Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

J Mac Safety Systems Ltd v Q Deck Safety Systems Ltd

England and Wales High Court (Patents Court)
Sep 4, 2025
Smart Summary (Beta)

Anonymised Summary of Judgment

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a dispute about alleged infringement of unregistered design right in relation to a plastic safety decking system used on construction sites for working platforms and fall protection. The claimant is Company A (the business that developed and sold the decking system) and the principal individual witness for Company A is referred to here as the Plaintiff. The defendant is Company B, a supplier and hirer of safety decking systems that was a customer of Company A from 2019 and purchased a substantial volume of Company A's product. Company B later developed its own competing system (referred to in the judgment as the defendant's system).

Company A relied on a set of four design documents (the "Macdeck Designs"): a 1m x 1m panel design, a panel perimeter design, a 0.75m x 1m panel design, and a pin design. Company B's competing items (the "Q Deck Components") comprise panels and pins analogous to each of Company A's components.

The pleaded causes included unregistered design right infringement, registered design infringement (later discontinued) and passing off. On the first day of trial Company B agreed to be entered for judgment on the passing off claim on the basis of its pleaded case; any inquiry as to damages for that claim was left to a form-of-order hearing. The trial focused on liability for unregistered design right infringement and on one factual issue relevant to quantum: the date when articles made to the Macdeck Designs were first made available for sale or hire.

There were late interlocutory applications and pleadings amendments at the start of trial dealing with specific disclosure, amendment of the particulars of claim, and amendment of the defence (including reliance on statutory provisos and a statutory innocent infringement defence). The judge dealt with those applications at the start of trial and made several directions (including permitting some amendments and refusing others); the consequences of some amendments were reserved for the damages/form of order hearing.

Four witnesses gave live evidence: the Plaintiff for Company A, and three witnesses for Company B (two directors and a third-party design consultant). The judge gave a summary assessment of credibility and reliability: the Plaintiff was sometimes combative but his inconsistencies were not material; the defendant witnesses were generally fair; and some evidential weaknesses and late disclosure issues (including deletion of social media material by the claimant's accounts) were criticised but did not alter the outcome on the principal issues. The deleted social media material was recovered by Company B and remained available for the trial; the deletion was noted as a serious matter to be addressed at the form-of-order hearing if necessary.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the features of the Macdeck Designs (as particularised in the pleading) are original for the purposes of s.213(1) CDPA.
  2. Whether particular pleaded features are excluded from design right protection because they are features that enable the article to be connected to or placed in, around or against another article (s.213(3)(b)(i) CDPA) (the interface provision).
  3. Whether particular pleaded features are commonplace in the relevant design field by reason of earlier products (s.213(4) CDPA).
  4. Whether particular pleaded features constitute surface decoration and are therefore excluded (s.213(3)(c) CDPA).
  5. Whether particular pleaded features amount to a method or principle of construction and are therefore excluded (s.213(3)(a) CDPA).
  6. When articles made to the Macdeck Designs were first made available for sale or hire for the purposes of s.216 CDPA (relevant to the length of the design right term).
  7. Whether each of the Q Deck Components constitutes an article made exactly or substantially to one of the Macdeck Designs (primary infringement, s.226 CDPA).
  8. Whether the Q Deck Components were copied from the corresponding Macdeck Designs (fact of copying, relevant to s.226(2)).
  9. Whether Company B knew or had reason to believe that the Q Deck Components were infringing articles (secondary infringement, s.227 CDPA).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Macdeck Designs (the 1x1 panel, the perimeter part, the 0.75x1 panel and the pin) were created on 4 January 2016 and are owned by Company A; the Plaintiff (as Company A's managing director) and an external designer worked together to create the designs.
  • The Macdeck Designs are original. Company A relied on the traditional UK authorities (skill, labour and aesthetic judgment) and maintained that even if the Court were to apply the EU-derived test for originality (the author's own intellectual creation) the designs would satisfy that test.
  • Company A accepted that some features were functional but argued that the author retained design freedom in the shape, size, number, spacing and arrangement of particular apertures, raised profile patterns and pin details such that the whole designs were original.
  • The articles manufactured to the Macdeck Designs existed and had been used on sites in 2016 as part of product demonstrations and approvals; Company A submitted that such use meant the designs were not “made available for sale or hire” in the commercial sense until 2017 (Company A argued the 2016 activity amounted to demonstrations and marketing rather than commercial availability).
  • Company A argued that the Q Deck Components were made to the Macdeck Designs and that Company B had copies of or access to Company A's products; accordingly, Company B's manufacture and supply amounted to primary and secondary infringement in relation to the pleaded designs (and Company B had knowledge or reason to believe that its articles were infringing).

Defendant's Arguments

  • Company B contended that the correct test of originality for a design under s.213(1) CDPA is the EU/CJEU-derived test (the design must be the expression of the author's own intellectual creation) and that Company A had not been put to proof on that standard in its particulars; Company B asserted that factual matters relevant to that standard were not sufficiently pleaded in advance.
  • Company B argued that many of the features particularised by Company A are dictated by technical function and therefore not original. In particular it relied on an earlier safety decking product (the pre-priority system that Company A had used/hired) as prior art to show features were commonplace.
  • Company B relied on the statutory exclusions in s.213(3) CDPA: (a) that some pleaded features are a method or principle of construction; (b) that features which enable an article to be connected to or placed around another article are excluded (interface provision); and (c) that certain surface features are surface decoration and therefore excluded.
  • Company B ran a factual case that its design process for the Q Deck system started from Company A's system (it had samples at the start of its work), that it took steps to alter appearance and to achieve interoperability, and that the ultimate Q Deck Components were sufficiently different in overall appearance such that they were not made exactly or substantially to Company A's designs for the purposes of s.226 CDPA.
  • Where copying was established, Company B submitted various defences including innocent infringement or lack of knowledge as to the subsistence of a design in particular parts of a design; some of those points were reserved for the damages/form of order hearing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Action Storage Systems v G-Force Europe [2016] EWHC 3151 (IPEC) Summary of the legal effect of the Intellectual Property Act 2014 amendment to s.213(2) (removal of the words "any aspect of") and guidance on particularisation and exclusions (including the interface provision). The court relied on Action Storage for guidance on how the 2014 amendment narrowed designs and on practical approaches to particularising pleaded designs and on the limits of s.213(3)(b)(i) (interface provision).
Neptune (Europe) Ltd v Devol Kitchens Ltd [2017] EWHC 2172 (Pat) Distinction between 'aspects' and 'parts' of a design and commentary that the 2014 amendment prevents claims in respect of disembodied features. The court cited Neptune to support the proposition that the statutory amendment prevents protection of disembodied or arbitrarily selected features and to assist in interpreting "part of an article".
DKH Retail Ltd v H. Young (Operations) Ltd [2014] EWHC 4034 (IPEC) Explanatory note that the amendment to s.213 was intended to limit protection for trivial features and reduce uncertainty. The court used this authority (by reference) to support the purposive reading of s.213(2) and to contextualise the limitations introduced by the 2014 Act.
Whitby Specialist Vehicles v Yorkshire Specialist Vehicles [2014] EWHC 4242 (Pat) Traditional copyright-style test of originality (skill, labour and judgment) and that a design must originate with the author. The claimant relied on Whitby for the contention that sufficient skill, effort and aesthetic judgment supports originality; the court treated Whitby as one of the authorities to be considered when defining originality for s.213.
Magmatic Ltd v PMS International Ltd [2013] EWHC 1925 (Pat) Support for the traditional view that originality requires the design to originate with the author and not to have been copied. The court referenced Magmatic alongside Whitby in the discussion of the meaning of "original" under s.213(1).
Infopaq International A/S v Danske Dagblades Forening (C‑5/08) EU authority developing the test of originality in copyright (early step in the CJEU line of cases). The court identified Infopaq as part of the EU jurisprudence the defendant relied upon for a higher standard of originality (author's own intellectual creation).
Cofemel-Sociedade De Vestuario SA v G-Star Raw CV (C‑683/17) CJEU statement that originality requires the subject matter to be the author's own intellectual creation and that technical constraints do not automatically negate originality. The court applied the Cofemel principle when determining which originality test to apply to s.213(1) and concluded the EU approach was apt to determine originality under the statute.
Brompton Bicycle Ltd v Chedech/Get2Get (C‑833/18) Clarification that a subject matter dictated by technical considerations may still be original if the author reflected personality through creative choices. The court relied on Brompton to resolve the tension between functional constraints and originality, concluding that functional dictation does not necessarily preclude originality.
Farmers Build Ltd v Carrier Bulk Materials Handling Ltd [1999] RPC Historical view that "original" in s.213 has the same meaning as in copyright and a two-stage approach (copyright originality then commonplace). The court cited Farmers Build for the two-stage approach to subsistence (originality in the copyright sense and then assessment of commonplace under s.213(4)).
C & H Engineering v F Klucznik & Sons Ltd [1992] FSR Authority concerning the meaning of "original" and copying in design contexts (historical copyright comparisons). Referred to in relation to the historical understanding of "original" for designs and in support of Farmers Build's statements.
Landor & Hawa International v Azure Designs Ltd [2007] FSR 9 (CA) Authority that a design is not precluded from protection merely because it has a functional purpose; commentary on s.213(3)(a). The court cited Landor to support the submission that functionality alone does not automatically bar design protection.
Ocular Sciences Ltd v Aspect Vision Care Ltd [1997] RPC 289 Interpretation of the interface provision and the concept of commonplaceness in design law. Ocular was used extensively as precedent on (i) the interface exclusion (features that enable articles to be placed together) and (ii) what is meant by "commonplace" in the design field.
Lambretta Clothing Co Ltd v Teddy Smith (UK) Ltd [2005] RPC 6 Principles about commonplace designs and the thinking of designers in the field. The court relied on Lambretta (via Action Storage) in summarising principles used to determine commonplaceness.
Ultraframe (UK) Ltd v Eurocell Building Plastics Ltd [2005] EWCA Civ 761 Guidance that commonplace designs are those "ready to hand" and not obscure prior art. Used in the court's summary of what it means for a design to be commonplace in the field of relevant designers.
Dyson v Qualtex [2006] EWCA Civ 166 Guidance on the 'ordinary reasonable consumer' approach and critique of conceptual uncertainty in s.213. The court cited Jacob LJ's observations in Dyson when discussing surface decoration and the interpretative challenges of s.213.
SAS Institute Inc v World Programming Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1482 Observation that the EU test of originality is higher than the traditional English test. The court cited this authority when addressing the comparative stringency of EU originality jurisprudence.
THJ Systems v Sheridan [2023] EWCA Civ 1354 Confirmation that the correct test for originality in copyright is the "author's own intellectual creation" test. The court referred to THJ Systems for confirmation of the correct test in copyright matters and as support for applying EU authorities to the originality question under s.213(1).
Sonia Edwards v Boohoo.com & others [2025] EWHC 805 (IPEC) Recent IPEC decision applying the EU authorities to unregistered design right originality. The court noted this later decision for completeness and stated it did not affect the analysis in the present case.
Ifejika v Ifejika [2010] FSR 6 Interpretation that "any making available for sale, on any scale, is relevant" when deciding if articles were made available for sale or hire for s.216 purposes. The court relied on Ifejika when considering whether limited or demonstrative commercial use in 2016 triggered the running of the design term.
Wooley v A Jewellers [2002] EWCA Civ 1119 Distinction between copying a part (copyright) and whether an entire design is substantially the same (design right). Used to explain the two-part approach to infringement: copying may be inferred from access plus similarity, but whether an article is "exactly or substantially to the design" is a separate assessment.
Original Beauty v G4K Fashion1 [2021] EWHC 294 (Ch) Statement that a simple causal link between the claimant's design and the defendant's design can establish copying. The court cited this authority in summarising principles that support an inference of copying where the claimant's design contributed to the defendant's design.
Efobi v Royal Mail Group Ltd [2021] UKSC 33 Principles relating to whether adverse inferences should be drawn where a relevant witness is not called. The court applied Efobi when considering whether to draw an adverse inference from the absence of the external designer as a witness; the court declined to draw an adverse inference on the facts of this case.
Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd v Premium Aircraft Interiors Group [2009] EWHC 26 (Pat) Referenced for propositions on comparing designs and the relationship between similarity and copying. Used indirectly via other authorities cited (as part of the established approach to assessing infringement and similarity).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Framework adopted for subsistence (s.213 CDPA)

The court set out the statutory framework in s.213 CDPA and relevant exclusions in s.213(3) and (4). The court considered whether the historic UK test of originality (skill, labour and judgment) or the EU/CJEU "author's own intellectual creation" test should apply to originality in s.213(1). After reviewing authorities and policy considerations the judge concluded that the EU authorities (Infopaq, Cofemel, Brompton and related decisions) provide the appropriate interpretive approach and that "original" in s.213(1) should be given the same meaning as in s.1(1)(a) (copyright), i.e. the expression of the author's own intellectual creation. The court acknowledged there can be tension where technical function constrains choices, but held that such constraint does not automatically negate originality; a design that is functional may still be original if the author had scope to reflect personality through creative choices.

Part of an article (post-2014 amendment)

The court considered whether the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design (a circumscribed shaded portion on the drawing) constituted "part of an article" after the 2014 amendment removing the words "any aspect of." The court held that the perimeter design as pleaded and drawn in the particulars was a contiguous, clearly circumscribed part of an article and therefore a permissible "part of an article" for design protection. The pleadings were sufficiently particularised to enable responsive pleadings.

Originality: application to each pleaded design

Applying the EU test, the court examined the Macdeck Designs as a whole and the specific features particularised in the Amended Particulars of Claim. The court accepted that many functional considerations limited some choices (for example, apertures sized to receive scaffolding poles, strap routing slots, pin sockets and features necessary to permit safe handling). Nevertheless, the court found that the author retained genuine creative freedom in the overall shape and configuration: choices about the number, size, spacing, location, profile of apertures, the patterning of raised anti-slip bumps on the surface, and the detailed shape and proportions of the pin head and shaft were sufficient to allow the author to reflect personality. The court therefore concluded that:

  • The Macdeck 1x1 Panel Design is original.
  • The Macdeck 0.75x1 Panel Design (a proportionally reduced version) is original.
  • The Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design is original (the author retained creative choices in the perimeter features).
  • The Macdeck Pin Design, although simple and highly functional, retained sufficient quality of choice in its shape and configuration for the court to find originality.

Commonplace (s.213(4))

Company B relied principally on an earlier commercially available safety decking product as prior art (described in the judgment as the pre-priority product) to argue that features were commonplace. The court applied the standard summarised in previous authorities (that a commonplace design is trite, hackneyed or "ready to hand" in the design field). After analysing the evidence about the prior products and their specific features the court concluded that, on balance, Company B had not proved that the Macdeck Designs (or the particularised features in dispute) were commonplace in the design field at the date of creation.

Interface provision and excluded features (s.213(3)(b)(i))

The court analysed the complaint that many of the particularised features are excluded because they enable the article to be connected to or placed around another article. The judge emphasised that the statutory exclusion requires a degree of precision in the interrelationship between articles—i.e., an interface that produces a stable, precise fit. The court's approach in summary:

  • Voids within specific apertures (the internal spaces sized to permit passage of scaffolding poles or to receive pins) were treated as the operative features enabling interface and were therefore excluded from design protection to the extent they consisted only of the required voids sized to receive other articles.
  • The external shapes surrounding those voids (for example, whether the aperture is defined by a square outline or a circle) were not, of themselves, excluded where the court was satisfied alternative shapes could achieve the same functional void—i.e., the court distinguished between the void (excluded) and the decorative/external shape (not necessarily excluded).
  • Large hand-hold apertures used intermittently by a user’s hand were not excluded because the interrelationship between a hand and a hand-hold is inherently imprecise and transient and therefore lacks the degree of precision required by the interface exclusion.
  • Pin shaft diameter and other elements that are designed to fit the connector (and which produce a snug fit) were excluded because they are designed to fit; by contrast certain visible profile and arrangement features around the pin were not excluded unless they merely duplicated the functional interface.

Surface decoration (s.213(3)(c))

The court considered whether particular raised profile features were surface decoration. The small concentric ring used as a roundel for branding (a circular space for a logo) was seen by the court, on the design drawing and the article, as a surface decoration and therefore excluded. By contrast, the majority of the raised anti-slip bump pattern was treated as functional (anti-slip) and, even though three-dimensional, was not regarded by the court as surface decoration in the relevant sense.

Method or principle of construction (s.213(3)(a))

The court considered the submissions that the pleaded particulars amounted to method or principle of construction (i.e., a too-general concept akin to a patent claim). Having regard to the post-2014 restriction and the fact that the claimed designs were expressed by detailed drawings (not abstract patent-like claims), the court concluded that the pleaded designs did not amount to excluded methods or principles of construction.

Authorship and entitlement

Company A's ownership of any design right was accepted by Company B for the purpose of the trial. The court considered whether the Plaintiff (a director of Company A) was an author whose work was created in the course of employment such that protection under s.219(1) applied. The Plaintiff explained the development process, admitted that an external designer (at a design firm) produced CAD drawings, and explained he had contributed concept and sign-off. The court found the Plaintiff to be a co-author who had sufficiently expressed intellectual creation and that, on the evidence, he was employed by Company A in the relevant period for the purposes of entitlement to UK unregistered design right. The court noted the absence of the external designer as a witness and considered but ultimately declined to draw an adverse inference under Efobi on the facts of this case.

When were articles first made available for sale or hire (s.216)?

The Macdeck Designs were created on 4 January 2016. The court examined whether articles made to the Macdeck Designs were first made available for sale or hire in 2016 or in 2017. The factual matrix included: (a) production of finished moulded boards and successful testing by June/July 2016; (b) social media posts and photographs showing Company A's articles in use on live construction sites in 2016 as part of demonstrations and approvals; (c) ledger and accounting records that were imperfect and partially migrated between accounting systems; and (d) a contract and order documentation for larger-scale manufacture toward the end of 2016.

Applying Ifejika and analyzing the commercial context, the court concluded that the articles made to the Macdeck Designs were made available for sale or hire in 2016. The judge treated the demonstrative trials on sites (where Company A placed panels for approval and use in the ordinary course of approval processes) as part of the commercial making-available process and therefore held that the term calculation under s.216 runs from 2016. The consequence is that the design term is subject to the licence-of-right regime for the second five-year period (s.237), limiting the claimant's relief to a right to licence/damages for part of the statutory term; precise relief was reserved for the form-of-order hearing.

Infringement: copying and substantial reproduction (s.226)

The court applied the two-stage infringement approach: first, whether there was copying (direct or indirect) and, second, whether the defendant's articles were made exactly or substantially to the protected design. The court adopted the approach in the authorities that, where copying is established, it is likely (absent an incompetent copyist) that the resulting article will be made exactly or substantially to the copied design; but copying itself is a factual inquiry and may be inferred from access plus substantial similarity.

Development history and copying inference

Company B started a design exercise in 2019 and engaged a design firm (Company C) to create a new panel compatible with Company A's system. Documentary and witness evidence established that Company B had access to Company A's panels, used them as a starting point, and instructed the design firm that the new system had to be interoperable with Company A's existing stock. Internal design documents and exchanges showed repeated comparisons with Company A's panel and iterations intended to make the new design look different while keeping functional consistency.

The court found that Company B used Company A's system as the starting point and that the development process involved repeated reference to Company A's design. A finding of copying (indirect copying via Company A's existing articles) was supported by the evidence.

Was the defendant's panel made exactly or substantially to the claimant's designs?

The court conducted a detailed visual and feature-by-feature comparison. The principal findings were:

  • The Q Deck 1x1 Panel (Company B's panel) shared many functional similarities with the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Design (outer dimensions, four-fold symmetry, concentric arrangements of apertures, a pattern of raised bumps, perimeter cut-outs and side slots). There were also visible differences (different shapes of the central apertures, additional oblong/pill-shaped apertures creating diagonal emphasis, a different arrangement and density of raised bumps and other surface pattern differences).
  • Taking the overall design from the perspective of the notional user/designer, the court concluded that, despite extensive copying, the Q Deck 1x1 Panel was not made exactly or substantially to the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Design as a whole: the overall appearance and visual cues (including the diagonal oblong apertures and surface patterning) would draw the eye to differences and an objective observer would regard the Q Deck panel's overall appearance as different.
  • However, when the court assessed the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design (the part-pleaded perimeter area) in isolation (and after disregarding features excluded by s.213(3) as appropriate), the corresponding part of the Q Deck 1x1 Panel was sufficiently similar. The court therefore found that the Q Deck 1x1 Panel infringed the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design (primary infringement).
  • With respect to the Macdeck 0.75x1 Panel Design (a proportionate variant), the parties agreed to treat issues mutatis mutandis; the court concluded that Company B's 0.75x1 panel did not infringe the Macdeck 0.75x1 Panel Design in the sense of being made exactly or substantially to it for the same reasons as applied to the 1x1 panel overall.
  • As to the Macdeck Pin Design, after excluding features in which design right did not subsist (the shaft diameter, the lower arresting disc and length elements), the court held that what remained was not pleaded as a separate part of the pin design for infringement comparison and therefore no finding of infringement was necessary. In the alternative (if the remaining features were treated as a design), the court would have found that the Q Deck Pin was made exactly or substantially to the Macdeck Pin Design; however the formal pleading position meant the court did not make a primary finding of infringement on the pin design as pleaded.

Secondary infringement and knowledge (s.227)

The court concluded that, in relation to the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design infringement, Company B had knowledge or reason to believe that the relevant articles were infringing. Company B had been a customer and had significant commercial dealings and visibility of Company A's system; internal documents demonstrated awareness. The court therefore found that Company B's acts of dealing with and offering for sale/hire the infringing articles amounted to secondary infringement where applicable.

Passing off

Company B submitted to judgment on the passing off claim on the basis of its pleaded case. The court recorded that the Claimant's passing off claim succeeds and that any inquiry as to damages for passing off is to be addressed at the form-of-order hearing.

Holding and Implications

CORE RULING: PARTIAL SUCCESS FOR THE PLAINTIFF

The court made the following principal formal outcomes:

  1. The court found that the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Perimeter Design (the pleaded perimeter part) is infringed by Company B's Q Deck 1x1 Panel: primary and secondary infringement were established in relation to that part of the design. The court therefore upheld Company A's infringement claim in part.
  2. The court did not find that Company B's Q Deck Components were made exactly or substantially to the whole Macdeck 1x1 Panel Design (and therefore did not establish primary or secondary infringement of the Macdeck 1x1 Panel Design as a whole), nor did it find infringement of the Macdeck 0.75x1 Panel Design or (as pleaded) the Macdeck Pin Design.
  3. The court held that articles made to the Macdeck Designs were made available for sale or hire in 2016; the statutory term calculation under s.216 runs from 2016, which engages the licence-of-right regime under s.237 for the second five-year period and limits the available relief to a licence/damages for that period. The precise relief and any accounting consequences were reserved for the form-of-order and damages inquiry.
  4. The Claimant's passing off claim succeeded (Company B had submitted to judgment on that claim) and an inquiry as to damages for passing off was directed to be addressed at a later form-of-order hearing.

Implications and procedural consequences (as recorded by the court):

  • Relief for unregistered design right will be subject to the licence-of-right regime for the second five-year period; the court will delineate the precise relief (licence or damages and quantum) at the form-of-order hearing.
  • The court declined to draw an adverse inference from the absence of the external designer as a witness on the available facts, but the absence was noted as regrettable; the court evaluated authorship and entitlement on the balance of the available evidence.
  • The deletion of social media material by Company A was recorded as serious; the court indicated this matter could be addressed at the form-of-order/interim remedies hearing but concluded it did not alter the primary findings on liability.
  • The court will hear counsel on the form of order. Time for seeking permission to appeal is directed not to run until after the form-of-order hearing (or making of such an order if agreed).
  • No wider novel legal principle was announced: the court applied established authorities (including the EU copyright originality authorities where relevant) to the statutory provisions governing unregistered design right; the decision is fact-specific to the pleadings, particulars and articles in evidence.

If the parties cannot agree the form of order, the court indicated counsels will be heard on those matters and on consequential directions (including issues reserved for any inquiry into damages and questions arising from later amendments to the defence).


Note: All personal names and the names of the litigating companies have been anonymised in this summary. The analysis and quotations are taken from the judgment as provided; no material facts have been created or inferred beyond those expressly recorded in the judgment.