Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

A (A Child) (Habitual Residence : 1996 Hague Child Protection Convention)

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Jun 12, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant father appealed a decision by Judge Arbuthnot dated 22 December 2022, which dismissed his application for an order concerning his child, A, born in early 2021. The judge found that the courts of England and Wales lacked jurisdiction as A was habitually resident in Zambia, not England and Wales, both at the date of the father's application (24 June 2022) and at the hearing in November 2022.

The child, A, and both parents were habitually resident in England and Wales before traveling to Zambia on 8 March 2022 for what was intended to be a short trip. The mother and child were retained in Zambia beyond this period, with the father formally withdrawing consent for A to remain there on 23 May 2022. The father returned to England and issued proceedings seeking the child's return, which were dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.

The father's application, dated 23 June 2022 and issued 6 July 2022, was made using Form C66 for an inherent jurisdiction order but asserted jurisdiction based on habitual residence in England and Wales. The father sought the child's return and wide-ranging orders relating to care and contact, emphasizing welfare considerations favoring residence in England. The mother contended that A was habitually resident in Zambia at both relevant dates and that the father had consented or acquiesced to A remaining there.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the relevant date to assess habitual residence for jurisdictional purposes under article 5 of the 1996 Hague Child Protection Convention is the date of the application or the date of the hearing.
  2. Whether the judge erred in finding that the child was habitually resident in Zambia at both the date of the application and the date of the hearing.
  3. Whether article 7 of the 1996 Hague Child Protection Convention applies when a child has been wrongfully retained in a non-Contracting State.
  4. Whether the father's application fell within the scope of the Family Law Act 1986 or was solely an application under the court's inherent jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The judge applied an incorrect legal test by focusing solely on whether the child had "some degree of integration" in Zambia, which was insufficient.
  • The judge failed to consider relevant factors, including the child's continuing connections with England and the absence of pre-planning for a permanent move to Zambia.
  • The relevant date for determining habitual residence and jurisdiction under article 5 of the 1996 Convention is the date of the application, not the hearing.
  • Article 7 of the 1996 Convention applies to retain jurisdiction despite the wrongful retention in a non-Contracting State.
  • The father's application was made under time pressure and sought substantive orders concerning care and contact, not merely a return order.
  • If the appeal succeeds, the habitual residence issue requires rehearing with possible oral evidence.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The judge's findings on habitual residence were correct and unimpeachable, based on a proper evaluation of the child's situation and evidence heard.
  • The judge sufficiently considered the relevant factors, and criticisms of the judgment's detail are matters of form rather than substance.
  • The 1996 Convention does not apply if the child is not habitually resident in a Contracting State at the relevant date.
  • The relevant date for habitual residence under the 1996 Convention is the date of the hearing.
  • The father's application was not within the scope of the Family Law Act 1986 but fell within the 1996 Convention's scope, so jurisdiction depends on that Convention.
  • Article 7 of the 1996 Convention applies only between Contracting States, thus not applicable here as Zambia is a non-Contracting State.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
In re B (A Child) (Custody Rights: Habitual Residence) [2016] 4 WLR 156 ("Re B") Established the principle that habitual residence corresponds to the place reflecting some degree of integration by the child into a social and family environment. The judge relied on this case for the test of habitual residence, including the degree of integration and stability of residence.
A v A (Children: Habitual Residence) [2014] AC 1 ("A v A") Clarified the habitual residence test as per the European Court, emphasizing integration and stability; also addressed scope of Family Law Act 1986. The court referred extensively to this case for the legal framework on habitual residence and whether orders fall within the FLA 1986.
In re R (Children) [2016] AC 76 ("Re R") Confirmed habitual residence as a question of fact requiring assessment of integration and stability, focusing on the child's situation. The court applied Lord Reed's observation on the limited appellate role and the need for factual evaluation of integration.
In re B (A Child) (Reunite International Child Abduction Centre and others intervening) [2016] AC 606 ("Re B 2016") Warned against legal gloss on habitual residence; emphasized factual global analysis considering all relevant factors. Used to caution against oversimplification of the habitual residence test.
Proceedings brought by A [2010] Fam 42 Set out detailed factors for determining habitual residence including duration, regularity, reasons for stay, and family integration. The court cited this to reinforce the multi-factorial and case-specific nature of habitual residence.
In re LC (Children) [2014] AC 1038 Emphasized necessary degree of stability and integration for habitual residence. Referenced to support the requirement of sufficient integration and stability in habitual residence analysis.
Owusu v Jackson [2005] QB 801 Confirmed jurisdiction provisions apply regardless of alternative jurisdiction in a non-member state. Used to explain the applicability of jurisdiction provisions beyond EU member states.
H v R [2022] 2 FLR 1301 Considered scope of Family Law Act 1986 and whether applications fall within inherent jurisdiction or statutory jurisdiction. Applied to assess whether the father's application was within the FLA 1986 or solely under inherent jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the central issue as whether the judge erred in her finding that the child was habitually resident in Zambia at the date of the application. It noted the division among judges regarding whether habitual residence for jurisdictional purposes should be assessed at the date of application or hearing but found it unnecessary to resolve this due to statutory provisions in the Family Law Act 1986.

The court scrutinized the judge's application of the habitual residence test, observing that the judge appeared to rely solely on whether the child had "some degree of integration" in Zambia, which was an insufficient and overly narrow approach. The court emphasized that habitual residence is a question of fact requiring a comprehensive and comparative evaluation of all relevant factors, including the child's connections with both the previous habitual residence and the new environment.

The court found the judge's factual analysis deficient as it focused almost exclusively on the child's integration in Zambia, omitting consideration of the child's ongoing connections with England and Wales, the lack of pre-planning for permanent relocation, and the mother's variable intentions including potential moves to South Africa or return to England.

Given these shortcomings, the court concluded that the judge had not applied the correct legal principles to the facts and that the issue of habitual residence at the date of application required rehearing before a different judge. The court also clarified that jurisdiction under the Family Law Act 1986 depends on the child's habitual residence at the date of application, which supports rehearing on that basis.

Regarding the scope of the father's application, the court found it was within the Family Law Act 1986 as the father sought substantive orders concerning care and contact, not merely a return order. Thus, the court did not need to address the mother's submissions on the 1996 Hague Convention's application to inherent jurisdiction orders.

Holding and Implications

The court ALLOWED THE APPEAL IN PART by ordering that the issue of the child's habitual residence at the date of the father's application be reheard before a different judge nominated by the President of the Family Division.

This decision means the prior factual determination of habitual residence is set aside due to legal error, and the case must be reconsidered with a proper comprehensive analysis. The court confirmed that jurisdiction under the Family Law Act 1986 depends on habitual residence at the date of application, making this the critical issue for resolution. No new precedent was established beyond clarifying the correct application of legal principles to the facts in this case.