- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Liverpool City Council v Ms A & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
The child at the centre of these proceedings is a 7-year-old boy of dual Italian and Romanian heritage, currently placed in local authority foster care. The applicant local authority, Company A, seeks a final care order and approval of a care plan for the child to remain in long-term foster care, with contact arrangements proposed for both parents. The mother supports the application and care plan, while the father opposes it, seeking placement of the child in his immediate care in Italy under an order of the Italian courts, with shared parental responsibility and local child protection services' involvement.
The matter has a lengthy litigation history involving three children of the mother. Previous final orders were made for the siblings, with one sibling placed in foster care and another under supervision with the father. A prior child arrangements order for the child to live with the father was appealed successfully, leading to this re-hearing focused solely on welfare decision-making for the child.
The parents' relationship ended in 2019, with subsequent complex contact arrangements and serious allegations including domestic abuse and criminality. The local authority issued proceedings in 2022, resulting in the removal of the child and one sibling into foster care. A fact-finding hearing in 2024 found the father violent and threatening, manipulative, and involved in criminal activity, with findings against the mother and other parties as well. No appeals were made against these factual findings.
A psychological assessment by an expert appointed by the court was found to be fundamentally flawed due to failure to accept the court's factual findings, leading to further delay and costs. The court declined the expert's request for anonymity, emphasizing the importance of expert accountability.
The court received detailed submissions on the relevant law concerning welfare decision-making under the Children Act 1989, emphasizing the paramountcy of the child's welfare and the need for a holistic, balanced analysis of all realistically possible options. The court also considered the Article 8 rights of the father and child.
Oral evidence was heard from an independent social worker, the allocated social worker from the local authority, the father, and the child's guardian. The local authority's care plan remained for long-term foster care, with cautious openness to contact and potential rehabilitation to the father's care under review. The independent social worker provided a cautiously optimistic assessment of the father's parenting capacity, supporting placement with the father in Italy with local support. The allocated social worker and guardian supported the local authority's plan but were found by the court to have provided unbalanced welfare analyses, insufficiently considering the positives and risks of placement with the father.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court should make a final care order placing the child in long-term foster care with the local authority.
- Whether the child should be rehabilitated to the care of the father in Italy under local child protection oversight.
- How to balance the child's welfare needs, including safety, stability, permanency, family relationships, and cultural identity, in deciding the appropriate placement.
- The extent to which findings of domestic abuse and risk assessments impact the father's capacity to care for the child safely.
- The court's approach to expert evidence that challenges its factual findings.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant Local Authority's Arguments
- Seeks a final care order for the child to remain in long-term foster care.
- Proposes continued contact with the mother on a fortnightly basis and progressively unsupervised contact with the father, including extended holiday time initially in the UK and then Italy.
- Expresses concerns about the father's capacity to promote the child's other significant relationships, including with siblings and foster carer, if placed in Italy.
- Emphasizes the importance of the sibling relationship and stability of current placement.
- Maintains reservations about the father's denial of domestic abuse findings and the need for successful domestic abuse work before rehabilitation.
- Criticizes the father's engagement and the sustainability of contact arrangements.
Mother's Arguments
- Supports the local authority's application and final care plan for long-term foster care.
Father's Arguments
- Opposes the local authority's application and final care plan.
- Seeks placement of the child in his immediate care in Italy with shared parental responsibility and support from local child protection services.
- Argues for maintaining and developing the child's relationship with him and the paternal family.
- Denies the findings of domestic abuse and asserts he has completed relevant domestic abuse work.
- Emphasizes his commitment, capacity for emotionally attuned parenting, and willingness to engage with professional support.
- Highlights the importance of the child's cultural and linguistic heritage and the benefits of living in Italy.
Guardian's Arguments
- Supports the local authority's care plan for long-term foster care.
- Opposes a move to the father's care in Italy, citing concerns about placement stability, risk of loss of important relationships, and the child's emotional well-being.
- Emphasizes the importance of maintaining all significant family relationships and providing stability.
- Expresses concerns about the father's capacity to promote the child's relationships with the mother, siblings, and foster carer.
- Notes gaps and omissions in the assessment of risks and advantages of both placement options.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Re B-S (Children) [2013] EWCA Civ 1146 | Requirement for the court to consider all realistically possible options and carry out a proper balancing exercise in welfare decisions. | The court applied this principle by undertaking a global, holistic, and multifaceted welfare analysis considering all options for the child's upbringing. |
| Re G (A Child) (Care Proceedings; Welfare Evaluation) [2013] EWCA Civ 965 | Mandate for a global, holistic, and multifaceted welfare analysis weighing pros and cons of each option. | The court emphasized the necessity of balancing advantages and disadvantages of each placement option in light of the child's individual circumstances. |
| Re N (A Child) (Care Order: Welfare Evaluation) [2024] EWCA Civ 938 | Once threshold is crossed, the court must carry out a pure welfare analysis without presumption in favour of parental care. | The court followed this approach, rejecting any presumption that the child should be brought up by the parent and weighing all factors equally. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court commenced its analysis by focusing on the child's specific characteristics and needs, emphasizing his young age, dependency, need for stability, security, permanency, and maintenance of core family relationships including cultural and linguistic identity. The court acknowledged the trauma and instability the child has experienced and the necessity for emotionally attuned, therapeutic parenting.
The court considered the child's wishes and feelings, noting his expressed desire to live with his father in Italy but also his attachment to his sibling and foster carer. The court recognized the limits of the child's understanding due to his age and experiences.
Regarding the father's capacity, the court found the independent social worker's thorough and cautiously optimistic assessment persuasive, concluding that the father can meet the child's holistic needs with ongoing support and that risks, including those related to domestic abuse, are manageable under the Italian support plan. The court noted the father's commitment, insight, and engagement with interventions.
The court critically assessed the local authority's and guardian's evidence, finding their welfare analyses unbalanced and insufficiently open to the possibility of placement with the father. The court identified failures to fairly consider protective factors, the support available in Italy, and the risks and disadvantages of long-term foster care, including cultural and linguistic erosion, placement instability, and potential loss of paternal family relationships.
The court noted concerns about the sustainability and quality of contact arrangements with the father while in foster care and the local authority's institutional resistance to considering rehabilitation to the father's care.
In weighing the risks of placement with the father, the court acknowledged the history of domestic abuse findings but accepted the expert psychological assessments concluding the residual risk is minimal and manageable with professional support. The father's denial of the abuse findings was noted as an obstacle but did not outweigh the overall positive assessment.
The court also considered the risks and benefits of remaining in foster care, recognizing the stability and attachment the child has formed but highlighting the transactional nature of foster care, risks of placement breakdown, and the child's significant dependency needs and long minority.
Ultimately, the court found the welfare balance firmly in favour of the child being rehabilitated to the father's care in Italy, given the father's capacity, the support plan, the child's needs for permanency and belonging, and the inadequacies and risks associated with continued long-term foster care.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision is to order the rehabilitation of the child to the care of the father in Italy, with the local authority invited to amend its care plan and file a transition and support plan to facilitate the child's move during the long summer vacation.
The direct effect of this decision is that the child will leave local authority foster care to live with his father under the oversight and support of Italian child protection services, ensuring ongoing management of risks and promotion of the child's welfare and family relationships. The decision does not establish new legal precedent but reflects the application of established welfare principles and the paramountcy of the child's best interests in complex cross-jurisdictional care proceedings.
Alert