Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Liquid Leisure Ltd, R (On the Application Of) v Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead

England and Wales High Court (Administrative Court)
Jun 16, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff applied for judicial review of the Defendant Council's decision to issue a Breach of Condition Notice ("BCN") on 5 October 2021 under section 187A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 ("TCPA 1990"). The BCN required the Plaintiff to secure compliance with Condition 2 of a planning permission dated 21 March 1988 concerning land at Sunnymeads Lake, Horton Road, Datchet ("the Site"). The Plaintiff leases the Site and has operated a water sports facility there since 2002. The Council is the local planning authority.

The central issue was the lawfulness of the Council issuing the BCN while an enforcement notice ("EN") relating to substantially the same matters was already in effect and an appeal against the EN was pending. Permission to apply for judicial review was granted on 20 December 2021.

The Site includes a lake within the Green Belt and mostly falls within Flood Zone 3a High Probability. The 1988 planning permission allowed the use of the Site for waterskiing and windsurfing, subject to Condition 2 restricting building, engineering, or other operations without express permission. Subsequent permissions allowed a clubhouse, boathouse, a replacement boathouse, and a cable water-skiing system.

In November 2020, the Council refused a Certificate of Lawfulness for several existing structures. On 21 December 2020, the Council issued the EN alleging an unauthorized material change of use from waterskiing and windsurfing to a mixed use including an aqua theme park, caravan and camping site, party venue, and child's play centre, with associated operational development. The EN required cessation of the aqua theme park use and included 23 requirements.

The Plaintiff appealed the EN on various statutory grounds, seeking to separate operational development from the material change of use and contending different enforcement time limits applied. On 5 October 2021, the Council issued the BCN alleging breach of Condition 2 due to unauthorized building, engineering, and other operations, repeating many EN requirements. The original compliance period was four months, extended to nine months.

The EN appeal Inquiry was initially scheduled for November 2021 but was postponed to March 2022 and then adjourned again, now listed for November 2022.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Council lawfully issued the BCN while an EN was already in effect and subject to appeal.
  2. Whether the Council took into account irrelevant considerations or acted irrationally or abusively in issuing the BCN.
  3. Whether the Council adequately considered the benefits of the Site's current use in its decision to issue the BCN.
  4. Whether the Council complied with the public sector equality duty ("PSED") when deciding to issue the BCN.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Under Ground 1, the Council improperly considered irrelevant factors, including issuing the BCN as a fallback and to narrow issues in the EN appeal.
  • Under Ground 3, the Council's decision was Wednesbury unreasonable and an abuse of statutory powers.
  • Under Ground 2, the Council failed to consider the benefits of the Site's current use despite public support, rendering its reasons inadequate and unlawful.
  • Under Ground 4, the Council failed to discharge the PSED in deciding whether to issue the BCN.

Defendant Council's Arguments

  • The considerations identified by the Plaintiff were relevant and material for the Council's decision.
  • The decision to issue the BCN was reasonable, proportionate, and within the Council's statutory powers.
  • The Council had regard to the EN appeal documents and public comments, meeting the legal standard for reasons given.
  • There was insufficient factual information to indicate that persons with protected characteristics would be affected by the enforcement action, as the Site would remain open for permitted use.
  • If the Court found a PSED breach, section 31(2A)(a) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 should apply to refuse relief.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Padfield v Minister of Agriculture [1968] AC 997 Principle against abuse of statutory powers and Wednesbury unreasonableness. The Court considered whether the Council's decision to issue the BCN was irrational or an abuse of power and found it was not.
Kestrel Hydro v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2016] EWCA Civ 784 Clarification of enforcement time limits for operational development and material change of use. The Court accepted the Council's primary case that operational development was integral to the material change of use, applying the 10-year time limit.
R (Community Against Dean Super Quarry Ltd) v Cornwall Council [2017] EWHC 74 (Admin) Requirement for enforcement action to be proportionate. The Court applied the principle that enforcement must be proportionate in assessing the Council's discretion.
South Bucks DC v Porter (No. 2) [2004] 1 WLR 1953 Standard for adequacy of reasons given by planning authorities. The Court found the Council's reasons for issuing the BCN met the legal standard for adequacy.
R (Bracking) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2013] EWCA Civ 1345 Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) obligations. The Court recognized the PSED was engaged and required consideration by the Council.
R (Buckley) v Bath and North East Somerset Council [2018] EWHC 1551 (Admin) Application of PSED in planning cases. Referenced as part of the jurisprudence applying PSED in planning contexts.
R (Gathercole) v Suffolk County Council [2020] EWCA Civ 1179 Application of PSED and section 31(2A) Senior Courts Act 1981. The Court applied section 31(2A) to refuse relief despite PSED breach, a principle applied analogously in the present case.
Sanders v First Secretary of State [2004] EWHC 1194 (Admin) Enforcement action and time limits. Considered in relation to the Council's discretion on enforcement notices.
Jarmain v Secretary of State for the Environment [2000] 2 PLR 126 Enforcement notice considerations. Referenced regarding the Council's enforcement discretion.
Fidler v First Secretary of State [2004] 1 PLR 1 Enforcement action principles. Referenced in consideration of enforcement action scope.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognized the wide discretion afforded to local planning authorities in enforcement matters, including issuing BCNs concurrently with ENs. It found no statutory bar to issuing a BCN while an EN appeal was pending. The Council's rationale for issuing the BCN as a fallback to prevent immunity arising from the 4-year enforcement time limit on operational development was a relevant and lawful consideration.

The Court rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the Council acted irrationally or abused its powers, concluding the Council's enforcement approach was proportionate and justified given the seriousness of the breaches and the risk of immunity. The Council was entitled to issue the BCN before the EN appeal was determined, as the EN was of no effect during the appeal, and delay risked parts of the development gaining immunity.

Regarding the Plaintiff's submission on benefits of the Site's use, the Court held that enforcement decisions differ from planning permission decisions and do not require a planning balance weighing benefits against harm. The Council had considered public comments and appeal documents, and the reasons given met the legal standard.

On the PSED, the Court found the Council failed to have due regard to it when issuing both the EN and BCN, despite evidence indicating use by persons with protected characteristics. However, applying section 31(2A) of the Senior Courts Act 1981, the Court concluded that this failure would not have changed the outcome since the Site would remain accessible and the enforcement action was unlikely to be withdrawn on that basis.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the claim for judicial review on Grounds 1, 2, and 3, finding the Council's decision to issue the BCN lawful, proportionate, and within its discretion.

The claim was ALLOWED on Ground 4 concerning failure to comply with the PSED, but NO RELIEF was granted due to the application of section 31(2A) of the Senior Courts Act 1981, meaning the procedural breach did not affect the outcome.

The direct effect is that the BCN remains valid and enforceable against the Plaintiff, but the decision does not establish new precedent beyond confirming the lawful use of enforcement powers in concurrent BCN and EN proceedings and the application of section 31(2A) in PSED breaches in planning enforcement contexts.