Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Conqueror Trading Ltd & Ors v Revenue and Customs (CUSTOMS DUTIES - VAT - whether customs values underdeclared - whether HMRC valuation methodology appropriate - whether appellant met requirements for onward supply relief)

First-tier Tribunal (Tax)
Nov 11, 2025
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Tribunal Decision (Anonymised)

Factual and Procedural Background

This decision concerns appeals by four importer companies (hereafter "Company A", "Company B", "Company C" and "Company D") against post-clearance C18 demands issued by the Respondent for customs duty and import VAT. The demands arose because the Respondent contended that the goods had been imported at understated customs values in breach of the customs valuation rules (the Union Customs Code and the WTO Customs Valuation Agreement), and that the appellants had incorrectly claimed onward supply relief (OSR) for some imports.

Aggregate contested amounts as stated in the opinion were (by company): Company A — customs duty and import VAT; Company B — customs duty and VAT; Company C — customs duty and VAT; Company D — customs duty and VAT (amounts detailed in the decision). The Respondent raised assessments after enquiring into a sample of imports and applying secondary valuation methods where it had reasonable doubts about declared transaction values.

The appeals were heard together over a three day hearing. Some appeals were made late but the Respondent did not object to late admission and the Tribunal permitted late appeals to be heard together because of overlap and absence of prejudice.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there were reasonable doubts as to the accuracy of the declared transaction values for the imported goods such that the declared transaction value could not be used for customs valuation.
  2. If reasonable doubts existed, whether the Respondent's chosen alternative valuation methodology (Method 6 — a fallback/data-based method) was appropriate and lawfully applied.
  3. Whether the appellants satisfied the statutory and regulatory requirements for onward supply relief (OSR), including evidence of taking title to the goods, removal from the State, and sale to a taxable person in another Member State.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The declared transaction values were correct because the goods were low-priced items (end-of-line, damaged, surplus or returned stock) and the prices on supplier invoices reflected genuine market transactions.
  • The appellants had provided sufficient documentary and commercial evidence of the imports, supplies and removals to support the declared values and OSR claims (including sales invoices and other records).
  • The Respondent's extrapolation of import values using a government mathematical model (Method 6) was inappropriate because the business operated in a specific market for very low-priced clothing and averages for commodity codes were irrelevant.
  • The appellants argued that some consignments had been cleared on entry and that only a small number of consignments had been stopped/inspected, implying there was not a basis to challenge all declared values.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent maintained it had reasonable doubts as to the declared transaction values for multiple reasons, including vague descriptions of goods, lack of contracts with suppliers, inconsistent or incomplete transport documentation, and evidence that payments recorded did not match declared invoice values.
  • The Respondent relied on statutory powers (including Article 140 of the Union Customs Code) to request additional information and, where doubts persisted, to apply secondary valuation methods.
  • The Respondent argued that Method 6 (valuation by reference to available data using a tool analysing comparable imports) was appropriate in the absence of reliable information to apply other methods and that the application used the lowest established comparable values to reflect the wholesale, low-quality nature of the goods.
  • In relation to OSR, the Respondent argued that the appellants failed to show they had taken title to goods, failed to provide reliable evidence of removal and delivery to taxable persons in other Member States, and failed to produce the commercial evidence required by the VAT Notices and regulations.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal set out the applicable legal framework: the assessments were brought under the domestic statutory provisions implementing customs and VAT rules (including relevant provisions of VATA 1994 and the Customs and Excise Management Act). The valuation rules at the time were governed by Articles of EU Regulation 952/2013 (notably Articles dealing with transaction value, the power to request information if there are reasonable doubts, and secondary methods including a fallback method). The Tribunal accepted that the burden of proof on matters of customs value and entitlement to OSR lay on the appellants.

On valuation the Tribunal considered whether the Respondent reasonably doubted the declared transaction values and whether those doubts were dispelled by information provided. The Tribunal accepted the Respondent's position that there were multiple indicia justifying reasonable doubts, summarised in the decision as: (1) pattern of purchases described as unsold consignments already in transit and rapid identification of onward buyers; (2) lack of clear and complete documentary supply chain evidence (absence of written contracts, inconsistent transport documentation); (3) bank records showing payments that did not match supplier invoice values; (4) an odd shipping pattern (landing in Port A, transporting to the State and then re-export to Eastern markets) that made little commercial sense for a low-margin model; (5) inability of tax authorities in other member states to locate many named customers; (6) supplier invoice unit prices that were implausibly low given raw material costs; and (7) evidence suggesting the companies operated at a loss.

The Tribunal evaluated the appellants' evidence and oral testimony (primarily from Director Wernick). The Tribunal found significant weaknesses: the principal company officer had limited or no first-hand knowledge of many transactions, relied on another individual (Person A) for operational matters but produced no direct evidence from that person, lacked access to many relevant emails and documents, and gave speculative explanations unsupported by contemporaneous documentation. Where documentary items existed they were sometimes inconsistent (for example, a supplier bill of lading showing Company A as consignee dated before the single supplier offer email). The Tribunal regarded a contemporaneous letter from an intermediary as general and insufficient to discharge the evidential burden on the appellants.

Because the Respondent's reasonable doubts were not dispelled by the information provided, the Tribunal accepted the Respondent's legal entitlement to reject the declared transaction value and move to secondary valuation methods. The Respondent's evidence was that Methods 1–5 could not be used due to lack of reliable information to identify identical or similar goods, absence of credible sales/resale evidence, and lack of data on costs of production; accordingly Method 6 (a fallback/data-based method using comparable imports by commodity code and transport mode, applying the lowest identified comparable value for wholesale low-quality goods) was used. The Tribunal noted the appellants did not meaningfully challenge the operation of Method 6 at hearing and did not show that other methods were practicable given the available evidence.

On OSR, the Tribunal emphasised that the relief is a derogation that requires strict compliance with statutory/regulatory requirements and VAT Notices (including documentary evidence of removal within time limits, and that supplies were to taxable persons in other Member States). The Tribunal found the appellants failed to show they had taken title to the goods (no supplier contracts, multiple indications that suppliers had not been paid, draft terms suggesting title passed on payment), and failed to provide reliable commercial evidence of removal and delivery to taxable persons (incomplete or unsigned transport documents, discrepancies between addresses and declared parties, and information from other Member States indicating many customers were non-compliant or untraceable). The Tribunal concluded the appellants did not discharge the burden of proof for entitlement to OSR.

The Tribunal also rejected the submission that goods would need to have been seized or stopped at import for the Respondent to form reasonable doubts or to challenge OSR claims, noting there is no statutory requirement that goods be seized before an assessment.

Holding and Implications

FINAL RULING: The appeals are DISMISSED.

Direct consequences of the decision:

  • The Respondent's post-clearance C18 demands and the valuation adjustments underlying those demands were upheld by the Tribunal.
  • The appellants failed to establish that declared transaction values were accurate and failed to discharge the burden of proof for entitlement to onward supply relief; accordingly the Respondent's assessments for customs duty and import VAT stand.

Broader implications:

The decision applies the existing statutory and regulatory framework to the facts of this case and does not purport to establish a new legal principle or precedent beyond the application of those rules to the evidential insufficiencies described. The Tribunal emphasised the strict evidential requirements for reliance on declared transaction values and for claiming OSR, particularly where the Respondent has reasonable doubts and requests further information.

Parties retain the statutory right to seek permission to appeal under the rules cited in the decision (applications for permission to appeal must be made within the timeframe stated in the decision).


Note on anonymisation: All personal names and corporate identities in this summary have been replaced with consistent placeholders (individuals as named in the text are referred to as "Director Wernick", "Officer Avery", "Officer Blackburn", "Attorney Pritchard", "Person A", "Person B"; companies and commercial entities are referred to as "Company A" through "Company M"; locations are described generically as "Port A", "Country A", "The State", etc.). The substance of the Tribunal's findings, legal reasoning and conclusions is drawn solely from the provided opinion and no information has been invented or inferred beyond that text.