- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Power Projects Sanayi Insaat Ticaret Limited Sirketi v Star Assurance Company Ltd
Factual and Procedural Background
The Defendant, Company A, applied to convert the claim brought by the Plaintiff under Part 8 of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) into a Part 7 claim, seeking directions for pleadings and disclosure. The hearing concerned Company A's objection to the use of the Part 8 procedure, as stated in its amended acknowledgment of service. The Plaintiff's Part 8 claim, issued on 28 November 2023, sought payment of US $6,297,000 pursuant to a demand made under a performance bond dated 22 November 2018 issued by Company A in favour of the Plaintiff. The bond was an irrevocable, unconditional on-demand payment instrument valid until 21 November 2021.
Company A contended that the sums under the bond were not due, asserting a defence involving a substantial dispute of fact, thereby rendering the Part 8 procedure inappropriate and justifying conversion to Part 7.
The Plaintiff is a company incorporated in Turkey and registered as an external company in Ghana, engaged in large-scale energy project contracting. It entered into a contract with a Ghanaian company for constructing a power-generation plant and subsequently subcontracted parts of the work to two Ghanaian and Korean companies (together "Subcontractors"). The Subcontracts required on-demand performance bonds, which Company A provided.
Disputes arose between the Plaintiff and the Subcontractors regarding performance and payments. Despite reminders to renew the bond, the Plaintiff made a demand for payment under the bond on 9 November 2021. Company A refused payment, citing the underlying contractual disputes and alleging that the Plaintiff had not fulfilled its obligations. The Subcontractors initiated proceedings in Ghanaian courts, which were stayed pending arbitration under the Subcontracts.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the use of the Part 8 procedure was appropriate in a claim under an on-demand performance bond where the Defendant asserted a substantial dispute of fact.
- Whether the Defendant was entitled to convert the claim from Part 8 to Part 7 on the basis of the alleged substantial factual disputes.
- The nature and scope of defences available to a bond issuer under an irrevocable, unconditional on-demand performance bond, particularly regarding allegations of fraud or lack of bona fide demand.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The Defendant argued that there was a substantial dispute of fact concerning the underlying contractual obligations and performance, making Part 8 inappropriate.
- The Defendant asserted that the Demand was not bona fide because the Plaintiff knew of facts undermining its entitlement to make the Demand.
- The Defendant relied on a late-served witness statement from its solicitor, which detailed the factual disputes and supported its objection to Part 8.
- The Defendant contended that it was justified in refusing payment pending investigation of the underlying disputes.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Plaintiff maintained that the Bond was an autonomous, independent contract and that the Defendant’s only defence was fraud known at the time of the Demand.
- The Plaintiff argued that the Defendant’s factual assertions did not amount to knowledge that the Demand was fraudulent or made without entitlement.
- The Plaintiff contended that the Defendant was improperly acting as an advocate for the Subcontractors’ dispute with the Plaintiff, which was irrelevant to the Bond claim.
- The Plaintiff objected to the late witness statement, arguing it was untimely and prejudicial.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CLS Civil Engineering Limited v WJG Evans & Sons [2024] EWHC 194 | Summary judgment threshold for assessing whether a Part 8 claim involves a substantial dispute of fact. | The court applied this to require that factual disputes must have a real prospect of success to justify conversion to Part 7. |
| Harbottle v NatWest [1978] QB 146 | On-demand bonds are autonomous contracts independent of disputes under the underlying contract. | The court reaffirmed the autonomous nature of the Bond, limiting defences to fraud or lack of bona fide demand. |
| Wuhan Guoyu Logistics Group Co Ltd v Emporiki Bank of Greece SA [2014] 1 All ER (Comm) 870 (CA) | Liability under on-demand bond is separate from underlying contract; fraud must be pleaded and proved; only fraud known at demand time can be a defence. | The court applied the principle that the Defendant must prove actual knowledge of fraud at the time of the Demand to resist payment. |
| Edward Owen v Barclays Bank [1978] QB 159 | Issuer of performance guarantee must pay on demand without proof or conditions unless fraud is established. | The court emphasized that the Defendant’s obligation to pay was unconditional absent proven fraud. |
| Ouais Group v Saipem [2013] EWHC 990 (Comm) | Issuer assumes risk of payment notwithstanding underlying disputes; disputes to be resolved separately. | The court reinforced the autonomous nature of the bond and the limited scope for defence. |
| AES-3C v Credit Agricole [2011] BLR 249 (TCC) | Dishonesty must be proven; honest but mistaken belief insufficient to resist payment. | The court held that the Defendant’s belief in the invalidity of the Demand must be honest and known at the time of demand. |
| National Infrastructure v Banco Santander [2018] 1 All ER (Comm) 156 | Only realistic inference of lack of honest belief in demand validity can constitute a defence. | The court cited this to require cogent evidence of fraud or dishonesty at the demand time. |
| Enka Insaat Ve Sanayi AS v Banca Popolare Dell' Alto Adige SpA [2009] EWHC 2410 | High standard of proof required to establish fraud exception to payment on demand. | The court noted the necessity for particularly cogent evidence to resist payment on fraud grounds. |
| Balfour Beatty Civil Engineering v Technical & General Guarantee Co Ltd (2000) CLC 252 | Discussed timing and evidence of fraud in resisting payment under performance bonds. | The court rejected the Defendant’s reliance on this case for allowing refusal to pay pending evidence of fraud emerging later. |
| Lady Ann Tennant v Associated Newspapers [1979] FSR 298 | Warning against speculative defences and improper refusal of summary judgment. | The court used this to criticize the Defendant’s approach as illegitimate in resisting payment. |
| Doosan Babcock Ltd v Comercializadora de Equipos y Materiales Mabe Ltda [2013] EWHC 3010 | Cases where injunctions sought to restrain payment under bonds. | The court distinguished this case, noting no injunction was sought here and the Defendant was not entitled to restrain payment. |
| TTI Team Telecom International v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd [2003] EWHC 762 | Similar to Doosan Babcock regarding injunctions against payment. | The court noted this precedent did not apply to the present circumstances. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by outlining the procedural context and the nature of the claim under an on-demand performance bond governed by English law. It emphasized the autonomy of such bonds, which require payment on demand absent clear fraud known to the issuer at the time of demand. The court noted that the Defendant's contention of a substantial dispute of fact must surmount the summary judgment threshold, requiring a real prospect of success on the factual issues.
The court examined the Defendant's objections and the late witness evidence, concluding that while the factual dispute between the Plaintiff and the Subcontractors was real and substantial, this did not amount to knowledge by the Plaintiff that the Demand was fraudulent or without entitlement. The Defendant’s evidence largely reflected belief in the merits of the Subcontractors’ case rather than proof of fraud or dishonest demand.
The court rejected the Defendant’s argument that it could refuse payment pending investigation, holding that the bond’s terms precluded such delay absent fraud. It found no evidence that the Defendant knew the Demand was fraudulent at the time it was made. The court also rejected reliance on later evidence or the Defendant’s alignment with the Subcontractors as sufficient to resist payment.
The court distinguished the present case from precedents where injunctions were sought to restrain payment, noting no such application had been made here. The court concluded that the Part 8 procedure was appropriate given the limited scope of the Defendant’s defence and that conversion to Part 7 was unwarranted.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED the Defendant's application to convert the claim from Part 8 to Part 7 and rejected its objections to the use of the Part 8 procedure.
The direct effect is that the Plaintiff's claim under the on-demand performance bond will proceed under the Part 8 procedure, facilitating a summary and efficient resolution. The decision reinforces the established principle that payment under such bonds is to be made on demand absent clear, contemporaneous evidence of fraud. No new precedent was established; rather, the court applied settled legal principles to the facts presented.
Alert