Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DS v AC

England and Wales Family Court (High Court Judges)
Mar 29, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment concerns an application for a Non-Molestation Order under the Family Law Act 1996 ("FLA"). The Applicant and Respondent had a relationship beginning in October 2021 which ended in September 2022. The Applicant described the Respondent's behaviour as controlling, including frequent calls and monitoring, but did not allege verbal or physical abuse. There were complaints about the Respondent's conduct towards women in a networking group, causing the Applicant to feel fearful. After the relationship ended by text message on 16 September 2022, the Respondent continued limited contact, including emails and phone calls, some of which the Applicant found upsetting but not threatening. The Applicant made a without notice application for a Non-Molestation Order on 8 November 2022, citing urgency due to unpredictable behaviour. The initial without notice application was refused by a District Judge, who scheduled an on-notice hearing. The Applicant did not attend the hearing, and the application was dismissed. Subsequently, a Directions Hearing was ordered to consider reinstatement of the application, which the Applicant requested. The Respondent opposed the order, arguing statutory tests were not met.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Non-Molestation Order should be granted on a without notice basis under the Family Law Act 1996.
  2. Whether the statutory criteria under sections 42 and 45 of the Family Law Act 1996 for making such an order are satisfied in the circumstances of this case.
  3. Whether the conduct alleged amounts to "molestation" justifying court intervention.
  4. The appropriate application of legal principles concerning the threshold for granting Non-Molestation Orders, especially on an ex parte basis.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The Applicant argued for reinstatement of the Non-Molestation Order application, emphasizing the urgency and unpredictability of the Respondent's behaviour.
  • The Applicant contended that the Respondent's conduct, including frequent calls and controlling behaviour, created a risk justifying the order.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent, through counsel, submitted there was no basis for the order as the statutory tests under section 42 of the FLA were not met.
  • The Respondent argued that the conduct did not amount to molestation warranting court intervention.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Horner v Horner [1983] 4 FLR 50 Definition of "molestation" as conduct amounting to harassment requiring court intervention. The court applied this definition to assess whether the Respondent's conduct justified an order.
C v C [2001] EWCA Civ 1625 Justification for Non-Molestation Orders when conduct causes alarm and distress. The court referenced this case to emphasize that positive intent to molest is not required.
Re T (A Child) [2017] EWCA Civ 1889 Focus on harassment or alarm and distress caused; caution against over-defining "molestation". The court endorsed the caution urged by this authority and applied its principles to the facts.
R v R [2014] EWFC 48 Principles governing without notice applications: exceptional circumstances required; caution in one-sided hearings; procedural fairness. The court relied heavily on these principles to refuse the without notice order and to stress the need for exceptional circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by outlining the statutory framework under sections 42 and 45 of the Family Law Act 1996 regarding Non-Molestation Orders, emphasizing the strict criteria for granting such orders, especially without notice. It noted that the term "molestation" lacks statutory definition but has been judicially interpreted to mean harassment or conduct causing alarm and distress sufficient to require court intervention, without needing proof of intent to molest.

The court reviewed the factual matrix, recognizing the relationship's deterioration and the Applicant's subjective feelings of distress. However, it found the conduct insufficiently serious or immediate to justify a without notice order, particularly given the lack of contact for three weeks prior to the application. The court stressed that without notice orders are exceptional and require a significant risk of immediate harm, which was not demonstrated here.

The court further noted that the Applicant's distress alone, without objective evidence of harassment reaching the necessary threshold, does not justify an order. The Respondent's communications, although frequent and occasionally angry, ceased before the application and did not amount to molestation warranting court intervention. The court agreed with the District Judge's initial refusal and declined to reinstate the application.

Holding and Implications

The court REFUSED TO REINSTATE the Applicant's without notice application for a Non-Molestation Order.

The direct effect of this decision is that no Non-Molestation Order was granted in this case. The ruling underscores the principle that without notice orders under the Family Law Act 1996 should only be made in exceptional circumstances where there is a demonstrable risk of significant immediate harm. The court reaffirmed that subjective distress alone is insufficient to justify such orders and emphasized the necessity of proper evidential basis before intervening. No new legal precedent was established; the decision serves as a practical reaffirmation of existing legal principles governing Non-Molestation Orders.