Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anon v Anon (Discrimination - Sex) [

Industrial Tribunals Northern Ireland
Jun 8, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, employed by the Defendant since 1999, presented a claim for sex discrimination and pregnancy discrimination under the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976 (as amended). The claim arose from several alleged acts: refusal to grant unpaid leave and lighter duties in May 2018 related to the Plaintiff's IVF treatment; the handling of a disciplinary/absence management process between March and May 2019; and a referral to Occupational Health in July 2019. The Defendant denied all claims and argued that the complaints were out of time and did not constitute continuing acts of discrimination. The tribunal heard evidence from both parties and several witnesses, including medical and occupational health professionals, over several days in December 2021. The tribunal anonymised the parties' identities pursuant to applicable procedural rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Plaintiff was subjected to less favourable treatment on the grounds of sex, contrary to Article 3 of the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976.
  2. Whether the Plaintiff was subjected to less favourable treatment on the grounds of pregnancy, contrary to Article 5A of the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976.
  3. Whether all complaints of unlawful discrimination were lodged within the statutory three-month time limit, and if not, whether it is just and equitable to extend time.
  4. Factual determinations including: consideration and outcome of requests for unpaid leave and lighter duties; impact on workplace attendance; reasonableness of absence management policy application; comparability of treatment with other employees; and the effect of disciplinary and occupational health procedures on the Plaintiff.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff alleged direct sex discrimination in the refusal of unpaid leave and lighter duties related to IVF treatment in May 2018.
  • The disciplinary and absence management process between March and May 2019 was discriminatory as it failed to account for absences related to IVF treatment.
  • The referral to Occupational Health in July 2019 constituted sex discrimination, as a male colleague with longer absences was not similarly referred.
  • The Plaintiff contended that her claims represented a continuing series of discriminatory acts, rendering the claim timely.
  • The Plaintiff relied on comparators to establish less favourable treatment but contested their appropriateness.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Defendant denied all allegations of discrimination on grounds of sex or pregnancy.
  • The Defendant contended that unpaid leave was granted on an ad hoc basis and lighter duties were facilitated without loss of pay.
  • The Absence Management Policy was applied uniformly and reasonably to all employees, including the Plaintiff.
  • The Defendant argued that the claims were out of time, as the alleged acts were discrete incidents not constituting a continuing series.
  • The Defendant challenged the comparators relied upon by the Plaintiff as not being appropriate or comparable.
  • The referral to Occupational Health was based on medical advice, not gender, and was consistent with company practice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madarassy v Nomura International Ltd [2007] IRLR 246 Clarification of the burden of proof in discrimination claims, requiring a two-stage process and cogent evidence to discharge the burden. The tribunal applied the principle that bare facts indicating possible discrimination are insufficient; the evidence must support a reasonable conclusion of discrimination.
Nelson v Newry and Mourne District Council [2009] NICA 24 Restatement of burden of proof and comparability requirements in sex discrimination claims. The tribunal used this authority to assess whether comparators were appropriate and whether the burden of proof shifted to the Defendant.
Mayr v Bäckerei und Konditorei Gerhard Flöckner OHG C-506/06 [2008] IRLR 387 Definition of pregnancy protection period in relation to IVF treatment. The tribunal concluded the Plaintiff was only pregnant within the protected period from embryo transfer and for two weeks thereafter, limiting pregnancy discrimination claims.
Sahota v Home Office and Pipkin UKEAT/0342/09 Distinction between acts occurring in connection with a protected characteristic and acts done on the grounds of that characteristic. The tribunal accepted that absence due to gender-specific illness (e.g., IVF treatment) does not automatically constitute sex discrimination.
London Borough of Greenwich v Robinson (EAT/745/94) Time off for IVF treatment is treated as sickness absence, not pregnancy-related absence. The tribunal found the Defendant was entitled to treat IVF-related absences as sickness absence, not requiring special exclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The tribunal carefully examined the evidence, including witness testimony and documentary materials, to assess whether the Plaintiff was subjected to less favourable treatment on grounds of sex or pregnancy. It applied the legal framework governing sex discrimination claims, particularly the burden of proof provisions under the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976 and relevant case law.

Regarding the unpaid leave request, the tribunal found the Plaintiff's evidence more credible than the Defendant's, but determined the comparator relied upon was not appropriate due to materially different circumstances. Consequently, no inference of sex discrimination arose.

On the claim of refusal to grant lighter duties, the tribunal found that the relevant manager was not informed of the request and that the Plaintiff had self-referred to Occupational Health, leading to a report recommending adjustments. Although the manager admitted overlooking this report, the tribunal found no evidence that this was motivated by sex. The comparators offered were not appropriate due to differing circumstances, including disability accommodations.

In relation to the disciplinary and absence management process, the tribunal accepted that absences related to IVF treatment were appropriately treated as sickness absence, consistent with established legal authority. The Plaintiff did not provide suitable comparators to establish sex discrimination in this context.

Regarding the referral to Occupational Health in July 2019, the tribunal accepted that the decision was based on medical advice and not discriminatory. The comparator cited by the Plaintiff was found not comparable due to differing medical circumstances and prior Occupational Health involvement.

The tribunal also considered the timeliness of the claim and concluded that the claim related to a continuing series of acts up to May 2019, making it timely. Alternatively, it would have exercised discretion to extend time due to the Plaintiff's mental health difficulties delaying proceedings.

Finally, the tribunal found that the Plaintiff was not pregnant during the relevant periods except for a limited protected period post-embryo transfer, and thus pregnancy discrimination claims outside that period could not succeed.

Holding and Implications

The tribunal held that the Plaintiff's claim for sex discrimination was presented within time but dismissed the claim on its merits, finding no unlawful discrimination contrary to the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Plaintiff's claims are dismissed with no award or order in her favour. The tribunal's findings clarify the application of discrimination law in the context of IVF treatment and absence management, reaffirming that IVF-related absences are treated as sickness absence and that the burden of proof requires appropriate comparators and cogent evidence. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing authorities to the facts.