- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Houghton v Revenue and Customs (CIVIL EVASION PENALTY - seizure of tobacco - appellant liable to penalty - reduction of penalty for disclosure and co-operation - reduction increased - appeal allowed in part)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerns a civil evasion penalty of £11,252.00 issued by the Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs ("HMRC") to the Appellant, a resident of Dubai, for the seizure of tobacco products on two separate occasions at Manchester Airport in 2021. The first seizure on 27 August 2021 involved 34,000 cigarettes and 4.5kg of hand rolling tobacco, and the second on 8 October 2021 involved 5,800 cigarettes. The Appellant did not attend the hearing but was given proper notice and options to participate remotely or by written submissions. The Tribunal proceeded in his absence.
The Appellant initially did not challenge the seizures within the statutory timeframe, leading to forfeiture of the goods. HMRC investigated further for possible dishonest conduct to evade excise and customs duties. Following no timely disclosure or cooperation from the Appellant, a penalty was issued and subsequently reduced for partial disclosure and cooperation. The Appellant appealed the penalty, disputing its amount and the dishonesty finding.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Appellant attempted to evade payment of UK excise duty on 34,000 cigarettes and 4.5kg of hand rolling tobacco on 27 August 2021 by conduct involving dishonesty.
- Whether the Appellant made an under declaration of excise goods in an attempt to evade payment of UK excise duty on 5,800 cigarettes on 8 October 2021 by conduct involving dishonesty.
- Whether the Appellant is liable to a civil evasion penalty in the sum of £11,252.00.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Appellant contended that he was unaware of the tobacco allowances and believed he could bring as many cigarettes as he wished, based on information received abroad and from duty-free shops.
- He acknowledged the seizures but disputed the amount of the penalty, describing it as excessive and expressing inability to pay.
- The Appellant asserted that he declared cigarettes on the second occasion and sought to explain discrepancies in his communications, including confusion about quantities and the presence of tobacco for family members.
- He complained about correspondence being sent to his mother's address and requested communication by email.
Respondents' Arguments
- HMRC asserted that the Appellant engaged in dishonest conduct to evade excise and customs duties by failing to declare tobacco in excess of personal allowances.
- They emphasized that the Appellant had sufficient notice of the hearing and options to participate, but chose not to engage fully or cooperate promptly.
- HMRC maintained that responsibility for knowing customs restrictions lies with the traveller, not duty-free shop staff.
- They awarded a 20% reduction for disclosure and 20% for cooperation but resisted further reduction, citing inconsistencies and incomplete disclosure.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Limited t/a Crockfords [2017] UKSC 67 | Objective test for dishonesty in civil and criminal cases | The court applied the Ivey test to determine whether the Appellant's conduct was dishonest, focusing on the Appellant's knowledge or belief of the facts and applying the standards of ordinary decent people. |
| Twinsectra Ltd v Yardley [2002] UKHL 12 | Earlier formulation of dishonesty test | Referenced as part of the legal evolution leading to the settled Ivey test. |
| Royal Brunei Airlines Sdn Bhd v Tan [1995] 2 AC 378 | Objective standard of dishonesty | Supported the principle that dishonesty is assessed objectively regardless of the defendant's personal standards. |
| Barlow Clowes International Ltd v Eurotrust International Ltd [2005] UKPC 37 | Clarification of dishonesty test | Reinforced the objective test applied by the court in this case. |
| Bintu Binette Krubally N'diaye [2015] UKFTT 380 | Civil standard of proof (balance of probabilities) | Confirmed the standard of proof applied by the Tribunal in assessing dishonesty. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal carefully considered the evidence including witness statements from UK Border Force officers and HMRC officers, as well as the Appellant’s written communications. The Appellant’s absence was justified given proper notice and opportunity to participate remotely or by written submissions.
Regarding the first seizure, the Tribunal found that the quantity of tobacco far exceeded the personal allowance and that the Appellant knowingly attempted to evade duty by passing through the green 'nothing to declare' channel and misleading the officer about the contents of his bags. The Tribunal concluded that the Appellant’s conduct was dishonest by the objective standards of ordinary decent people.
For the second seizure, although the Appellant initially declared some cigarettes at the red channel, he failed to disclose the full quantity until after being asked to bring his bags for search. The Tribunal rejected the Appellant’s explanation that he only referred to the cigarettes on the counter and found that the failure to disclose the full amount was dishonest conduct aimed at evading duty.
The Tribunal applied the civil standard of proof and the legal test for dishonesty as established in Ivey. It found that the Appellant had the requisite knowledge or belief of the facts and that his conduct was dishonest objectively.
On the issue of penalty reduction, the Tribunal acknowledged HMRC’s 20% reductions for disclosure and cooperation but determined that a higher reduction for disclosure was appropriate (25% for the first seizure and 30% for the second) based on the Appellant’s partial admissions and disclosures. The Tribunal rejected the Appellant’s inability to pay as a mitigating factor, consistent with statutory provisions.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal ALLOWED THE APPEAL IN PART by increasing the reduction for disclosure to 25% for the penalty related to the first seizure and 30% for the penalty related to the second seizure. The Appellant remains liable to a civil evasion penalty, but the total amount is to be recalculated accordingly by HMRC.
The direct consequence is a reduction in the penalty amount payable by the Appellant. No new legal precedent was established; the decision applied established principles regarding dishonesty and penalty reductions under relevant Finance Acts.
Alert