Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Goddard-Watts v Goddard-Watts

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Feb 15, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff and Defendant were married in 1996, separated in 2009, and divorced in 2010. Their financial relief claims arising from the divorce were initially settled by consent in 2010. Subsequent findings revealed that the Defendant had misrepresented his assets and failed to disclose significant capital accumulations, resulting in two prior financial relief orders being set aside. This appeal concerns the third determination of the Plaintiff's claims made in January 2022 by the judge.

The Plaintiff appeals the judge's adoption of the "Kingdon approach," which relied on a 2016 determination that she had received a fair share of the Defendant's company, referred to as "Company A," in 2010. The Plaintiff argues that a full, fresh investigation of all financial matters is necessary to achieve a fair resolution, contending that without this, the Defendant benefits from his fraud.

The financial remedy proceedings have been considered by courts on five occasions between 2010 and 2022. Initially, the Plaintiff received approximately £7.6 million, and the Defendant received approximately £9 million based on disclosed assets, which did not include two trusts later found to be relevant. The Defendant was found to have deliberately concealed his beneficial interest in these trusts and made false statements regarding disclosure, leading to the setting aside of the consent order and directions for rehearing.

Subsequent hearings involved expert valuations of Company A's shares at various points in time, with valuations ranging from £6 million in 2010 to over £16 million in 2016, and complex transactions involving share sales to a third party. The Defendant's non-disclosure and misleading evidence led to further orders being set aside. The judge in 2022 accepted a valuation of Company A at £56.4 million but adopted the Kingdon approach, concluding that the Plaintiff had already received her fair share and awarding an additional lump sum to address the Plaintiff’s needs and contributions to the children post-divorce.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the judge erred in adopting the Kingdon approach, thereby failing to conduct a full de novo assessment of the Plaintiff's financial relief claims in light of the Defendant's fraudulent non-disclosure.
  2. Whether the Defendant should be allowed to benefit from his fraud by limiting the Plaintiff's claim to the value of assets as previously determined in 2010 and 2016.
  3. How to appropriately assess the Plaintiff's claim considering the increase in value of Company A post-separation and the impact of the Defendant’s fraudulent conduct on disclosure.
  4. The applicability and scope of the Kingdon approach following the Supreme Court decision in Takhar v Gracefield Developments.
  5. The extent to which the Defendant’s conduct, including fraud and non-disclosure, should influence the court’s exercise of discretion under section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff contends that the judge failed to give adequate weight to the Defendant’s fraudulent non-disclosure and that a full re-examination of all financial matters is necessary to achieve a fair outcome.
  • The Plaintiff argues that relying on the Kingdon approach improperly limits her claim to earlier valuations and ignores the true financial landscape affected by the Defendant’s fraud.
  • The Plaintiff submits that the Defendant has benefitted from his fraud by preventing a full and fair determination of her claim.
  • The Plaintiff challenges the judge’s finding that she had made no contribution to the marital partnership post-2010 and emphasizes her significant contributions to the children’s welfare, which should be reflected in the financial relief.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Defendant defends the judge’s use of the Kingdon approach, asserting the 2010 division of assets was objectively fair and verified by expert valuation in 2016.
  • He contends that the Plaintiff was compensated for his litigation misconduct through indemnity costs and an additional lump sum awarded in 2022.
  • The Defendant argues that post-separation increases in the value of Company A are not subject to division and that the Plaintiff’s claim should be limited accordingly.
  • The Defendant relies on authorities supporting the principle that if a division of assets was fair at the time, there is no justification to revisit it despite prior non-disclosure.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kingdon v Kingdon [2010] EWCA 1409 Flexibility to isolate non-disclosure issues and address them without reopening entire financial orders; discretion in rectifying defective orders due to fraud. The court adopted the Kingdon approach to limit rehearing to issues relating to non-disclosed assets, rather than conducting a full rehearing of all financial matters.
Sharland v Sharland [2015] UKSC 60 Misrepresentation or non-disclosure justifying setting aside an order does not necessarily require starting anew; courts have "enormous flexibility" in procedure. Supported the principle that not all financial relief proceedings tainted by fraud must be wholly reopened; endorsed the Kingdon approach.
Takhar v Gracefield Developments [2019] UKSC 13 Fraudulent judgments can be set aside without a bright-line rule; fraud vitiates earlier proceedings and res judicata does not apply; but no broad overruling of Kingdon approach. The court considered the impact of Takhar on the Kingdon approach and concluded that Kingdon remains valid in family proceedings, emphasizing bespoke and fact-specific procedures.
H v H [2010] EWHC 158 Objective fairness of an asset division at the time precludes reopening the division despite subsequent misconduct; conduct considered through costs and awards. Used to argue that the 2010 division was fair and should not be revisited, supporting the judge’s decision to adopt the Kingdon approach.
Williams v Lindley [2013] EWCA Civ 718 Distinction between non-disclosure and supervening events affecting financial relief orders. Cited to clarify the legal framework distinguishing types of challenges to financial relief orders.
Martin v Martin [2018] EWCA Civ 2866 Consideration of "straight line apportionment" in financial remedies. The court refused to determine this issue summarily, leaving it for the restored hearing.
TT v CDS [2020] EWCA Civ 2015 General approach to litigation conduct in financial remedy proceedings; conduct usually reflected in costs but can affect awards. Referenced in discussion about whether fraudulent non-disclosure should affect financial awards beyond costs.
Hip Foong Hong v H Neroira & Co [1918] AC 888 Fraud unravels all; judgments tainted by fraud are invalid throughout. Cited with caution to illustrate the general principle of fraud's impact on judgments but distinguished in family finance context.
R v Humphrys [1977] AC 1 Fraud vitiates the decision of earlier proceedings, negating issue estoppel and res judicata. Supported the principle that fraudulent judgments do not bind parties in subsequent proceedings.
Prest v Petrodel Resources [2013] UKSC 34 Family proceedings differ from ordinary civil proceedings in issues of liability and quantum. Used to highlight the distinct nature of family financial remedy proceedings.
Wyatt v Vince (Nos 1 and 2) [2015] UKSC 14 Consideration of contributions to family welfare and the effect of delay in claims. Referenced regarding the assessment of the Plaintiff’s contributions post-separation and impact on delay.
Akintola v Akintola [2002] 1 FLR 701 Conduct in financial remedy proceedings must be quantifiable monetarily to affect awards. Discussed in context of how misconduct should be considered under section 25(2)(g) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.
Ezair v Ezair [2012] 1 FLR Similar principles on conduct and its impact on financial awards. Used to illustrate orthodox approach to litigation misconduct.
OG v AG [2021] 1 FLR 1105 Summary of conduct’s role in financial remedy cases. Referenced in the discussion on the impact of conduct on awards and costs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged the extensive procedural history marked by the Defendant’s deliberate and material non-disclosure in multiple proceedings. The judge initially adopted the Kingdon approach, reasoning that the Plaintiff had already received a fair share of the marital assets, including Company A, as determined in 2010 and 2016. This approach was supported by precedent allowing flexibility to isolate non-disclosure issues without reopening entire financial orders.

However, the appellate court critically examined whether the Kingdon approach was appropriate given the scale and persistence of the Defendant’s fraud, which had caused significant delays and deprived the Plaintiff of a full and fair hearing. The court recognized that fraudulent non-disclosure "infects" the reliability of the Defendant’s evidence and impacts the fairness of the prior valuations and settlements.

The court considered the Supreme Court’s decision in Takhar, which affirmed the principle that fraud can vitiate earlier judgments and that finality should not override the need to protect the court process from abuse. The court distinguished the family law context from ordinary civil proceedings, emphasizing the need for bespoke procedures and flexibility.

While the judge’s reasons for adopting the Kingdon approach were acknowledged, the appellate court found that the approach was too blunt and failed to account adequately for the comprehensive financial landscape and the Defendant’s fraudulent conduct. The court noted the Plaintiff’s entitlement to a full rehearing on a "blank page" basis, including consideration of post-separation increases in value and the Plaintiff’s contributions, particularly to the children’s welfare.

The court concluded that the judge erred in exercising his discretion by limiting the rehearing to isolated issues and not conducting a full reassessment of the Plaintiff’s claim in light of the Defendant’s fraud and the current financial circumstances.

Holding and Implications

The court ALLOWED THE APPEAL and held that the judge erred in adopting the Kingdon approach to the Plaintiff’s restored financial relief application. The Plaintiff is entitled to a full and fresh hearing of her claims on all financial matters, considering the entire financial landscape and the Defendant’s fraudulent non-disclosure.

The direct effect is that the previous orders relying on isolated valuation and division of assets are set aside, and the Plaintiff’s claim will be reheard comprehensively. No new precedent was established beyond affirming the continuing validity of the Kingdon approach subject to the facts and the extent of fraud in individual cases. The decision underscores the court’s duty to prevent parties from benefiting from fraudulent conduct and to ensure that financial relief proceedings are conducted fairly and fully.