- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bridging Finance Inc v Lyons
Factual and Procedural Background
The judgment arises from a contested bankruptcy petition presented by Company A, acting by its receivers, seeking a bankruptcy order against the Defendant, a property investor. The petition debt stems from a personal guarantee dated 26 October 2018, originally amounting to approximately CAD 55 million, later amended to about CAD 39 million (£26.6 million) following partial debt discharge from asset realisation.
In late 2018, the Defendant sought to take control of a property investment project in Northumbria, involving a company facing planning and borrowing difficulties. To finance this, the Defendant approached Company A through its senior managing director, leading to a loan facility agreement secured by a personal guarantee from the Defendant. The loan was made to a company ultimately controlled by the Defendant’s investment company.
The property development failed, resulting in the involved companies entering administration between 2019 and 2022. Company A went into receivership in April 2021. Following default, Company A served a statutory demand on the Defendant in November 2022, which the Defendant unsuccessfully sought to set aside. The bankruptcy petition was presented in July 2024, served by substituted service.
The Defendant opposes the petition, challenging the court’s jurisdiction and disputing the petition debt on several grounds, including alleged misrepresentations, estoppel, waiver, and procedural non-compliance. The trial was conducted over two days with some procedural complexities, including late evidence admission and non-attendance of key witnesses for cross-examination.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court has jurisdiction to make a bankruptcy order against the Defendant, given his asserted centre of main interests and business activities.
- Whether the Defendant carried on business in England and Wales during the relevant three-year period under section 265(1)(c)(ii) of the Insolvency Act 1986.
- Whether the petition debt is genuinely disputed on grounds including misrepresentation, estoppel, waiver, and non-disclosure of a freezing injunction.
- Whether procedural non-compliance, specifically delay in presenting the petition without explanation as required by the Insolvency Rules, warrants dismissal of the petition.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Company A)
- The Defendant carried on a personal business as a serial property entrepreneur through at least 33 UK companies, constituting carrying on business in England and Wales during the relevant period.
- The Defendant also carried on business in relation to a London property (Hamilton Terrace) in his individual capacity, including development, letting, and sale during the relevant period.
- The Defendant’s involvement in incorporation, promotion, financing, guarantees, and control of companies indicates a personal business distinct from the companies’ businesses.
- The petition debt is not genuinely disputed; alleged misrepresentations and collateral agreements are inherently implausible and unsupported by contemporaneous evidence.
- Non-compliance with procedural rules regarding delay is excused due to the circumstances and absence of prejudice to the Defendant.
Respondent's Arguments (Defendant)
- Challenges the court’s jurisdiction, asserting his centre of main interests is outside the UK and that he did not carry on business in England and Wales during the relevant period.
- Contends that shareholdings and property ownership do not amount to carrying on business personally.
- Claims the petition debt is disputed on grounds including material misrepresentations by Company A’s representative, a collateral contract not to enforce the guarantee, estoppel, waiver, and failure to disclose a freezing injunction.
- Argues that after emigrating in 2010, he ceased active involvement in UK companies, delegating management to an associate, and became a passive investor.
- Asserts procedural non-compliance by Company A regarding delay in presenting the petition.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Re Brauch (A Debtor) Ex parte Britannic Securities & Investments Ltd [1978] Ch 316 | Definition and scope of "carrying on business" in bankruptcy jurisdiction context. | Used as primary authority to assess whether the Defendant’s activities constituted carrying on business personally, noting parallels and distinctions. |
| Anglo Irish Bank Corporation Ltd v Flannery [2013] BPIR 1 | Factors relevant to determining carrying on business and residence for jurisdiction. | Considered but found of limited assistance; court noted negative jurisdiction finding in that case. |
| Masters v Barclays Bank plc [2013] EWHC 2166 (Ch) | Clarification of carrying on business and residence concepts. | Referenced in analysis of carrying on business and use of addresses for service. |
| Alan Turner v Ronal William Trevorrow and anor [1994] FCA 1091 | Australian authority on carrying on business requiring the business to be the debtor’s own. | Reviewed to support the principle that control of companies does not necessarily equal carrying on business personally. |
| Westpac Banking Corporation v Faress [2011] FMCA 26 | Requirement that business carried on must be the debtor’s own for jurisdiction. | Noted but given limited weight due to lack of detailed evidence and opposition. |
| In re A Debtor (No 784 of 1991) [1992] Ch 554 | Continuing effect of unpaid trading debts on carrying on business. | Considered but found unhelpful for one-off acts like company promotion outside relevant period. |
| Durkan v Jones [2023] EWHC 1359 (Ch) | Property letting can constitute carrying on business for jurisdictional purposes. | Applied to hold that Defendant’s activities with Hamilton Terrace amounted to carrying on business. |
| Markham v Karsten [2007] EWHC 1509 (Ch) | Test for genuine triable issue in disputed petition debt cases. | Adopted to assess whether Defendant’s dispute of debt raised a genuine triable issue. |
| Alexander-Theodotou v Michael Kyprianou [2016] EWHC 1493 (Ch) | Standard for setting aside statutory demands based on genuine triable issues. | Referenced to confirm the applicable test. |
| Ashworth v Newnote Limited [2007] BPIR 1012 | Equivalence of genuine triable issue test and real prospect of success test. | Confirmed the test to be applied to disputed debts. |
| Angel Group Limited v British Gas Trading Ltd [2012] EWHC 2702 (Ch) | Warning against “cloud of objections” tactics in debt disputes. | Applied to caution against meritless disputes raised by Defendant. |
| Coilcolor Ltd v Camtrex Ltd | Similar caution against unmeritorious disputes in insolvency proceedings. | Applied alongside Angel Group in assessing disputes. |
| Collier v P&MJ Wright (Holdings) Limited [2007] EWCA Civ 1329 | Requirement for evidence supporting disputed facts in debt claims. | Used to reject unsupported assertions by Defendant. |
| Coyne v DRC Distribution Ltd [2008] EWCA Civ 488 | Rejection of manifestly incredible evidence supported by contemporaneous documents. | Applied to discredit Defendant’s unsupported allegations. |
| Macplant Services Ltd v Contract Lifting Services (Scotland) Ltd CSOH 158 | Consideration of commercial improbability in assessing disputed debts. | Referenced to assess plausibility of Defendant’s claims. |
| West Bromwich Building Society v Crammer [2002] EWCA Civ 1924 | Inquiry into why arguments were not previously raised in proceedings. | Applied to question lateness and bona fides of Defendant’s grounds. |
| Conway v Kenny [1999] EWCA Civ 639 | Single transaction can amount to carrying on business. | Supported finding that sale of Hamilton Terrace constituted carrying on business. |
| Salomon v Salomon and Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 | Corporate personality and distinction between individual and company business. | Referenced in assessing whether Defendant’s business was separate from his companies. |
| In re Charles Bright (1901) 18 TLR 37 | Recognition that an individual may conduct a business separate from that of a company. | Used to support the concept of personal business distinct from companies. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by considering the statutory framework under section 265 of the Insolvency Act 1986, focusing on whether the Defendant carried on business in England and Wales during the relevant three-year period. The court analysed the Defendant’s activities in light of established case law, primarily Re Brauch, which held that an individual conducting business through multiple companies may still be personally carrying on a business if the companies form part of his business machinery.
While the court found strong factual parallels between the Defendant and the debtor in Re Brauch—both being property investors using multiple companies—the court was unable to isolate acts attributable solely to the Defendant’s personal business rather than his companies. The court emphasized the legal distinction between the Defendant as an individual and the companies, noting the Defendant’s roles as investor, shareholder, and guarantor were intertwined and not clearly separable.
Consequently, the court rejected the general business basis for jurisdiction, concluding the Defendant did not carry on business personally through the companies during the relevant period.
Turning to the Hamilton Terrace property, the court found that the Defendant’s activities—ownership, refurbishment, letting, and sale—constituted carrying on business in England and Wales within the relevant period. The court relied on Durkan v Jones and related authorities to hold that property letting and sale could amount to carrying on business, even if the activity was limited in time and scale.
On the disputed debt, the court applied the established test for genuine triable issues and found the Defendant’s claims of misrepresentation and collateral agreement inherently implausible, unsupported by evidence, and raised late. The guarantee was integral to the loan, independently advised, and properly executed. Other grounds of opposition, including estoppel, waiver, and non-disclosure of a freezing injunction, were dismissed for lack of legal basis or evidential support.
Regarding procedural delay in presenting the petition, the court accepted the explanation that delay arose from jurisdictional service issues and waived the defect due to absence of prejudice.
The court noted the Defendant’s opposition had developed into a series of points of doubtful merit, some not pursued or supported by law, creating an impression of a “cloud of objections” rather than bona fide grounds.
Holding and Implications
The court’s final decision is to MAKE A BANKRUPTCY ORDER against the Defendant.
This decision confirms that the court has jurisdiction based on the Defendant’s carrying on business through property dealings in England and Wales during the relevant period. The rejection of the general business basis underscores the importance of distinguishing individual business activities from those conducted through corporate entities. The dismissal of disputed debt grounds and procedural objections reinforces the court’s approach to genuine triable issues and procedural compliance.
The ruling directly affects the parties by enabling the bankruptcy order to proceed and does not establish new precedent beyond the application of existing legal principles to the facts.
Alert