Court will grant Defendant's motion for summary judgment for the following reasons.
In his summary-judgment motion, Defendant identifies himself as Frederick rather than Frank.
I. FACTS
Plaintiff is incarcerated at the Kentucky State Reformatory (KSR). He sued Frank W. Kemen, KSR Hospital Administrator, and KSR doctor Steven White. He stated that on November 9, 2007, he was seen by Dr. White who diagnosed a hernia. He alleged that he was told by Dr. White that the Kentucky Department of Corrections would not repair it and further alleged that he received no pain medicine or treatment. He stated that Dr. White advised him that he would be sent to physical therapy within 10 days to get a hernia belt.
Plaintiff stated that he filed two grievances and wrote a letter to Dr. Kemen about his lack of treatment and about the fact that $3.00 was deducted from his account even though he had not been treated. He stated that on November 26, 2007, he received Dr. Kemen's denial of his grievance. He states that he appealed Dr. Kemen's decision but the Health Care Committee concurred with Dr. Kemen's decision.
Attached to his complaint were several letters and grievances written by Plaintiff concerning his alleged lack of medical care for his hernia and copies of encyclopedia entries regarding hernias. Included is a November 21, 2007, letter written by Plaintiff to Dr. Kemen asking for medical treatment for his hernia. He also attached a grievance form dated November 10, 2007, with a response from Dr. Kemen as follows:
You submitted a sick call slip on 10/29/2009 because of a soft lump in the left groin. Dr. White diagnosed a small hernia that can be reduced (pushed back into place). This hernia is not a threat to your life or health. Therefore, it cannot be repaired at state expense per DOC policy. A truss or hernia belt is perfectly adequate treatment. You do, however, have the option of having your hernia repaired at your expense. Because you requested the appointment with Dr. White, you were appropriately charged a $3.00 copay, as required by DOC policy. You can buy ibuprofen or acetaminophen in the canteen.II. ANALYSIS
Summary judgment is proper "if the pleadings, the discovery and disclosure materials on file, and any affidavits show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law." FED. R. CIV. P. 56(c). The party moving for summary judgment bears the burden of demonstrating the absence of a genuine issue of material fact. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986).
The moving party's burden may be discharged by demonstrating that there is an absence of evidence to support an essential element of the nonmoving party's case for which he or she has the burden of proof. Id. Once the moving party demonstrates this lack of evidence, the burden passes to the nonmoving party to establish, after an adequate opportunity for discovery, the existence of a disputed factual element essential to his case with respect to which he bears the burden of proof. Id. If the nonmoving party will bear the burden at trial on a dispositive issue, the nonmoving party must go beyond the pleadings and by his own affidavits, "or by the depositions, answers to interrogatories, and admissions on file, designate specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial." Id. at 324 (internal quotation marks omitted, citing FED. R. CIV. P. 56(e)). If the record taken as a whole could not lead the trier of fact to find for the nonmoving party, the motion for summary judgment should be granted. Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574, 586 (1986).
Dr. Kemen argues that he is entitled to summary judgment because the only theory under which Plaintiff argues that he is liable is that Dr. Kemen was involved in the grievance process. He contends that he cannot be held liable under a theory of respondeat superior or because he participated in the grievance process. He asserts that he never provided medical care for Plaintiff and that Plaintiff has stated no facts to indicate that he was personally involved in any of the medical decisions.
In his response, Plaintiff asserts that Dr. Kemen did have a duty as a supervisor. He asserts that Defendant Kemen as a physician knew that a hernia left untreated could be serious and that he was on notice via the grievance filed by Plaintiff of Plaintiff's hernia. Therefore, Dr. Kemen had a duty, argues Plaintiff, to examine Plaintiff to better ascertain his medical condition before making his decision.
Plaintiff argues that Dr. Kemen directly participated in the grievance process, learned about the violation of his rights and failed to fix it, and allowed or encouraged the illegal acts or was grossly negligent in managing the people he was supposed to supervise. In support, Plaintiff cites Duckworth v. Franzen, 780 F.2d 645 (7th Cir. 1985). Actually, that case does not support Plaintiff's position. In addition to being from a different circuit, it reaffirms that "Section 1983 does not recognize a doctrine of superiors' liability." Duckworth, 780 F.2d at 650.
By the same token, a plaintiff cannot maintain a claim against a prison official based solely on his or her denial of the plaintiff's grievance. "The mere denial of a prisoner's grievance states no claim of constitutional dimension." Alder v. Correctional Med. Servs., 73 F. App'x. 839, 841 (6th Cir. 2003). A plaintiff's claim is against the subjects of his grievances, not those who merely decided whether to grant or deny the grievances. See, e.g., Shehee v. Luttrell, 199 F.3d 295, 300 (6th Cir. 1999) (reversing denial of summary judgment to prison officials whose only involvement was the denial of administrative remedies); Martin v. Harvey, 14 F. App'x. 307, 309 (6th Cir. 2001) ("The denial of the grievance is not the same as the denial of a request to receive medical care."). Thus, where the only allegation against a defendant relates to the denial of a grievance, a plaintiff fails to allege any personal involvement by the defendant in the alleged denial of medical treatment. Id.
Because Plaintiff's only allegations against Dr. Kemen arise out of the decision to deny his administrative grievances, Dr. Kemen is entitled to summary judgment. See Shehee, 199 F.3d at 300.
III. CONCLUSION ORDERFor the foregoing reasons, the Court GRANTS Dr. Kemen's motion for summary judgment (DN 27). The Clerk of Court is DIRECTED to terminate Dr. Kemen as a Defendant in this action.
Date: September 23, 2010
In June 2003, the parents took the child to Over the Mountain Pediatrics for evaluation by a pediatrician, Dr. Julie Dennis. Dr. Dennis referred the parents to Children's Hospital to address the child's autism and special needs. The occupational therapist who evaluated the child noted that the child enjoyed a "[s]upportive, committed family." Based on the evaluation conducted at Children's Hospital in July 2003, the child began receiving occupational therapy through Children's Hospital to address several identified problems: delayed cognition and ability to attend to task, delayed self-care skills, delayed feeding skills and decreased toleration for food textures, and delayed sensory processing. The child also began receiving speech therapy through Birmingham Speech and Hearing. In a patient-intake form, the mother characterized the relationship between the family and the child as one of intense love, but also one in which frustration, resentment, and exhaustion sometimes interfered. For those problems, the family, starting in October 2003, began seeing Dr. Jodi Brooks, a psychologist, and Carolina Endert, a social worker, for counseling and support.
The child entered Grantswood Elementary, a public school within the Jefferson County district, at the start of the school year in 2003. The child was placed in a special-education setting with a one-on-one aide and seemed to perform well during the 2003-2004 school year. In therapy sessions, the mother related that the school had reported that the child was disruptive and defiant; however, the school generally was responsive to the child's needs and the mother's expectations, which the mother conveyed in a meeting with school representatives. To supplement her special education, the child had continued receiving speech and occupational therapy, until her goals were met. In late March 2004, the mother obtained additional in-home services through the Family and Community Services program at Glenwood, Inc., a Birmingham mental-health treatment center, to help the family implement structure for, and provide respite care to, the child. Endert also advised the mother on parenting and disciplinary techniques for the benefit of the child. In addition, the parents addressed the child's health issues, consisting mainly of respiratory illnesses, earaches, and constipation, through Dr. Dennis.
On April 16, 2004, the child visited Dr. Moran, an adolescent and child psychiatrist. Dr. Moran recommended that the child continue taking the medication melatonin to assist her sleep and try taking the medication Metadate CD to improve her focus, and Dr. Moran discussed the risks and benefits of the medications Prozac and Risperdal to address the child's other problems of compulsiveness and perseveration. Although the father felt the child had inherited his sensitivity to medications, the parents implemented the medication regimen suggested by Dr. Moran. The mother related on May 7, 2004, that the school had reported that the child seemed to be doing better since she had begun taking Prozac.
The child underwent adenoid and tube placement surgery on May 20, 2004. Before the surgery, the mother took the child to Dr. Dennis to assure that the child's lungs were clear enough to withstand the procedure.
In June 2004, the parents started attending a support/education group together, as well as attending individual sessions, at the mental-health treatment center operated by Glenwood, focusing on using consistency when disciplining the child and having appropriate expectations of the child. After a beach vacation, the family returned to Birmingham and the child underwent dental-rehabilitation surgery. The child appeared to be doing well and to be bonding with M.H. during this period.
As the new school year approached, the mother arranged for Glenwood to send a representative to Grantswood Elementary to make recommendations for the child. The mother testified that she learned at some point that Grantswood Elementary had lost funding over the summer for a one-on-one aide to attend to the child during the school day. The mother informed Endert that she was discussing with her church the possibility of starting a faith-based school for higher functioning autistic children and their siblings.
In August or September 2004, while under the supervision of Grantswood Elementary employees, the child ran away from the school playground, which was not fenced. The school employees eventually found the child some 30 or 40 minutes later, crying and screaming in a briar patch in nearby woods. The mother testified that, following that incident, the child developed post-traumatic stress disorder, which caused her "meltdowns" to escalate to the point the child was out of control if she was not restrained. Endert's notes indicate that, after that incident, the child displayed increasingly aggressive behavior, began eating like an animal, began scratching at M.H., and generally regressed in her behavior. The mother testified that the child had a meltdown in which, among other things, she placed her head through a bedroom window, the first time the child had done anything that severe. The mother testified that at that point she became concerned for the safety of the child and M.H. On September 20, 2004, the parents admitted the child to Children's Hospital for acute psychiatric care, at which point Dr. Finn first became involved with the child. The mother also arranged for a Glenwood representative to visit the school to identify the source of the child's agitation. The parents further placed a peg board over the child's bedroom window for protective purposes.
The child remained in Children's Hospital until September 29, 2004. During her stay, the child was placed on an individualized behavior-modification program, and the parents participated in family therapy focused on medication management, monitoring medication side effects, garnering resources, parenting strategies, and modifying the school environment to incorporate the skills they learned. Initially, the child was not receptive to the treatment; however, after a change in her diet and the placement of items from her home to mimic her routine, the child began to interact more appropriately. After discussing the matter with the parents, the psychiatrists at Children's Hospital prescribed the child Risperdal and Benadryl, and they did not observe any side effects from the medication. Upon concluding that the child showed a brighter mood and a calmer effect, and upon receiving reports that the child seemed less impulsive and more compliant once she had access to her favorite toys and routine, the mental-health professionals at the hospital held a discharge conference with the parents. During that conference, the parents discussed all the findings, recommendations, and safety plans regarding the child, to which they verbalized understanding and concurrence. The doctors diagnosed the child with autistic disorder and recommended that the child continue to see a psychiatrist for medication management, that the family continue to participate with in-home therapy staff, that the family therapy focus on behavior management, that the child restart occupational therapy, that the school provide a one-on-one behavioral aide on a daily basis, and that the play area at the school be fenced.
After the discharge of the child, the parents became very proactive in assuring that Grantswood Elementary could meet the child's educational and other needs as set out in the discharge plan. The mother complained to Dr. Brooks that the school did not seem to be educating the child as much as babysitting her and that the child was not receiving enough one-on-one attention. On October 1, 2004, Endert recommended that the mother involve a special-education service in the next IEP meeting. The mother indicated that the parents were meeting with advocacy groups, apparently the Alabama Disabilities Advocacy Program and the Special Education Action Committee, to assist with the problems they were encountering with the school. The father also met with an occupational therapist to formulate a plan to implement the therapist's recommendations at the school, and he received information from relatives while he was in California regarding how that state handled children with special educational needs. Endert indicated that the parents were amassing an "impressive" amount of information regarding the educational rights of the child. The mother indicated that the parents met with school officials to discuss the problems, but a Jefferson County Board of Education official stated that the child did not need a one-on-one aide and that no fence would be erected. The school system also indicated that it wanted to delay reentry of the child into school. In response, the father prepared a report showing that, based on the opinions of her mental-health professionals, the child needed the one-on-one behavioral aide. After receiving no positive response, the parents filed a grievance with the school system. The father then contacted medical professionals in the United Kingdom and contacted the Sparks Clinic for further testing in an effort to help the child.
The parents did not resolve their grievance during the 2004-2005 school year. The child went to summer school and started back at Grantswood Elementary at the beginning of the 2005-2006 school year. While attending school in late August 2005, the child gained access to a pair of scissors. When a teacher attempted to quickly recover the scissors, the teacher accidentally cut herself badly. Although the principal of the school did not blame the child for the incident, the child blamed herself, and, as a result, she again regressed in her behavior as she had following the briar-patch incident. Following the scissor incident, the child was again evaluated by the Sparks Clinic and was found to have autistic disorder and mixed developmental delays; she was also found to be at risk for a diagnosis of mental retardation due, in part, to cognitive deficits indicating that the child behaved at an age equivalent of 3 years, 5 months. The clinic professionals believed the child had a number of strengths, including "a loving and caring family," that would help in modifying her behavior. The clinic set out a litany of educational recommendations for the child and indicated that those recommendations, among which was the use of a one-on-one behavioral aide, should be included in the child's next IEP and implemented by the child's school.
In October 2005, representatives of Grantswood Elementary reported that M.H. had indicated that the father had acted sexually inappropriately with her. DHR investigated the incident and found no evidence of sexual abuse. Following that report, which the parents perceived as retaliation for their grievance, the parents removed both children from the public-school system and the mother began home schooling the children through a licensed faith-based program. The father there-after attended a three-day seminar on autism treatments.
The record indicates that the parents eventually filed petitions for assistance with the United Stales Department of Education Office of Civil Rights and the American Civil Liberties Union regarding the matter. However, the record does not indicate the actions taken by those entities to assist the parents.
The children's home schooling initially went well. The mother noticed that the child was interacting well with church members, and the parents became more active in advocacy issues for disabled children. On November 30, 2005, after a third visit to the Sparks Clinic, the child was diagnosed with pervasive developmental disorder and mild mental retardation, as well as behavioral issues including aggression, hyperactivity, defiance, and significant impulsivity. The clinic again provided the parents with behavioral-modification and other techniques to use to help the child, including a recommendation that interaction with M.H. be encouraged. The parents were advised to implement those recommendations in addition to continuing to see Dr. Finn for medication management. Based on the new diagnoses, the child qualified for financial assistance through the Alabama Department of Mental Health, which the parents accessed.
In January 2006, the child began exhibiting more bizarre and unpredictable dangerous behavior without any overt precipitating event. After the child indicated that she wanted to hurt somebody, the mother admitted the child back into Children's Hospital for observation. The child remained in the hospital from January 16, 2006, to February 10, 2006. The treating doctors initially stopped all medications and placed the child in a therapeutic milieu with one-on-one supervision. They then replaced the child's medications, at that time Risperdal and Celexa, with Seroquel, Zoloft, and Depakote, and instituted a structured behavioral-modification program. The hospital discharged the child, who they indicated was in a stable condition, to the parents with a plan to follow up with Dr. Finn.
According to the parents, following her discharge, the child did not seem to be benefiting from her new medications, so Dr. Finn changed the medication regimen. On February 20, 2006, the child underwent tube-placement surgery for her ears. The next day, the child experienced another "meltdown" requiring the mother to restrain her. Based on all the above concerns, the parents and Dr. Finn had the child admitted to Hillcrest Hospital on February 21, 2006. The intake records from Hillcrest Hospital that were completed by the mother indicate that the parents wanted to be involved with the child's treatment and that, although the child's condition had been very stressful on the family, the parents were very loving and supportive to the child and hoped the child would be stabilized. The next day, the mother informed Endert that the parents were considering placing the child outside the home and that the mother was contacting the Alabama Department of Mental Health to obtain a Medicaid waiver for assistance.
The child did not do well in Hillcrest Hospital. As stated above, on February 22, 2006, a staff member laid down with the child in the child's bed, provoking a violent reaction. The child continued to require constant supervision due to hyper-activity, impulsivity, sexual acting out, and assaultive behavior. Changes to her medication and participation in therapeutic exercises did not seem to have much positive effect. The child also had very poor reality testing. The child, however, eventually improved and was discharged on March 21, 2006, into the care of the parents with instructions that the child be kept on the medications ReVia, Vistaril, and Risperdal as monitored by Dr. Finn.
In late March 2006, the mother informed Endert that, after her discharge from Hill-crest Hospital, the child's care and educational needs escalated. The mother contacted DHR and arranged to meet with its "Multiple Needs Committee" to obtain financial assistance in order to get help for the child. In April 2006, the mother also informed DHR that, based on the child's comments, she believed that the child had experienced some sexually inappropriate conduct while she was hospitalized. The mother consulted with Dr. Dennis, Dr. Finn, and a children's health insurance program clinic regarding her concerns.
On May 1, 2006, the mother informed Endert that she had enrolled M.H. in a faith-based school and that the child would soon be evaluated by mental-health specialists employed by Glenwood. Dr. Finn admitted the child to the mental-health treatment center operated by Glenwood on May 2, 2006, with a diagnosis of autistic disorder, disruptive behavior disorder, and moderate to severe mental retardation. The initial treatment team's meeting notes from May 3, 2006, indicate that "[the mother] is a strong advocate for services for [the child]." Subsequent notes also indicate that the child enjoyed "tremendous family support." Glenwood discharged the child from the treatment center on June 21, 2006.
The child appeared to benefit from Glenwood's intervention, and, as a result, the mother wanted to enroll her in the school operated by Glenwood. The mother felt the child would benefit from the rigid structure and consistency the child had received at the treatment center. However, because Glenwood did not have any vacancies at its school and the director of the school doubted that the school would benefit the child, the parents were not able to enroll the child in the education program at Glenwood. After that plan failed, the parents arranged for the child to be evaluated by the Alabama Department of Mental Health to determine her eligibility for residential services.
In the meantime, the parents enrolled the child in a public summer-school program for evaluation. The parents met with public-school officials and developed an IEP for the child, which the mother signed. The father, however, objected to the IEP on the ground that the child was entitled to free, appropriate, safe, inclusive, and the least restrictive placement with educators and other professionals trained to teach and provide special services to autistic children. Endert advised the parents that it appeared that the public-school system could not meet the child's special needs and that she hoped the mother would spotlight the educational plight facing autistic children. As a result, the parents again decided to home school the child rather than place her in the public-school system.
Between October 2006 and January 2007, the mother home schooled the child. The child also received speech and occupational therapy through Children's Hospital and recreational therapy through Mitchell Place. In November 2006, the Department of Mental Health began providing in-home respite services for the child.
In January 2007, the mother reported to Dr. Finn that the child had bit her tutor and had also hit M.H. while M.H. was sleeping. Dr. Finn noted that, according to the mother, the child needed "almost hand-over-hand supervision" to limit her impulse-control difficulties. By March 2007, the parents agreed that the child was not benefiting from the mother's home schooling. The mother felt that the child would benefit from placement in a group home; however, the father believed that the child should not be placed in a group home at that time. The father testified that the child responded better to his authority. Thus, at that point, the mother started working nights outside the home and the father took over primary care of the child. In May 2007, the father enrolled the child in the HANDS program, an educational program specializing in autistic children operated by graduate students. After the child's in-home respite service provider resigned, and the father's working hours extended, the mother was forced to quit working outside the home.
In March 2007, the parents, upon the recommendation of the Department of Mental Health, met with representatives of Ability Plus. The mother testified that the parents agreed to try placement of the child in the group home operated by Ability Plus for the rehabilitation, education, and development of the child. The parents envisioned that they would be allowed free access to the child and that, "if it doesn't work, we'll bring her home." The parents met with Dr. Finn on July 19, 2007, and stated to him that they believed the child had a good prognosis because of the structure and consistency she would receive at the group home. The placement would end Dr. Finn's psychiatric care of the child, which would be turned over to Dr. Manjula Swamy. At trial, Dr. Finn summarized his interaction with the parents as follows:
"You know, like many parents they wanted advice. I gave them advice. And like smart parents they are, they didn't take my advice all the time. They wanted to make their own choices and decisions and talk it over among themselves. But, in general, they were not non-compliant. They generally did what I recommended or tried at least some-times with success and sometimes not so. But they worked — we had a good working alliance, I felt."
The child started living at the Ability Plus group home in Athens on July 23, 2007. Bobbi Mason, a supervisor at the group home, testified that, after the child first began residing in the group home, Mason and the mother had constantly talked on the telephone about the needs of the child and that she developed a "very close" relationship with the mother and a very good relationship with the father. The mother also constantly visited the child at the group home, with the father attending visits mainly on the weekends. Mason testified that the child loved the visits because "[the mother] likes to nurture [the child]." Regarding the visits, the mother testified as follows:
"Q [By Counsel for the parents]: When you all were in Ability Plus visiting with [the child], what would be going on around you all while you were visiting with [the child]?
"A: Well, in the beginning it was varied. And it was such a long drive. I must say there were times when we would come and everyone would play together. That would be [M.H.] and [the child] would interact and the other children as well.
"[M.H.] is a very caretaking little mothering little person. And she would take charge and she would set a tone for the children and make up games for them. It was a lot of interacting with the children. And mother would be there. There were also occasions where I would just fall asleep on the bed with [the child] or I would take a nap while the kids were playing. They would be in there with me, but we were all together.
"Times where [the child] would crawl in bed and I would tickle her and hold her. And often — I would not leave until we had reconnected on an emotional level. That was my objective. The kids needed to play, but we needed to bond."
Mason testified that she sometimes felt that the cuddling between the mother and the child was "just too much touching" considering the child's diagnoses and behavior "but that [it] was a therapy thing that [the mother] liked to do." The records show that the mother had been engaging in that therapeutic activity since the child was much younger, and the mother testified that the child needed cuddling. Mason admitted that, although the child did not like to touch or hug others, she did like to hug the mother.
DHR offered no evidence to support Mason's subjective belief which was not expert testimony, that the cuddling between the mother and the child was an inappropriate therapy for the child.
The sexual-abuse allegations made by Ability Plus staff members in late 2007 interrupted the visits between the child and the parents. The mother testified that, when she first saw the child again in late January 2008, she was alarmed to find the child was "emaciated skin and bones," much thinner than she had been when visiting the parents approximately 30 days earlier. Records show the child weighed 57 pounds on December 28, 2007, when she was returned by the parents to the Ability Plus group home, but that her weight had dwindled to 52 pounds by January 9, 2008, when she was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa. The mother immediately began taking food supplements and Ensure protein drinks to the child to help the child restore her weight, and, together with the efforts of Ability Plus staff, the child eventually regained the weight.
As set out above, DHR conducted its first ISP meeting on January 30, 2008, in the absence of the parents. In the ISP report, the team, which consisted of DHR, Ability Plus representatives, and Department of Mental Health employees, listed as "family members strengths" that the family loved one another and that the family wants what is best for the children. As noted, the ISP report did not indicate any reason for DHR's involvement with the family other than the allegations of sexual abuse. Accordingly, DHR did not identify any problem with the parents' supervisory skills that needed attention. DHR had previously determined, following its prior sexual-abuse investigations in 2005 and 2006, that "both parents displayed appropriate protective capacities surrounding the children."
Consistent with that general theme, the juvenile court returned M.H. to the unrestricted custody of the parents on February 11, 2008. The record shows that, at the time of trial, M.H. had been in the care of the parents for over a year and a half and that, except for her fear that DHR would again remove her from the family home, that the child was doing exceedingly well. Apparently for that reason, at the close of the trial, the guardian ad litem basically recommended that the dependency petition as to M.H. be dismissed, which the juvenile court did.
In July 2008, the mother and M.H. moved to Huntsville to be closer to the child and to get out of the Jefferson County environment. The father continued to live in Birmingham and he would stay in Huntsville on weekends, until he finally moved there in the summer of 2009. On July 9, 2008, at a coordinated meeting with employees of DHR and Ability Plus, the parents presented a list of concerns regarding the care and education the child was receiving while at the Ability Plus group home, fully evidencing their commitment to meeting the child's needs.
That document stated, in part:
"After eight years of working with professionals, and researching both independently and in structured forums, coupled with what I have observed this past year with [the child's] stay at Ability Plus, I have come to a considered conclusion.
"As [the child's mother] who has an ultimate knowledge of who [the child] is and what she needs, I am convinced that while I need the services of Ability Plus for structure and for 24/7 help with [the child], (and I thank all of you for your diligence and support up front), [the child] needs the added ingredient of her Mother and family, who will nurture her with love and warmth, and will take a very personalized interest in her health, development and welfare. [Hardy], I think the records DHR has of my extensive work and involvement in procuring professional and educational intervention for [the child] bears witness to at least some of the knowledge, skills, and experience I possess.
"That being said, it is my intent to more proactively involve myself in a `co-operativ[e] relationship with Ability Plus and in [the child's] care, which will involve at least an increase in my visits with [the child], and a direct involvement with [the child's] School, lEP's, Educational Programs, and in developing a relationship with her Doctors. In light of this, what courtesies and considerations would Ability Plus request of me?
"I have requested a list of [the child's] Doctor's names and contact numbers. I have Dr. Reynolds, (ophthalmologist) and Dr. Swam[y], but I would like her Pediatrician's name and her dentist's name. I will schedule independent visits with each to make sure all are aware of [the child's] complete History, as I did with Dr. Reynolds when I had to educate him about [the child's] Retinopathy of Prematurity about which he had never heard. This was vital information to [the child's] diagnosis and prognosis. It is critical that I be brought up to date on [the child's] mental and physical status, and meeting one on one with each doctor should accomplish much of this.
"I also want to be certain that Ability Plus has all of [the child's] medical records, because I suspect that if you had understood and followed all of the records, this most recent situation involving DHR may never have happened. I thought we had communicated clearly in the presence of Ziva Hatcher of Mental health and Amy Hubbard your ex-social worker, about the origins, extensive investigations, professional conclusions, and recommended management by two prominent Birmingham Psychiatrists and Autism specialists, of [the child's] sexual obsessions, but I was mistaken. I'd like to keep any misunderstandings to a minimum through more effective communication and my own physical involvement.
"I spoke with Dr. Dennis, [the child's] previous Pediatrician and told her that [the child's] weight was about 55-60 pounds, and that she was probably in excess of 4 feet tall now. Dr. Dennis of Mountain Brook, Alabama, has been caring for [the child] since she was a little over a year old, and she has been concerned about [the child's] history of being substantially under standard weight since her premature birth. We know that one good flu virus could emaciate [the child] and potentially result in hospitalization. [The child] had the RSV shots every month from April to October for the first two years of her life.
"Bobb[i] Mason told me that you have an RX for [the child's] food supplements. The aids told me that there was none in the home because [the child] goes through them faster than Medicaid will pay.
"I would like to ask that [the child] be given one supplemental drink after each meal. This [e]nsures that she will eat her meals, but also that she will get the extra calories and nutrition needed to thrive.
"I will augment any product that Medicaid refuses to cover. We have brought what amounts to a case in my car, along with jumbo cans of Ravioli, for snacks, because I know this can be costly, which we'd like to drop off this afternoon when [the child] returns from school.
"I am requesting that I be kept informed by DHR while our trial is pending, and then by Ability Plus of anything that concerns [the child's] care, welfare, and training. For all of the years of hard work and study I have invested in my precious daughter's life, I am able to contribute in a positive way to her overall care, and would like to be considered a primary resource, and kept in the loop. My efforts are precisely why [the child] is in your facility now. I've been, for nine years, seeking assistance with, not exclusion from [the child's] care.
"I learned recently that her Medicaid waiver, for which I spent years petitioning, had simply been allowed to terminate for want of minor paper work that seems to have fallen through some crack. I had the papers sent to my home, filled them out and signed them, and [the child's] waiver has been reinstated as of yesterday 7/07/08, per Amanda Roberts of the Florence County Dept. of Medicaid.
"I spoke with Mr. Reed at SSI on June 23, 2008, and he informed me that [the child's] SSI [supplemental security income] payments had gone from a status of suspended, to terminated for lack of attention. I told him that I had communicated [the child's] living status and was available to sign any documents necessary, but had never had any request. Amy Hubbard had told me that Ability Plus Administration would handle the paper work, and I just trusted this. Mr. Reed said that Ability Plus has a liaison in place and should be able fairly easily to request and fill out the necessary application, but an application would have to be resubmitted since it was allowed to expire. Yesterday, the Medicaid Supervisor asked for my permission to communicate with Mrs. Allen, and I encouraged her to, so Mrs. Allen should have been contacted and updated on all of this. I'd like to see Ability Plus rightfully compensated, and I'm a little surprised that no one has spoken up, but these are the types of challenges I hope to help alleviate by being more present.
"I have observed [the child] trembling, going rigid, and exhibiting aggression, all of which indicate to me that she may possibly have toxic levels of [Risperdal] in her system. We need to have her blood levels checked as soon as possible. She has also nodded off while sitting upright in chair, in front of me. This seems to indicate a possible excess of sedative. This coupled with [the child] giving herself a black eye, and being asked to leave her swimming class are indicators to me that she needs to have a re-evaluation of her medications and of their toxicity levels. Could we do this as soon as possible please?"
At that point, Hardy, the DHR caseworker, instructed that the parents were to be invited to all IEP meetings, which apparently had not been the case before. As set out above, see supra note 8, the parents were eventually invited to attend all medical and psychiatric appointments for the child on May 5, 2009, and the record indicates that thereafter they did so. In addition, the father continued to conduct research on alternative methods for treating the child's autism up to the date of the trial.
In summary, the evidence appears undisputed that the parents understand that the child suffers from a variety of mental conditions impairing her ability to behave normally and that the parents have, as the mother put it, "exhausted every resource" in an effort to treat those mental conditions and modify the behavior of the child. The evidence also appears undisputed that the parents continued up to the time of the trial to be active participants in the education, care, and nurturing of the child despite their physical separation. At trial, DHR presented no testimony indicating that the means employed by the parents to meet the special needs of the child were inappropriate in any way. In fact, the evidence indicates that, while in the custody of DHR, the child receives treatment for her special needs almost identical to the treatment the child received while in the custody of the parents. Unquestionably, the parents remain committed to appropriately meeting the special needs of the child in the future. The juvenile court could not have been clearly convinced otherwise and could not have rested its dependency determination on the ground that the parents could not properly meet the special needs of the child.
c. The Alleged Inability of the Parents to Properly Supervise the Child
The evidence also appears undisputed that, due to her various mental conditions, the child requires supervision in order to assure that she does not harm herself. The evidence reveals that the parents took various measures to assure that supervision, such as modifying the bedroom of the child, obtaining in-home services to augment their monitoring of the child, advocating for a behavioral aide to be with the child while at school, and placing the child in a group home.
The dissent also argues that the child is a danger to other children.___ So.3d at ___ (Thomas, J., dissenting). However, the dissent has not cited any legal authority that a child who is dangerous to other children is therefore dependent. The dependency statute allows a juvenile court to transfer custody of a child in order to prevent harm to the child, see L.B.S. v. L.M.S., 826 So.2d 178, 190 (Ala. Civ.App. 2002) (plurality opinion), not to prevent the child from harming others. Nevertheless, we conclude that the same evidence proving that the parents possess adequate supervisory skills to protect the child from harming herself also proves that the parents can properly supervise the child to prevent her from harming others.
In arguing in its brief that the parents simply lack the capability to meet the child's special supervisory needs, DHR asserts that "Dr. Finn stressed the child needed supervision, which had not been provided by [the mother], the child's primary caregiver during his tenure." Actually, in the portion of his testimony specifically cited by DHR, Dr. Finn testified as follows:
"Q [By Counsel for the parents]: And were you ever able to during the time that you worked with [the child] to get those behaviors under control such that you could say she wasn't a danger to the safety and welfare of other children or sometimes even adults?
"A: Well, I felt that with supervision that was being provided by her parents, she was reasonably safe. But without such supervision, I was concerned for her safety. And, also, concerned that if — in particular the mother who I worked with most of the time wasn't able to provide that support and that limit setting and control over her behavior, didn't know that she would be safe."
Dr. Finn did not state that the mother was incapable of properly supervising the child so as to keep the child reasonably safe. Dr. Finn testified that, "with the supervision that was being provided by her parents, [the child] was reasonably safe." However, Dr. Finn stated that if the parents, particularly the mother, was not able to provide that supervision, with appropriate limit setting and control, then he did not know that the child would be safe.
The dissent reads into Dr. Finn's testimony the doctor's "doubts that the mother could properly control the child's behavior.'' 70 So.3d at 1267 (Thomas, J., dissenting). If Dr. Finn doubted the ability of the mother to properly supervise the child, DHR could have clarified that opinion on cross-examination, keeping in mind its burden of proving dependency by clear and convincing evidence. However, DHR did not question Dr. Finn further on that point. We do not read Dr. Finn's testimony as stating any opinion that the mother was incapable of properly supervising the child. Moreover, nothing in Dr. Finn's testimony indicates that the father was incapable of properly supervising the child.
DHR did not present any expert testimony indicating that the parents were incapable of providing appropriate limit setting and control so as to prevent the child from harming herself. The record indicates that the parents had been instructed in techniques designed to provide structure and consistency for the child so as to avoid triggers to the child's episodic misbehavior, to minimize any attention to misconduct, to redirect the child to more beneficial conduct, and to reward proper behavior. The record contains no evidence indicating that the parents had failed to properly use those techniques. The record also shows that the parents implemented discipline techniques advocated by an Amish psychologist and that the parents had used physical restraint as a last measure to protect the child.
During the trial, Mason, in responding to a question regarding the child's sexual acting out, testified as follows:
". . . when [the child] walked by and kind of smacked my hand or hit my head or something, whatever she done. I stood up and, I said, . . . we do not do that. I will not hit you. You will not hit me. And her dad answered and said she listened to you because you spoke in authority. With her mom, she will just laugh about it and continue to do it, but he said she does not do me that way. And she stopped. She said I won't hit you. I said, no, you will not hit me."
Even assuming that the juvenile court could have extrapolated from that simple statement that the mother could not act appropriately to prevent the child from harming herself, an issue that we do not decide, that interpretation would not support a finding that the parents, plural, lack the ability to properly supervise the child. See Ala. Code 1975, former § 12-15-l(10)k. (defining a dependent child as a child "[w]hose parents . . . are unable to discharge their responsibilities to and for the child (emphasis added)); see also J.B. v. DeKalb County Dep't of Human Res., 12 So.3d 100 (Ala.Civ.App. 2008) (plurality opinion) (recognizing that children are not dependent If one parent in a two-parent household is capable of properly caring for them). As stated by Mason, the father conveyed to Mason that the child responded to his authority more readily than that of the mother, an occurrence not uncommon among many nuclear families. The father further testified that, within 60 days of the trial, he would be able to assume full-time care of the child. The record contains no evidence indicating that the father is incapable of properly supervising the child so as to prevent her from harming herself.
The dissent also points out that the father testified that the mother was overwhelmed by the demands of home schooling the child and that she missed the final two days of trial, "in part because of her inability to cope with the additional stress of the proceeding." 70 So.3d at 1267 (Thomas, J., dissenting). Actually, the father did not testify that the mother was incapable of protecting the child from harming herself; he simply testified that the mother could not handle home schooling a child with special needs and that the child was not benefiting enough from that form of education. The mother missed the last two days of the trial on the advice of her physician, who, in a letter to the judge that was entered as an exhibit at trial, stated that he was treating the mother for "inner ear disorder resulting in the loss of her equilibrium and vertigo. She is also manifesting significant anxiety and hypertension from prolonged stress. . . ." However, DHR presented no evidence indicating that the mother suffered from any condition that would prevent her from adequately supervising the child.
Moreover, we note that the evidence shows that Ability Plus and the elementary school the child attends use techniques similar to those employed by the parents to control the behavior of the child. Those techniques have not always successfully prevented the child from harming herself, as Mason, Williamson, Duncan, Bowden, and Nix testified. The evidence does not indicate that anyone is more capable of supervising the child than the parents. DHR has utterly failed to show how depriving the parents of the custody of the child has materially lessened the incidences of self-injurious behavior or improved the supervision the child receives.
On the other hand, the mother testified that the child had regressed while in the care of Ability Plus. The mother stated that the child had stopped urinating or defecating on herself before her admission to the Ability Plus group home but that she had recently resumed that behavior. Mason agreed that the child appeared to be regressing in the period leading up to the trial, detailing the self-injurious behavior and other misbehavior committed by the child while in the group home and in the custody of DHR. That testimony tends to prove that the child actually received superior care and supervision in the home of the parents.
The record contains insufficient evidence to support a finding that the parents cannot adequately protect the child from harm. The record shows that the parents are at least as capable as DHR of properly supervising the child. Hence, the juvenile court could not have rested its finding of dependency on that ground.
d. The Parents' Medical Choice
At oral argument, DHR contended that the juvenile court could have found the child dependent based on evidence indicating that the parents intended to try a new course of treatment for the child if the child was returned to their custody. The mother testified that, during the period leading up to the trial, while living at the Ability Plus group home, the child had exhibited very "drugged behavior" and was acting like "a space cadet" and "a zombie." The father testified that if the child was returned to the custody of the parents, he would immediately take her to Dr. Finn to have her "detoxed," as Dr. Finn had done years earlier, so that her medications could be reevaluated. The father testified that he would then take the child to one of several autism specialists who use a program designed by Dr. Rick Solomon, which the father had researched. The father testified that, in conjunction with the medical treatment, the parents would also implement in the home adaptive-behavior analysis and teaching techniques that he had studied.
In R.C. v. State Department of Human Resources, 587 So.2d 335 (Ala.Civ.App. 1991), this court reversed a judgment finding a child dependent on the basis that the custodians of the child would not consent to a surgical operation designed to lengthen one of the child's legs. 587 So.2d at 337-38. The court held that the State Department of Human Resources is authorized to intervene and obtain a judgment compelling the medical treatment under Ala. Code 1975, former § 12-15-l(10)e., only when the custodians of a child are refusing a treatment deemed necessary for the child's health or well-being. 587 So.2d at 338. It follows that, under R.C., a child would also be dependent if the form of medical treatment selected by a parent endangers the health or well-being of the child. Absent those two scenarios, however, the State may not intervene in the medical decisions made by parents.
At oral argument, DHR conceded that it had not presented any evidence indicating that the program described by the father would endanger the child in any way. The dissent mentions the program, — So.3d at — (Thomas, J., dissenting), but it also fails to explain how a decision by the parents to try another recognized method of treatment for autism, following the failure of numerous other treatments, indicates the dependency of the child. In the absence of any evidence indicating that the child would be harmed by the new treatment, the juvenile court could not find the child dependent on the basis of the parents' proposed treatment plan.
VI. Conclusion
In conclusion, this court holds that the juvenile court impliedly found that the father did not commit sexual abuse as alleged in the dependency petitions filed by DHR. This court determines that the juvenile court could nevertheless find the child dependent on any ground proven by sufficient evidence at trial. However, after thoroughly reviewing the evidence, this court finds that a reasonable fact-finder could not have been clearly convinced of the dependency of the child. We therefore reverse the juvenile court's judgment, and we remand the case with instructions that the juvenile court dismiss the dependency petition relating to the child and restore custody of the child to the parents.
REVERSED AND REMANDED WITH INSTRUCTIONS.
THOMPSON, P.J., and BRYAN, J., concur in the result, without writings.
THOMAS, J., dissents, with writing, which PITTMAN, J., joins.
THOMAS, Judge, dissenting.
I respectfully dissent. I disagree that the juvenile court did not have before it clear and convincing evidence of grounds, other than the alleged sexual abuse of the child by the father, upon which it could have found that the child was dependent. Our standard of review in a dependency case in which the juvenile court heard ore tenus evidence is deferential.
"`Matters of dependency and child custody are within the discretion of the trial court. Where ore tenus evidence is presented, the judgment of the trial court is presumed correct and will be reversed on appeal only upon a showing that it was plainly and palpably wrong.'"L.H. v. Lee County Dep't of Human Res., 40 So.3d 747, 749 (Ala.Civ.App. 2009) (quoting F.G.W. v. S.W., 911 So.2d 1, 5 (Ala.Civ. App. 2004)).
The testimony in this case was sufficient for the juvenile court to have found that the child is a danger to herself and others, that the child acts out in sexually inappropriate ways, and that the parents are not capable of providing appropriate supervision and care for the child, providing sufficient support for the trial court's determination that the child was dependent.
The mother testified that in 2004 or 2005 the child had meltdowns including one instance when the child put her head through the bedroom window, breaking it. The mother testified that the child "would just start, having fits endangering her own physical body and possibly [M.H.]." The mother stated that during those melt-downs the child would be out of control and that the mother was afraid for M.H.'s safety. The mother also testified that the child would bite or scratch herself and take her feces and "smear it all over the room."
Bobbi Mason, the house manager at the Ability Plus group home, testified that the child had exhibited self-injurious behaviors and that she had harmed other children. Mason testified that, because of the child's tendency to harm herself, Ability Plus performs an examination of the child when she returns to the Ability Plus group home from any visitation. Mason also testified that the child would "stomp her feet until they bleed," that she would "pick her skin until she make[s] it bleed," and that the child was a danger to herself. According to Mason, the child "will hit younger babies," and Mason stated that the child has an obsession with "wanting to hit a baby or want[ing] to harm a baby," that "[the child] hits younger kids," and that the child is "pretty aggressive." Mason further testified that the child could be dangerous to younger children. According to Mason, the father had stated that the child did not mind the mother. Mason testified regarding an incident when the child had struck her. Mason stated:
"I stood up and, I said [to the child], we do not do that. I will not hit you. You will not hit me. And [the father] answered and said she listened to you because you spoke [with] authority. With [the mother], she will just laugh about it and continue to do it, but he said she does not do me that way. And she stopped."
Mason also testified to the child's tendency to behave in a sexually inappropriate manner. Mason stated that the child would ask the father if he wanted "to do the hunchie" and that the child had stated that "[the father's] peepee went in [the child's] mouth." Mason further testified that the child would touch herself and put her finger into her vagina.
According to Mason, there also had been problems with the parents' visits with the child. Mason stated that at times "the [mother's] cuddling was inappropriate" and that she "felt [there] was too much touching." Mason further stated that the mother would get angry and speak harshly to the staff and that such harsh speaking was inappropriate in front of the child.
Rhonda Williamson, a special-education teacher at the school the child had attended, testified that the child needed one-on-one supervision because the child would act erratically and try to harm herself or others. According to Williamson, the child became focused on the youngest child in the classroom, stating that she intended to hit the other child. Williamson stated that twice the child did hit the other child. Williamson further testified that the child was a danger to children who were younger or smaller than the child.
Donna Duncan, an inclusion assistant at the school the child had attended, testified that there had been numerous episodes at school when the child had acted aggressively, had yelled curse words, or had made inappropriate, sexual comments. According to Duncan, the child would become agitated and "fixate" on younger children and talk about hurting them. Duncan testified that the child had thrown a toy at another child and had "split his eye open," that the child had head-butted her, and that the child had "slapped [her] as hard as she could."
According to Duncan, the child began making sexual comments one day while the child was eating a hot dog, stating that she was going to eat the hot dog "like a hoochie woman" and that the child began making "obscene gestures" with the hot dog. Duncan stated the child then said that she had to go to a home where a man would "whip the hell out of her" and that he had "a hoochie big thing that's going to hold [the child] down." According to Duncan, the child also stated that the man told her that she would "stay in the dungeon room with her daddy," that she was not going to ciy, and that the man was not going to hurt her. Duncan further testified that the child would often talk about "opening daddy's peepee" and how the child was "not going to be afraid" and how she was "not going to tell." Duncan stated that the child would talk in a deep, gravelly voice when making these comments. Duncan further testified that the child would touch her own genitals and would grab the genitals of other children. According to the mother, the child has engaged in inappropriate, sexually related conversations and actions for the last four or five years, beginning when the child was six or seven years old.
Amanda Bowden, another inclusion assistant at the school the child had attended, testified that the child would attempt to harm herself by trying to bite or scratch herself or by head-butting objects and that the child would take toys and "try to physical[y] insert them into her vagina area and push as hard as she could push." Bowden also testified that the child would hit, kick, and attempt to bite staff members and that the child was aggressive toward other children. Bowden further testified that the child required constant supervision to prevent the child from harming the other children.
According to Melissa Nix, the nurse at the school the child had attended, the child exhibited self-injurious behaviors such as scratching and pulling her hair. Nix also testified, as had Bowden and Duncan, that the child was aggressive toward other children, stating that she had observed the child walk into the room and slap another child in the face without any provocation. Nix had also observed the child slap another child across the chest, again without any provocation.
Nix also testified that the child had told her that a man had come into her room, had thrown her bed covers and mattress to the floor, and had pulled her pants down. According to Nix, the child then "started saying uh, uh, uh and [the child had made] a thrusting motion with her hips." Nix further testified that the child then became upset and stated that the man had hurt her, pointing to her vagina and her bottom. Nix testified that the child then said, in a different voice, that the man had told her not to tell anyone what had happened. According to Nix, the child had told her that it had been "daddy" who had come into her room. Nix stated that the child had never been alone with a man at the school. According to Nix, the aggressive and sexualized behaviors exhibited by the child were not typical of the other autistic children that she had observed.
Dr. Edgar Finn, a psychiatrist who had treated the child from when the child was 6 years old until 2 years before the trial, testified that the child was a danger to herself and to others, including other children such as her younger sister, M.H., and that the child required close supervision. Dr. Finn stated that he was not surprised that the child had bitten her tutor and drawn blood or that the child had struck M.H. while M.H. was sleeping. According to Dr. Finn, the child was a danger to M.H. if the child was not closely supervised. In spite of the child's aggressive behavior, the mother stated that she would sometimes take a nap during their visits with the child at the Ability Plus group home, allowing M.H. "to take charge" of the child. Dr. Finn also testified that the child's impulse-control issues could place the child's own safety at risk.
The mother did state that her mother was in the room, indicating that the children were not completely lacking adult supervision.
Although Dr. Finn testified that he felt that the child was reasonably safe with the supervision being provided by the parents, Dr. Finn also testified that he was "concerned that if — in particular the mother who I worked with most of the time wasn't able to provide that support and that limit setting and control over her behavior, I didn't know that [the child] would be safe," indicating his doubts that the mother could properly control the child's behavior. The father testified that when the mother stayed home with the child and attempted to home school the child, dealing with the child and the child's schooling was too much for the mother to handle. Additionally, the mother was absent for the final two days of the trial, in part because of her inability to cope with the additional stress of the proceeding. Dr. Finn further testified that the parents would not always take his advice regarding how to care for the child, although he stated that, in general, the parents were not "non-compliant." The parents stated an express desire to remove the child from her current placement at the Ability Plus group home and return the child to their home, utilizing other, outside-the-home services to assist with the child's care.
The juvenile court also heard evidence that the parents had refused to cooperate with DHR and the staff at the Ability Plus group home. Iris Johnson, a DHR case worker, testified that she had difficulty getting the parents to attend an ISP meeting. Johnson also testified that, when she went to the parents' home for an ISP meeting, the mother became irate and she kept screaming that she would not let anyone take M.H. Johnson stated that she was allowed to see M.H.; however, Johnson was not allowed to ask M.H. any questions or see M.H. without one of the parents being present, causing Johnson to cancel the ISP meeting. According to Mason, the parents were encouraged to attend the child's psychiatric appointments; however, the parents had only attended one appointment. The parents also had not provided any voluntary child support while the child had been in DHR's custody and had provided only a minimal amount of clothing.
According to Latasha Hardy, a DHR social worker, the mother had become irate during one of her visits with the child at the Ability Plus group home. Hardy testified that she had received a telephone call from one of the staff at the Ability Plus group home during one of the mother's visits. Hardy stated that she could hear the mother yelling and swearing. Hardy also testified that the child was saying "leave, mommy, just leave, mommy," and that the child was yelling in the background the entire time. According to Hardy, Ability Plus banned the parents from the group home after that visit and that any future visits had to take place at another location.
The juvenile court heard the testimony of the witnesses and observed their demeanor over the course of a four-day trial. It is important to remember that
"`[t]he ore tonus rule recognizes that the trial judge is better able than is the appellate court to determine the credibility of the witnesses. The trial judge has the discretion of accepting or rejecting testimony of a witness and of giving appropriate weight to testimony because he or she is in a better position to consider the demeanor of the witness and that witness's candor and/or evasion. If the judge has determined that a witness has lied or is lying under oath, he or she can take that fact into consideration when weighing other evidence presented by that witness. See James v. James, 532 So.2d 1031 (Ala.Civ.App. 1988).'"Dabbs v. Four Tees, Inc., 36 So.3d 542, 557 (Ala.Civ.App. 2008) (quoting Dilorio v. Long, 839 So.2d 650, 654 (Ala.Civ.App. 2001)).
"In ore tenus proceedings, the trial court is the sole judge of the facts and of the credibility of witnesses, and the trial court should accept only that testimony it considers to be worthy of belief. Ostrander v. Ostrander, 517 So.2d 3 (Ala. Civ.App. 1987). Further, in determining the weight to be accorded to the testimony of any witness, the trial court may consider the demeanor of the witness and the witness's apparent candor or evasiveness. Ostrander, supra."Woods v. Woods, 653 So.2d 312, 314 (Ala. Civ.App. 1994). "The ore tenus presumption is based on the trial court's unique position to directly observe the witnesses and its `better opportunity to pass upon the credibility of their testimony.'" Fluker v. Wolff, 46 So.3d 942, 950 (Ala. 2010) (quoting Ex parte Pielach, 681 So.2d 154, 155 (Ala. 1996)).
"`This court is not allowed to reweigh the evidence or to substitute its judgment for that of the trial court. Ex parte Bryowsky, 676 So.2d 1322 (Ala. 1996).'" G.H. v. KG., 909 So.2d 206, 208-09 (Ala. Civ.App. 2005) (quoting Estrada v. Redford, 855 So.2d 551, 555 (Ala.Civ.App. 2003)). Additionally, "`[i]t is our duty to affirm the trial court's judgment if it is fairly supported by credible evidence, "regardless of our own view of that evidence or whether we would have reached a different result had we been the trial judge."`" Sankey v. Sankey, 961 So.2d 896, 901 (Ala.Civ.App. 2007) (quoting Griggs v. Griggs, 638 So.2d 916, 918-19 (Ala.Civ.App. 1994), quoting in turn Young v. Young, 376 So.2d 737, 739 (Ala.Civ.App. 1979)).
Mason, Duncan, Bowden, Williamson, Nix, the mother, the father, and Dr. Finn all testified regarding the child's tendencies to harm herself and other children and Mason, Duncan, Bowden, Nix, the mother, the father, and Dr. Finn testified regarding the child's tendencies to act out in a sexually inappropriate manner. The testimony of Dr. Finn, the father, the mother, and Mason raised a question as to whether the parents, particularly the mother, were capable of properly caring for, supervising, and controlling the child. The juvenile court also observed that the mother was absent for two of the four days of the trial. Additionally, the juvenile court also had before it the recommendation of the guardian ad litem, urging the juvenile court to find the child dependent. The juvenile court could have concluded from the evidence of the child's self-injurious and aggressive behaviors that the child would be in danger of harming herself or M.H. if the child was returned to the parents' home because the parents lacked the ability to sufficiently supervise the child or adequately address the child's many special needs. I believe that this evidence was sufficient to support the juvenile court's judgment determining that the child was dependent, and, therefore, that judgment was not plainly and palpably wrong. Thus, I would affirm the judgment of the juvenile court.
PITTMAN, J., concurs.
Alert