Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hoey & Ors v Revenue & Customs

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
May 13, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

During the tax years from 6 April 2008 to 5 April 2011, the Appellant worked as an IT contractor in the UK for various UK-based entities ("the End Users") under arrangements with two offshore entities that employed him ("the Employers"). The Employers paid a significant portion of the Appellant's remuneration into employee benefit trusts ("the EBTs"), which then made interest-free loans to him. These arrangements were part of a marketed tax avoidance scheme designed to avoid income tax and national insurance contributions under the PAYE Regulations. The scheme was disclosed to HMRC under DOTAS legislation, and no income tax was declared or paid on these payments at the time.

HMRC issued discovery assessments and a closure notice challenging the tax treatment of these payments, asserting they were taxable employment income under the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 ("ITEPA"). The Appellant conceded, following Supreme Court precedent, that the amounts paid via the EBT contributions were earnings from employment and taxable. However, he contended that the PAYE tax obligation lay principally with the Employers and that he was entitled to a PAYE credit, which HMRC denied by exercising a statutory power under section 684(7A)(b) ITEPA ("the 7A power") to relieve the End Users of PAYE obligations.

The First-tier Tribunal ("FTT") heard the appeals in July 2019 and dismissed them, holding it had no jurisdiction to consider the lawfulness of the exercise of the 7A power and concluding that the Employers had no taxable profits under the Transfer of Assets Abroad ("TOAA") provisions. Both parties appealed to the Upper Tribunal ("UT"), which upheld the FTT's decisions on jurisdiction and the quantum of the Employers' profits but made obiter findings limiting the retrospective effect of the 7A power and rejected the FTT's EU law conclusions.

The Appellant then sought judicial review of HMRC's exercise of the 7A power, which was refused permission at first instance and on renewal. Permission to appeal was eventually granted by the UT and this court. The appeals and judicial review claims were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the proper construction of section 684(7A)(b) ITEPA, and can the 7A power be used by HMRC to deprive the Appellant and other Claimants of the PAYE credit?
  2. Was the 7A power lawfully exercised in this case?
  3. Does the First-tier Tribunal have jurisdiction to review or address HMRC's exercise of the 7A power?
  4. Is there a separate liability to income tax under the TOAA charge, and did the FTT err in law in determining that the Employers' profits were nil for TOAA purposes?
  5. Do any EU law questions arise, particularly regarding the right to free movement of capital, and if so, is there unjustifiable interference with these rights?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The 7A power cannot be used to impose or transfer liability to pay PAYE tax; clear words are required to deprive the Appellant of the PAYE credit.
  • The 7A power operates only prospectively and cannot be exercised retrospectively to affect accrued rights.
  • The 7A power should not circumvent the specific redirection regulations that include safeguards and appeal rights for employees.
  • The PAYE code’s core purpose is to place PAYE obligations on employers, not employees, and the principle of legality prevents HMRC from depriving the Appellant of accrued rights without clear authority.
  • HMRC's exercise of the 7A power was unlawful, procedurally unfair, and breached legitimate expectations based on HMRC guidance.
  • The FTT has jurisdiction to determine the availability of the PAYE credit as it affects the amount of tax payable.
  • The TOAA provisions do not apply because the Employers had no taxable profits; payments into the EBTs were wholly and exclusively for the Employers' trade.
  • The TOAA provisions unjustifiably interfere with EU law rights to free movement of capital.

HMRC's Arguments

  • The 7A power is a wide discretion enabling HMRC to relieve payers from PAYE obligations where it is unnecessary or inappropriate for them to comply, including retrospectively.
  • The 7A power overlaps with but does not conflict with the redirection regulations; it is a separate statutory tool.
  • The PAYE credit is a contingent credit relevant only at the collection stage, not at the assessment stage, and thus outside the FTT’s jurisdiction.
  • The exercise of the 7A power was lawful, based on internal policies and proper consideration of relevant factors, including the knowledge of the End Users.
  • The Employers made a transfer of assets abroad by entering into employment contracts offshore, triggering TOAA provisions.
  • The Employers had no deductible payments wholly and exclusively for their trade because the payments to the EBTs served a dual purpose including tax avoidance.
  • The TOAA provisions do not infringe EU law or, if they do, such interference is justified and proportionate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
RFC 2012 plc (in liquidation) (formerly Rangers Football Club plc) v Advocate General for Scotland [2017] UKSC 45 Established that payments by way of EBT contributions for onward loans are earnings from employment chargeable to income tax. Accepted by the Appellant as binding; used to clarify that such payments constitute taxable employment income.
McCarthy v McCarthy & Stone plc [2007] EWCA Civ 664 PAYE system recovers tax due on employee income from the employer; PAYE Regulations do not impose liability on employee. Reinforced that the 7A power does not impose tax liability but changes collection point.
R (O) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2022] UKSC 3 Principles of statutory construction, including the principle of legality and interpretation of statutory powers. Applied to construe section 684(7A)(b) ITEPA as a wide power subject to public law principles.
Whitney v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1926] AC 37 Three stages of tax system: liability, assessment, and collection. Used to explain the distinction between liability and collection in PAYE context.
Lord Howard de Walden v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1942] 1 KB 389 TOAA legislation is penal and intended to deter tax avoidance by transfers abroad. Reaffirmed the penal and deterrent nature of TOAA provisions.
Inland Revenue Commissioners v Brackett [1986] STC 521 Broad construction of anti-avoidance provisions; employment contract can constitute transfer of assets abroad. Applied to hold that entering into offshore employment contracts can be a relevant transfer under TOAA.
Lord Chetwode v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1977] 1 WLR 248 Definition and scope of "income" for tax purposes under TOAA provisions. Guided the court on the meaning of income and the requirement that income arises after deduction of allowable expenses.
Vodafone Cellular Ltd v Shaw [1997] STC 734 Principles governing deductibility of expenses wholly and exclusively for trade purposes. Used to assess whether payments into EBTs were deductible expenses of the Employers' trade.
Edwards v Bairstow [1956] AC 14 Standard for appellate interference with fact findings in tax cases. Referenced in assessing the reasonableness of the FTT's findings on deductibility and profits.
Interfish Ltd v Revenue & Customs Commissioners [2014] EWCA Civ 876 Duality of purpose in expenses can render them non-deductible. Considered in arguments about whether payments to EBTs served both trade and personal/tax avoidance purposes.
MacKinlay v Arthur Young & Co [1990] 2 AC 239 Distinction between partners and employees in deductibility of expenses; fiscal motives generally irrelevant. Supported the conclusion that payments to employee (Appellant) were deductible despite tax avoidance motive.
Clark (Inspector of Taxes) v Oceanic Contractors Inc [1983] 2 AC 130 Test for UK presence of offshore entities for PAYE purposes. Applied to reject argument that Employers had UK presence.
R (on the application of Aozora GMAC Investment Ltd) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2019] EWCA Civ 1643 Legitimate expectation in tax collection procedures. Considered and rejected as basis for procedural legitimate expectation claim.
MCX Dunlin (UK) Ltd v HMRC [2021] EWCA Civ 186 Interpretation of tax appeal provisions and jurisdiction of tax tribunals. Discussed in relation to the scope of the FTT's jurisdiction over PAYE credit issues.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed statutory construction exercise of section 684(7A)(b) ITEPA, concluding that the 7A power is a broad discretion enabling HMRC to relieve a payer from PAYE obligations where it is unnecessary or inappropriate for that payer to comply, and that it can be exercised both prospectively and retrospectively. The court rejected the Appellant's arguments that the power cannot affect accrued rights or impose liability on the employee, clarifying that the power does not impose or transfer tax liability but shifts the point of collection from the employer to the employee.

The court held that the PAYE credit is a contingent credit relevant at the collection stage and does not affect the amount of tax payable under assessment provisions in the Taxes Management Act 1970 (TMA). Accordingly, the First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal lack jurisdiction to consider the lawfulness of the exercise of the 7A power or the availability of the PAYE credit; judicial review is the appropriate route.

Regarding the lawfulness of HMRC's exercise of the 7A power, the court found that HMRC acted lawfully, taking into account relevant considerations including the lack of knowledge or involvement of the End Users in the avoidance scheme and the impracticality of pursuing alternative statutory powers. The court rejected claims of procedural unfairness and legitimate expectation.

On the TOAA provisions, the court accepted that the Appellant's entry into offshore employment contracts constituted a transfer of assets abroad. However, the critical factual question was whether the Employers had any taxable trading profits. The court upheld the FTT and UT findings that the Employers' trading income was nil because payments into the EBTs were deductible as wholly and exclusively incurred for the purposes of the Employers' trade. The court rejected HMRC's contention that the payments served a dual purpose including tax avoidance, emphasizing that the payments were primarily remuneration for services rendered and that a fiscal motive alone does not negate deductibility.

The court noted the complexity and penal nature of the TOAA legislation but accepted HMRC's concession that the TOAA charge does not take priority over the charge to tax on employment income under ITEPA. The court declined to address outstanding EU law arguments as unnecessary and inappropriate in light of the conclusions reached and the UK's changed status.

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision is as follows:

  • The 7A power is a wide power that can operate both prospectively and retrospectively, overlapping with the redirection regulations, and was available and lawfully exercised in the Appellant's case.
  • The exercise of the 7A power means no PAYE credit is available to the Appellant or other Claimants, who remain liable to pay the income tax due on the employment income assessments.
  • The First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal do not have jurisdiction to review or decide on the exercise of the 7A power or the availability of the PAYE credit; judicial review is the proper avenue for such challenges.
  • There is no separate liability to income tax under the TOAA charge as the ITEPA charge takes priority, and the Employers' profits were correctly found to be nil due to deductibility of payments into the EBTs.
  • The appeal and cross-appeal are dismissed in their entirety, and the judicial review claim is refused.

The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the tax liability and collection arrangements but does not establish new precedent beyond clarifying the scope and application of the 7A power and the jurisdictional limits of tax tribunals regarding PAYE credits.