Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Reynolds v. Nationstar Loan Servs., LLC

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District.
Apr 27, 2016
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary: Reynolds v. Nationstar Loan Services, LLC, No. 4D14–4045 (Fla. 4th DCA Apr. 27, 2016)

Factual and Procedural Background

Charles Reynolds executed a promissory note and mortgage in favor of Lehman Brothers Bank FSB and later defaulted. Aurora Loan Services, LLC, the loan servicer, filed a foreclosure complaint alleging it was the owner and holder of the note. A copy of the note, attached to the complaint, lacked endorsements. More than a year later Aurora filed the original note with the court, which bore two endorsements: an undated endorsement from Lehman Brothers Bank to Lehman Brothers Holdings and an endorsement in blank from Lehman Brothers Holdings. Reynolds answered and asserted lack of standing as an affirmative defense. After the complaint was filed but before final judgment, Aurora was purchased by Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, and Nationstar was substituted as plaintiff.

At trial, a Nationstar employee testified regarding the documents and the default. The witness testified there were two endorsements on the original note and that the note was in Aurora's possession at the time the complaint was filed, but did not testify when the endorsements were made. The witness attempted to testify that Lehman Brothers Holdings was "the same as Aurora," but Reynolds objected and the trial court sustained the objection. The trial court denied Reynolds's motion for involuntary dismissal and entered a final judgment of foreclosure for Nationstar. Reynolds appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellee (Aurora/Nationstar) proved it had standing to bring the foreclosure action at the time the complaint was filed—that is, whether it was the holder of the promissory note when suit was initiated.
  2. Whether the trial court could treat as established the asserted identity or relationship between Aurora and Lehman Brothers (i.e., take judicial notice or otherwise accept testimony to show Aurora was the servicing arm of Lehman Brothers) without proper proof or a timely request for judicial notice.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Reynolds asserted that Aurora (and thus Nationstar as successor) lacked standing because the plaintiff did not prove it was the holder of the promissory note at the time the foreclosure complaint was filed.
  • Reynolds objected to testimony attempting to equate Lehman Brothers Holdings with Aurora and relied on the absence of evidence showing when endorsements were placed on the note.

Appellee's Arguments

  • Aurora/Nationstar alleged in the complaint that it was the owner and holder of the note and produced the original note at trial showing two endorsements.
  • At trial, Nationstar's witness testified that the note was in Aurora's possession at the time the complaint was filed and described the endorsements on the original note. In briefing, Nationstar suggested (in a footnote) that Aurora is the servicing arm of Lehman Brothers, arguing an identity/relationship that would support standing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Westport Recovery Corp. v. Midas, 954 So.2d 750, 752 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007) Standing to bring an action is a question of law subject to de novo review. The court applied the de novo standard in reviewing whether the plaintiff had standing at the time the complaint was filed.
Elston/Leetsdale, LLC v. CWCapital Asset Mgmt., LLC, 87 So.3d 14, 16 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012) Whether a party is the proper party with standing is a question of law reviewed de novo. Reinforced the court's approach to review standing as a legal question resolved without deference to the trial court's factual findings.
McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Nat'l Ass'n, 79 So.3d 170, 173 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012) Standing is determined at the time the lawsuit is filed; a plaintiff may establish standing by status as the note holder, and if the note does not name the plaintiff as payee it must bear a special endorsement in favor of the plaintiff or a blank endorsement. The court applied this rule to require proof that Aurora was the holder of the note (by endorsements or other evidence) at the time the complaint was filed; absent such proof, standing was not established.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began with the legal principle that standing to sue is determined at the time the lawsuit is filed and is a question of law subject to de novo review. The court relied on authority holding that a plaintiff establishes standing by showing it was the holder of the note at filing; if the note does not name the plaintiff as payee, the note must bear an endorsement either in favor of the plaintiff or in blank.

The court examined the record and found the complaint attached only a copy of the note without endorsements. The original note, filed more than a year later, showed two endorsements, but there was no testimony or competent evidence concerning when those endorsements were placed. The Nationstar witness testified that the note was in Aurora's possession at the time the complaint was filed but did not testify when the endorsements were made. The witness's attempt to testify that Lehman Brothers Holdings was "the same as Aurora" was stricken or sustained as objectionable by the trial court, and Nationstar did not offer other evidence to establish the asserted identity or the timing of transfers.

The court considered Nationstar's suggestion in briefing that it was "well known" that Aurora was the servicing arm of Lehman Brothers and noted statutory provisions governing judicial notice (§ 90.202(11), (12), Fla. Stat. (2013)) and the procedural requirement for a timely request under § 90.203, Fla. Stat. (2013). The court concluded it could not take judicial notice of the asserted relationship without a timely and sufficient request and, in any event, Nationstar did not otherwise prove the connection. Because there was no competent evidence that Aurora held the note at the time the complaint was filed, Nationstar failed to establish standing at the time of filing.

Holding and Implications

The judgment of foreclosure is reversed and the complaint for foreclosure is dismissed.

Implications: The direct effect is that the trial court's final judgment of foreclosure was reversed and the foreclosure complaint was ordered dismissed for lack of standing at the time the suit was filed. The opinion rests on application of existing standing principles and procedural rules governing proof and judicial notice; the court did not announce a new legal rule beyond applying established precedent to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

WARNER, J.

Samuel D. Lopez of Samuel D. Lopez, P.A., Pembroke Pines, for appellant.

Nancy M. Wallace and Diane G. DeWolf of Akerman LLP, Tallahassee, and William P. Heller of Akerman LLP, Fort Lauderdale, for appellee.

Opinion

WARNER, J.

Charles Reynolds appeals a final judgment of foreclosure. He claims that the appellee, Aurora Loan Services, LLC, failed to prove its standing at the time the foreclosure complaint was filed. We agree that Aurora did not prove standing because it did not prove that it was the holder of the promissory note at the time of the filing of the suit. We thus reverse.

Reynolds executed a note and mortgage to Lehman Brothers Bank FSB, on which he later defaulted. Aurora, the loan servicer, brought a foreclosure action against Reynolds. Aurora alleged it was the owner and holder of the note. A copy of the note without any endorsements was attached to the complaint. Over a year later, Aurora filed the original note with the court. It had two endorsements on it. The first was an undated endorsement from Lehman Brothers Bank to Lehman Brothers Holdings. The second was an endorsement in blank from Lehman Brothers Holdings. Reynolds answered and asserted Aurora's lack of standing as an affirmative defense. After the complaint was filed but before final judgment, Aurora was purchased by Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, and Nationstar was substituted as party plaintiff.

At the trial, an employee of Nationstar testified as to all of the relevant documents and the default. With respect to the note, the witness testified that there were two endorsements, one from Lehman Brothers Holdings, and one from Lehman Brothers Bank to Lehman Brothers Holdings, which he said was the same as Aurora. Reynolds objected to the witness's testimony that Lehman Brothers Holdings was “the

same as Aurora,” and the court sustained the objection. The witness then testified that the note was in Aurora's possession at the time the complaint was filed. He did not testify as to when the endorsements were placed on the note. Based upon this testimony regarding the note, as well as other testimony about other elements of the claim, the court denied Reynolds's motion for involuntary dismissal and entered a final judgment of foreclosure for Nationstar.

A determination that a party has standing to bring an action is a question of law which is subject to de novo review. Westport Recovery Corp. v. Midas, 954 So.2d 750, 752 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007). Whether a party is the proper party with standing to bring an action is a question of law to be reviewed de novo. Elston/Leetsdale, LLC v. CWCapital Asset Mgmt., LLC, 87 So.3d 14, 16 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012).

A party's standing is determined at the time the lawsuit is filed. McLean v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Nat'l Ass'n, 79 So.3d 170, 173 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012). “[S]tanding may be established from a plaintiff's status as the note holder, regardless of any recorded assignments. If the note does not name the plaintiff as the payee, the note must bear a special endorsement in favor of the plaintiff or a blank endorsement.” Id. (citation omitted).

Reynolds claims that Nationstar did not prove Aurora's standing at the time the complaint was filed. Nationstar's witness testified over objection that Aurora had possession of the note prior to filing the lawsuit, but there was no competent explanation of how or when the transfers from Lehman Brothers Holdings occurred or whether they occurred prior to the suit being filed. There was no evidence as to when the endorsements on the note were made—they were not on the copy attached to the complaint and only appeared over a year later when the original was filed. To make up for this deficiency, the witness tried to testify that Aurora and Lehman Brothers Holding were one and the same, but the court sustained the objection to this testimony. Without that evidence, there was no testimony to show that Aurora was a holder of the note at the time of the filing of the complaint.

In its brief, Nationstar states in a footnote that “it is well known, particularly among judges who preside over hundreds of foreclosure actions, that Aurora is the servicing arm of Lehman Brothers.” This information might qualify for judicial notice either as “[f]acts that are not subject to dispute because they are generally known within the territorial jurisdiction of the court” or “[f]acts that are not subject to dispute because they are capable of accurate and ready determination by resort to sources whose accuracy cannot be questioned.” § 90.202(11), (12), Fla. Stat. (2013). However, we cannot take judicial notice of this “fact,” nor can the trial court without a timely and otherwise sufficient request under section 90.203, Florida Statutes (2013). Here, however, when Reynolds objected, Nationstar did not attempt to otherwise prove the connection between Lehman Brothers and Aurora. Without evidence of such, Nationstar was unable prove that Aurora held the note at the time it filed suit.

We thus reverse for entry of a judgment of dismissal of the complaint for foreclosure.

CIKLIN, C.J., and KLINGENSMITH, J., concur.