Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Newell v Abbott & Anor (HOUSING - RENT REPAYMENT ORDER - landlord unaware of selective licensing scheme)

Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)
Jun 19, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerns a rent repayment order made under Chapter 4 of Part 2 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016. The Appellant, a solicitor and former owner of a three-bedroom flat in The City, was ordered by the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to repay rent to two tenants (the Respondents) who occupied the flat. The flat was subject to a selective licensing scheme under the Housing Act 2004, but the Appellant did not obtain the required licence, being unaware of the scheme due to outdated contact details and a low level of active management. The tenants applied for rent repayment orders, and the FTT ordered repayment of 80% of the rent paid during a 12-month period. The Appellant was granted permission to appeal and represented himself, as did the Respondents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a landlord unaware of the existence of a selective licensing scheme has a reasonable excuse for controlling an unlicensed house under section 95(4) of the Housing Act 2004.
  2. Whether the First-tier Tribunal erred in principle in determining the quantum of rent repayment, particularly whether the amount ordered was excessive given the seriousness of the offence and relevant statutory provisions.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The FTT failed properly to consider the defence of reasonable excuse, particularly the objective reasonableness of his lack of awareness of the licensing requirement in his specific circumstances.
  • The FTT erred in calculating the rent repayment amount by basing it on a 12-month period rather than the shorter periods specified by the tenants.
  • The FTT wrongly assessed the seriousness of the offence by comparing it only to similar licensing offences rather than to all housing offences subject to rent repayment orders.
  • The FTT panel expressed disagreement with binding Tribunal guidance, undermining confidence in the fairness and consistency of the decision.
  • The penalty imposed was disproportionate, influenced by the panel's preference for a higher award contrary to legal principles.

Respondents' Arguments

  • This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Acheampong v Roman [2022] UKUT 239 (LC) Guidance on assessing seriousness of offence relative to other housing offences for rent repayment orders. Used to illustrate that maximum orders should be reserved for the most serious cases and that licensing offences are generally less serious.
Awad v Hooley [2021] UKUT 55 (LC) Consideration of landlord conduct in rent repayment orders. Referenced regarding conduct as a factor in determining penalty.
Aytan v Moore [2022] UKUT 27 (LC) Examples of rent repayment orders for licensing offences. Used as comparator for penalty levels in licensing offence cases.
Daff v Gyalui [2023] UKUT 134 (LC) Ranking seriousness of housing offences subject to rent repayment orders. Referred to in assessing relative seriousness of licensing offences.
Dowd v Martins [2022] UKUT 249 (LC) Assessment of seriousness and quantum in licensing offence cases. Used as comparator for penalty percentage in similar offence context.
Ficcara v James [2021] UKUT 38 (LC) Factors under section 44(4) of the 2016 Act for determining rent repayment order amounts. Emphasised importance of landlord conduct and seriousness of offence.
Hallett v Parker [2022] UKUT 165 (LC) Purpose of rent repayment orders to deter rogue landlords. Referenced to explain mitigation for respectful landlord conduct and relative seriousness of licensing offences.
Hancher v David [2022] UKUT 277 (LC) Deliberate failure to licence and its impact on penalty. Used as comparator for deliberate licensing offence with penalty percentage.
Irvine v Metcalfe [2023] UKUT 283 (LC) Seriousness of deliberate failure to licence and penalty assessment. Referenced for penalty percentage in cases involving deliberate offences.
Kowalek v Hassanien Ltd [2021] UKUT 143 (LC); [2022] EWCA Civ 1041 Statutory limits on rent repayment order amounts and periods. Applied to reject Appellant’s argument about rent periods and confirm limits on rent repayment sums.
Marigold v Wells [2023] UKUT 33 (LC) Approach to reasonable excuse defence: fact-finding and objective reasonableness. Guidance adopted for assessing Appellant’s reasonable excuse defence.
Simpson House 3 Ltd v Osserman [2022] UKUT 164 (LC) Penalty assessment in licensing offence cases involving poor landlord conduct. Referenced as comparator for penalty percentage in licensing offence context.
Williams v Parmar [2021] UKUT 244 (LC) Discretion to order less than maximum rent repayment based on seriousness and mitigating factors. Used as precedent for assessing seriousness and appropriate penalty percentage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the defence of reasonable excuse under section 95(4)(a) of the Housing Act 2004. Applying the guidance from Marigold v Wells, the Court examined the facts relied upon by the Appellant, including his unawareness of the selective licensing scheme, the Council’s attempts to notify him at an outdated address, his minimal management style, and his efforts to contact the Council during the Covid-19 lockdown. The Court found that although the Appellant was unaware of the scheme, it was objectively unreasonable for him not to have been aware given his circumstances and the general expectation that landlords keep themselves informed of legal requirements. The Court noted the Appellant’s legal background and long-term property ownership but concluded these factors did not amount to a reasonable excuse for failing to obtain the licence.

Regarding the quantum of the rent repayment order, the Court rejected the Appellant’s argument that the FTT erred by basing its calculation on a 12-month period rather than the shorter periods specified by the tenants. The Court held that the FTT was entitled to focus on a 12-month period during which the offence was committed and that the tenants’ specified periods did not limit the Tribunal’s discretion.

The Court then examined the FTT’s assessment of the seriousness of the offence. It found that the FTT erred in law by considering only the seriousness of the licensing offence in isolation without comparing it to other housing offences subject to rent repayment orders. The Court emphasized that licensing offences are generally less serious than other offences such as violence or unlawful eviction, and this relative seriousness must inform the penalty assessment. The Court also criticized the FTT panel for expressing disagreement with binding Tribunal guidance, which risked undermining confidence in the consistency and fairness of decisions.

In reassessing the appropriate penalty, the Court considered precedents and the Appellant’s conduct, concluding that the offence was inadvertent and committed by a small-scale landlord providing generally good accommodation. The Court determined that a repayment of 60% of the rent was appropriate to reflect the seriousness of the prolonged failure to obtain a licence, balancing deterrence with fairness.

Finally, the Court decided to redetermine the amount of rent repayment itself rather than remit the matter to the FTT, due to the absence of findings on disputed misconduct allegations and to avoid further delay and expense.

Holding and Implications

The Court ALLOWED THE APPEAL IN PART, set aside the decision of the First-tier Tribunal, and substituted an order that the Appellant pay each Respondent £4,320 within 21 days, recoverable as a county court order if unpaid.

The decision clarifies that in assessing rent repayment orders for licensing offences, tribunals must consider the relative seriousness of the offence within the wider context of housing offences. It reinforces that a reasonable excuse defence requires an objective assessment of the landlord’s circumstances and conduct. The ruling also underscores the importance of tribunals applying binding legal guidance consistently and avoiding expressions of disagreement that may undermine confidence in judicial processes.

No new precedent was established beyond the application and clarification of existing principles. The direct effect is a reduction in the rent repayment order from 80% to 60% of rent paid, reflecting a more proportionate penalty for an inadvertent licensing offence by a small-scale landlord.