- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Harber v Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs (INCOME TAX - penalties for failure to notify liability to CGT - appellant relied on case law which could not be found on any legal website - whether cases generated by artificial intelligence such as ChatGPT)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Appellant disposed of a property and failed to notify her liability to capital gains tax ("CGT"). The Respondents issued a penalty for failure to notify liability amounting to £3,265.11. The Appellant appealed on grounds of reasonable excuse, citing mental health conditions and/or ignorance of the law.
The Appellant submitted a document ("the Response") containing nine First-tier Tribunal ("FTT") decisions purportedly supporting her reasonable excuse claim. However, the Tribunal found these cases were not genuine and had been generated by an artificial intelligence ("AI") system. The Appellant was unaware of their inauthenticity and did not know how to verify case law through official legal websites.
The Tribunal applied established legal principles, particularly those from the Upper Tribunal decision in Christine Perrin v HMRC, and concluded the Appellant did not have a reasonable excuse. The appeal was dismissed and the penalty upheld.
Procedurally, the hearing was initially held in August 2023 but adjourned upon discovery that the Response had not been shared with the Respondents in a timely manner. The case was relisted to allow proper consideration of the Response and further submissions.
Regarding the substantive facts, the Appellant purchased a property in 2006, let it out, and sold it in 2018. She was aware of landlord responsibilities but did not notify HMRC of CGT liability, believing her income was below the tax threshold and expecting HMRC to contact her after the sale was registered. The Appellant suffered from anxiety and panic attacks, exacerbated by personal circumstances.
HMRC contacted the Appellant in 2021 regarding letting income and requested information. After receiving no timely response, HMRC issued a notice and subsequently assessed CGT and imposed a penalty. The Appellant appealed the penalty but not the CGT assessment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Appellant had a reasonable excuse for failing to notify her liability to CGT within the statutory notification period.
- Whether reliance on case law generated by artificial intelligence, which was not genuine, could constitute a reasonable excuse or affect the appeal.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Appellant argued she had a reasonable excuse based on her mental health condition, including anxiety and panic attacks.
- She also contended that it was reasonable for her to be ignorant of the legal requirement to notify HMRC of her CGT liability.
- The Appellant relied on several FTT cases (later found to be AI-generated) purportedly supporting reasonable excuse claims for ignorance of the law and mental health issues.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Respondents submitted that the Appellant's mental health condition did not prevent her from managing the property sale, calculating the gain, or dealing with lodgers, and thus did not amount to a reasonable excuse.
- The Respondents challenged the authenticity of the cases submitted by the Appellant, verifying that none could be found on official legal databases.
- They argued that the Appellant’s ignorance of the law was not objectively reasonable, given her prior contact with HMRC and awareness of tax obligations.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Christine Perrin v HMRC [2018] UKUT 156 | Framework for assessing reasonable excuse in tax penalty appeals. | The Tribunal applied the four-step test from this case to evaluate the Appellant's reasonable excuse claim. |
| CPR Commercials v HMRC [2023] UKUT 61 (TCC) | Discussion of "blind eye" knowledge in penalty appeals. | The Tribunal noted HMRC did not allege deliberate avoidance ("blind eye" knowledge) by the Appellant. |
| Kay v LB of Lambeth [2006] UKHL 10 | Importance of the use of precedent in the legal system. | Referenced to emphasize the harm caused by citing fabricated judgments. |
| Ardmore Construction Limited v HMRC [2014] UKFTT 453 | FTT judgments as persuasive authorities. | Used to underline the significance of genuine FTT decisions as persuasive precedent. |
| Mata v Avianca 22-cv-1461 (PKC) | Example of reliance on AI-generated fake cases in US courts. | Used illustratively to highlight the risks and harms of submitting AI-generated fictitious case law. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal first examined the authenticity of the cases submitted by the Appellant, concluding they were fabricated by AI, as none appeared on official legal databases and contained stylistic inconsistencies, such as American spelling and repetitive phrases. The Tribunal accepted that the Appellant was unaware of their inauthenticity and did not know how to verify case law.
Applying the Christine Perrin framework, the Tribunal established the facts relied upon by the Appellant, including her mental health condition and ignorance of the law. It found that while the Appellant suffered from anxiety and panic attacks, these did not prevent her from managing the property sale, calculating the gain, or handling related matters.
The Tribunal further analyzed the Appellant's knowledge and actions post-sale, noting she recognized a capital gain and anticipated HMRC contact but did not proactively seek advice or notify HMRC. The Tribunal concluded that a reasonable person in the Appellant's position would have contacted HMRC or sought professional advice rather than waiting passively.
Consequently, the Tribunal held that neither the mental health condition nor ignorance of the law, in these circumstances, amounted to a reasonable excuse. The reliance on AI-generated cases was disregarded in the substantive decision but noted as a serious issue causing waste of resources and undermining the legal system's integrity.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed and the penalty upheld.
The direct effect is that the Appellant remains liable for the penalty imposed for failure to notify CGT liability within the statutory period. The Tribunal did not set any new legal precedent but reaffirmed the established principles governing reasonable excuse claims. The Tribunal also highlighted the serious consequences of submitting fabricated case law, emphasizing the importance of integrity and accuracy in legal proceedings.
Alert